Skip to main content
Loading video...

Reavers of Midgard Review - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 21:07

hey folks welcome to another broken people review and today it's Reavers of Midgard this just recently got properly released in the UK on retail I think Kickstarter backers are supposedly getting theirs now all very soon I picked up a Kickstarter version of this at Essen after hearing about the game seeing a playthrough in the dice tab but not knowing if I would like it or not champions of Midgard is the one that came before this this is part of a trilogy they're doing where champions of Midgard was a hybrid hero this is a full-on euro and the third one will be a full on the mirror fresh interesting idea I'd like to see how that turns out but I wasn't the biggest fan of champions of Midgard looks the business and it's a cool alternative to something like say laws of Waterdeep but the dice luck in it was just too much for me you could buy gear up to go for one big battle that dice hoes you and your crippled because you don't got enough time to recover did not like that at all however I have not played it with Valhalla or the dark mountains expansions I hear that fixes the problem I would like to play it with those expansions if anybody wants to show me that then please do and now maybe maybe it'll elevate it to a point where I'm like yes this is how I want it and I might even buy it who knows I feel that if they can just fix that problem then good but we'll see that's for another day this however reverse is the full-on euro version I mean this is a full-on euro version of the game you know there's nothing to merit fratty in this apart from the occasional rolling of dice and even then it's easy to mitigate what those roles are but in this one you are definitely the quintessential River

Vikings you're going out and pillaging places and conquering places and a lot of it is done with sets of cards you essentially have a ship action and there's several I think five actions on the board five or six and you place your ship on one of those actions and based on player order you get a bonus so if you go there you get a bonus that's better than the person next to and better than one after and better than the one last you know it might be say you go to a space and you can draw these two cards if you go there first you get two bonus cards next player gets one they get Jack they get Jack and various you know there might be another space where you to do free things at this space ex-player gets to expect gets one next pair gets one so the idea being that everybody gets a chance to do the action you just took similar to how games like empires the boy did it but with some like differences in air whereas in that one you could kind of do different actions if you wanted it was still that concept of I take in action now does anybody else want to also do the action you can instead rest and get yourself a die on some food but predominantly you all ideally want to spend the resources and do the action and do whatever it says now the vast majority of this game is based around cards you know there are cards for objective scoring there are Reaver cards which are like characters and crew on your ship there's spoiled cards for set collection for art and tapestries that out of tapestries yeah I'm wondering how often I can get that joke into a review narrow since I used it in a tapestry but you know it's a

cool film I love that scene but you know tapestries and art and armor sets you've got three different tokens you can collect farms walls and towers which you can attack and get stuff there's farm cards where you can like fun so that's tool cards and that where you can get resources but also choose to pillage that place which gets you more resources but these negative pillage liked ogres that look like Diablo time devil symbols it's kind of weird but yeah there's everything is about cards it's all cards with the occasional tiles thrown in for the territories but you know that's a minor thing you could have just mean a card as well but it's all about collecting all these different cards and putting them into what is called your glory pile right and yeah if any of you are more adult lis orientated than me then yeah this gets a lot of sniggering when you play this game but yeah because they have not called it something better honestly if you're a kid ask your parents but you know with this it's basically collect these cards get points at the end of the game for lots of different ways I mean this is essentially a point salad a euro game with the Vikings themes or slapped onto it and that's definitely the first aspect I want to get into if you're going into this looking for a formatic viking experience you won't get here I mean you've got dice for the crew you've got card collection all over the shop one particular crewmember doesn't necessarily feel like it's different from another crew member apart from what

bility it has you know the free clans that you've got you know they don't feel that different it's just different things they give you with bonuses you go out to claim a territory towel you basically just spend the resources and claim the tile it's the theme is very kind of narrowing this not to say there's no theme at all and certainly what they do do with the theme in this is I mean the fact you're pillaging stuff makes sense but the way the board looks it is gorgeous I mean I've got a play mat for this as well but Wow I mean this board is chunky and it is colorful it is a I mean that's only part of the board and you can already see the color popping off this board it's a bit busy and it does get in the slight way of people for graphic design but to be honest it's not too difficult to see where all the current slots go and where the action slots are but when you've got the whole thing sprawled out on a table with all the cards everywhere it does get a little bit busy but the theme does come out in the artwork and what's on the cards but yeah don't play this thinking you're gonna get a formatic immersive Viking experience this is a point salad gyro at the end of the day and probably I would say more of a mid-weight one I mean people have said it's heavy I think there's quite a lot of rules to absorb so it's probably more complex than it needs to be but there's mainly just because there's a lot of rules the mechanics of the game are actually pretty straightforward and so I would put this kind of in the mid weight to heavy sort of bandwagon you know that

borderline there definitely don't play this if you're not used to heavy games in general though because I think this might overwhelm a few people with the options that you have and you do have a lot of options I wish there was maybe more locations to go to but when you go to one location you get like multiple choices of Reaver cards you go to another location you've got three different territory charles to go to there's two locations that work pretty much the same thing where you take two cards but each one you've got about five different cards that can come up and you've got nothing all right so hang on so these weren't like this these were like that these work like that these work like that there's a a lot to explain card wise before you get started with the game and it can be a bit of a lengthy teach and certainly I think your first game is gonna go pretty slowly as you adapt to all these cards in it everywhere once you get used to it though the graphic design makes sense it's pretty clear to see oh yeah that's a die for that face that's a food that's a favor you know that's this type of card for the most part it's pretty good although I will say the cards have like a circle in the middle with like a picture like say up a village or a tower key or something like that it's a little bit hard to tell those apart on other cards when they say they score for certain things you kind of is that oh this bonus allows me to draw one of which type of card oh that one okay because the colors aren't quite that easy to differentiate as I say it's a bit of a busy board and it can make life a little bit difficult or a little bit fiddly to get things going and certainly this is a quite a fiddly game to do because you do have a lot of these

cards everywhere they all do different things and everybody's triggering effects at different times and it can get a little bit like oh my god yeah whatever game plays for about six rounds and you know you essentially go through this many rounds of placing the worker down and getting all your points and of course the one with the most points wins of course but it's not particularly different from a lot of other euro games that you've played you know it's get a ton of points have the most at the end job done the game plays two to four players there's no solo mode unfortunately and I think this is actually one of those games I think will have benefited very nicely from a solo mode so it's a bit of a shame to in put one in really but two to four players it's scales fine you basically change up like how many pawns you put down to do actions to play you have to each four players you have one each and free player you take it in turns to have two one one in the sense so you always have four actions that are triggered every round it's just a case of what actions I do wish there were more locations though because you find that the same locations get visited on a regular basis and you may find that one or two locations don't even appear for a good majority of the game the trading action usually only gets done more in the late game whereas the one that lets you collect Reaver cards tends to only really happen in the early game and then you find that the sea battles are taken by like one person and mainly everybody is gunning for the farm cards the keep cards and the territory tiles they are the three main actions that are used pretty much every round yeah if you if you want to do the

action then you're only really going there for the bonuses chances are you'll find that somebody else wants to go there as well when it's like fine I'll just wait for you to do the action net but ideally you're picking actions based on whether you think opponents want to do the action or not or whether you want those bonuses it's like hmm well if I go to the keep cards I know you won't you can't afford it you have to spend a lot to afford it you can do it but I don't think you're desperate for them what I'm after so you know what I'm gonna go to raid keeps it's that kind of decision-making you have to make each round but it does feel very dry in how it plays I mean the idea that you're just basically collecting cards of different sets I mean here's some set collection here's a choice do you want the basic resources or the advanced one here's some tokens that get you majority scoring at the end you know it game does feel very dry in how it works I didn't really get the theme leaping off this game for me other than how gorgeous it looks under the play mat it's really good now the retail version has just normal tokens in it so and they're decent tokens I've seen it out in production it's a good quality reduction if you've got the Kickstarter version node and you've got these game trays with you know like funky colored Dyson and the dice of good quality I like the dice and you've got a lot of them in here you know there's a good amount to see in here you've got recess boards you know and they're in both copies I believe you've got cards that you can sleeve which still fit in the box and you've got a game trade for these tokens now I think the retail versions a little bit easier to work with though a nice regard

because those wooden turbans are cool but I hate this one games do this the way they differentiate one food and five food for example is a small drumstick and a slightly bigger drumstick when they're all in the same cubby hole within a tray trying to differentiate the small from the big ones is a pain yeah I will much rather they I mean with the retail version it's probably easier do I can only speak from having played a Kickstarter version here but having to sort of constantly looking and going that's a big food that's a small food is a bit irritating really you're actually better off having two separate piles on the table just but one for small more for baking just maintaining that and actually using the tray but at least it makes for convenient storage when you put it back in the box the tokens themselves are good quality I mean I like the recessed board be says boards are good because you've got spaces for the dice you've got slide in for upgrades you've got slots at the sides for artefacts you've got upgradeable actions at the bottom because the one of the best things I like is the multi-use function of Reaver cards where you get dice when you take a river card but then you can either discard it form or dice you can promote it to a leader so that the wild symbol on the particular color die becomes anything you want and you can also upgrade your actions at the bottom where the four main actions that are written down here you can have up to free cards below each one and then every time someone goes into action all of them trigger at once before the action results however that links back to my

whole fiddly concept which is you go to an action and then you first have to say right does anybody have any Weaver abilities right okay trigger them now simultaneously let's do that I've done mine anybody else done there good good good right now I'll do my action the now you now you now you it does take a while to resolve each action I would like maybe more of the game to be simultaneous and with that said this is a 60 to 120 minute game on the box I would dare say that's more closer to 90 to two and a half hours on the box it can be quite long with a bit of downtime with four players I actually think playing this with two or three players is probably better just to keep that time length and downtime down because with four of you that's just a lot of effects going off particularly by the mid game onwards you've got Reaver abilities all over the shop you've got all the different actions multiple cards multiple things just going it does get a little bit fiddly and so really this is more for two players I'd say free players max four players if you want but I think it's scale best at lower player counts and sadly there's no solo mode so although I like it it's produced great I mean yeah it's a bit fiddly with those tokens but there's nothing I can't handle and certainly the Kickstarter version gives you game trades which are great and you know lots of cool tokens you still get the dice in the retail version and the retail version still looks really good you know there's nothing wrong with the production in the retail copy it would also cost you a bit less

this is quite a pricey game for what you're getting and certainly that's a bit of a negative as well just how much you have to pay for this game which is essentially a point sabot but it does feel quite dry but it is enjoyable it is one where you do have some interesting decisions to make and there's a lot of different paths to victory the objective cards that you get might gear you to certain ways or you might just pick a particular route and you kind of need to stick with that route and not diversify too much otherwise you will have problems but there's definitely tension for the spaces like are you gonna go there I don't want you to go there cuz I want the bonus oh you've gone there are right now where am I gonna go well it could go there but you're just gonna benefit from it as much oh it's like you know you get the attention with the action selection and what cards you're going for and whether someone takes your cards first but you can probably get away with two and free players don't have that level of tension without needing a fourth player but it can just take a bit of a long time and it is definitely a very dry game and I've said that downtime can be a little bit annoying at times when you're waiting for all those Reaver abilities to trigger then you're doing the action and then you're waiting for the next person to do the action etc and the first player marker depending who's got that you could be waiting a while before it's your main action and yes okay you can say well hang on you get to do the same action when they do it so technically the down times less right well yes and no but if you actually think about it I don't think you actually gain any extra actions in the game from simply just saying oh well you

know on your next turn you do something yes you get to achieve more actions but you could just have more locations and each take your turn you'd probably have the same amount of interaction with the game but I like this concept that you're considering whether someone will take an action or whether you take the action or to do it so I like the game but for its cost and certainly for how the theme is kind of lost and how slightly fiddly it can get I mean the rule books not bad but there were a few times where I'm thinking well how does this current work so don't think the Dasara at the back caters for all cards and some of them sometimes you want a bit more like here I need to know a bit more about this cart on top of that there are one or two aspects of the game I don't think have much of an impact you know some cards can get you points for certain things but it's just like yeah it's really not a lot of points what do I even care and the negative tokens I was expecting them to have more of an impact as well but they really don't matter that much you've got to you know you're finishing this game on anywhere between 150 to 250 points losing 10 to 15 points is not as bad as you might think if you've gained a lot from it and you need to gain about five or six of those pillage tokens to get that kind of negative from them because it's a triangular scale one three six ten fifteen twenty one so having three even four of those is not that damaging really so there's a current with - lets you get rid of one of your tokens and give one to another player well that's

really not that interesting I mean you might have saved yourself a point free points maybe and you give another player minus 1 or minus 2 it's such a small differential effect that they just don't really matter it would be much better if I'd simply take in the card that allows me to get a bunch of resources and conquer a farm which could potentially get me two points for the farm and maybe 500 in the majority you know it's it's more impactful but I feel like the negative Diablo tokens as I call them we're just kind of a wasted concept there they don't make it much difference I don't really care if I get rid of them or not I just go you know what I want the resource is great because usually you'll make up for it and there's a lot of ways to get rid of those tokens during a game that they just don't really a player that much but all in all I still enjoy it but I am I mean an honest of whether it will stay in my collection or not because I have other point game point salad games that I do prefer that also don't have theme post are 28:49 is a good example positive 28:49 is super dry but then this is an exactly formatic either but it's shorter it's easier to learn the decisions and that one that probably maybe a bit tougher to make then this one it's a nod say a little bit more streamlined and this one is and it's done in the shorter time and still has a decent amount of variety and it's like I kind of prefer that one to this one really but not to say this is a bad game I think this is still fairly solid and I think there's some people out there who are gonna get a kick out of it and really enjoy it I still enjoy it for me

the rating I would give this is a half-decent seven out of ten it has some room for improvement I wish it had a solo mode I wish it wasn't quite as fiddly with some of those components and I just wish it wasn't quite as super dry and busy with just lots of different cards and it is as much as they are nice cards and nicely produced but I still enjoy it with two to three players I would be happy to bring this out and have a you know a decent point salad game where everyone's writing on each other's plans and you're doing all these combo plays with the Reavers you know you can have different paths and focus on different actions you know there's a good amount of variety to keep you entertained but I was kind of expecting this one to be a little bit better yeah oh just a bit better than that actually was but seven is still good I would still like to play this I just don't know quite if it's gonna make a collection keeper I'm gonna I'm gonna have to think about it but for now it's on the Shelf but it could be in danger if something else similar comes out to threaten it in the future so you know all in all decent game but could be better Reavers of Midgard I'll be interested to see what the expansions do the champions though which I've not played and I would definitely like to see what this new American coming out that they will do eventually is you know I'd like to see how that's gonna differ from these ones I think it will be a solid trilogy all-round but you're probably going to be one of those people that pick your poison as two hybrid euro America which one do you want so that's it for me and Reavers of Midgard from grey fox games I'll see you on the next broken meatball review and regardless of

whether you've finished and torch down my humble little farm that was oh no aren't you whatsoever it's still only a game take care and I'll see you on the next video

you

Progress saved