Morty Sorty Magic Shop Review: Where's the Magic?
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal. And I'm Mike Delisio. Today we're taking a look at a game called Morty Sorty Magic Shop. Yes. It's called Morty Sorty. It's such a weird a weird title of this. In fact, I had not even heard of this game.
Oh, but it was one of the three games nominated for the Spiel des Jahres, which is the biggest German game of the award, not of just No, it's the biggest board game award.
board game award there is. Um, and so this as far as I mean we have a English version of it from Schmidt, but it's not sold in America yet as far as I can tell, but we got a copy of it because by the time you're watching this, it may have won or lost, we're not sure. Um, we have opinions of whether it should win or lose, but we'll save those. This is a game in which you're sorting potions out. Yeah, you could have got that from the title, but how does it play? Here you go. Each player is going to have their own board here. We're going to be placing potions on that board. Each round of the game you're going to pull out some five potions from the bag, four in a two-player game, and kind of drop them here like this. If any of them have a blue lid like this one, you'll put it up here underneath this board. So you'll see it's underneath the five there, and you'll redraw and drop another bottle.
And then players are going to be taking turns drafting these tiles, taking one, and putting these in a display, and the leftover ones are taken out of the game. Now, when you put these tiles in your display, you're going to be looking here a little bit at your board, and what's going to happen is each bottle can go in specific places. So this one here has a gold lid, and it's a number seven. So you can see here this says gold lids can go on all three rows. And so, I can put this seven anywhere I want. If I have this gold lid three, again, I might put it here, but I might want to put it here because they have to go in ascending order. So, I'm probably not going to put it in this spot. This black lid seven can only go on the bottom shelf, and the silver lids can only go on the middle or the bottom shelves like this. So, here I have a black two. I might decide to put it here, but that means I'm never going to be able to put out a black one. Now, all the different bottles have two colors. There's yellow and green, and then purple and blue on the different sides. Whatever side drops out must be the side you use, although you may spend a cat to flip the side of one of them, or you may spend one of the kittens to put the same number next to another number on a shelf. And you can also pass and take no jar to get another kitten.
Uh at the end of the game, kittens are going to be worth two points each. Now, if you ever do it so that you have three jars in a row in a column, I'm sorry, not in a row, in a column, and they are all different colors. This is why color matters, or one of the reasons color matters. Then, you may take one of the blue ones up here, which is wild, and blue can go in any spot. If that finishes another column, you can take another one, etc. Now, you'll notice that there are some numbers printed on the board here. If you have a jar in that spot that matches that number, at the end of the game, you're going to get points based on the number of ones you do that. There are nine different spots. If I get all nine, I'm going to get 30 points. If I get one of them only, I'll get two points. You don't have to put those numbers in those spots because again, you're trying to get things ascending, but you can.
Also, if you finish a row completely, you will get a free kitten and points at the end of the game 4 6 and 10 depending on which row you finish. At the beginning of the game, you're going to decide if you're going to play the simple game which will use this scoring board or the advanced game which is going to use these four boards here. What these boards have and there's two different sides for them is simply they're going to score at the end of the game and when all the tiles are drawn from the bag. So, for example, this would be black lids times your green is worth points. This one here, your blues, each blue by itself is four, a group here is extra 14 and every group there or having the most, I'm sorry, having the biggest group of purples itself is 14 and the second biggest group is six, but every purple is four. But, that can switch if you change it to the other side where here you're trying to get the purples in different rows. If you play with the base game, you're just going to take your biggest group in each color and score that many points.
And then you're also going to have two of these next to the board, doesn't matter if you play basic or advanced, although you can take these out to make it even simpler. And on these, the first person to do something, if you have a three gold lids in the top, two gold lids in the middle, one gold lid in the bottom, you'll put one of your tokens on these spots. Each player will have little tokens that match their board. And the first person to do so also gets a kitten, but these are points at the end of the game. These have two sided and there are four of them, but you're only going to use two of them in a game. So, at the end of the game, you'll add up points for those, the points you got from rows, the leftover kittens which are worth two points, your points for having things that in these spots here, and then scoring whether you're doing basic or the advanced scoring and whoever has the most points is the winner.
So, the way this game looks, yes, it looks old. It looks as if it's a game from the '90s or early '00s. The artwork and stuff. And in a sense, when I first saw it, it almost looked like Quacks of Quedlinburg. Um like, "Hey." And um
It looks old, for sure. I think it plays old.
Yeah. Well, I wasn't going to go there right away, but yeah. But you're right. It It just has the feeling of, "Hey, your potions are from a bag." The I I was trying to think, "What is original to this game?" So, the the one thing that's original maybe is when you pull the potions, you drop them, and the side they're on is the side they're on, which for for a good chunk of the game doesn't matter. It only matters when you're trying to make that column of three to take a blue one from the top.
Right.
Also, you're going to find, and this will happen This has happened in every game I've played of this, you pull tiles from the bag, you're like, "Oh, a blue one goes to the top. Well, let's replace that. Another blue one goes to the top. Well, let's replace that. Okay, another blue one. Okay, not a blue one." And it's like, couldn't there have been a better way to have done that?
very clunky. It It It really does not feel like an elegant thing. And I will say that uh it's hard for me not to be a little cynical. And it's And I have to say it I I cannot review this without stating that I knew that this was nominated for the Spiel when I played it.
Yeah. And there's nothing we can do about that.
I tried not to to make that play in, but it's very hard to because I feel like Have you ever heard of Oscar bait? Have you ever heard those movies that are Oscar bait? To me, this is Spiel bait. The cover looks like this is what's going to appeal to German families. Right?
Which isn't necessarily a bad thing. You're trying to sell games. Why would you not want to make one that appeals to people?
But But Well, I think what they've done is they've taken the safe route every possible way they can. They went right down the middle, and they shaved off every possible rough edge. And in so doing, they've shaved off any personality this game might have had. It just feels so wrote and by the numbers, and it feels like something that came out 15 years ago.
Yeah, the the So, there's two different ways to score the base game and the advanced game. I think you probably only played advanced, but I played both. And the base game is so boring. And the advanced game is okay. The problem is this game has such guardrails up. There are nine spots. They're like Fill the spot with these numbers and you get points. But, that's also where you're going to put those numbers anyway. So, you should do it.
Yes.
The only reason you wouldn't do it is on the off occasion that I have a a four and a seven, and it wants me to put a six there, and I get a five, and I go well, I'd rather finish the row than not. Maybe.
Yeah.
Maybe. Or if I get a blue one, and there's a yellow and a green, and I'm like, well, I'll put it in that column. Oh, it's green. Well, I guess I'll pay the cat to switch it. And you might as well sit there and go, well, the the cats are two points at the end of the game.
Sure.
So, is it worth It's And skipping a turn to get a cat, I haven't tried that yet. I'm curious. What if I skipped every turn and took a pile of cats? I mean, I there's maybe there's a limit on cats, but again, I'm just being stupid here, but what I mean is there's not a lot in this game. And people who are proponents of the Spiel des Jahres would say, that's the point.
point. Yeah, but you can still do it in a way that leads to some kind of compelling decision. So, I really like Raco. So, I feel like I'm predisposed to like a game like this, and I've liked other games that use that kind of an idea of sorting things by numbers. I like it. I think it's a human nature satisfying things to to put things in order, right?
Yes.
And so, this has that, but honestly, I'd rather play Raco, because what this adds to it, I don't think is terribly compelling. When you talk about the difference between the basic and the advanced game, and you're right, I only played the advanced game, because I looked at the basic rules, and I'm just like, what what what why? Just go to the advanced game. All that really does is just add more scoring things, more things to consider when scoring, but it doesn't really make it more interesting in my opinion. Um you know, I don't know that this is a game that you can put the advanced stuff out there. It's not going to appeal to, you know, beyond a family game or anyway, so I don't know.
Yeah.
It's almost a children's game the basic
It's almost it's it's it's almost too many too big of a game for how few options it actually gives you. So, there's five potions out there. If you're first, if you're not first, you have less than that. So, there's five. You're going to look at them and go, well, I can't even put these out. Oh, look, this one matches this spot perfectly. That is the one I take. There's no angst really. The angst is, I hope you don't take the one I want.
yeah.
And the idea putting them in order is an interesting one, but the fact that the black ones can only go on the bottom means again, there's just natural ranking. Always take a black one over a gold one cuz the gold one can go anywhere.
Exactly.
Always I don't know. And I know that people will be like, oh, if you played a lot For me, I don't even have the desire to go into this one more.
Right.
But I'm hesitant to say it's a bad game. Don't don't get me wrong. I'm giving it a bad rating.
Yeah.
I didn't dislike it, but I'm bored playing it. Like so bored.
I did dislike it, but I don't think it's a Well, I can't say I really do think it's a bit of a poorly designed game because I think again, or maybe not poorly designed. I think it was maybe poorly developed. I think it's been
Yeah, that's a good that's a good call.
developed to this just just shiny sheen that again makes it very very generic. I mean, mechanically it works, right? And maybe, you know, I have to take into account I've played a whole lot of games, and I've played a whole lot of games that feel very much like this, and most of them were from 10, 12 years ago.
Mhm.
Um and so, I think that's kind of where my thing is. I didn't enjoy playing it. I have no desire to play it again. It just Yeah, it's it's it doesn't feel like of its time.
Yeah, and so maybe and and so again, I'm sure in the comments we're going to get people who love it and that's fantastic. If you love it, I think that's great. Tell people about it. But for me this game feels pale both in the production, which I think could have looked nicer. I mean, how many times I've seen the games with mandrake or whatever they're called in a jar and mushrooms and it's like, okay, that's not that interesting.
Mhm. But it's safe.
Right. And then [clears throat] everything else is a choice. And it's a family game and it says 30 minutes on here. I might argue it's slightly longer than that. Yeah. But you do the same thing over and over and over and over again and at very few points is there angst. The angst comes closer to the end of the game when you're running out of places to put stuff. Sure. And even then you could take a cat, which is worth two points, which might matter. The scoring is somewhat interesting somewhat I I'm just bored. It's a five out of 10 for me. I just really can't recommend this. I'm sure there's an audience for it. So I'm not saying that the game is terrible. I don't like it.
I'm going to come in at a four because I didn't like it the first time I played it. I didn't like it the second time I played it. I don't want to continue playing it. I mean I I know and and I want to make it very clear. I am not saying that there's not enough game here for the Spiel des Jahres because I think that it fits. It fits the weight that they're going for. But you can have a game of this weight that has more compelling decisions, that is more interesting.
10 better games for the Spiel des Jahres than this. I'm just saying.
At least Well, there were many more that were nominated as recommendations that didn't
I agree. Many of the games in the recommendation list are better than this.
are better than this and by a significant amount in my opinion. So it's a four for me. It's a pass. I would not recommend it.
There you go, folks. That's Morty Sorty Magic Shop. I'm Hassle Castle.
I'm Mean Mike. We'll see you next time.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.