Super Motherload Review
Transcript
welcome to John GS games today I'll be reviewing super motherload this is a light deck building game about blowing up and digging holes in the Martian crust to get minerals to buy extra skills to make your deck better at blowing up and digging deeper holes into the Martian crust first I'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review as a bonus I've done a full two-player playthrough of this game you can see the link to that down below in the description all right so here is pretty much everything you need to see in order to learn how to play Super motherload we see over here is the starting main mining tile where we're going to be drilling down on Mars over here we have a major achievement section which only has three cards in it and once some of these get taken they never refill we've got three minor achievements and whenever these are taken they refill with another one so there's always going to be three of these and then finally this is the player area for the character I'm going to be playing as to teach you the game this is a deck building game and everybody starts with a seven card deck which is identical you Shuffle that up and then you draw four cards from the top of your deck and this is what you're going to be starting with everybody also Begins the game with a single bomb on a player's turn they can take two actions from a list of three potential possibilities the first of those is simply draw two cards from the top of their deck that will take one of those two actions and with all these actions you can do it twice to evaluate your whole turn so you could just draw four cards and that would be your entire turn then play with pass to the left the second possible action on a turn is to drill and we look at these four cards that we have in our hand we have these little icons in the top left we've got red and blue in our hand right now there are three different colors total and
then there's also a wild color which can come in later but I'll explain that in a second when you do a drilling action you can discard as many cards as you want from your hand as long as they all have the same color drilling icon on them you discard them down into your discard pile and then you evaluate those drill actions so in this case I discarded two teal drill actions what I can now do is take this tile which is too large and I can drill down from the surface of Mars so the way drilling always works is you have to be orthogonally adjacent to either the surface of mars or from a previously drilled Cavern so we could do a couple things we could drill over here and cover these two items up here we could drill over these over here we could also drill down here and we see this plate here with a teal surrounding it you can only drill into plates if you have discarded bits of the correct color so this can only be drilled by Teal so I could do this it would probably be a good idea for the player to do this however and they cover up a gold and an iron once a player has finished Drilling and it's important to note that you're not limited by two or three drills you could drill down eight if that was the number of little bits you had you just stack the little tiles along next to each other but when you're doing a drill action it's always going to be in a straight line now that we finished drilling we're going to take minerals from the pile that are equal to the same ones that were covered up so in this case it' be one gold and one iron and we see in the top left that the gold is always worth three bucks and the iron is always worth two bucks I put the six different mineral types up here uh so that all players can see it I generally put this out in every game just because it's good to know what all these things mean once you play it a couple times
you'll have the numbers memorized but definitely not for that first game you take these minerals which at this point are pretty much just money in this case five total and you put them on a single one of these four pilot Stacks now these are only mine like the white player only has access to these four each other player is going to have their own stack of four and they are in order these are all red cards all teal all yellow and all wild you cannot split these resources up from a single drill action so I would just need to place these directly onto one of these so for instance I might put it onto this card right here and now we see that it costs 10 to purchase this card and I've only put five on there so we're just going to leave that there and we're not actually going to purchase this card until we've reached the $10 threshold The Last Action type you can do on your turn is bombing and only red cards in the game actually allow bombing and that's this little symbol down here and it shows you a pattern this is a pattern of a 2x1 and this is a pattern of a 3X one and by discarding a single card for instance this one right here I would then get to do a 3 by1 bomb action because I discarded that card now you need to get rid of this bomb token in order to do that so you need bombs to actually do the explosion at this point the player takes this piece that is the size of the pattern on this card and they can bomb down the surface with the same rules as drilling however I didn't mention when you're drilling you're not allowed to drill through these Rocky spots right here no matter what kind of color drill you have you cannot go through these and likewise when you bomb you are not allowed to go through these steel plates but bombing is able to go through these rocks so a really good action here might be to
bomb right here which would get a gold and an iron but then also this plus two right here which means I would immediately draw two cards from the top of my deck into my hand actions like this are great because there's no natural way to draw back cards in your hand you don't refill at the end of a turn you just have to spend actions on your turn to draw two cards or evaluate things on the board that let you do that so let's say that was my second action I would then draw these two cards into my hand and now I would once again get an ir and a gold to put down I can put these down on any one of the stacks I like but I'd like to illustrate how we buy the pilots so I'm going to put them down on here we now see that this is 10 gold and the card costs 10 to buy so we get to purchase this card immediately when you purchase a card you discard all of the minerals from it and then you immediately look to the icon in the bottom center of the card this is a purchase ability that happens the moment you take this card in this instance I would just get one bomb from the bank so I once again have it available to me and then this card would go directly into my disc pile you can now notice that the following card is going to cost $15 and if you look deeper into the stack you'll notice that they always cost five more so the more you buy from a certain stack the more expensive they get however you get more stuff on them you might have noticed that this first card has a single blue drill bit and then this icon which allows you to draw one card the next one down is going to give you a drill bit but you get to draw two cards when you play this card once you get past that they seem to get worse however if you look in the bottom left those hexagons are the victory points that having these cards are worth in your deck so it still makes sense to keep drilling down on these different stacks
of cards in essence you can think of this not as adding more doggy space dudes into your deck but strengthening the skill value of your dog space dudes you are in this little piloted minor going down the surface and the more cards you buy of a certain person the better they are at doing various skills at this point i' like to mention the other three types of instant effects when you buy cards just going to go through them briefly the first one is this hand that means when you purchase this card it actually comes directly into your hand not into the discard pile this next one here just has a little arrow symbol that is the universal symbol for actions in this game so when you get this card you put it in your discard pile but you get a third action on that turn or potentially fourth depending on the number of these you were able to get in a turn and the last one is probably the most powerful and that is the mineral doubler the way this works is the moment you take this card and you put it in your discard pile you are able to double the value of a mineral that's already out onto one of your Pilots say for instance if this mineral had already been on this pilot when I was able to purchase this card I could then double it so I would then take this doubled Platinum tile right here and I can put it down either on the pilot that had the doubled mineral or on any of the other Pilots if I wanted to in this way you can actually purchase multiple pilots in a single turn if you set it up in such a way that you can keep going over the different stacks and keep purchasing them I'd also like to note that some of these minerals like the diamond up here are really large value so if you're able to double a 12 value then you can get a lot of value out of this mineral doubling action it's important to note that there's a hand
limit of five that is only enforced at the end of a turn so if at the end of a turn you have more than five cards in your hand you have to discard down until you are at five and now I'd like to talk about the major and minor achievements you can see up here on the major achievements they show you the various number of skill cards that you can purchase from your different pilot stacks and essentially on your turn if you're the first person to do this pattern then you get to take that card and it doesn't go into your deck it just goes face up in your area and it's going to give you five points at the end of the game so for instance this one would require you to be the first person to have bought three red cards and three of your wild cards and likewise over here three teal and three wild or two two and two and now the minor achievements these give little quests that you can work towards on a specific turn and if you satisfy it then you can once again take it and put it into your player area for instance if I had instead of bombing like this bomb like this I would have covered up two different Rock chunks and we look over here we see that this minor achievement says bomb at least two Rock spaces in one action well that was a single action to do so I would take this and I put it face up in my player area it's going to give me two victory points at the end of the game and we would then take another card from the top of the stack and put it in its place you're never allowed to draft more than one minor achievement a turn or one major achievement a turn and as I said before when you take major achievements they do not refill now I'd like to talk briefly about the wild cards you can see it's got a multicolor drill so you can discard this along with any other set of colors in order to do big drills but it's also important to notice that the first card in the stack has the special
ability now this is a four player game and each of the four player colors are asymmetric in many different subtle ways for instance only the white deck has this bomb option associated with the teal card another deck when you buy a teal card it might come directly into your hand or it might have the mineral doubler all these little options on the bottom are kind of scrambled around and randomized for each of the four player colors some of the player decks also have different drill bit icons as well we see that the teal deck it only ever has one drill bit going on but there is another player deck where you can get multiple teal icons on a single card kind of like this yellow card here but the biggest asymmetry between the four different player colors is this single icon on the very first of the Wild Card stack and this is an ability that only this player character gets access to this one in particular lets you when drilling with this character right here you can actually drill through rocks normally you cannot drill through rocks you have to bomb but if you got this Captain Birdman card here then you can on that turn and you see that the subsequent more expensive cards in the wild stack don't have this ability anymore this is the same way for all the different decks so you'll only ever have one card with that special ability on it I'd like to briefly explain the special ability icon on the other three player character colors uh so for the green character here we see that if you do a drill action with this guy is a wild you can actually split those mineral tokens up between multiple by Stacks normally you have to have all them going to one this guy lets you split them up the orange one is simple you just get a bomb from the supply every time you play this wild card and the purple one lets you
drill diagonally when you do a drill action with this guy so for instance if I had this piece right here instead of being forced to go orthogonally you could drill at a diagonal only when you play this card the second card in the Wild Card stack always has this little circle with a cross slash through it now what this means is whenever you use this card to do a drill action you also must choose one of these minor achievements and discard it from the game in order to draw another one from the stack and put it in this is the only really way that the game forces a cycle of the minor achievements other than people getting them now let's talk about these alien head symbols on the board I'm sure you noticed them and you wanted to know what the heck these are about now whenever you cover up an alien artifact head by doing a drill or a bomb action you are going to immediately take one of the random alien tokens that are in a pile and you're going to put it in front of you and only you get to look at it in this case we could take this one right here we take a look at this and we can keep it face down in front of us until we choose to use it this one in particular would give us a bomb and allow us to draw one card in when we decide to actually use this token but we can keep it in front of us for as long as we want to once the last alien artifact head is destroyed for instance if someone did a drilling action like this we immediately get to delve deeper into Mars at this point we're going to add a whole another layer to the strata we take it and we add it in here now one one cool thing is that each of these boards is different they're kind of randomized in their own fun way and the player who took the last alien artifact head gets to decide which side of the
board is going to come in we see that this next board says depth two instead of depth one and we continue to dig down down down and once again once all the alien heads are taken we are going to add another board however at this point we remove the top one it is gone for the rest of the game and we slide this over and now we cut in with depth three and the player who did it gets to once again choose which side is going to be picked it is important to note if you're playing a two-player game you don't actually use the depth 3 board at all you would immediately jump to the fourth layer the game is going to end once the last of the alien artifact heads are covered up on the fourth and last Board of the game the that player will finish their turn but nobody else will take any future turns once the game is over each player is going to pull out all the cards that they purchased throughout the game that have victory points in the bottom left corner they add those together along with their major achievements any minor achievements that they got and a couple of the alien artifact tokens also give you victory points you sum that together and that's your score now I am a huge sucker for goofy tiebreakers and I forgot to mention that the player who last dug a hole is going to be the start player for the game and the tiebreaker is the player who lied about digging a hole to become the start player automatically loses I don't know how fair that actually is but I just love that they put that in the rules for my review of super month load I'm going to explain my thoughts on each item of this list starting at the the top and working my way down so let's start with the positives and the first of these has to be the subtle asymmetry that's pervasively spread throughout this entire game it's very cool to see the
way the different player decks have these very tiny ways that they're different constantly so it really kind of adds up and I can imagine the balance task that the designers had for this game really was a mountain to make sure that this deck is similar to that deck is similar to that deck in the way they play but they each have that one fundamentally different player ability you know the one that lets you drill through Rock seems like the most powerful one by far but the other ones are subtly powerful in their own ways and when you look at the other cards in the deck as well you see that certain uh whole player colors don't have access to good uh buying abilities when it comes to cards like one of the decks just does not have any buying abilities that immediately gets you another action to use but instead it'll just say draw two cards so that's one of the three options it's a slightly worse version of that get another action but I can just see how all these things kind of go together to balance out all of these different player characters but not in such a way that it feels like each of the player characters are grossly different just like fun little ways where you realize oh that teal deck over there they get lots of different icons on their cards but mine only sticks to one well I imagine I'm am stronger in a slightly different area in the game positive number two is that I love the achievement structure and how it influences the decisions that you're going to be making throughout the game you have these major and minor achievements and first of all the major achievements those are the ones that uh give you a bonus of five points for being the first person to draft a certain number of cards from your buying pool into your deck and this is great
because since each of our decks are asymmetric you might automatically just assume you're always going to want to do one or another pattern to get through your deck because it seems like a really good combination however you need to think about how that's going to affect the major achievements that are available because you might really have great red cards and you like the way that synergizes ones but in this game maybe there are no red major achievements at all and you need to decide whether or not it's still worth it for you to go for that particular strategy then with the minor achievements they give you little quests little goals that you can Orient your turnaround oftentimes completely derailing a plan that you already had to just go for something like have no cards in your hand while you just say you know what I don't even have very good drill actions but I'm going to do these two actions to empty my hand to take those two points that I will have for the rest of the game and new ones keep coming out so it keeps it kind of fresh and it stops it from just being try to maximize the amount of money that you drill on every single turn and maximizing the amount of money you drill is fun but it's good to have a little bit more options on what you decide to do each turn and positive number three is just that this game looks fun it grabs so much attention when it's on the table and it is fun while you're playing it just has a very unique feel to it with the Mars digging and the different tunnels getting dug down and you have amazing illustrations I love the artwork I love the fact that with our asymmetric decks are asymmetric art you know every single one of our decks has completely different people kind of different styles one of them has animals in it for some reason uh another one seems to be kind of like crazy kamakazi blow things
up kind of guys it's just a good artistic Vibe which really pulls you into the game you really feel like you're in this zany cookie video gamees atmosphere where you are just mining mining mining digging digging and without fail this game always grabs other people while we're playing it who maybe have never seen before first time they're at that game night where this game comes out and they say what is that and you say oh it's you know you're digging Mars it's a deck builder where you're just blowing things up and they say I want to play the next game it just it seems like pretty much everyone who sees it wants to play it and ah I can't help but see that as a big positive and now for neutral number one this game is incredibly tactical in fact it's almost entirely tactics the only minor bit of strategy has to do with how you draft your cards going for those major achievements other than that it's pretty much a completely different game state every single time it comes back to your turn and every one of your turns is pretty much around maximizing the output that you can get on this turn through victory points or through money and that's fine however it means that sometimes downtime can be a bit of a problem late game with larger numbers of players this is not a big deal because this is balanced out by the fact that people oftentimes have very short turns as well so in general they are an okay length of turn but every every now and then you're going to bump into a turn that just takes minutes and minutes and minutes as someone is just like ah no I can't do this oh but no I can't do this oh and you're just thinking oh man I really want them to finish their turn because there's only so much I can think about before it gets to my turn because things are going to change and you can
definitely analyze the board and hope that things are going to happen to you and try and have your turn laid out but the fact that so much can get bombed and drilled between even that single Last Action the person has to your right until your turn kind of leaves you in a position where you need to be ready to change on the Fly and you have to be ready to handle the timing restrictions or implications of that and neutral number two has to do with the mineral doubler action in the game and now this is by far the most fun action in the game but it also feels like it might be too close to a dominant strategy I have not necessarily seen this win every single time but I have a hard time wrapping my head around doing something other than having your drafting uh style the order in which you buy the cards in your little personal Tableau be completely dictated by the one of those cards that has a mineral doubler on it making sure that you have a specific Emerald or a diamond or something on a different card so that when you get that you can buy two cards at the same time I feel like if you are a player especially a new player who doesn't quite see the strength of the mineral doubler and how to constantly be trying to maximize the output of it they are just not going to win if everyone around the table understands that that's totally fine that's why this is a neutral point but but it also means that it's something that you're going to be doing every game like I think pretty much every game is going to be about setting up the perfect situation so that when you take that mineral doubler it has a huge impact and you draft Cards into your deck getting those cards into your deck is the biggest Victory Point gain that you have
and so the only way that you can get the most victory points and money onto these guys is to pretty much buy every single one of your mental doublers and ultimately that kind of bugs me but it's okay because that action is still so fun and now for the one negative point for this game and to be honest it's a light negative I had a hard time really coming up with a solid bad thing that I disliked about the game but ultimately the only thing that's come up consistently a couple times that has definitely negatively impact the game play is the way those minor achievements can stagnate in a two-player game I have not really seen this happen in the three and four player game but specifically in the two-player game it could just lock down where all three of them might be significant hard to get to and the two players just kind of start to ignore them and you might go half the game where nobody gets any of these minor achievements now you might be saying hey wait a minute that second Wild Card had that little circle with a slash through it where every time you play it you have to discard a minor achievement and I think that's good but in a two-player game it's not enough I've had two-player games where one of us just never gets any of our wild cards because it just doesn't make sense for the major achievements so they're obviously not going to be digging down and getting those minor achievement kicker outers I think that that little symbol with the cross through it should have been on more cards in the game maybe it should have been on every single one of these second level cards in all four Stacks so that there's a little bit more progression and fluidity to get those cards moving because when it stagnates it's just a bummer and that really reduces a lot of the great decisions
that you have on your turn uh as I mentioned that's a big positive I love having those options and if they are just out of your reach well then you're missing a good part of the game now I've only seen this in the two-player game so this is a very minor critique but I wish there was some way to get that minor achievement row moving more when it stagnates and now let's talk about replayability the first time that you play this game odds are good you're going to think it's totally awesome and the second time you're going to play it you're GNA say it's even more awesome and the third time you're like it's still really awesome and that fourth time you're like okay it's pretty good but I think I've probably seen everything and then the fifth time you're like okay yeah I've seen everything this game has to offer but I still had fun and the sixth seventh eth ninth time you're pretty much going to have a similar feel to that or that's my feeling as to how the replayability curve has gone for myself and I think it'll continue on I'm going to keep this game because it is fun to play I just don't see myself getting to it more than once every couple months at this point because I don't think there's another awesome layer of strategy underneath I think I've kind of pulled it all out I think you know the game is really about maximizing that mineral doubler really playing tactically with the minor achievements you have available you want to make sure that you are getting trying to go go for those major achievements and really see what other players are doing and that's pretty much it and every single time you play it you're pretty much going to be doing the same thing as the last time fortunately the same thing as last time is still a fun light and very enjoyable experience so for as far as replayability is concerned I think it has pretty good legs into the
future just on Raw fun alone but don't expect to keep finding new things on the 10th or 15th play of the game and now let's talk about player count super mother load plays two to four players and honestly it plays really well on all of those different player counts uh the only knock I have to any of them has to do with that negative that I talked about before where in a two-player game it seems like those minor achievements have a tendency to slow down a little bit more than i' like and I wish there's some way to get those moving but it does not stop the two-player game from being a very fun experience most of the games I played have been two-player now three and four also work really well I think if I was really to put my thumb down on the best player count it would probably be three the only reason for that is in a four-player game late game there can be a little bit of downtime depending on the players that you're playing with where it can just take a little while to get back to your turn considering how tactical and how much the different board states can change so three gets a slight Edge but honestly four is great I will never not play this game four if there are four people in total who want to play it it plays great two to four I I it really is nitpicking between these different player counts in conclusion I was excited about this game the moment I saw a video of it online and I got even more excited when I started playing it and I've just really enjoyed playing it the whole way through it's never disappointed me and I think it is just a consistent fun cardboard box that's going to be staying on my shelf for quite a while for all the different reasons that I've explained already it just has a lot of familiarity with a little bit of newness sprinkled on pretty much every single aspect of it
it's got deck building which feels kind of like normal deck building nothing too crazy but it's a little bit different you're not drawing up your hand and you have ways to pull things in your hand and oh you're like just strengthening these different Pilots that's cool you also have this like blowing digging up Mars which is a very like very tactile experience you feel adding the different things to the board and you just feel like you're blowing stuff up and it's so cool and you're getting the minerals and you're putting them down it's a very miserly fun experience you have this great art and just every time I played this game everyone around the table has really enjoyed it and I think every time I played the game with new players they've ended the game saying I really want to play that again that was super cool why have I never heard of this game and in general I don't think it got as much Buzz as it deserves it's a really solid game I think its replayability might be a minor knock on it but it's a light game it's going to play in an hour or less pretty much always unless you have a very slow group and I think you can get this out with new gamers in general I think it's actually a pretty good introduction into deck building as a genre so it's not too intimidating to have an entire game based entirely around it and it just has this really fun awesome blow things up get points for everything uh experience and at the end of the day I've always enjoyed playing it and I think you probably will too if you'd like to see more reviews like this and full playthroughs Vlogs and all the various different video stuff I do please consider subscribing to my YouTube channel thanks for watching