Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why Was Warhammer 40k Streamlined?

Transcript 10:14

in this video I'm going to talk about streamlining game systems and what it's done to 8th edition Warhammer 40,000 so I did a video quite some time ago about streamlining wargaming rules systems you can check it out up here pachow and a lot of people the comments were very interested in the comments there were a lot of people that were like yeah streamlining is good I only have so much time in the day that kind of stuff and then there were other people who said well you know but if you dumb down the system too much then I don't enjoy it and I like a crunchy rule set that's fun to me and so there was a lot of back-and-forth that way which totally makes sense because the answer to most things is usually as you know from watching this channel in the past it depends however with the new release of Warhammer 40000 eighth edition there's been a lot of streamlining there has been a lot of tweaking the rules the core rules system is in the book maybe what eight to ten pages something like that if you bought the starter box they gave you actually like an extra piece you know you got the rules anyway in the starter box but then you got this extra kind of like full you know pullout thing that's basically all the core rules they've really stripped things down in this new eighth edition of Warhammer 40000 and the question I guess is that was it really a good idea

predominantly yes now how you may judge what's good depends on your perspective obviously but in the perspective of a company that is owned publicly owned by shareholders it's been real good for them they have sold a lot and a lot and a lot of stuff because of the new eighth edition and it's mainly because I see people all the time now in the game store that I haven't played a game of 40k against in a very long time or I didn't even know played 40k and either they they never have and now they're getting into it or they're like oh yeah I know I used to play like in 3rd edition and I stopped a long time ago but now you know I'm coming back because the rule is really cool and it's easier and I enjoy it and blah blah and that's pretty much you know all across the board there are people out there who don't like 40k in general for what a reason and that's fine but for people who are vaguely interested in it they've kind of gotten the itch people who are you know used to do it and got tired of all the different problems I mean say what you will but seventh edition the last edition of 40k was dense there was a lot going on there admittedly you know the original 40k had a lot going on too but really seventh edition got to the point where it was becoming quite bloated there were so many different rule sets and so many different conflicting things tournament organizers had to go through all this work to try to figure out how to actually make it

competitive and fair and that's why they had to rip off the band-aid with eighth edition so from the standpoint of is it selling a lot more 40k stuff for Games Workshop the answer is yes I had a conversation during Gen Con with a Games Workshop employee and he said it did a lot better than we thought which is why right now it's difficult to find some specific things for 40k in your local shop whether it's an independent shop or even a four you know actual Games Workshop shop and it's difficult to find some of that stuff even on the website they've done quite well with this new edition it's brought people back into not just 40k but it's brought people back into the Hobby which you know me I'm all about that so in that situation the streamlining the thing that brought people back into it because it made the game perceived to be fun again yeah that was a big deal that was a smart move on their part now a lot of people have also it's not a lot some people have said they don't like the new edition of 40k because actually one comment I said I saw said that well now it's a baby game I don't even really know what that means but I think they're saying that because a lot of the rules have been simplified therefore it becomes a simple game and I have to disagree when age of sigmar first came out a lot of people had the same complaint they said we've turned it into a four page Rules document that kind of streamlining can't be good for

the game there's no strategy there's no and yet I keep seeing tournaments and I keep seeing people who played Warhammer Fantasy back in the day many of them who gladly now are playing Aegis Sigmar even in tournaments when you pull a lot of the extra extraneous stuff out of there and this is maybe just me I've felt that really crunchy rules systems the main benefit that a really crunchy rule system has is that the person who knows the rules the best every last little minut detail that person is more likely to win because they'll remember some specific loophole that will allow them to win again this is your mileage may vary this is my opinion and this is something that I have come across many times playing different people over the years where all of a sudden there's this thing that my opponent does and I go that's not and you look through and actually in the rules once you dig through 28 different paragraphs you find out yeah that's the thing you can do when you take a lot of that stuff out when you take those things out the more kind of things that you take out of a rule system the less loopholes very frequently you have available this old chestnut gets thrown around a lot in any kind of tabletop gaming but look at chess look at go very very simple rule systems yet you know some of the most strategic games out there I think that when you start to strip away the the minutiae of a lot of

these different rules you then have to really start to focus on the actual strategy when I'm setting up my forces in 8th edition 40k I have to remember well ok my my opponent has some terminators terminators can deep strike in I have to be very conscious of where I place my guys in the backfield so he doesn't have the 9 inch space to be able to drop his guys in because there's no more scatter anymore you know that when you when you want to deep stripe it deep strike in you just deep strike in so that kind of stuff you that's the strategy that's where you have to figure things out constantly trying to remember is that dangerous terrain or what kind of thing do I have to do here can this happen all those extra things in my mind when you strip a lot of that away it allows you to focus a lot more on the actual strategy and a lot less on the actual rules because really rules aren't strategy now the trick is however is it doesn't seem to necessarily work for everyone privateer press streamlined their rules which was actually kind of part of the subject of the original video that this this whole you know the one that I put out they mark three was supposed to be streamlined and that didn't necessarily catch the audience from what I understand sales have not been as crackers as they have with 8th edition 40k that's then now caused premature press to start working on a new skirmish game well it's not a new game it's the

same game it's it's it's the same stuff it's kind of almost a little bit like ages Sigma or skirmish Age of sigmar skirmish uses all the regular ages Sigma rules it just kind of limits some of them gives you some other little options but you can only use certain models certain units in the game this is the same thing with the new company of iron which is coming out soonish from cover to your press you can't use like big war jacks you can't use war casters you can only use I think like Jack Marshal's and smaller war Jack's and there's little things and there's limits and so that does the the idea is to not necessarily streamline although I think there's some of that but it's really again it's trying to get new players into the game again it goes back to that chess thing you know you can teach a little kid chess but you're probably gonna be able to stop them if you really want to over and over again until they get that strategic stuff kind of built up in their mind and can start to defend themselves I you shouldn't do that don't teach a five-year-old how to play chess and just stop them cuz that's just not nice first of all but the trick is is that simplifying rules to a degree obviously you don't want to completely just go down to we each roll a die and see who wins that's not I mean that's not much of a game I mean war with the cards that's that's not really a game specifically cuz there's not a heck of a lot of strategy in that but games like go which you have you know each side pretty much

you the black and the white and and the rules are pretty simple chess again rules are pretty simple but it's what you can do with them that really makes the difference between a pretty interesting game design sometimes interesting game designs can get too bogged down in rules versus a really good game design which can be elegant and have simpler rules but still have a really good effect and when you do that hopefully you make it so that people enjoy it and you make it so that you know maybe they buy more your product and then that's really kind of in the world of business which we have to remember tabletop wargaming is a business when you sell more product you're doing well

Progress saved