What's MISSING in my game?
Transcript
Are there any features which you wished were available in the game? This is one of the most valuable play testing questions that I've come back to over and over again during my first decade as a board game designer, and it's frequently made my games better. Today, I have 10 published games and more on the way. If a player or multiple players have a strong urge to take an action in your game which is not currently allowed within the rules, it might be worth considering whether the rules could be altered to allow it. Is there a reason that action is prohibited? Listen out for missed opportunities. If players try to do something that your game doesn't allow, pay attention. That tells you what they expect from your game. Sometimes a player misreads a rule and accidentally creates a better version of the game. Maybe ask, "If you could add a rule to this game, what would it be?"
This surfaces frustrations and hidden potential in your game. But take care though, cuz some players will start designing your game for you, introducing mechanical fixes or wild suggestions for radical changes to the game. That's your job, not theirs. The role of a play tester is to tell you how your current design feels. You decide what to change or not. For hundreds more play testing questions like this one and a rationale for each of them, pick up my book, Adam in Wales Play Testing, available now on Amazon.