Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wargame Archaeology: The Many Deaths of Wargaming

Transcript 1:00:39

all right are we live I think we're live hello to hello to everybody out there hopefully hopefully hopefully you can now see us we are a mere two minutes late you know I'm gonna take it that's fine I told everybody to show up an hour early so don't worry about it they've all been waiting here the whole time actually it's your fault thanks to Brent smart smart move Brent it's like always announce your stream uh one hour early so Brent is really in that game I'm usually 10 five 10 minutes late Brent is 1 hour late and that's like the yeah I think that's a smart move it's a sweet spot yeah yeah I mean it just really shows that you're important if people wait for you for a whole hour and then I hope nobody was waiting for us for a full hour if I was that important it would totally go to my head all right so um to officially get started uh hi I am Liz Davidson from Beyond solit I'm here with Fred servil from homo ludin and with Brandt from the armchair drons and we are here to talk about war game archaeology and in this case we're talking about the oldest of the old saws within our Hobby and that is the topic of War games are dying yeah because they've been dying from they were born just like all of us you know you're born and you begin to die that's also true of War Games we're gonna talk yeah I you expect that you would go uh so deeply philosophical so fast it's uh

you're always next level definitely next level uh so Brien um so yeah we're gonna see some collections from Brand's archives he's put together like a little uh slideshow for us of like Little Treasures he's collected over the years talking about the death of various Hobbies but especially War gaming what makes you collect this stuff like this is so handy and I would never think to do it so talk to us about your archal stuff I hang on to the the other ones I went and found just to you know as as a point I found those more recently I I wasn't holding on to those the wargaming stuff I hold on to just because I do find those kinds of archival pieces interesting um it's it's the same reason that on the Shelf back here I've got like 15 different company cataloges from over the years I've still got the classic 1981 TSR games catalog that came in all the red and blue box basic and expert sets because that for a lot of us that was like the the the Sears wish book you know that we're opening up oh man I want that game and I want that game I want that game and so that's you know uh a lot of those those archival pieces I really get a kick out of going back and seeing it's a lot easier to collect them now digitally right they don't really take up physical space so it's it's a lot easier to be a digital packrat than a real packrat so um but yeah the others the the non wargaming ones um they didn't take long to find but I wanted to pull them up just to to provide some perspective that that it's not just wargaming that that that is dealing with these crises and and to be

clear and Liz will pull stuff up here in a sec it's it's not so much that war games necessarily are dying but that the audience uh the issue of the the ages of the audience right the graying of the hobby is the term everybody loves to use and uh and the graying of the hobby has been going on since like 1978 as near as I can tell and and we're all still here like we're all still playing we're not running short of War Gamers there's there's still plenty of us around and uh and the the the joke that I've taken and making the last few years is um Everybody worries about you know where the next generation of War Gamers coming from AARP doesn't worry about where the next generation of retirees are coming from right AARP has been graying since it was founded it's still here so so speaking of the common phrase that's being used here is on the graying of the Hobby and I have really bad news for for myself especially which is that I am now contributing to the the gray of the hobby I've started to get like white hairs at the temple and I'm I'm now officially also part of the gray of the Hobby and I am young for a war gamer it's true but still still starting to gray you're still part of the problem have you crossed have you crossed that bridge yet are you still the only I've I've been gray for quite some years now I'm actually I think I'm older than what people would expect it's just that I I I look young on YouTube U Maybe i' I've been graying for for for quite a while but I still look dashing and

that's I think very dashing especially in hats yes especially not yeah I have a teenage daughter it's a wonder I have hair at all yeah but that does solve the problem of the grain of the hobby not having hair anymore so in a way that's a that's a hack Brant yeah that that was a bit of the commentary that showed up somewhere online where folks were talking about if you're bald you don't have to worry about going gray yeah pretty smart the the uh now it in terms of like being one of the younger folks in the room my first origins was in 05 and that's not I've been going forever like I there's people in the comments been going to Origins 15 years longer than that um but my first origins was in in ' 05 I was in my early 30s and and within a year or two I got Shanghai into to help and work with the war College where I was one of the speakers there and a panel moderator and and I was always the kid brother in the room right I I was always the the young guy in there with a bunch of the older folks trying to maintain order and Sanity in the panel discussions and and there was a running joke of you know having the pool for how quickly the Brandt will lose control of the panel in the seminar um because because again I was always the kid brother up at the table in in the front of the room I was the kid brother at the table for like 18 years I me they just there there weren't a ton of folks coming in behind us and and that's definitely changed in the last five to 10 years and and I'm glad

to see that because now I'm not the kid brother in the room anymore but but it it took quite a while I mean there's still you know when I show up at connections uh outside of the last two or three years as the the Georgetown University wargaming Society has pushed more and more younger folks towards the professional wargaming ranks I mean again I was pushing 50 and I was the young guy in the row so but what do you think has changed over the last five years so you say that there is more young people coming in right now do do you think there is a reason for that is it a structural reason is it because of specific games that entered our hobby what would you say actually drove that renewal of the I think it's a couple of things and and again my academic background is in quoid social science so I'm I'm throwing out random ideas with zero real evidence to back them up so so if anybody what we do yeah we've got some great anic data for y'all in a moment yes yes I'm I'm totally good for this this is exactly that um a couple of things one on the professional side I think there's been a much heavier push for um sort of organizing and sharing that information whether it's around the georget university wargaming Society folks or more people paying attention to pack Sims um better spread and information about opportunities for people to get engag AED on the professional side with some of the job postings that folks are sharing a lot more widely and then U Goose itself with

a lot of their public Outreach their their seminar series especially when that kicked off during the pandemic and everybody stuck at home with nothing to do anyway that that that definitely helped bring some attention on the professional side but those folks were interested in wargaming more widely than just as a potential job and that that bled over into the hobby side I think that definitely helped I see I see it from a different end which is in my like you know I'm a latecomer to wargaming yeah um given just you know I started playing them earlier you know but as a 2018 I was like I'm not really a war gamer and then within a couple years I was like all the way over the line but I think it's also because from the hobby side um we're getting I think a lot of interesting kind of crossover genre wise yeah so you know I would say things like undaunted are are very helpful like you know I was I played P's house is like one of the starter things for me was somebody like oh have you played P's house yet that was really cool and like I was starting to run across amel's games amabel Holland and so I got in kind of through that and like wanting to play games about ancient Rome and then before I knew it I was hooked so there's definitely changes on the professional side but I think also the hobby side making this yeah I I was definitely getting to the Hobby side of things I just I I the professional side I think is a little easier to pinpoint because there there's been two or three key moments within the last five years or so that have really made a difference on the professional side on the hobby side I think there's a bunch of different things one of them quite frankly is I

think there's a lot of folks playing things today that 25 30 years ago if we were playing those same things we would be flying the wargaming flag loud and proud but today folks are a little more hesitant to consider themselves War Gamers and and some of that is some 40K stuff some of that is the Star Wars X-Wing battles I mean a lot of these games have a very high toy factor to them um which is nothing wrong with that but things like the um uh the hordes and War Machine from Privateer Press um you know if we'd had some of those things growing up we'd have been playing those right alongside Gettysburg right alongside our D and D games you know whatever it may be I think the oh in some cases I think there's some Gamers that that 253 years ago would have been heavier War Gamers that are off playing Katan and Ticket to Ride and and carcassone and whatever because that's an option now that didn't exist in the 70s and 80s in the 70s and 80s you were playing Monopoly clue and sorry or you were playing war games because there wasn't a lot of middle ground and and that strategic noncombat Middle Ground didn't exist for a long time so I think we've we've lost some nent War Gamers to go do other things but I think we've got more people out there that are War gaming without calling themselves War Gamers that are

off playing Memoir 44 sandwiched between Ticket to Ride and carcassone yeah that are off playing undaunted same thing U that are off playing Star Wars attack wi again look you swap out the the the x-wings and Star Wars for by planes and you're playing dawn patrol right that's that's a World War I air combat game and everybody goes well damn that's a war game but even for Star Wars even without going doing that analogy Star Wars is a system that was originally a war game it was Wings Of Glory it was B ples exactly the same system was just adapted it's just that they realized they could reach out a different audience so uh so they expanded the system to like something that is that was IPL Le and I really like this idea brand that a lot of more people are actually War gaming without calling themselves War gamer and maybe this is what is dying like the necessity to call yourself a war gamer is not relevant anymore in a market where we have serious or more engaged games that and people can jump from one things to one thing to another a heavy economic game a war game which in a weird way when we look back at the general that was the whole strategy of Avon Hill they were making board games for mature board games for an adult public and they didn't really focus necessarily on war games they made economical games they made sports game and actually we leave in the dream of the founders of avadon Hill right now we leave their dream where we have that range of mature game that we can uh explore and we don't have to limit ourselves to being War Gamers uh it doesn't make actually even sense

if you look at what the founders were trying to do so yeah oh look late 80s there's still ads in the general for Avalon Hill say you know why are we bringing you four different football board games you know um so so this was something they' done for a long time I I'll tell you if you can dig it up if you can find a copy they're damn impossible to find uh why cheat and steel from Avalon hill was a blast of a game it's dirty tricks and politics and it is a riot I mean it it would be a killer today it'd be a ton of fun yeah all right we're going to slides yeah do it and then we can come back to this because I want people to see these this stuff and enjoy it and I know that uh Brent your schedule's tight so making sure that we yeah me too I have uh have exactly 60 minutes so in 45 I have actually my schedule's less tight now that we're starting at the time you guys were intending us to start not the one I was wrong about a little better off so so some of these slides and I'm not sure how how readable some of these things are going to be because they're a little small but but one of the things that I found is there are there are a bunch of different Hobbies out there that are all dealing with this existential crisis of everybody's getting older this one is one about um hot rod car sort of you know muscle cars and classic car collecting and restoring that they've got concerns this one's from uh from from the hemings website which is heavy on um sort of model car restaur not model cars like little remote control ones but like classic car restoration

and hot rods and muscle cars and whatever and and they're dealing with the graying of the hobby um what do we got what's the next slide in here that we've got all right also um Mike will come back to your giveaway at the end also I'll make sure to plug to plug it all right so yes coin world so numismatics I like numismatics yeah coin collectors are dealing with the fact that we don't have a lot of kids interested in the hobby these days you know the the the car restoration folks are are you know their hobby is graying the coin collector hobby is graying what's our next one is the next one the astronomy guys or they uh this one's the hot rods again oh is it hot rods again and then here we have yeah here's more hot rods and classic cars um this one is uh I think yeah there's our there's our astronomers so and what's funny with the astronomers is that they are actually making the same points as you were earlier uh Brent that actually the pandemic helped fighting the graying of the hobby because people were more at home uh and actually had more time to you know explore what they like and everything and I'm wondering if there is the grin of the hobby this thing I'm wondering if it's just not a reflection or a symptom that something that is wider is that we leave less time to people to actually enjoy themselves today like there is too many competing like things for the free time that we

have we're probably more involved in our work because we're always connected so you have a less strong connection we have access to Too Much entertainment probably ready available on streaming and everything and I'm wondering if there is not this and then when you suddenly uh stay stuck at home home and you want to do something else than just looking at a screen all time then you ReDiscover the fact that hobby hobbying is actually something that is good for your also your sanity and something like this like is there um maybe something in there that is more like structurely uh happening in society that makes it so that we just have less time for hobbies generally and spend more time consuming media without actually engaging with it so I think there's definitely something to that also I just want to appreciate by the way that astrophotography is definitely Sheltering in space nerds I love it but um I okay so I definitely overwork and I feel like a lot of people I mean I'm an elder Millennial right uh and I feel like everybody talks about oh be on the grind you need to like you know even our Hobbies get monetized now um you know all those sorts of things um I kind of feel like it's hard to you know war games are a commitment to time if you're playing like the really chunky ones and you have to find people to do it with if you're not a solo gamer like me and so you just kind of like I think it's hard to fit it into your life until like

actually I wonder so I know that people think about Avalon Hill is something that you know oh so it started with teenagers now everybody's old but I actually wonder if what happened is that you have a heavy gaming phase when you're a teenager and you have time and then you have that phase again then when you're older and your kids are grown up and you're contemplating retirement or have retired because your time distribution throughout your day is has changed again does that make sense like I wonder if people just blip out for their their career Pursuit years and then they you're not the first person to anecdotally notice that that it's it's a lot easier to keep a game set up on a table for more than you know a 4our session when when you can tell a 13-year-old to stay away expect them to leave the room versus telling a 13-month-old to stay away when they don't understand what you're saying so yeah um so yeah that that is I think you're on to something in that the way in which we've allocated our Leisure Time Has Changed and there are Hobbies today that are different than the Hobbies we had 20 30 50 years ago and and folks may not be coming around as much to those things one of the other things that I did notice in most of the the places where I found something about people having a problem with the graying of the hobby is that these are not cheap hobbies and that at a certain point somebody's got to be bankrolling what you're doing now

when you're a kid you may have some parents that are investing some in you being able to partake in these Hobbies whether it's Christmas gifts or birthday gifts or you know just randomly supporting what you're doing as opposed to in your 20s when you're just worried about renting gas you know and food maybe a distant third and so then you know by the time you get to your 40s you've now got some disposable income to jump back into those Hobbies you enjoyed as a kid so it's not just a Time factor I I think there's a definite money factor involved in the examples that I was pulling up here so yeah and like I know that you say your teenage daughter might have left you with gray hair brand but she's now a teenager which means that you probably have more time to game as well at least I'm just I'm gonna get decided not to have kids so I'll just be able to game all the way through no problem well and and and my daughter will say like last night we pulled out Ticket to Ride New York and me and my wife my daughter sat on and played a game quick before she had it off to bed but we uh we are definitely a board gaming family and have a bunch of them on the shelves anybody that was at Origins last year met my teenage daughter uh because she was our intern helping you know with admin tasks around our booth at Origins um you'll see her again this year because she wants to come back and do it again so so she's she's around um in terms of the graying of the wargaming hobby this is where a lot of this stuff kicks in and so these are these are a variety of things over a number of years because you'll see some of the years noted down

below this one was was written in the early 2000s by Greg kikian and a lot of folks I'm sure have already seen this and read it it's not hard to find a farewell to hex's somewhere on on the web um but you know know Greg says War Games died back in 96 um I'm not sure he's right but he was probably at the time he wrote this it was probably a defensible position now what's happened in the 20 odd years since he wrote this it's changed quite a bit but at the time he was writing this you could have made a case for it because again as he said he's he's walking around conventions and not seeing any new war games in the 90s what seeing is people playing 1970s Z war games yeah so so that was his point his point was that in the late 90s people were playing game from the 70s and how true is that I'm just wondering like is it just the kind of uh circles that he was in because I don't think there were necessarily a gap in production uh I think in the late 90s uh GMT was entering probably the field there was definitely a gap in production there was a gap in production yeah because the the Avalon Hill at R so SP had already been sucked up by TSR and that was right after TSR had been sucked up by waty and and watsy wasn't touching any of the SPI owned War gam stuff that t

the TSR owned SPI property right so now you've gone through like three sales there Avalon Hill was literally on its last legs GMT was just ramping up and had two three maybe four games under their belt gdw stuff you could still find but they weren't printing anything new the the classic companies that war Gamers of my era grew up with were gone and the Next Generation that we're all playing with now hadn't fully appeared yet so so no wargaming in the late 90s was was a non thing you couldn't F if you were finding it it was on used game shells now that does mean there was no war gaming at all you know Hasbro was public in battlecry back then so you could still play a commands and colors Civil War Game and and you'll still find plenty of people that are mad they won't republish battle cry because it was a great game but but compared to what else you could find on the shelves at the time it was hard to find War Games the other thing that happened in the late 90s is you had several Distributors go out of business with the first collectible card game Crash and so now it's not that that the collectible card game CR directly affected the war games but without a distributor through which you could push the war games to retail stores there was no way to get them out and folks had to go direct to the market that was actually interestingly enough we we we managed to dig it up um looking for something else but we managed to dig

up um what we think is the first P 500s from a war game company and that was GMT and 98 putting a couple of games on p500 I don't have that right in front of me where I want to note actually I want to something really quick so also War Games died in 1996 Katan was published for the first time in 1995 is that correct uh so but I don't think I I think that's when it was published in Europe I don't think it made it to the states yet right well what I mean is what's so interesting right is he's declaring the death of something before I would say the rise of modern hobby board games as any of us knows it yeah regardless of whether we're playing war games or not so like a lot of these games are still here right D and D Magic like gerps is kind of it's there you know I don't know anybody who's serious about gerps at this point like on a like a m how many role players are you hanging out with at all not very many but what I mean is that like what's really interesting right is that even this stuff like you can see like these things are a lot of these are still around but there's been there's been such development since this time like he did not know what was about to explode into the world over the next few decades Fred were you g to go somewhere similar yeah so what I was thinking I was I was just looking at uh the production because because I remember that for um uh for SD Easton uh I was uh working on on something with Harold regarding uh looking statistically at working production uh over time and looking at how it evolved

using PGG data and I didn't necessarily see a big gap in the 90s it was probably not moving as fast as the other decades but and when I'm looking back I'm like looking at the 90s as a decade to see okay what games were released within that decade and how did they influence the Hobby and I mean there are some pretty Heavy Hitters there is path of Glory Hannibal um battlecry I mean battlecry this is a big shift for the hobby for the people uh you've got breakout number so the um like one of the biggest uh one of the biggest uh at at the time one of the biggest area impulse with the people so the oparation of cdgs uh great battles of Alexander which was massive published We the People what year was it published and by who so we the people in 1993 uh Avon Hill okay Avon Hill was dead within five years yeah but it means that in the 90s you had like breakthrough in terms of game design and maybe battle you absolutely did so in terms of production stuff were happening in the 90s so I I feel weird like if I was in the 90s a war gamer and I saw appear with the people I saw appear battlecry I saw appear path of story like I would I wouldn't say oh War gaming is dying I would be impressed by the it feels like the late 90s was full of innovation and most of the big games that we know today were released then and actually their influence keep like having an impact right now and you also had the

gamers that were publishing in the 90s and actually yeah Mike is just pointing it out you look at D6 stuff like Tunisia the first version was released in 95 or 96 like you had some pretty big uh accent counter games that were quite critical some SS some Wass so I'm like I'm looking at this article and I'm looking at what was the production back then I was like there was a renewal of hex encounter there was new mechanics coming up there was the beginning of the one of the most influential sh series of the hobby which was comments and colors and I'm like like I look at this I'm like well this is just a pessimistic [ __ ] you know it's like it's not factual it's not factual it's just yeah it's absolutely factual for the problem was you couldn't buy them anywhere because the the distribution had collapsed first of all the companies disappeared right Avalon Hill was gone within five years of publishing We the People the companies disappeared The Gamers never got into actual distribution they were always direct to Market they they were always either direct to the to the game stores or direct to the consumer I don't think I alth now we have kick if the gamers ever went through distribution houses it was for a very limited time uh MMP had had you know just taken off but wasn't really there yet GMT was just starting and then almost died within the first five years so some of these things existed but they were really hard to find what collapsed was you couldn't walk into toys RS and go pull squad leader off the shelf and and so so as as cosian is

writing this he's not wrong in that wargaming had largely disappeared from the public sphere that didn't mean people weren't playing that meant you couldn't find it unless you you really wanted to and were going to dig around for it what that means is you're not going to get casual people wandering into the room so MMP didn't almost die GMT almost died and and Jean and Tony have talked about it in the past about the fact that they almost went under and there were a couple of of quick business decisions between P 500s and a and and got lucky on a couple of hits that saved the company but hey the good news is that yeah we're not gonna regardless regardless of uh perceptions here War gaming live long enough to die several more times yeah oh yeah yeah let's let's let's keep going through here so here's 1990 yeah and these aren't necessarily in chronological order they're kind of in the order I dug them up yeah yeah so we're basically talking about yeah this is actually this is sort of an interesting comment because I feel like somebody could have said this today like Fred Fred and I have been this little Deja Vu path before but like oh we've matured we wanted better looking and more demanding games than what we started with but that doesn't mean the games are actually better yeah I love the decline of the Roman Empire which by the way is also now not accepted by historians as like a natural narrative at all so you know um we've got another the

general uh War gamers are dinosaurs a blip in history hang on starting hting here uh oh friend is yours yeah I I can see the I can see the slide for the my slides haven't moved I'm still on farewell to hex's are you oh no no we're on the general 25th anniversary issue that's what everybody in the audience sees right well they're ahead of me just making sure yeah I don't know what's going on all right I'm I'm G to go off of the YouTube thing on my side screen here so I'm look like I'm not even looking at you guys so is the is the 25th anniversary is of the general is that the one that's right after [ __ ] in there yeah so so this issue of the general had essays from a whole lot of different folks so there's essays from from Greenwood and uh and zaky and a bunch of other people in here so so that's that's where a couple of these Quotes come from and I'm not going to try to read them verbatim but but they definitely talk about changes in the demographics in the Hobby and and the bottom one is talking about um you know youthful audiences of the 60s and 7s became gamers in the 30s and 40s and older but it talks about not having another generation come in behind them this was written in 88 that they're talking about the graying of the hobby right we're 35 years later and the Hobby's still getting gray right now you know we're we're we're supposed lot of War Gamers here yeah um but don't you think that there is at the core like a bias in the in in the people writing

this like the people who are writing this are people who've been in the hobby for a very long time and actually what's gray is not the necessarily the hobby but just the people surrounding them and maybe they don't realize that they are not just interesting interacting with the rest of the Hobby and they are just within their own uh St yes no part of it is a bunch of these guys writing are guys that worked for Avalon Hill either helping sell games for the company or helping run the conventions so they were in a place to actually interact with that audience um Liz I'm I'm G to steal the screen from you if I can here for just a second because yeah absolutely go for it here I'm just going to switch it so it's like let me switch it to just us and then I'll add you into the stage you're on stage yeah this is this is also from that same issue of the general that 25th anniversary issue where it's talking about why isn't our high schooler playing a war game today and it lists some of the reasons again these were the reasons from 88 computer War Games waylaying the novices Graphics of most novel level War Games frankly can't compare with what they're used to in video game arcades right third the players who try Advanced Computer War Games find that days of player required to finish the game but that they're not going to take that long to play tabletop games and then when they do try Advanced board war games they end up spending more time arguing over the rules than playing which one of those reasons is no longer valid today every single one of them still is

yeah well we do have better graphics now in tabletop board gaming we do have better graphics now I think we we yeah but I think that's fair um but then again I feel like in a in an era where uh computer are so prevalent in every aspect of Our Lives I feel like actually board games have a better case for themselves now more than ever in a weird way because actually they're proposing an alternative to something that we were confronted and we don't necessarily want to like it's not like uh computers are not a hobby anymore like they are we have to be in front of them most of the time and we actually want to avoid them as much as we can so in a way I think this became a strength I would say for board gaming in general that it actually provides fun enjoyment interaction um uh and a fun play experience uh with something that is not a screen uh that is being that is involved actually in the in the process so in that sense the situation changed because I guess in the 80s the relationship with computers for the the mass um most of the people has radically changed them to what it is today so I think there is the context slightly changed in that in that regard um trying to go back to the slides it's just I just uh I'm on the side so I love this one Fred you see it right it's like the way to actually yeah it's all black on my side no I can see it black on the YouTube yeah I guess if it's if it's if it's uh not yeah not broadcasting for us

it might not be broadcasting for the other let me remove it stop sharing yep you can see me right yeah yeah we can see you everything is working it might have just got mad yeah it's black screen in the chat too yeah okay share screen let's try it again gray.pdf can you'all see it again yeah here all right so we were here uh but I just kind of went back by another gr of the hobby from 1993 yeah yep so this is 93 slide cancelled yes exactly I canel it but go go back to the the 93 one real quick one of the notes Here is it is a question of asked in Hobby periodicals lamenting the gray of the hobby so they're they're in in 9 referencing other people also talking about this so it's not like this was just a one-off bit of discussion you know 30 years ago this was this was a real conversation yeah but I love this doing okay because they provide a rare example of the best method for C being the graay of the Hobby in other words have a child and force them also look how Progressive they've gotten an understanding of War gameing to his or her children oh this changed if you remember the general from the 60s that we're reading that's a big shift yeah that's actually a really big shift yeah it's it's interesting that when the market comes under tension it's like people become more inclusive all of a sudden it's like oh wait a minute let's open up to to to uh to new audiences that's good I guess yeah it's you know you know I'll take it yeah and then

orgaming then continue to survive so that it could die again in 2006 yeah so in in uh' 06 what do we got yeah this this one's from armchair General magazine and so Michael pek is actually a defense journalist who covers a lot of wargaming topics also he writes for Business Insider and foreign policy now I I know Michael Michael's a good dude um but one of the things he was talking about is it's a hobby of graying Boomers who increasingly find it difficult to find opponents for face-to-face play man you again you go back through those older magazines and it was hard in the 60s to find people for face tof face play that's not new easier now because it's easier to throw stuff up online and say hey I need somebody to play so yeah I actually want to come around to that um I don't want to I want to make sure we get through our slides just people see them but I do want to talk I personally I truly believe that the internet is fantastic for wargaming yeah I absolutely convinced that YouTube the ability to look at games through channels the ability to watch people play them uh the rise of solo gaming but also the rise of things like vassel vassel and yeah you know rally the troops you know we we have more options than ever to find each other and I'm firmly convinced that that is gonna that's gonna get us through a lot yeah yeah and like as of right now I am I'm in three uh asynchronous games on right the troops right now like I have no issues in fighting someone to to play

with and I think that's probably the biggest shift I think it has always been a challenge to find people to play with and we see it in the early issues of the general like most of the most of the uh most of the big part of the content of the magazine was actually finding players for uh PBM so so uh uh like playing over actual mail not email but that was a big thing and it's definitely a challenge that we're struggling with um less and less uh and I guess the fact that you can play on a computer makes it also look closer to uh to uh to maybe like a video game maybe brings in a new audience because the barer turn three is maybe a bit easier especially with rule enforced uh Solutions like ready the troops I think that for me I did need see that in five years from now if that platform continues to develop the way it's doing with this really fine curation of game and everything it might be actually um uh have an impact on the hobby that we don't necessarily foresee uh I think it's yeah it's it's something that is definitely solving the main issue that we have as a community which is as you said Liz finding each other uh and spending some time playing with each other I'm up to six different asynchronous Civ six games at this point yeah that's a lot a few but again when you're only checking in one turn per day right turns per day over the six games that's that's what we try to average or more if you're in a meeting yeah yeah at some point I

lose I I I I if there were too many I lose strike and I remember the week where andan abys was released on ready the troops I just went a bit overboard and I think I had five or six game of andan abys at the same time playing different faction in all of them and I was getting a bit confused at some point I was I was just too excited with for the game being there but yeah and I've never played as much like I played on R the troops I'm probably four or five times men yeah much than than the actual physical copy of the game so War gaming died again in 2011 we lamented its graying um this one was more focused on min's wargaming but still same problem I guess this one makes me think of my grandfather actually so what's interesting is all these old Hobbies make me think of my relatives who are older in the family so you know my grandfather has an entire room dedicated to model trains and he loves to paint like War Miniatures not Min as small as you might see in like a in a modern board game but he's got these beautiful like Napoleonic painted Miniatures and all this kind of stuff he loves coin collecting my great-grandmother also did um and all these little things that have to do with motors and engines but what I noticed about these is these require money and they require space and I really you know I live in an apartment and I just have to do my best but I would really probably get more gaming in if I had a house so I have a house and I actually had so I've got a dining room table up here in my office with me that I don't get to use throughout the month of

December because that becomes the gift wrapping station for the family oh no but the rest of the year I can put a game up there and leave it set up like if we still had a cat I'm cat proof out here in my office right you know I'm I'm out over the garage here so so I'm fine um but even that's a four-seater dining room table and there's only so many games I can set up on it and leave yeah but that said you know one of the things that that came up in one of the online comment somewhere you know people just don't have place to play anymore man when I was a kid growing up playing I don't think we ever I I can't ever remember a single time where we didn't put a game on a table because we didn't have the space for it every single time we wanted to play something we could find somewhere to put it yeah right it might have been on the floor of a bedroom and we had to pick it up by the end of the day but we yeah that's what I was about to say as a kid you can play anywhere like if you ask me to play uh I don't know I just got downfall and I don't have a ble to fit it in if I had to play downfall on the floor like my back would kill me and I would be like justay like laying around in pain for the following downall that's absolutely true of us today but when somebody's saying you know one of the reasons kids aren't playing is they don't have anywhere to play n man I mean we always found a place to play growing up so these are all Snippets from from folks comments online in different places that uh you know over the years of of folks saying you know hey this this graying of the hobby thing's been going on for a while so I mean that the whole thing is we've been talking about this for at least 35

years and again we haven't run out of War Gamers yet so no this whole idea of the the graying of the hobby yes War Gamers tend to Trend older all you gota do is look around a room full of War Gamers to know that but I don't think we're lacking for people coming up to play behind us I think we could do a better job of helping encourage them I think we roll to play a war game with you don't that's not your friend group that's not where you're naturally pulling from unless you're related to them somehow so that's you know as as the folks that have been around for 25 30 40 Years playing War Games you're playing with the people you grew up with and unless you're related to the 22 year olds you're not going out actively trying to find 20 hey fella want to play a war like that's not happening that's so creepy Brandt you can't do that that's why nobody's doing it but the other thing is you know what's I actually I think that Brent you've said a lot of things that are super very true one I think is that when you talk about friend groups right the the people who have been playing together for 35 years probably don't know where to find the um the 18y olds who are doing it their way right they're doing it their own way they're finding their own way of meeting up and socializing and it might not look the same right but it would you know I think it's really really natural that uh steuart's wandering around OCS Maps hanging in his

TR but I also think that what you said about people defining themselves also makes a lot of sense like I think I'm a war gamer is something different from I play a whole bunch of games some of which could be considered war games and we're kind of in like a self-de era of conflict and I mean Hey kid one Supply rules but um you know I think what's going on too is that I I think that we might have fewer people saying I'm a war gamer and that's who I am and that's what I do but that doesn't mean that those people aren't going to be playing war games and I also think that that is something that you know as you know like how many Charles S Roberts discussions have we sat through at this point about like what is a war game and what counts and what doesn't count and who gets to be included and ET um you know we're fighting you want to be off the stream in 15 minutes don't go down that road no no I'm just saying like those are conversations yeah I I'm just saying right like you know we're having conversations about who we are and who's included and who counts and it I think a lot of the life of wargaming depends on how broad your definition is because to me we're in a golden age historical gaming is everywhere there's so many interesting games to play Zenobia 2 is going on so like I'm I'm feeling like my cup run over right now I'm really happy with what I've got I would suspect even the most gatekeep of the the old school hex

encounter Zuber Alis grognard's would still argue that we are in a relative Golden Age of War gaming given the the you know the buffet of options that we've got before us these days that that you know again your your your title screen was you know wargaming is dying again I I don't know that anybody's looking around at wargaming going man wargaming is D War Gamers might be dying but I don't think and that's not necessarily A Bad Thing Brent like that's it might it might be good for the hobby uh that a few of them die that's the but uh to be fair I think it's a really good point that what you're saying isz is like so who's like if we Define a war gamer as someone who play war games I think we probably never had as many War Gamers as today I mean look at Star Wars rebellion I would would definitely qualify this as a war it's called Star Wars Star Wars yeah no but but but I mean it does contain actually even in its DNA in terms of of design it does contain a lot of um a lot of um War gaming DNA I think there is like a lot of cdgs that are being released right now like Battle of Versa is a great example that was released recently but uh I mean 13 days was a good example water and all this and all of those people who are playing this wouldn't consider themselves they may don't don't make it part of their identity to be a war gamer but they do play those games and we just have more war Gamers than ever we have more war

games than ever but we still have people who are complaining or worried or gatekeeping and Brent you're saying even the most gatekeeper is not going to say that there is anything at risk I would say actually that's I'm not sure that's true you do have they argue that war gaming as a hobby is changing and and a lot of them don't like that and that's I'm not here to make or refute that argument today all I was saying is that even the people that would come into this discussion with a super narrow definition of what is a war game are still going to look around at the available options in the market and think holy [ __ ] I got a lot to choose from and and my my options for what to play in terms of topic scale playtime Graphics publisher designer any of that stuff is light years ahead of where we were in 197 or 1983 like even if you come at this with the most narrow possible definition of what is a war game You' got a [ __ ] ton of choices to to to pick and choose from yeah and uh and if you're thinking about and we're talking about this off stream in the introduction even if you look at smaller publisher and the the possibilities for production like if you want like at the material aspect like the the opportunity for people to push things out there I think it has never been the low like for publishing the the barrier to entry has never been lower than this so I think in all aspects production the number of Gamers like the all of the stuff that we have I feel like it's it's pretty we're

living a pretty amazing time so I think we should make the best out of it and I yeah uh yeah the uh th those barriers to entry have have largely in terms of being a a game producer that collapse is within the last 10 to 15 years because when I was making a go of it as a publisher in the mid 2000s um look there's a reason I'm not anymore right I wasn't very good at it and it wasn't near as much fun as I thought it was goingon to be but one of the reasons it wasn't near as much fun is that a lot of the print on demand capabilities if if Steve had opened blue panther in 2005 I might still be in business as a publisher working through him because what he's able to do today and and make it so seamless for a small press publisher like Holland Spiel catastrophe red sash white dog pick them like all of these dudes um and and the other people that have followed a similar business model there there are a couple other companies doing print on demand like blue panther that that to be able to put out a solid competent quality production like that on demand is incredible is incredible is so far ahead of the the the very bad versions of what I was able to do in ' 050607 and I was getting counters professionally printed and and and and uh and diecut but the stuff he can do is so much better that change has come

within the last 10 to 15 years yeah and it's it's a great change like I'm I'm not slagging on it at all it's just that is as recent as literally anything else we've got except the rally of the troops TTS world so yeah yeah and like also just because Mike uh brought up one of our um one of the greats of our hobby who's been such a big part of of the community I also think it's important like one thing that's really I think wonderful about this particular era is that you know Mark has a channel where he's like sharing going through his game collection and putting up his games like you know Fred and I are looking back at war game archaeology from our perspective as people who don't have that experience but we're also still in a really amazing era where people who have been around since the beginning like since the Laur was written right are still are still here and willing to share with us like what they have experienced and what they knew and I really think that this is a cool time because we're at a cross-section where especially the internet has made possible um you know this this kind of blend between you know people who are more new school and who' have come in more recently and the people who are from the old school who are still sharing knowledge with us you know all the way through I think it's really neat we have an incredible archive and set of perspectives yeah I Brad hessle who used to help you know worked at SPI in his early 20s lives here in town with me and and uh we've had more than a couple of

beers on occasion here and there um haven't talked a ton of wargaming he's just a fun dude to hang out with but but yeah those guys are absolutely still around and and more often than not are willing to entertain the questions that you have for them of hey tell me what it was like in the old days um you know how did you go about making some of these decisions what were some of the things you did what' you like what' you not like what what's changed for the better for the worse um they they're all more often than not pretty willing to talk to you about these things yeah um and and I don't necessarily know that it's some sort of you know oh we must pass this you know sacred information on to the next gener I I think they're just you know mostly nice and a people who are happy to tell a story to you yeah but I as a historian see it as like ah yes I will this this information that will become sacred when people can't get it anymore one of the most fun times I ever had at a game convention was at Gen Con and' 06 when a couple of us ended up in a bar with Bob bledsaw before he passed away he was one of the guys that founded judges Guild back in the 70s and Bob just telling War Stories of the early days of role playing and there were three or four of us that just kept buying Bob drink so we could keep him talking we got like five hours of Great War Stories out of him um you know nobody had anything to record it on nobody was trying to publish it or you know or or live streaming or anything we just you know Bob was an interesting dude telling great stories so yeah and actually that's one

of the thing that I've been pretty happy with since we started this uh war game Archy series is actually um uh like the uh a part of the hobby that has been here sometimes since the 60s but most often started also in the 70s uh a bit younger than the one who started really really from the uh from the from the beginning has been have been reaching out and actually being very uh encouraging about the initiative and the thing that is really cool is that a lot of them have put in a lot of work to document things archive things give access uh to those things the fact that we can go through the general all in PDF that's awesome there is a lot of other magazines that also have been archived uh there is a very nice guy who reached out to me on B actually had scanned the the catalogues from Avalon Hill and over the years just to see how they were portraying the different games and everything and it's just so cool to see that like this eagerness to also share those things and everything and I think there is so much to be done and I do believe there is a lot to to learn about those old games all the time in the Obie but also how people engage with the games like the actual people that were going through those times I think is super interesting uh I'm still playing dday since uh so that's the thing uh so that's so that's pretty cool and expect actually some uh stream of old games uh coming soon uh in the in the future but I think it's I really like that the fact that there is this um it creates spaces for conversation that I think are are

super interesting both as a player as a designer but also just to talk to people that I wouldn't necessarily we wouldn't necessarily have met uh in another context and just having them share their stories and and what they went through is is is just so cool I think it's um I think it's really great I'm happy we we started doing this I think that's really nice yeah I would say this has made my experience of playing war games a lot richer yeah I feel like I have a greater sense of context for what I'm doing and like I probably would have still just been happy not knowing some of the stuff that I've been knowing now but I I think that you know learning your history always kind of enriches right what you're doing in the present at least that's true for me yeah yeah so yep you know oh where did Brent go did he disappear on us yeah Brent disappeared he said [ __ ] it I've done I've said what I had to say he he said that he was hungry and that we was going to have dinner too late because of us and I think he was really eager to just go and and and and eat something which is fair yeah and at some point he's back let's just slander him for a second before I put him in kiding he's back he's back now there's not much you're going to say that other people hadn't already said about me just today oh man no I uh I I had a pair of links I was trying to share in here so I got come on Liz you gotta you gotta let the links through I I can't control that part are you trying to put them in the chat yeah I was trying to um there's the

private chat or if you send it to me on Discord I can put in the comments chat all right there's one of them oh yeah okay I can put it on if you want L yeah yeah if you're signed in Friday you can go for it yeah but um yes so out of respect for everybody's time we've got a couple links coming in I want to make a couple of announcements one is that uh Meandering Mike who has joined us for our stream uh asked if he could talk about a giveaway on his channel uh which is it's Meandering Mike's man cave if I recall correctly uh and Mike the um the giveaway is gonna end on Tuesday is that correct so if you're out there I'll pop it up for you I think that was what he said earlier and we cannot share links in the in the chat I got I can I can share things in the YouTube chat because I'm logged in over here yeah so I am putting a couple of links in for yall I'm trying to find Mike's comments but I think it was Thursday or Tuesday I don't remember one of the two he just he threw he just threw it in the chat that it's Tuesday uh Tuesday night so Tuesday night so if you want to go do a g a giveaway go check it out gotta support other war game channels all part of the same crew uh and we have a couple of links in the chat from brand that should open a new T allegedly yeah it's just it it's from our TBT columns from Throwback Thursdays with some of the folks looking back at the 82 and 74 Avalon Hill cataloges so see R Russ

knows oh man um but uh Fred I don't know when we're doing our next installment of horror game archaeology but we definitely just think soon I actually would like to see those scans of cataloges or some sent us a dissertation that looked really good too oh did I send it to you already no you still need to sent to me but I was very curious about the the the blurb keep nagging me for me to send you the stuff but yeah I I I I got that everyone that PhD test is about um uh yeah it's an analysis about actually the war game community in a specific area in the US over a specific period of time paper I'm not sure it's not a paper it's really uh it's really uh it's 300 pages so it's there there's a dude who's at one of the universities in Finland that recently published oh the short one yes we had linked it to Tuesday news day where he had done a bunch of structured interviews with folks about sort of how you found opponents and and built up your sense of community within the wargaming community over the years yes and he anonymized everybody in the paper what's funny is there's if you've been around wargaming long enough you can read through it and you you can attach names to who a lot of those people yeah Rex Martin yeah you're yeah that's that's the one yeah now this this isn't Rex Martin this is Chris aot is the guy that I'm talking about um and Rex Martin I can tell you what is the topic of his uh so it's called cardboard warriors uh it was published in 2001 okay uh and and and let me get

a uh yeah and it's the RIS and full of the American war gaming subculture from 1958 to 1999 so there so so there there there is this idea that it collapsed uh in the in the late 90s so that must be a pretty interesting yeah and it was through it yeah it really did and and and it was so I grew up playing just quick note here I grew up playing war games with with my father I'm I'm one of those Second Generation War Gamers right Dad was dad was playing War games dad was cool I wanted to be cool like Dad I wanted to play war games and and I didn't know what I was doing for a bunch of them I was kind of helping push counters around felt good about it but as I as you know I I learned from him and got a lot better at it I grew up in the military moved around a lot a lot of War Gamers at every base we went to I left for college in 1990 and came out through Roc and joined the army in 94 in the four years I was in college the war Gamers disappeared in the military they were gone you could not find them anywhere of any kind and I didn't start running into real war Gamers again until the the early 2000s when I left uh for Ohio to go to grad school and a lot of that was because those War Gamers had the Columbus area board game Society infrastructure to work around and then Origins right there in town um but I we're not talking just one local place I was living in Columbia South Carolina at the time I was

regularly traveling to Tidewater Virginia no shortage of military folks couldn't find the war Gamers traveling to California on a regular basis traveling to Louisiana on a regular basis could not find the war Gamers anywhere and that that was most of the 90s they just they were gone and they all came back which is great but but the lived experience was you had a hard time finding War Gamers from 93 to about 99 so I I'll go through this and I will send the link to you uh Liz but it's funny because so in his dissertation he's actually making the argument the problem was Gen X uh and oh no that don't do not go at Gen X they are tough I would not no yeah so yeah but anyway I have to I have to go now it's been an hour yes yes we must go but this is we should do this again and uh we'll be back in touch with when when we'll be back for some more uh war game archaeology so War gaming is dead Long Live War gaming and we'll see y'all next time yeah see you soon everyone bye everybody bye bye thanks again Brent

Progress saved