Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 19:38

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, if you ask me, those Russian nesting dolls are pretty full of themselves. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Axis and Allies Stalenrad from Renegade Game Studios.

around. Uh-huh.

in Access and Allies. Stalenrad from Renegade Game Studios. Two players take on the roles of either the Vermacht or the Red Army as they battle for supremacy in the city of Stalingrad in 1942 1943. Now, I'm not going to get into the weeds of this review. Of course, uh Access Analysis has been around for a while. I'm going to tell you some of the basics of how this version works and then tell you what I think. Now, first of all, you have two game boards. you actually have the board of kind of the the the Dawn River leading to toward the Vulga. And then of course you have a board of the city of Stalingrad itself. These are both full-size boards. And they kind of handle this well because if like uh one infantry unit goes into the city, it becomes two infantry units and only two infantry units can leave and they instantly just become one infantry unit.

So that's kind of handled very well. Now there are two game scenarios you can play here. First of all, you can play as the Germans advancing along the dawn toward the Bulga River in kind of the wider environs of the area and then advancing and engaging into the city itself. And then you can play the operation Uranus scenario which begins several turns into it in which the Soviets have launched their attempt to encircle the sixth army in Stalenrad and then the Germans can kind of start reinforcing as normal. More on that later, but essentially how the game works is uh you have for the first time here that I know of in an Access Analysis game these order cards. And essentially there are 14 order cards, 14 phases of the game, and you essentially just kind of flip them over every time you you do them and follow them through. Now, the first order card calls for a winter uh roll. Essentially, you're going to roll the dice. After about turn six, I believe you roll the dice to determine if it's good weather or bad weather. If it's bad weather, your aircraft are a lot less effective. Essentially, they're not able to fight. Next, you have access reinforcement. Now, at the beginning of the game, before Operation Uranus is launched, um the Germans can't really reinforce like they can in a standard access and allies game. Essentially every other turn you will get a a supply token or you will get a single infantry unit that will come in from the uh left side of the board uh the western side of the board and then you know you can use

that but there's not a lot going on there. Now after Uranus and Winter Storm a few turns later you can start spending your IPC production to bring in more units as you will. However, there's only a handful of I think only about four uh spaces on that larger uh dawn board where you can actually get resources from and just one a piece. And then when you invest the city of Stalenrad, you will be able to get some more. Next, you have access movement. So, essentially the access player, the German player can move their units uh providing they've got they're within their movement aotment uh to any space on the board they can reach. Uh there are also roads if you kind of begin, you know, for the mechanized units or the tanks, if you begin and end along roads, you get a bonus there. Uh so you can move uh to any other location. Now again, you can also move into spaces with your enemies.

You're setting up your attacks at that point. I should also point out that there is an eight piece stacking limit for any land units in any one region. Next, you have the allies react step. Now, generally what this is used for is if you have artillery and the Germans are attacking you with air power, you can take shots at them. You can roll one dice. If it rolls a a one, you can actually take out one of the German aircraft. Now, next you have the axis attack. Now, when the axis attack, again, you look at all the spaces on the board where you have both Axis and allies units, and you can go ahead and put them on the board. Now, I should point out during the movement phase, if you move into one of those spaces, you actually lay down an assault token. Now, an assault token says, "This is the very first time an attack is taking place in that area. That will be important for a few reasons, but you go ahead, you move your units in there during the movement phase, and then during the attack phase, you've got that assault marker there.

You go ahead and you move to the battle board. Now, again, unlike a lot of Axis and Allies games, you don't keep fighting until one side is done. You only fight one round of combat and then you of course fight it much the way you do in other Access Allies games. You're going to roll depending on the numbers of the units you've got. Defenders are removed, but they still get to fire. And then once it's all resolved, you put uh the units that are still standing in that space. If the Germans take it over, they put a German uh conquest marker in that space. If, however, both sides are still standing, you flip the assault marker over to a battle marker. Next, you have the Axis air landing. The Axis have to land their aircraft back in bases. Now, every air base can only hold up to four units, but you can move anywhere on the board with your aircraft. Next, the Allies have their counter offensive preparation. This is where they're preparing for to launch Operation Uranus. So, essentially, they're going to take uh reinforcement cards and they're going to decide if they want to put them in the northern flank or the southern flank. And there are different areas where this can possibly uh where these uh this offensive can possibly begin depending on the turn that they actually launch it. They have to launch it by turn seven at the latest, but they can launch it a few turns earlier if they like. But you go ahead and you set your cards down and you're slowly building up forces for this massive counterattack. Next, you have the Heroic Workers of Stalingrad.

In Stalingrad, depending on the turn, you will either be able to build one tank or one artillery piece that then you can use as normal in the game. Next you have allied reinforcement and the allies can go ahead and spend their IPCs to build units and they can bring those units onto the dawn board or the stalenrad board at very specific areas. There's areas showing through which they can reinforce. Those units are immediately able to take part in any movements or attacks. Next, the allies can move the same thing. They can move any of their units along the board provided they've got the movement uh points to do so. they can go ahead and take advantage of road lines where they've got mechanized units or tanks that can do so. And then if they move into any spaces with German units, you put down an assault token. Now here we have the access reaction. They can fire their artillery against uh Allied aircraft and then you have the allied attack. So now the allies are the attacker. Again, you move to the battle board for one round of combat. Next you have allies aircraft landing. They have to land back at their bases and then you go to the end of the round. you check for victory and you also do any end of round cleanup you need to do and then you advance the round marker to the next round. Now that is the basic flow of the game but there's some other things that are going on here. Um for instance uh you've got different units than you have in a lot of the other access and allies.

Like I say you've got the mechanized infantry which we have seen before. You also have German assault guns. And these German assault guns can essentially uh take out tanks. They can target tanks. So if you're fighting, if you get a hit, you can actually determine that they're firing against a tank and the enemy has to lose their tank. Uh the Russians, the Soviets actually have Katushia rockets where they can get like free pot shots at the uh at the uh axis on their turn. You also have things as you're moving into Stalenrad in the city itself. Um you actually have barges that bring across uh units from reinforcement zones there in the city. And then once the weather turns bad, they flip over, they become kind of ice bridges, right? And you can bring in units that way as well.

And these can be attacked by alli by access air power as well. Then you also have ambush areas in the city where if a unit, an infantry unit is in that, they can take pot shots at uh sniper shots at enemy units that are in adjacent areas. As I mentioned too, you have supply tokens. Now, any unit is in danger of being out of supply. If ever it's completely surrounded, cut off from its supplies. Uh you can't draw a straight line. Uh the Germans can't draw a straight line back to their um uh starting spaces. Or if the Russians are surrounded, uh they can potentially be out of supply. If you're out of supply, your units are not going to fight as well. There's a special place you put them on the battle board when they're unsupplied. However, if they have a supply token in there with them, which can be air dropped in, uh, then they actually do fight at full strength. So, as long as they've got supplies there, they can do it. If you actually overrun an enemy and they have supply tokens there, you can capture those supplies.

Now, as I mentioned, the Soviets by turn seven have to launch Operation Uranus. Now, if they launch it earlier, there are spaces on the board that show where they have to enter if they launch it earlier. And if they launch it by turn seven, then they they can generally have better options for launching their assault. Now, critically too, once they do that, you put down the winter storm, this is the German counter counterattack, and you put it three uh spaces out. Once the Germans reach that, then they can reinforce. Normally, they've got a stack of IPCs uh that they've got uh because they have uh been waiting to spend them. They can't spend them until that point. And once they spend them, they can hurry and buy whatever they want to buy. And from that point forward, they'll collect IPCs and reinforce normally on their turn. Now, there are different victory conditions, major and minor victory conditions based on which units hold what on the board at various times. But if you are able to fulfill your victory conditions, then you win.

Axis and allies stalenrad. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen. So, if you know me, if you know the channel, I love Axis and Allies. I have a PhD. Uh my my focus PhD in military history. My focus was the Second World War. And I can trace back my interest in the Second World War and my desire to pursue this degree in the fact that when I was 12 years old, I started playing Milton Bradley's Axis and Allies. So, there's a lot of love for this series of games.

And I'm always excited when Renegade Studios in these last few years has been releasing new titles and some titles we've seen before that are just coming back into print. So, I have to tell you, um, I was really looking forward to Stalingrad for a lot of reasons. It's fun to see a access and allies game now that is just focused here on this this crucial arguably turning point battle of World War II in Russia in the Soviet Union, the Eastern Front. This is such an important battle and it's a it's it's one we've seen in a lot of games. Um, you know, Undaunted Stalingrad is great or Stalingrad the Vulga 1942, another solitary game. There's so many great games about Stalingrad and it's fun to see this finally get the Axis and Allies treatment fullon. Now, a couple of things, couple of observations. First of all, I was really excited about the fact that this has two full-size game boards and one is kind of the dawn area and one is the city itself. And I really like that idea of as you move in, your forces get bigger, your infantry forces get bigger, as they move out, they get smaller. I think that is really cool and and I really like that. And I like, you know, what areas on the the dawn board lead to the different parts of the city.

I think it's really fun, really interesting. I like the idea of the the Russians kind of building up for Operation Uranus, right? And they they're selecting cards and they're making decisions about which flank, the northern flank or the southern flank it's going to go on by placing the cards under the board on that side. And it's it's really cool. It's it's a real fun and interesting system. Now, it's kind of difficult as Germany. I mean, you're you're you're very powerful at the beginning of the game in a lot of access and allies games, and you can get pretty far pretty fast. Um, but the problem is when you're taking losses, those losses really aren't replaced. Specifically, if you're losing, you know, aircraft and tanks and these sorts of things at the beginning of the game, they're not replaced. You get, you know, one infantry token every other turn, one infantry sculpt every other turn. And that really sucks from the German players perspective. It seems like the Russians are able to kind of get a small but steady stream of replacements coming in pretty quickly.

But then as the game advances, as the game continues and both sides are just being worn down by the attrition of these battles and again they are attrition battles because unlike as I say like unlike the other access and allies where you are rolling until one side or the other is eliminated here as I say it's really cool because you don't complete battle like that you know if you don't kill everybody the battle goes on and there there are certain conditions when you flip from assault to to battle, right? Um, that's pretty cool. Like, you know, when you're doing a river crossing with an assault, the defender is going to get some advantages, but if it's a battle, they don't get those advantages anymore kind of a thing. So, that's that's that's really cool. And there there are other things like fortifications on the board and and and various other defensive things. And then when you get into the city of Stalingrad and there's the ambushes. The game also does come with some optional rules. They've got some cards for optional roles that you can play. I actually haven't played any of them yet. I'm looking forward to doing those in time. It gosh, it does such a good job of abstracting a lot of these these conditions that were, you know, we're in the battle um with supply and and what have you. It's it's it's just really a fun game. Now, I do have some reservations. Um my first my first issue with the game is it's a long game. Now, it doesn't wear out its welcome. I have fun throughout the game, but just know that it's it says it's three to five

hours. Yeah. And for your first game, look at that higher end there. It's a long game and they're trying to because again, they're trying to simulate so much here. Like I say, I had fun. This game didn't wear out its welcome. It didn't last longer than the fun it generated. I had fun to the end, but it is a it is a long game. Also, too, you've got this system with the cards and you flip over the cards to see which state you're in. And to me that felt a little tedious. Um I think that could have been done if you just had a track on the board that said what happens where and you and you and you put it there and you knew which ones to skip at certain times and stuff. I think that would have worked better than the than the cards. I I don't know. I just thought it's it's kind of an extra and unnecessary little thing on the board.

Uh I would have much preferred a track that did that. you've already got the track for the time and stuff, but I would have preferred to track just kept track of the phases as well. But it's 14 phases per uh round, you know, and that's both both sides turns, but it's just, you know, I'm always a little leerary of a game when they've got phases that go into the teens. But those complaints I have are pretty minor in the grand scheme. And they didn't they didn't really detract too much if at all from from the sheer fun and the joy I was having. I should point out in the video you're seeing here of this game that we played. Um, I am using the Axis and allies hit dice which replace it comes with just some regular six-sided dice and I am using the hit dice which you can buy separately which I love for access and allies because you can roll everything at once and see all your hits. Uh, and then also I'm using the poker chips. You can buy the IPC poker chips for access and allies. Again, that's sold separately from from Renegade. And I prefer that to the paper money. Um, paper money is fine, but I much prefer using the poker chips. So, they don't come with the game if you're watching the video, but the game itself is a lot of fun. I really like this. Um, I like this. In fact, I know I know North Africa came out last last year and that was fun. I like North Africa, but to me, this one is far superior uh than North Africa. Um, this game just I don't know. I I love the theme. I love the the

the mechanisms here that they're using and just the way they're adapting Access and Allies to some of these kind of battles. They're scaling back from the global war just to to to certain theaters and and and battles and they did a great job here. So, my recommendation for Axis and Allies on the Cody scale. Uh right now, I'm going to give Stalingrad an eight. And honestly, with more play, I could see this becoming a nine in time. It is really a lot of fun. Thank you once again for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on Board Gamegeeek, on our Facebook page, on Twitter. We'd ask you to like and subscribe to all of these. It's very important that you like and subscribe to this channel. That means a lot to us. And if you like what we do here, please check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, books on history, even post some of my lectures on that channel. Uh please subscribe to that. It would mean the world to me. And if you do really like what we do on this channel, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. What's the difference between Ukraine and Russia? Ukraine's president is a comedian. Russia's president is a clown.

Somebody help me ground. It's a long time and I'll be dying. I wind up in the fight.

Okay, there we go. Best roll. And I got that on tape. That's the best roll of the game. Second best roll of the

Progress saved