Skip to main content
Loading video...

Critical Foundations: Discussion

Transcript 16:49

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a new run-through review for Critical: Foundation Season 1. Uh this was a game that was actually announced, I think it was announced prior to or at least definitely advertised around Gen Con this year in 2022 uh by Gigamic. A company that has done only one other game that I'm aware of it when sorry, that I have personally played and that was Turing Test. And uh this one was extremely intriguing just because of this was advertised as a tabletop RPG where it's episodic and each episode lasts about 30 minutes and that was like, "Okay, cool." Like if they're able to condense the types of role-playing into about a 30-minute episode, like and there's nine episodes in the in the box and that's season 1, so obviously they have plans for more.

Sure, like let's let's give that a shot. And they're half right. Like it's it Okay, so this is a little weird because I planned on doing this as a run-through or as a series on the channel, but it's just you know, I do so many series on it and like or on the channel that I just got to make cuts somewhere and because the group that I play this with, I've I've been playing like D&D with for years and so we have a very certain type of play style that this game does not mesh super well with that. So, with that being said, I think that Critical is a great entry point for a for a group that has never played a tabletop RPG before and for a DM that has never DM'd before or GM or whatever you want to call it uh because there's two ways to go about this.

You like I you can review this as if it's trying to compete with things like D&D, with Pathfinder, Starfinder, you know, etc. And then this is complete garbage. That's not at all what this is supposed to be and I don't think that that's what they intended, but if you're saying, "Hey, it's like an it's an RPG that's in 30 minutes." That just that doesn't make any sense. So, what it is it is a RPG light that allows players who have never touched any of those I just previously mentioned before and see if they like it. And I think that this succeeds extremely well at that. Because of the fact that it's isolated into 30 minutes or longer. I mean, you like the DM can elaborate a little bit more, but if you're trying to play the game the way it's designed, it is very heavily like walls around the players and they're on the rails as well. And the DM also doesn't have a whole lot to go on because it's like, "Well, I didn't create this world. I'm not making the story. I'm trying to tell the story that's in the box and so that's kind of I'm very limited as to the information that I'm given and what I can tell you and what you guys can do."

So, if you're experienced in any, you know, TRPG, I don't know if this is quite the game for you because it's going to feel extremely restrictive. Hell, like okay, so personally as a as a player, I don't like modules. Like that's just me personally. Like uh Ravenloft or Icewind Dale. I just don't like those because I know they're doing the same thing. They're like, "This is a book that's trying to tell a story. The DM has a lot of leeway, but he still has to kind of stick with the book, otherwise just make your own story. There's a place for those, I totally get that, and there's a place for this. So, basically what it is is the DM has like or the GM they have to call it. The GM will read the episode, understand who the MPCs are, understand you know, what options that they're given. And I'm not going to spoil really anything from this just because it is its own self-contained story. And but like a slight example is in one of the episodes, like the episode tells the GM, "Hey, you can play this in one of two ways. either do this or you can do this, but it doesn't really matter either way."

Like but it just depends on what kind of atmosphere you want to bring. Do you want to make it tense and you know, plausible that the that the players can succeed here or do you want to make it feel like, "Oh man, this guy is just way too powerful. Like we don't know if we're going to be able to beat him, yada yada yada." And then just make him feel hopeless, but then do something else in the later episodes. Uh you're also restricted with the cards that are coming in the box. So, each episode basically gives the players, "Hey, here's the items you're given. Here's what the the GM is going to need and you know, behind his screen." It does come with a screen, which I was very I was very pleased with. I think they did a good job. The screen is actually very very nice. Everything in the box is is well nice. This works just like a you know, D&D screen where it has all like, "Okay, key elements, dice checks, combat, and then attributes and skills." And so, what a general like D&D screen would have.

Um And so, you keep all the the you know, pertinent information stuff behind here and it's like, "Oh, okay. So, they they asked about this. So, boom, here's your stuff." Uh but like I said, at the end of the day, the characters can only can a certain amount of stuff. They can only do a certain amount of stuff. Combat is very quick, which I personally like cuz I don't like combat. Um and the role-playing is also light, which once again, not for me or my group, but but I cannot, you know, emphasize enough how amazing that this is for players who have never touched an RPG cuz it's so forboding to try and cuz if you're like, "Oh, yeah, okay, we like we all hang out together and we play games. Let's try and do an RPG." And you don't have a DM.

You know, like some people might know someone who DMs, but they have their own groups. So then it's like, "Okay, well now we need to find someone who wants to DM." And that's its own thing and that that person has to basically make a job of. And you kind of have to do it here. Someone has to be the one running it, but it's it's very refined. Like they're not overwhelmed with I have to make a world or I have to read this entire book. Um the players can't really like just go off the rails to, you know, throw a wrench in things. Uh so then you don't have to worry about like coming up with stuff on the spot. Um like if players are asking about certain things. Like I'll I'll spoil episode zero because it really is like nothing. It's like, "Hey, here's the bare minimum of the rules. Once you're comfortable with that, then you go to the actual game and here's a little bit more rules." Glad they have it, but entirely skippable. But there's a point where they have to raid in episode zero, the prologue, which is like 10 minutes.

They have to raid like a a base. And if they go to the area with the base and they want to go to like cuz there's a little card that shows the compound. They're like, "Oh, we want to go here." You just say, "Nothing there." Or I mean you can hype it up a little bit, but it's like, "Yeah, you search for a little bit and still find nothing of interest." And they're like, "We go here." Nothing of interest. So obviously it's like, "Yeah, you're you're meant to just just to this one area that is in the episode that I can give to you. Uh so that's very relieving if someone is like forced or they choose to play the GM. And then on the on the player side, they they're given characters, they choose a back I mean but still very restrictive. It's like, "Okay, you have these four characters. These are the four class types. You pick a background, but there's two cards that you can choose from that's specifically assigned to that class."

Like the character sheet is very like clean. Uh I'm not going to pull them out, but you like they have your four attributes, you're good at one of them which just means when you're told to do that specific check, you add one to it. And then uh and then you can kind of roleplay a little bit, but you don't have to come up with this massive backstory. You don't have to like actually mold a and and play as a certain character. You're just very like, "Okay, this is kind of the overall skeleton like that I'm going to I'm going to play as in this in this world." Uh but you can only ask certain things. If it's like, "Hey, here's what's going on." You know, you can be like, "Oh, okay, who's the enemy? You know, where's the item? What's the And and then most of the time, especially when I was playing, my players just knew what to ask. Or what's kind of cool and and I'm very surprising of this is if if they even ask in a roundabout way, it's like, "Oh, okay, they even kind of thought of that." Because this while this is what's directly in here, uh like if they're meant to specifically ask about this, well, they also they kind of asked about it. So, sure, then I can just give them that information.

There was one moment in one of the scenarios where uh something was happening and a player didn't like he he wanted to do something, but the book the episode didn't specifically say if they could do it, but it still worked out in the actual story Uh just because there is enough wiggle room that the GM can work with something like that. And like it's not so like rigid that it's you might as well just read it out and just see what the story is. Like the players can role-play. They do get to make their own actions. Uh And the GM can go with the flow a little bit, but still at the end of the day you got to follow the episode and they're short. 30 minutes goes by like that. It's very quick.

So, would I say that 30 minutes is enough time to get a RPG feel? For my group and me, I would say no. But I think for a lot of people that have never touched this type of game, yes. I think 30 minutes would be good. It's 30 45. Like if you're if the GM is really kind of like amping it up and really getting into the scenes. Um But at the end of the day, that's huge because my sessions, like whenever I'm playing, which is like they're like 5-6 hours. Like that's just what we do. Um and that's a lot. That's a lot for a lot of people. So, you can because there's not a lot of episodes in here, you can just kind of just enjoy it. Just do pick an episode, like do it once a week. Like and and then play something else. Like this doesn't have to be your whole your whole night. It could be. You could just sit down for one Saturday, just go through all of them and then really get into the world. But then you're like I kind of want season 2 out now.

So, very interesting concept. I think that they did do a really good job with this. It is in a cyberpunk-esque world. I think that's cool. And so also, let me talk about some of the actual game mechanisms. I was I was talking about the whole concept. The game mechanisms are very clean, very simple. Um I know a lot of people are turned off by playing certain characters or even getting into a TRPG just because it's a lot of rules or it's a lot of math. All that is out the window. You basically have equipment that's like, "Hey, here's how many uses it can do." Uh here's your weapon. It adds one to damage. All the numbers are very low. So, when you're doing damage, you roll a die. It's like, and uh combat is very simple. It's just like, "Oh, okay. I I want to shoot this guy." It's like, "Okay." And then they roll. It's like, "Okay, to shoot is a physical check. It's whatever." So, they roll and you roll a D12. Um but the numbers only go from critical failure to three, I believe is the the highest.

And the GM has the enemy card. It has a difficulty, so it's like, "Okay." Like, "Okay, so yeah, so you shoot." And they're like, "Okay, I got a three." Perfect. Yeah, and then you can amp it up. If if the difficulty's three, they hit. And it's just one damage. Sometimes it might be two. You might be able to drop them in one hit depending on their health. And you know, if if the enemies take damage or if the players take damage, it's one wound or they might if they take but they can only ever take two max wounds. If they take a third one, then they go down. You can critically fail, which obviously doubles the negative effects. You can also critically succeed, which is like cuz critically succeeding in D&D is rolling a natural 20, failing is a natural one. You in this, it's like, "Okay, the the GM knows, okay, to do this, it's a difficulty check of two."

Um if someone rolls and they do and they get a four, well, they critically succeeded cuz as you critically succeed when you double the difficulty check. So, if they're scaling a wall, it's like and they roll a four uh or they get a four total, then it's like, "Oh, yeah, you just like basically run and just grab it and leap all the way over and look super badass doing it." Or if they're like, "Yeah, I rolled the axe and got and critically failed." It's like, yeah, you failed. You tried climbing over the wall, slipped and land on your neck, and they would you would have taken one wound, but now you're taking two. So, your your neck is all messed up. You guys do whatever you want. But, they do something in here that I very much like is that if you critically fail the you're given a compensation token, and this is for and players can spend those at any time to add a D8 to their D12 roll. I I really like that. I think again, this is very much geared towards people who have never been in a TRPG before because of that. Cuz in every other thing, if you critically fail, it's usually very bad for you.

And they didn't want to have that. Man, I keep failing. It's like, yeah, uh, so here's something to really make you feel Oh, yeah, you failed this time, but now you're going to use that token to shoot this guy, and yeah, the difficulty is is four, but you rolled you rolled a three with your plus one, and you rolled the D8 and got another four. It's like, you got a critical success this time, and you Yeah, you wing it, but what really happened is actually a ricocheted and shot him in the back of the neck. You can just do whatever whatever you want. It does allow for that. So, I'm like, I I have had a good time with this. I think a lot of people should check this out because it could be a turn-off where it's like, really? Like, like it's I don't think it's going to be enough. I think it is enough. I think you can still have a a solid, you know, fun, light time. You don't have to be too stressed about it. Or, this would definitely tell you if you're ready or if you guys or if people would like a actual, you know, big, you know, tabletop RPG. Um, so this one is actually kind of weird to actually give a score for because it's like, yeah, this obviously isn't geared for me, even though I did have a good time with it. I think if they do support it with more seasons and this just doesn't die off and they're like, oh, we did this and we just made one season, then that would be kind of lame. But, based off whenever I was talking to my Gen Con, they did say they had plans for more, so going to take them at their word. Uh, so yeah, I'm going to give Critical Foundation season 1 an eight. Like, I think it does a really good job for what it intends to

do. Uh, and even for the my group and the players I was playing with, we still had a good time and it was it was super fun because we didn't have to feel like we were ruining characters or, you know, pissing other people off by doing certain things because it is kind of nice every now and then to be on rails, to just go through a story instead of being stressed out about trying to make this everything epic. So, that's my thoughts on Critical Foundation season 1. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey, everyone. Thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved