Skip to main content
Loading video...

Deception: Murder in Hong Kong Review

Transcript 20:02

welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing deception murder in Hong Kong in this 4-12 player game one person sitting around the table is secretly a murderer and everybody else needs to figure out who it is and how they committed this murder the catch is that one other person around the table knows who it is and how they did it but the only way they can communicate that to the rest of the players is through silently giving Clues on little player boards first I'll go over the way the game plays and then I'll jump into my review this is the starting setup for a four player game of deception each player takes four murder weapons and four key pieces of evidence from the very large Stacks like these are all the pieces of evidence here and there's a smaller but still substantial stack of murder weapons to choose from you place all these cards face up in the middle of the table and then each person gets an accusation token and now before we pass out the roll cards each player looks at the various cards that are in front of them and the ones around the table once they're ready it's time to pass out the hidden rolls now in a standard game you always need to have one forensic scientist and you need to have one murderer and then you put a number of investigators as you need to make up the total number of players so in this case it'd be two investigators or forensic scientist and a murderer so you Shuffle these up and then you deal these out to the four players each player looks at their cards and the one who has the forensic scientist immediately flips it over and they actually ditch all the cards that are in their area because they're no longer a suspect they actually are the person who's going to be trying to tell everybody else what's going on at this point the forensic scientist asks everyone to close their eyes and then asks the murderer to open the rise in

this case it would be this player down here and then the murderer silently points to one card from the top row which in this case would be a murder weapon and one card on the bottom row which is a key piece of evidence so for instance they could Point like right here pointing to the wrench and the cotton once the forensic scientist nods that they get it then the murderer closes their eyes and then everybody else opens their eyes and the game Begins the forensic scientist is on the same team as the investigators they are trying to out the murderer specifically the murder weapon and the key piece of evidence and to do that they have several boards they always have this cause of death board which has several different items on it and then the next thing that they need to do is they pick one of these four location boards that has something on it that best matches perhaps the um the either the the key piece of evidence or the weapon so perhaps they would pick this one right here because it has building site as an option and they know they're trying to get people to crescent wrench so they add this here and then there is a very large stack of random clue tiles they draw four of these and they're going to add them to the table so when they're all done there are going to be six of these tiles that the forensic scientist is able to use to give Clues the forensic scientist is not allowed to say anything all they do is they take one of these little bullet markers and they put it on one of the options for all of the boards that are in front of them so for instance they might take this one here and put it down to building site because they think that correlates pretty well with the wrench and for cause of death they have an interesting decision to make right because they could go severe injury because getting hit over the head or somewhere with a wrench is going to be a severe injury but they could also go

with accident because if it's a building site maybe the wrench just fell on somebody's head but let's say in this case they go with severe injury over there and there's no particular order that they put these tokens down in in fact the order they place them is a clue to the investigators perhaps which of the clues on the boards are stronger versus which are weaker so now they look at corpse condition and maybe they would just say intact because you're not going to be falling apart with the wrench the victim's occupation maybe they'll put worker trying to tie it in with the building site but remember they also have to convince uh the investigators that cotton is an important thing as well so looking at these different things here like motive of the crime that could potentially be really any of these and so the and forensic scientists might do that one last because it doesn't really affect anything and same with the victim's build although they could definitely go with fit if they're going for a worker and then perhaps motive of the crime doesn't really matter they'll just put jealousy down here they put this one last so they hope people don't look into it too much and according to the rules each player starts clockwise from the forensic scientist and they have 30 seconds to make a case for various um combinations that these could match up with right now that would be actually the murderer so they would be trying to lead the other investigators off their Trail potentially trying to point out that like a travel could cause a severe injury and you definitely use a trowel when you are at work for instance and they might also mention the machine with a work site like there are different things that they might point out and no other player is allowed to interrupt that player while they're talking and then you move clockwise and then each player does one of these for up to 30 seconds once everybody has had a chance to talk that is the end of round one the

forensic scientist is going to draw another random tile they are going to get rid of one of the previous ones one they think that does not really relate to the evidence at all they'll flip this over and now they'll add this piece of evidence to the overall system so in this case evidence Left Behind now they can try to point at the Cotton first in this case they probably put natural down there once again all players would have 30 seconds each to discuss their theories and that would end the second round so once again the forensic scientists would try to get rid of the one that doesn't uh add them enough information so they might get rid of this one they'll draw another random one victim's clothes he'll add this in here and now once again they're probably trying to point people to Cotton because they have lots of good signals towards the wrench so I don't know maybe they would go with neat assuming that people understand that cotton clothes are neat it's kind of hard to give that correlation but they're doing the best they can and then for one last time each person gets 30 seconds to talk around the table now there are these accusation Badges and each person gets only one of them and once they do a formal accusation they have to discard it and they don't get another one in the game and you can actually use these at any point in the game you don't have to wait until the third round although the later you go the more information you're gonna have and when you make a formal accusation you point to a single murder weapon and a single key piece of evidence in somebody else's area and the only thing the forensic scientists can say is yes or no and if they say no that does not mean that this player is not the murderer they just mean that was not the exact combination of items that were the murder weapon and key piece of evidence and according to the rules once you get to the final person you're not allowed to interrupt them and once they

finish nobody else is allowed to make a final guess so this is a little peculiar I guess it means that everybody needs to guess before the final person takes their um their turn to discuss the situation if at any point somebody makes an accusation that's correct they say wrench and cotton then the forensic scientist says yes and the game is over and everybody but the murderer wins if everybody uses their accusations and nobody has gotten the exact match then the game ends and the murderer wins and everybody else loses at this point I'd like to talk about the two extra roles that come in the game the rules that you can bring these in with six or more players I've used them with eight or more players I think that's probably a better account for it but anyway the first one is the accomplice when you Shuffle this in and the accomplice is on the same team as the murderer the only difference is the accomplice does not point to any object so when the forensic scientist says murder open your eyes they also say accomplice open their eyes so the accomplice sees who the murderer is they see what the um the actual items are that they pick and the murder sees through the accomplices as well and at the end of the game if the murderer is not picked then both the accomplice and the murderer win so it allows the murderer to have somebody else on their tail trying to lead people astray but if you're using the compost you should probably also use the witness so once you um once a forensic scientist asks the murder in the accomplice to close her eyes then they ask the witness to open their eyes and the forensic scientist points to the two people at the table that are the murderer and the accomplice but they don't actually tell the witness who is the murderer and who is the accomplice so the witness has a lot more information than everybody else because they can narrow it down to two people with whom the murderer could be but the problem is that at the end of

the game if the murderer is caught then the murder in the accomplice can still win if they can point out who the witness is is so the witness needs to make sure they're not too obvious because they could just throw the entire game if people if these two guys figure out that this person is a witness then the game ends even though they were picked I guess the idea is they they kill the witness before the court uh case actually happens and that's how you play deception murder in Hong Kong so now let's begin my review for deception murder in Hong Kong and we'll start with the Positive points the first of these relates to the forensic investigator role and there are a couple different things that I like about it the first thing has to do with the decision to kind of be playing one type of game or the other now the way the rules are written you're supposed to pass out all the roles randomly and then someone will randomly become the forensic investigator but what we found that we do is we pick somebody to be the forensic investigator first and then deal out the rest of the rules randomly and I know that is kind of a variant I suppose but it's really nice because there's usually someone at the table who really doesn't want the stress or risk or whatever of pulling up the card and seeing that they are the murderer in this game and so you could just be like okay well that person you get to be the forensic investigator for this play and spoiler alert that's usually me I have baggage when it comes to social deduction games I get so stressed out and I just really dislike being the person who is like the murderer or the Spy or the werewolf or whatever where they reveal that card and they realize they have to deceive and lie to their friends in order to play well and I just really dislike that for the most part in Social deduction games now it's really not that bad is the murderer in this game but that's a tangent I'll talk about that in a little bit but it's

great having the option to get out of that and just know right from the beginning you're going to play this game with your friends they're gonna do that you know who's lying who's back and forth and you don't have to worry about that you're kind of above that game looking down trying to guide things trying to tell everybody who the murderer is you know what's going on and you don't have that stress of potentially being the murderer uh the other side about the forensic investigator is that it's just a mechanically interesting situation to be in it feels kind of like uh concept and Mysterion that has that Vibe where you have this puzzle in front of you a bunch of different pieces of data and you're trying to hone everybody else in on a very tiny subset of that data and you have these really broad Concepts and clues to to get people there you have to kind of triangulate from many different angles and the fact that this game is so many tiles and you pull them out randomly adds a very interesting layer of strategy for that forensic investigator to figure out how they're going to get through these um really not helpful tiles often like what kind of clothing were they wearing well they were poison so they could be naked they could be fully clothed that doesn't have any effect and so how are you going to best navigate and give the right clue to not pull people away from what you're trying to get at so mechanically it's just a really interesting thing that I love having in the game and it's also great to have the option of just not potentially being the murderer which I usually dislike positive number two relates to the really important decision that the murderer has to make right at the beginning of the game of which murder weapon do they choose and which key piece of evidence in your average social deduction game uh once you reveal that

card and you're the werewolf or you're the Spy how well you play that game is strictly dependent on how well you can lie and deceive all the people around the table but in this game while you do have to do some deception I mean it is the name of the game you will sink or swim based off of that decision that you make you can pick a bad murder weapon and a bad piece of evidence and lose really fast so you need to look around the table and find uh each of those things that will disguise themselves with the rest of them around the table like you don't want to pick a food article when there is no other food around the table and you don't want to pick a bludgeoning instrument if nothing else around the table uh could really kill somebody by hitting them over the head with it so it's great that you have this important decision and you might find yourself not needing to lie or deceive your friends very much at all in the game if you pick correctly and I really like that addition to the game positive number three relates to the general atmosphere at the table that this game Fosters in many social detection games I've seen in the past it gets to the point where there might be elevated voices and like arguments come into play as people are trying to you know push the blame back and forth on each other but in deception it almost feels like a fully Cooperative game like at certain points you forget that somebody is actually deceiving you because the best way to play it is to be civil like if you are the murderer and somebody looks over to you and they they point to your murder weapon and your key piece of evidence and they have it right and they say I think this might be it because of this and that and the other thing the best thing that you can do is say oh I hadn't thought about that I guess that is a pretty good idea but I think it's a stronger uh pick if you

look over here this and that and that way you disguise yourself as an investigator you don't get your hackles up there's no like increase of emotion it's very analytical and calm and I like that it means that as the murderer it's less stressful too because I don't feel like I'm straight up lying to my friends I don't feel like I'm trying to make connections that don't exist what I'm trying to do is say like in an alternate reality this and that really could be the solution to the game like that person effectively could be the murderer now you know that you are the murderer but you can kind of have a split decision in your head and it feels less stressful and I like the general atmosphere that this game brings to the social deduction genre now let's talk about my one neutral point which might be a bit of a nitpick but from a graphical perspective I found that there can be confusion as to which cards are the murder weapons and which cards are the key pieces of evidence sometimes it's obvious based off of what's on the card but sometimes it isn't and those key pieces of evidence could definitely feel like murder weapons and that confusion has crept into a couple of games I played it one game was completely kind of lost because the forensic investigator got it mixed up and this game is pretty short so it's only like 15 minutes or so that is kind of uh ruined by that mistake but I wish there was a little bit more emphasis in the the graphical display on the cards to really hammer in which one is the evidence and which one is the murder weapon through like maybe a big symbol in the top right corner or just saying weapon and saying evidence or something like that on the card it's not a huge

deal but it's something you definitely need to keep in mind and stay on top of that it's sometimes pretty easy to get the two confused so now let's go into my negative points and the first of these relates to the information overload that can start to happen with higher player counts the rules say that you always have four key pieces of evidence and four murder weapons that are in front of you no matter how many people are playing what that means is in a six player game they're gonna be 40 cards on the table but in a 10 player game you're looking at 72 cards around the table and that is just crazy especially if you're the forensic investigator trying to give Clues and I mean it's going to take you like five minutes just to read all the cards around the table and then double back and try to hone in and then everybody else around the table now they have such an incredible amount of information to parse that it gets really overwhelming when only two of those things are the answer to the game and now I think this is why there are extra roles like the witness and the accomplice to kind of make that a little bit easier but I really think that the rules should have had some stipulation like once you get to six or seven players now you go down to three pieces of evidence and three pieces of um murder weapons in front of you and once you hit 10 maybe you have two and two or just less right to the point where I almost feel like house ruling it if I find myself in a situation to play it with a lot of people because it does play well with a lot of people except for that issue uh so yeah I just think they should have done a little bit more to make it less overloading when it comes to that and negative number two relates to the kind of awkward way that the rules tell you that you need to do accusations especially in the final round of the game it says that once the

final person gives their little talk about their 30 seconds about who they think did what nobody else can accuse that point only that one person so it means that everybody is kind of incentivized to make accusations right before the last person and it's just clunky and weird and we've kind of thrown it out we every time we play now we just say you know once everybody has had their say now we do the accusations because it pretty much never makes sense to accuse anybody before that because you may as well have more information there's no penalty for making the game go longer as the investigators so that's just a little weird we've we've gotten to the point where we pretty much house rule that we've another house rule that I talked about with the forensic investigator and these things are not huge impacts on the game but it's confusing the first time you read it and you kind of read it over and over again you're like this doesn't make sense and I think we decided not to play according to the rules before we ever actually played the game because it was just kind of so weird and awkward all right so now let's discuss the replayability of deception murder in Hong Kong and I think it's definitely above average there are a ton of pieces of evidence and uh murder weapons in this game to the point where you know every time you play you're gonna see a very different selection of uh all these cards in front of you and there's a really big stack of the forensic investigator tiles that they randomly pull so you're not going to feel like you're always you know having to figure out what kind of clothing the person was wearing because you'll probably go several games before you get that tile again uh so I think mechanically what they have in the Box it has really long legs as far as replayability is concerned just through the variety of the cards and the tiles

and all that stuff also the asymmetric kind of roles you can play specifically if you decide to choose if you can be forensic investigator or not beginning the game that gives a different vibe you could play the game twice in a night and you essentially play two different games if you're the forensic investigator in one and not in the other all right so now let's discuss the different player counts that deception murder in Hong Kong supports and it's a lot of them right you go from 4 to 12 and I have played a four player game and it was pretty underwhelming uh having one person as a forensic investigator and then three other people one of whom is a murderer it just doesn't feel like there's enough going on enough really good interactions it feels like the sweet spot for this game is the six to eight range because at that point you can start bringing in those other roles like the witness and the accomplice and the game is fine without those and the gameplay is okay at five but you really do add quite a bit to the game when you add those extra roles in but as I mentioned before once you start getting into that level of seven to eight people there is just way too many cards around the table uh to the point where I really do feel like I want to start house ruling down just removing at least one like having three pieces of evidence and three murder weapons in front of everybody if we're playing like a Nate player game again because it's just way too much and to that point even if you start removing those pieces of evidence I think nine or more players is gonna start to just get too long that's just too many people who can talk for 20 to 30 seconds in in each one of the rounds like this game plays best when it's like 15-ish minutes and you're going to get a 15 to 20 minute experience if you're playing with eight but I think if you have 10 people it's probably going to stretch on much longer than that so I

would not recommend that quite as much I think six to eight is a sweet spot in conclusion I've been pleasantly surprised by deception I went into it expecting to really dislike it because I really dislike most social deduction games where you can randomly become a werewolf or a spy and then I feel like I have to stress out and lie to all my friends oh I just really dislike that and this game gives a couple different alternate paths I could be the forensic investigator as long as everybody else is okay with that and even when I'm not the forensic investigator if I reveal that I'm the murderer it's just a lot less stressful than most other social deduction style games because I feel like the decision of what cars to pick in front of me for the burger weapon and the key piece of evidence is a large piece of how well I will do in the game and how I deceive my friends feels like soft lying like it's you're postulating things that really could be truthful in an alternate universe where that person is actually the murderer you actually as the murderer pretty much play as the investigator just making um ideas and trying to match up the cards around the table the only difference between you and everybody else is you know what the combo is and you just need to lead people to other combinations and try to convince them that those are stronger without losing a civil nice atmosphere around the table so I've enjoyed playing the game it's a pretty good time but I don't find myself going out of my way to play it pretty much ever I don't think I will own the game at any point the one I've been playing is a friend's copy and when it gets played at game nights um somebody asked me if I want to play some nights I say yes some nights I say no I could see myself playing it quite off into the future it's a good game it's just not a amazing game for me but

what I can say is it's probably my favorite social deduction game which is NOT saying a lot but this is a pretty fun one if you like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching

Progress saved