On The Underground Paris/New York Board Game Review
Transcript
hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks top gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a brand new train game we're not really brand new because a reworking of a reprint that was released some time ago so we're going to be looking at on the Underground the New York Paris Edition and in this game you will be placing your tracks onto a map of the Paris or New York underground and you'll be enticing the passenger to use your routes that will give you points that will play to win the game so in this video I'm going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we're telling you what we do like we don't like we'll come back we'll tell you whether or not on the Underground Paris New York is worth your time and bother to date and in the future so remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] see ya after this bollocks so on the Underground Paris New York how'd you play this game so first thing you're going to do is you're going to put the board out onto the table it's a double sided board on one side you've got the Paris version on the flip side you've got the New York version the rule book does tell you that if it's your first game then play the New York version because it's going to be a little bit easier but this game is relatively simple anyway right so it doesn't really matter which version you
play pendant on the amount of players you'll select a number of scoring tokens in this will tell you what color tracks you will control right you're gonna have one set of tracks that's got 20 pieces and one set of tracks it's got 15 pieces right there's a deck of cards that refers to all of the stations on the track and some of the stations will have two cards in the deck designated by the gray Circle way so either you will draw four destination cards and then you'll place the destination tokens on that space you'll place the passenger on the starting spot add the first player will take their turn in the first turn of the game as a sort of a handicap mechanism the first player will have less turns than the last play right so on your turn you'll be able to take one of two actions you can either take like a branch top and two Branch tiles can be traded in that allow you to place a track at any space other than the two ends of the track which leads us on to the next action you can take is you could place one of your track tolls so when you place a track tile you have to place it adjacent to an existing piece of track but only at either end if you're gonna Branch off from that track then you have to trade in two Branch tiles and then you'll be able to place a track but there's a couple of little rules for the New York side and that is if you cross over a bridge you have to make sure you don't place a track over water on your last turn because you can't stop on a bridge right so there's a couple of different icons before the first connection of your line to each national rail station you'll be able to get one point if you connect to a Terminal Station you will get three points and for every three bridges that you cross you will get three points
right you'll see also that there are a limited number of spaces for tracks an exception to this is on the Paris map where you can trade in two brass tiles to stick a piece of track down where there's no spaces right and on a pair of sword as well there's a couple of little exceptions on the board the rer stations you're going to get zero points if it's the first line that connects and one point otherwise terminal stations will give you two points or one point and one branch Target or two Branch tiles where Alliance connected to a terminal station and when a line is connected to a landmark you'll be able to take that top and if you've got a set of five different Landmark tiles then you're going to trade them in for seven points right that's huge there's also something called clusters you'll see that there's big purple blobs on the board if you connect to your first cluster you ain't gonna get no points but for every subsequent cluster you'll get an extra point so for two clusters you'll get one point for three classes you'll get three points blah blah blah get the idea no you're thick then so at the end of your turn you will move passenger in the New York map you'll move the passenger twice and on the Paris map you'll move them once there's a few little fiddly rules as to how the passenger moves basically they want to use as fewer lines as possible and they're lazy [ __ ] so they don't want to walk right each line the passenger uses will score that player one point when the passenger arrives at the destination you'll remove the destiny how can you draw a new card and you place the Destination type on that space way so at the end of the game comes when there's no more cards in a deck you'll make sure that everybody has the same number of turns and the player with the most points will be the winner of on the Underground personal so what do we like about on the Underground Paris slash New York
so the first thing that we like about this is it's fun watching your lines pay off especially if you place them in spots which other players don't hey what the [ __ ] you're doing that for you to act it's also fun to be able to block players especially when they thought that their track was going to give them a bumper payout right and there's also the excruciatingly annoying person that benefits from placing one tiny little piece of track when you've placed down five right so there's all sorts of ways to annoy other players and all sorts of ways to get annoyed so I suppose in a sense that is sort of equilibrium in it so the second thing that we like about this game is that there's two boards each with their own unique rules like in the New York version the passenger is going to move twice right and on the Paris version the passengers only going to move once but you've got those landmarks that are going to give you so many points if you can collect five different ones so the fact that there is a little bit of variety and essentially you've got two games in one is pretty good deal on it I suppose so the final thing that we like about this game and this is probably the most important thing because it would have been bloody nightmare otherwise destination cards tell you exactly where the station is you've got a little pointy thing that tells you where you've got to put the destination token and even then you've got a grid reference on there so there's no nothing about searching for all these different weird locations and that really does help we're going to move pretty quickly right so don't be lying but on the Underground Paris New York so the first thing that we've done a lot about this is the aesthetic is quite Bland and unappealing I mean just look at Central Park on the New York map it
is just a blob of green paint right somebody's just taking a bus and going pull up across it right so it really doesn't seem to amplify the frame it I don't really get the impression that I am traversing the metro in Paris right there's a few landmarks dotted around but they're all pastel Shades and it seems to be like sort of scratch illustrations so it just doesn't inspire me at all and after a while it just feels like you are looking at a piece of whiteboard right so the second thing that we don't like about this is that at the end of the day you are at the mercy of that Bloody random card draw you're placing your pieces of tracks out on the board thinking yes the passenger is going to move here and then that random car is drawn and the passenger decides to go for a massage in a Turkish bath instead so all the plan in the world could count for [ __ ] because if that card that's drawn messes up your plans then the passenger is just basically going to go wherever the hell he likes right and that is is quite frustrating so next thing we not really keen on with this game is that the rule book is a little bit unclear in places for example the Clusters aren't really explained that well I mean it seems quite simple now but it doesn't really make it clear whether the Clusters are the actual purple blob or whether they're the circles within the blob so we had a little bit of an argument when we first played this that maybe if you connect tracks to three stations in that purple blob that means it's three clusters because you've got the solitary clusters on their own right so it's a bit confusing the rule book doesn't really make that clear and there's some phrasing in the rule book that sort of confused us with regards to branches and whether or not you could place certain tracks in certain positions right and
that sort of broke the game up a little bit hard to understand and the rule book is a little bit obtuse so final thing we really frustrating about this game is that towards the end of the game when you've got most of the Trap pieces on the board the upkeep does become a bit of a ball like you're going to be starting off with a passenger be counting all these different branches and tracks and going one two three four five one two three four button it just ruins the flow of the game right so if there was some sort of way of like tracking the passengers movement maybe a shortcut to see where they're going to go who's got the longest line on a certain position but there isn't you're gonna have to get your finger out and start pointing at the board making mistakes thinking ever balls up and in the end you just go well yeah it's got to be that one in it so to summarize is on the Underground worth your time of bother today and in the future so we're going to say maybe maybe not it's a fun but uninspiring Euro take on an already saturated train game genre it could have benefited from more thematic links to the mechanics right it doesn't actually feel like you're messing about on the Underground at all it just feels like you're sticking guitar modes out onto a board that's all it feels like towards the end of the game there is some mind-numbing upkeep and truth be told some players can over study the board too much right which puts a drag on the game I haven't said that the game is relatively short and it does urge you to exercise your brain just enough to say that you've had a light workout right I suppose the Eternal and infernal question that I'm asking myself is would
I rather pay ticket to ride and the answer is yeah so there you go that is on the Underground Paris and New York Edition remember if you're new here and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment down below hit the like button on all that YouTube [ __ ] we'll see ya next time