Everdell vs Wingspan – Which is Better?
Transcript
in this video i'm going to be looking at two games everdell and wingspan and i think i can recommend which of these two you would like more i'm going to do that using the perfect board game formula which breaks games down into five attributes those attributes are theme mechanics luck strategy and complexity now the perfect board game formula can help you compare games like these it can help you identify games that you like the most and it can help you identify the right kind of game for the right kind of mood if you'd like to learn more about that you can check out the site theperfectboardgame.com however i'm going to jump right into comparing these two games and i'm not going to do an overview of the rules because as i go through these attributes i think the relevant aspects of the games will come out so the very first thing you'll notice about both of these games is they have very impressive components uh everedell with its ever tree and like the very uh seemingly realistic berries and the twigs and then wingspan with its dice tower the beautiful artwork on the cards and the eggs and like it's very colorful just amazing amount of unique artwork on every individual card but components don't influence whether or not the game is good in fact they're often confused with the very first attribute which is theme theme like components is what the game represents in everdel you are animals that are building a city and in wingspan you are a bird watcher who's collecting information about birds
but really when it comes to the theme rating it's when you play the game does the actual gameplay represent something meaningful or analogous to a real life situation is there something about this game that really makes you feel like you're building a city with animals or does it really feel like you're collecting birds that question for both of these games can be answered with a big no both of these games score very low in the theme rating despite having fantastic artwork and let me tell you a little bit about why if we look first at everdel everything thematic is completely superficial it has nothing to do with animals if you look at how the game is played gameplay is largely buying cards that will enable you to buy more cards and collect resources that allow you to buy more cards and more expensive cards that are worth points but none of that really has any meaning if you've ever played a game called dominion which is a really big game that came out several years ago but really well known game it's kind of like that in the sense that it feels very much like the cards are mostly meaningless and then they kind of like tacked on like oh well you know we'll call this one farm because it gives you food and we'll call this one like woodcutter because it gives you wood but like a chipmunk chip sweep it's just it's just artwork it's just artwork that's slapped on there so for its theme rating everdell is really a one and i would only give it a one because
at least it has a theme the lowest rating is a zero and zero is like checkers so not impressed by the implementation of the theme at all if we look at wingspan by comparison it's a lot better but it's still not very impressive now what makes it better well right off the bat you're looking at the cards the cards have numerous facts about the animals that you're reading it talks about what continents they live in how large their wingspan is uh interesting information and then what i find really interesting is the information about the nests that they have and the number of eggs that they lay is proportionate to how many eggs they lay in real life it says that in the rule book also they have a environment and a um food that they that's representation representative of their actual diets in reality which is great you've got three environments here uh you've got dice that will help you you know gather food to feed your birds and all of that stuff is thematically very strong but the gameplay what are you doing again you're collecting cards which you're playing on a board in order to have more powerful actions so that you can collect more cards and the cards are worth points and they help you meet objectives it's basically the same type of gameplay nothing about what you actually do aside from where you place it it's something that go you go and like oh wow this is like a real bird watcher i bet this is done in real life like i don't know it doesn't represent
anything so i think that it's a lot better a lot more effort has gone into making a stronger theme but the gameplay it falls short um for theme i would give it a 2 or maybe even a 3 but not much higher than that so now let's talk about mechanics the mechanics rating is how ingenious is the gameplay and how memorable are the rules both of these games are really solidly average they're both card drafting games here you're drafting from a set of birds you've always got three that you can look at and you're placing them in different rows each row is associated with an action so there's a little bit of a placement factor over here in this game where you place the buildings doesn't matter you're just collecting 15 you can put them in a row you can put them in column whatever the placement is your workers so you're placing a worker over here to take that action and you're getting resources much like wingspan you're getting resources to pay the cost to draft the card and put it into your city and each card is either going to give you more resources or help you get more cards so both of them don't do anything very innovative which puts them in a pretty average score however there is something really clumsy about everdel something that i really don't like in everdel each round you have spring summer and autumn you're taking another worker so you start with two you take your
third one and the next round you take your fourth one and then in the last round you take your fifth and sixth one so you're placing more workers as the game goes on the game actually starts to drag on and feels like it's getting longer one of the things that the game designers did is they even made it so that the game is played at a different pace for every single player and it's very possible that after everyone is done somebody is still taking turns now i like thoughtful games and i like it where i really have to consider the best use of my workers but to have the game drag on is is not very appealing and i think that is not serving its mechanics score very well if we look at wing span by comparison in wingspan at the end of every round you're taking one of your action cubes and you're placing it on a scoring sheet so every round you actually have less and less moves but each move has become more powerful based on how you've played in your rows so the game actually feels like it's getting faster and this is really attractive to me so when it comes to mechanics while they're both kind of average this one is a solid five and this one i think is a little bit better because it takes classic mechanics and just adds something to make it more interesting with that like accelerated gameplay so i give it a 6 or a 7 for wingspan moving on to the next attribute is luck to know a little bit more about the luck score here's the thing with luck um i put a 7 at
right at the place where an inexperienced player can beat an experienced player based solely on luck now in both games uh it's card drafting so you get to look at several face up cards but technically speaking in everdel you can look at seven cards that are face up at any time or sorry eight cards that are face up and in wingspan you can look at three and in wingspan there's also dice and the roll of dice is going to determine what kinds of resources you can get in the first place so while in both games you spend time you know waiting for the lucky card to come up in wingspan there's a lot more waiting and hoping because there isn't so much exposed and then the dice i mean you can be holding on to the best card but because it requires a fish or because it requires a mouse and if you look at the dice there's only one fish and there's one mouse on here a lot more luck involved in wingspan so for wingspan luck a seven whereas in everdell luck is about a five or maybe a six i think in everdel an experienced player can always beat uh an inexperienced player even if they have bad luck but in wingspan um i mean almost anybody can play this and do well there's so much luck involved almost anybody could win the next category is strategy so strategy has to do with how much planning ahead and how many factors you
have to consider when making your move and strategy and luck kind of affect each other usually when there's more luck there's less predictability and you can't plan ahead which gives you a lower strategy score and in games where there's less luck you can usually plan more both games have high luck scores so it's really hard to say that they could have a high strategy score however because there are more cards exposed you can see more plans and you and you can actually pay closer attention to what other players are doing when you play everdell whereas in everdel there are objectives as well but everyone is competing for those objectives every single round and unfortunately if somebody draws the right card that plays into the objective they're going to probably win the objective or perform better than other players and there's nothing you can do about it because of luck so less foresight involved in this game lower strategy score i would say for strategy it's about a four or a five whereas everdell strategy is more like a seven last category is complexity so usually with complexity a four means that a child who can't read very well would not be able to play the game or or it's right on the boundary where like a six seven eight year old can play a game and usually that's because reading interferes with it both of these games involve a lot of reading and there's a lot of abstraction there
because every single card does a different thing uh you can't explain that you you have to read every single card to understand what it does and how it plays off of other cards so already you cannot have a lower score than a four or five you can't have a lower score than a five on these games because of how much longer everdel is and because the text on these cards is a little bit more complicated and the relationship between the cards is more complicated and because of the lack of a theme it's not very intuitive so everdell really has a much higher complexity than wingspan wingspan still has a lot of text on cards but largely the effects of cards are the same all of the predators they all kind of say the same thing they all basically get points for consuming birds with a smaller wingspan and so even though there might be gosh i don't know how many of each card 50 let's say 50 predators in the whole deck they're all basically the same you don't have repetition in the cards over here at everdel so with wingspan of 5 for complexity with everdell probably a 7 for complexity so hopefully that'll help you decide which of these games you prefer more i will now tell you my personal preference so when i buy games i'm always considering two things i'm looking for the games that i like and i'm looking for the games that my
family likes personally i would rather play everdell because i like games that are very thoughtful i like games that involve a lot of strategy and i do not like luck so i would play this over wingspan all the time however because of how much more drawn out this is my family would prefer to play wingspan and i would prefer to play a game that other people will play with me so i would own wingspan if i was planning on a game that more of my family would get in on and enjoy playing so that's my recommendation if you'd like to look at more comparisons and more scores using the perfect board game formula go ahead and check out theperfectboardgame.com and to have more recommendations don't forget to subscribe to my channel boardgamedad thank you so much for watching take care and bye