Is Hegemony the Best Game of 2023!?
Transcript
what's up everybody welcome back to the channel today we are reviewing hegemony hegemony and we have a special treat we brought in a third person to better represent the dueling classes yay yeah you'll be working class I be working class today I'm going to be capitalist you going be middle class A is an asymmetric hand management game that plays roughly 3 hours every class be a capitalist middle class working class or the state are doing their best to outperform the other classes on your turn You'll Play a card for your highly personalized hand of cards and then choose whether you'll play it for the action written on the card or discarded for the basic action after grueling five rounds of negotiating yelling and probably crying the game ends and whoever has the most points has achieved hegemony the theme of this game is incredibly impressive like I I was pretty shocked for what it felt like mechanically a fairly simple game everything felt like it perfect matched what it should have you know this is how people should design games where you have a theme first you have an idea that you want to communicate and then you find mechanisms that fit in with how it kind of like is in real life Mike can you come please help me in the kitchen you've been on the couch watching anime all day let's find out oh sorry sorry look I I pulled more of my cubes than I did of yours from the bag you know I I didn't I I got to stay
here and watch J just suuk kaisen you know it's not it's not me it's just them's the rules sorry yeah I totally agree like after playing many games with Mike and Kim that are obviously very fictional playing a game that is a little bit more realist for a fairly novice board game player it was kind of refreshing if you understand the theme I think the rules of the game is just like a quick learn it feels so like educational and not in a learning and not like a force it down your throat kind of way like it feels like it feels like a I'm not a big like RPG type player or like a D and D typ player I don't not my thing CU I I don't want to jump into we'll GA her to do that eventually for this channel Mike you can join we'll do D andd but that's a different top but my point is that this game like whatever class or faction whatever you give another state you feel like you jump into those shoes pretty like naturally it doesn't feel forced at all it feels like you really believe like no no freeo really is the best thing or like you know you really start to believe that and you really want that I don't know how a game's able to do that I feel like also if you choose different classes you you actually felt vested in you know making sure that your class was really well represented and the cars that you use really represented their best interest more so than any other game that it's it's like Kim was saying like it does feel as if the game is encouraging a sense of role playing like I'll be damned if you're able to play this game on your first or second play and not feel like you are that class like when the state starts increasing taxes when you're the capitalist you're like what is this I'm I'm being oppressed what is this
nonsense it's so painful every every character every class is able to propose a bill and they essentially can move a policy to the left or to the right through that mechanically you are facilitating a great amount of table talk and interaction between the players if you're the middle class you can be like well you know what I'm going to increase the decrease the cost of healthcare here I'll vote for you working class but you know you got to help me out over on this policy yeah I just like I mean because you're so uh you believe that you go that class right you're able to negotiate and kind of like um make under the table agreements like you know if I lower the prices of these things and lower inform Goods you're going to buy for me so it's cheaper for you that kind of thing there all these discussions I think a lot of games discourage and I think it's a big missed opportunity that this game really does um capitalize on it is a different game in a sense that most games you're either working for yourself or your own board or you're really coming after other people this game somehow makes it so that you're kind of watching for your own again your own class but you kind of you need to make some concessions with the other classes too you can't operate in your own little bubble exactly yeah in society yeah yeah you can't just close in and go on your own thing you lost the first game you play I did I was the middle class and I was just like oh I can create businesses and I can go to work I'll just ignore can't do it all by yourself I got nothing passed nothing no bills are being passed I just lost so the way the voting works is you draw these little cubes from a bag and you
people vote yay or nay on the bill and then whoever gets their colors the most colors out ends up passing the bill but you go in turn order and everybody's allowed to spend what the game calls influence and so the influence thematically could be something like fry exactly it could be like back room dealing and stuff so like everybody like picks up their cubes and you can decide like and you do it secretly too so nobody has no idea any idea the Shady stuff it's like you know who it's the Shady stuff it's like who you know not like what you know kind of thing is it do you get stuff to go through yeah mechanically it just it just works so well for the theme maybe but yeah you always had lots of influence it hit it hit and even the mechanic behind constructing a business Works beautifully in this game so both the middle class and the capitalist can create businesses and so if it gets to the point where the middle class feels like maybe the working class isn't working with them he can be sort of diabolic and be like well I'm going to build those business that's a small you know family run joint that doesn't hire part-time workingclass employees and it's going to be purely self- functional so you're just going to be unemployed but but then the working class can strike back and say well okay then I'll just go and strike in your other businesses and it really also depends on again who you're playing with uh you know depending on your class so for instance when I was playing working class I was really cognizant about my population with immigration so I need to make sure the policies were voted that way and making sure they were employed and so as soon as they were not and there was a mechanism I think where if you had too many any unemployed individuals you can have the option of
going on strike and so it's not like you're coming after the other classes but it's just more of a representation of hey we need income because we need to be employed to keep the economy going so goes back to just you know learning these little things about right your your class yeah exactly and the game facilitates that too right like because one of the policies you can vote for is the immigration policy so it's like okay we can get more immigrants to increase the economic prosperity of of a lot of people at this board but we also might get an influx of a lot of unemployed people if we don't have enough business to hire these people which means the working class can go on strike this why you were awful Lim class CU he he kept opposing all immigration and he really just only like that's the strategy that was the best strategy of the time immigration no trade just you know that was the best okay no I guess not I lost but that was the worst strategy you lost but it felt like a good strategy at the time I was like yeah makes just only like give my own employees jobs and only my companies and I'll feed only okay but hear me out one of the mechanics that you have one of the mechanics you have in the game is the middle class and the lower class the working class have to purchase Goods they have to be consumers to gain victory points because it's all about the prosperity of their their class just have no money they can't sell anything exactly but it's it's directly proportionate to the population level so the higher you rise your population but be that you be the working class or the middle class the more you have to supply for them that that that's why I kept my population low because I wanted to keep the cost low keep the demand low so you
can keep the supply low I feel like with any of the classes you can win the only one I'm like it on is the state I feel like the state is not no no I feel the state we all hate the government no state is the hardest to win in the game I well State strategy and like goals are very he kind of has to balance everybody exactly it's a little more difficult because it's so like abstract compared to everyone else where it's very want t but you know the happiness of your workers there is a very clear track and of how to achieve that capitalist money very easy to keep TR how much money do you actually have for the state it was like super unclear that's only one I'm like you that's why I think that's why we talk about to we only we love playing three players there no State there isn't that like unclear figure and unclear objective nobody likes to play the state so but we should say that this is this is pretty much like a four player game three player did work really well I think had a four player actually you think so I think so I think you're I think the state is important though you're missing no okay I I feel like it is a deao four-player game but I think it did function very well mhm I would say when we were played three player missing the state was a bit of an issue because really I think the goal is to make everyone on par balanced right you can't have you know too many um unemployed workers can't have the capitalist having too much money so I think the state really does play almost the functions like a a dungeon master a moderator because he's trying to make everybody at the table happy I've never gotten a benefit from the state I was always losing she's just bitter and trust me the state does things this is a good four player it does it does do does
help with some things and I do agree that you know it's nice to have someone that actually is watching the fund of the state money and stuff but I I kind of like when it's a bit more extreme and like Capital scho really crazy or the Wen crass middle class I like being able she likes the chaos but we can't just gush endlessly and and Rave about this game no we can't we we have we are critics there are some issues we I won't speak for everybody I'm going to speak for myself I I did find that you know we played quite a bit and everybody got a chance to play every single role and I felt that I felt that the working class was kind of boring and so because it's asymmetric you're going to have issues where some people won't have as much fun with some classes I I agree but I think it's almost like personality dependent I feel like can be said about any game where you know there's asymmetric or like there different types of player powers stuff people have their own personal preferences to things like I personally love capitalist class working class I feel like yeah you're just stuck being everyone's employee being call in the machine I think it Rage Against the Machine I think it does lead to my personal like values stuff and that's why I don't let the state cuz I feel it's boring to just Bally I have because we hate the government we pay too many taxes I mean always Revolution what I said but I I don't I I personally have I like having a personal objective and I like to win and I like the status is very like I don't know like try to be the the middl man be like a it's okay it's okay all the kids can
play like and get along well like I want to be the Victor exactly that's why I like to say but that's what you say about the uh working class and that's why I feel like it's it depends it's a I think it's more individual preferences rather than a fault of the game yeah like when I play working class I think I I totally agree I felt like the the one-way track was to happiness which to me excellent um even he just wants to Kat Kat Kat IP iPad IP all you do is just work and Buy iPads um yeah like I it's it really again it depends on who you play with right so someone coming in and just really if you have a friend that you want to play with that you want to introduce him to a sort of heavier game I feel like this is a really good like introduction to a heavier game that 4 Hour intruction no to a heavier game the class because you can give him you can give the individual that work in class yes because it's a little simpler and so they can get their head around but the one criticism I have which was which is kind of related to that and this is an additional criticism is that the game kind of feels player group dependent in that it kind of it doesn't require it but it definitely uh benefits from having the same group of people you play with because and this is a good thing and this is a bad thing but the game the way the balance of the game works is the Players balance one another if the working class gets too far ahead okay and score it is up to the state for example to maybe close some businesses in the public available business section or maybe it's up to the capitalist class to make their goods a bit more expensive
and if you're a new player and you have a new player sitting at that table he's not going to balance the other players as well as an experienced player is good so it's not it's not a huge deal but it's something to keep in mind we really like this game but we don't think it's for everyone no we I think that everybody should try it everybody should at least try it I think this is an experienced game bring your grandmother bring that's right but it's don't everybody should not rush out and buy this game I know I know we're hyping the living hell out of this game but everybody should not it is amazing but you should not buy it until you're like d that sure that your player group is going to enjoy this game yeah like playing a heavy game like this for the first time I remember Mike saying this is going to be a hard game like he mentally prepared me to actually pay attention which you really need to in this game so I guess it could be a con if you're just looking to just hang out with a few friends and just really unwind so to speak because this one actually you need to be fairly engaged right or else you just won't be and like pull it out be like hey come over for some drinks and dinner that and like forour game let's go um unless your friend is like that kind of would be down for it don't just you that's say just this out it's a game understand that come over for this game all right so let's get the final thoughts Mike you're the working class we're going to go bottom up we're not going to trickle down we're going to bottom up you start yeah I really enjoy the game it's great I learned a lot um love the mechanics um you know it's just just find good friends to play with I guess that's my conclusion score oh score out of 10 10
out of 10 n and a half and a half we two halfes here oh uh nine okay yeah for me personally it was the top game of 2023 uh I give it a 10 out of 10 it is my most memorable game of the year and I think big part of is and if you watched our videos before you know that I love theme for me it's the theme theme drives the gameplay it was so well thought out that I enjoyed every play of it every minute of it for like four hours per play and it's the kind of game where I can I can see wanting to play 10 years later it's so nice and refreshing to see something so incredibly unique that provides such a wonderful memorable experience when playing and and that it's not for everybody this is not you know these designers didn't set out to create a game that's going to appeal to you know everybody and I love that I love that because sometimes when you try to appeal to everybody you appeal to nobody this is going to be a game that's going to require a very specific audience and I am that audience I am that audience and so I I would give this I would give this a nine no a 10 F I give this a nine I give this a nine yeah I think it's I think it's a brilliant game and I think it's something that everybody should try so I hope I hope this review has helped you in trying to make your purchasing decision I know we did a lot of hyp train stuff it's not supposed to be hyp train it's just it's such a good like Well Done game right outside of um whether like this game just if you look at all the details just so well done you have to give it a shot yeah give it a shot even
if you don't think the theme is for you and I ADM the them Stu everybody but the game the play the enjoyment that I'm like who can deny that we need we need to find an economics professor just play with us and see what their enjoyment level is no we'll lose terribly and then we'll be like embarrassed possibly all right guys thank you so much for watching bye peace subscribe like comment all of the Revolution oh that reev revolutionize the Subscribe button boom bye peace uh in conclusion excellent game say in conclusion conclusion