Skip to main content
Loading video...

Vasco da Gama Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 21:03

hey everybody today i'm talking about vasco de gama which is a 2009 release board game designed by paolo mori and published by what's your game this one takes 90 to 120 minutes to play and accommodates two to four players now if you can't tell by the box art alone this one is your quintessential dry and beige euro where you're trying to get as many victory points as you can over five rounds the game board is basically divided up into these different sections where you have kind of independent actions which you're going to take and i suppose the core mechanisms you're going to use is an element of worker placement you've got some programming and a smidge of push your luck and that's because the order in which you do things is based on this really innovative initiative mechanism which to be honest i've never ever seen before and i find it quite intriguing so as you can see here from this section you've got this grid numbered from 1 to 20 and basically the first part of the game is you're going to be drafting these different numbers so for example you know the one would be um guarantee you to go first place in these terms in terms of taking your actions as 20 would go last but you might think oh why don't i always just go for the lower numbers and get the best initiative and that's because of this token here so as you can see this big number five indicates where this little token goes this little pawn and what that means is that at the moment everything below that five is going to end up costing money equal to the distance of the token and where that marker is so if i was to take the two then i'm gonna pay a difference of three

because the difference between two and five is three and i will say that money is extremely tight in this game so that is not an easy decision to make but that is not perfect information either because once you've actually ended up drafting all your different numbers you are going to flip the next tile over and that is going to show where that marker moves so it's going to move up or down up a maximum of three or down a maximum of three which is going to change the uh the amount of money you're going to have to pay say for example that would go to a five to a seven meaning now that everything under a seven is going to cost you money but you've already taken or you've already drafted the numbers that you want so um you know it's tough luck if you've taken all the low numbers and you can't afford to resolve your actions so i think this is a really cool system and basically you're going to take do that four times because you've got four actions you can take and once you take one of those numbers you're going to say let's say i take this 11. and you're going to put it on one of these different action spots here now as you can see based on the scaling you've got different number of action spots here so in a two player game the first three spots are available on each area um in the three the next one and the four the next one as well so in a two player game these two spots are essentially blocked to keep the game nice and tight so let's take a look at what the actual actions are so the idea is you're supposed to be sending them or kind of collecting crew collecting boats and sending them off to voyage and you can do that in a pretty systematic way so for example this area here lets you take a number of these different crew members into your kind of supply and that is based on this chart here so if you want to take all of one color from one of these

different windows and this is scaled based on the player count as well so in a three player game you've got three of these windows open and the two player only two and four or four of them will be open but you're gonna look on this chart as i said and maybe depending on the number of different pawns that you want to take so say i wanted to take three different colors um i would have to pay six but that doesn't mean that i have to pay for all the pawns so that that would count as a single color so i could for example take these two oranges as just um just by paying one coin now in addition to that you can always choose to buy a captain of your own color and that's going to cost you one coin per each other crew member that you've taken that turn and these are really important because you're going to need them in order to sail and to get points the next area is this one here which is based on these characters and these characters are going to offer you kind of unique player player abilities throughout the game and you've got four different characters here and you've got this additional section like this where you can get money and that money is indicated at the start of the round based on this tile here so five coins is going to go in the top box three coins in the second box so you can always go there and take a bit of money to boost your finances but as i said you've got these player powers as well and these can do really cool things and what i really like about this game is that you can actually have more than one of these powers should you want to and you can actually stockpile them and really boost off each other and get really powerful turns if you choose to invest in getting all the characters so the first one is the king and the king is going to give you the ability to take another

worker but unfortunately you're going to have to be restricted to going 21st or 22nd in initiative order so you are always guaranteed to almost go last but you can still get a powerful another action out of that um it's particularly useful if you aren't too fussed about going first the the priest guy here lets you take one of these missionaries which basically counts as a uh a separate uh what you call like a crew member but of a different color and these are useful because some of the boats require more workers than others and you might need a white one and basically at the end of each turn you're gonna end up generating one of these white ones automatically should you control the priest the the salesman here the merchant he lets you send off the merchant ships onto this board here which i'll explain shortly and this guy is simple he just gives you initiative order in terms of breaking the ties you'll always go first and he'll generate you two points at the end of each round and if anybody ever snatches him off you by taking that player power he'll he'll generate two points instantly this area here is going to be where you are actually going to buy your ships in the first place and to do that you are either going to pay one coin in order to take one ship or four coins to take two ships from this area here additionally you can always choose to pay coins using this area here and you're going to pay a coin for each one of these symbols here so this will say two so it's going to cost me two coins to take this one but these ships work in quite an interesting way so let's say i had bought this um this

seven tile here so what this means is that i'm gonna have to cash in four workers of different colors it doesn't matter what those colors are as long as they're different and when i do that i can flip it over like so which means that the ship is almost ready to sell as long as i have a captain to go with it and if i have a captain i'm going to go to this area here and potentially send them on a bit of a voyage so let's say i've done that and i can send them to any of these areas equal to or lower to the value of their ship so as you can see this is a value seven ship so i could send it up to a value seven and get a corresponding reward uh instantly so let's say i put it here like this i would generate two points instantly but could potentially gain more out of doing that so after all the tokens have been drafted and all the workers have been placed onto the board they are going to be resolved in initiative order so even though this yellow player placed first in this area the red player will still go first because the initiative value is lower than the yellows so for example the three is going to take their tile before any other player does so that's a really cool interesting mechanism here that can add a lot of depth to the game and really does add that element of programming because you don't want to start taking actions that you can't really fulfill before having other criteria in your kitty so for example i might want to send something on a voyage but i don't have the crew members or the ship to do it in the first place so it's really important that you get things in the right order and basically managing how much you're

willing to pay in order to go first so i really do like that element uh in addition if you ever do find yourself backed into a corner not having the funds or anything to do the action that you wanted to do you can always choose to discard the token in order to get the amount of money depending on the row it's on so for example if this if the yellow player forsake or did forsake his 11 action he can end up taking three money to his bank so once all the actions have been resolved you're going to go into the next phase which this area of the board is really going to start coming into play so when this happens you are going to look at the um all the different ships onto the under these different locations so for example you've got the uh you know the red nine here and the yellow seven and you're going to have a look at all the different symbols in this top right hand corner of each tile so the red player is going to start generating points you've got two points for the red player you've got two points for the yellow player you've also got another point here for the yellow player and a coin for the yellow player so if they're on the board you're going to start generating things based on the tile but in addition to that if there's ever a row completed for example here this location in terra d boa gente is completely filled with tiles then they are going to shift up into the next row if there is a place for it and to do that you're going to have a look at the number so this is the number five or in fact the number six boat you're going to go up into the next row if there's a free slot for it and occupy it like this and it's also going to apply for this one here but still abiding by that restriction of that you can only go to a location equal to or lower than your then your tile value

and as you can probably tell there is quite a bit of scope here to get more and more mileage out of your ships should you choose to invest them early you know for example you might want to place a quite a high number on a four even though it's going to get you fewer points by only getting four points you are potentially going to keep shifting up and generating more and more things so you know you can end up scoring one point and then two points and three points and four points as long as the um those rows are completed but of course it's a big gamble because if there's ever not a spot for you to go into let's say for example this six here or let's just say this was occupied by pretending that was a six or something um then this one shifts up and if it's got nowhere to go it's going to get taken out of the game and stop generating points but you will get your captain back ready to use later whoever's got the sailor tile is also going to have the option to place one of these merchant ships and these are really good because not only when you place them are you going to get the reward instantly such as getting you know a new crew member a new captain some money um but they are also really useful to be blockers and also used to um or can be used to your advantage if you choose to fill up a row that you particularly have loads of people on so you could do this for example just to complete the row so that you start generating points and that's a really cool mechanism mechanism as well that can be used to interact with the other players in quite a catty way but also quite a beneficial way and that's basically going to be how the game is going to play out until five rounds are over and then you're going to calculate who's got the most victory points so if you can get over the pure dryness of this game

there is a lot to like about this one some pretty innovative mechanisms that i haven't seen before particularly in relation to the initiative order this is fantastic so not only are you trying to get things in the right order by placing things in the right spots and activating them but also bearing in mind how much you potentially are going to pay for these things and whether you are going to take a gamble and just to get those lower initiative orders so for example you know this seven could be the benchmark and i could really gamble for this four and i could potentially be free for me if it goes down three spots but it also could go go up three spots and end up costing me a small fortune in order to take that four to get priority of the action i want i think that's really great it adds a lot of scope to the game and i think where a lot of the depth really does shine through but in addition to that i do like this this system here so this is quite dynamic and has an element of area control that i haven't seen before where things are shifting and aren't just stagnant because not only are they going to start generating new things it's a bit of an engine you know you've got the coins and the points they're going to generate but once those rows are complete they are going to shift up into the new spots and potentially get you more that way and it does keep things feeling fresh things are constantly going on and off the board the merchants are going on and off the board and just kind of blocking things and it already all does always tie back to this initiative order and the way you're gonna do things and i do like the way it all works together and how you're gonna have to kind of link up your actions and program the way you're gonna do things i also really love the way that the player powers work now these aren't

you know they aren't massive um extremely deep kind of player characters who just change the game a lot but they do add um quite a bit of sizzle into your game and if you have them in your possession they can start ramping up some nice benefits you know getting an extra action pattern is extremely valuable generating one of these missionaries a town it does start to pay off and have having an income of crew members without even having to go to the crew members spot is really worth having even just having the um the first player marker from start to finish and you've got five turns there and they each generate or this one generates you two points per turn that can get you quite a significant point swing should you need it and of course the merchant is also useful and the fact that you could have more than one i thought was fantastic and it does kind of keep the jostling for position and keep battling for these characters um throughout the game because you do want them at your disposal i would say that without this initiative mechanism the game is pretty linear and probably does have a bit of a glass ceiling on where or what you can get out of it because it is pretty um formulaic in terms of what you're doing you know getting a ship loading it up with crew members and sending them off to get points and i suppose you could say that about a lot of games but the fact that you do have that um unique element of the game something that does make it stand out from the crown and make it feel a bit different is really nice because a lot of people or sorry a lot of games do go back to those state same old standard tropes and just keep doing the same thing again and again just with a new skin whereas this one does at least have something to call its own and something that you

can think you know this is what vascular the gamma does differently to everything else so i do always love it when a game tries something different and vasco de gama certainly does have its own identity simply because of this core mechanism now the game does take about 90 to 120 minutes to play um i would say that maybe in the initial game that you play this it's going to take more towards that two-hour mark but if you've got players who are more familiar with this one you're going to start getting through those turns quite quickly and i potentially think you can get that down under the 90-minute mark i'm sure you play this regularly because in reality the turns aren't too complex yes you're going to have a bit of a puzzle in your head in which order you're going to resolve things there's going to be a bit of analysis paralysis at times where you think you know can i afford take to take this action should the marker go up so that these are up but but these things that can bulk the kind of turns down and make things take a bit longer are what adds the interest to the game in the first place so i think in times of the time investment i think the game does a good job of keeping things interesting throughout and you are always trying to map out your turns quite or as efficiently as you can to make things you're doing things in the right order but also breaking initiative in terms of getting the particular tiles you want because if there's a really strong 11 spot going and there's no other ones available and you really want this 11 tile you're going to have to take a gamble to take a note a low initiative but sometimes you'll find yourself not having the funds to do that should the market go up so it really is a game of tight resource management in terms of managing your money but sometimes taking

that gamble is going to pay off and sometimes it's really going to kind of blow up in your face because i found myself timed in this game where i took a whole turn and i just didn't have the funds to do what i wanted to do when i thought i would and i ended up pretty much wasting a whole turn but you will get compensated for that in future rounds and you can actually recover from that should you play well now i will say i am a little bit concerned about the replayability of vasco de gama because there really isn't much variability there isn't much modularity in this game whatsoever i suppose the only differences is going to be the order in which these tiles come out that's going to kind of influence the game quite a bit um and of course the different ships and things coming out and and the availability of the workers that's the only kind of dynamic element of the game for example the um characters here they're always going to be the same from game to game they're always going to do the same thing so it would have been nice to maybe you've seen these character tiles be sided or something and have a slightly different or slightly tweak on what they can do from game to game to keep things a bit more interesting because you are essentially going to be doing the same thing every time you play it the player interaction is passive but it's pretty meaningful in this game and you're certainly going to feel the influence of the other players as you play it because they're going to start taking the titles that you want um are they going to um you know take or kind of trump you in terms of getting the initiative and bearing in mind that they're going to have to pay for that you've got a limited resources in terms of the crew members you're going to take because you might want a particular crew member and again they're going to beat you in initiative and snatch all the ones that

you want so this isn't a game where you can ignore your opponents and you are going to have to think about what they're going to do in order to prioritize your actions and beat them to the post this i suppose the main part of the interaction doesn't lie here because you are going to want to control these rows particularly these higher powered ones here where you are going to potentially be generating a lot of points should that row be complete and sometimes you'll find yourself completing them by getting a big bunch of points initially but you have to bear in mind that you're going to potentially be generating a lot of points for them if they're dominating the row in terms of control so there is a bit of give and take there and you're going to have to min max your turns i'm kind of way up if those decisions are going to be worth it for you or going to benefit your opponent more than it is yourself i do think this game is going to have or going to be somewhat polarizing in terms of the way it looks there are going to be a lot of people who look at this game and just think instantly that it's going to be boring and i can completely understand why it's very brown you've got these grumpy old nobles from many years ago but i suppose if you are a fan of the euro genre this is something you've come to expect and probably going to be something that you're going to start to like and enjoy but it's not going to be one of those games that are going to start inviting people to play and it does feel very stuffy it is the quintessential beige brown euro however the production quality is good i mean all these worker tokens are extremely nice and like you know they're nice and thick and durable the um the board is very clearly laid out you know you've got these nice different segmented areas on the board which are very easy to determine which

does what you know this section is this this section does this and so on whereas which i really like because i think it makes the game a lot easier to explain and also the meeples are nice and chunky all the tiles are really good and durable so yeah no no complaints in terms of the quality of the game but i suppose the visual aspect is going to be somewhat um polarizing i would also say that i would hesitate to play this game at two players because i think that initiative puzzle isn't as interesting and it isn't quite as um you know thought provoking if that third player or that fourth player is injected into the game because i do really like the way that you know you it's not like an area by area is resolved at a time you know this might be the number one might be here then the number two then number three then then four and i do like the way that all works together and the more players invested in the game that way um it starts to become a bit more brain wracking and the puzzling aspect to it does start to shine through a bit more and again the added interest in terms of um breaking the bank in order to go first is going to start shining through so the final thoughts on vascular gamma are that this game is extremely sharp um yes i'm always going to go back to this initiative mechanism that is really where the game does start to shine through but i was equally as impressed by this system here the way that the um the ships move the things that you're going to have to invest in the race you get your ships loaded up and sent to these areas to get the most points to get the initial bonuses i love the way that things are

triggered in order i love the mistakes that you can make in this game it actually adds a lot more interest to it because you will find yourself making mistakes and silly things that you didn't mean to do and i'm overseeing some mistakes that you've seen along the way there is some scarceness in terms of getting to these worker placement spots which is important and you can actually use them to use that to your advantage if you want to block people out of the certain spots here because you know you might just take a high token you've got no intention of using it and just to stop people going from a certain spot and just to take up one of those locations to go to because you might really know that someone wants to snatch a player power off you i want to grab one of these areas so i love the way you can use them as blockers in order to just take money overall um you know not to beat around the bush the game is so well put together yes it is so dry it is so brown and you know that that in itself is going to put a lot of people off but the gameplay is fun despite the way it looks and um i would recommend it so that is vasco de gama a great mid-weight euro that i had a lot of fun with and this one gets my shield of quality so i hope you've enjoyed this review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved