Gnomic Parliament Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel
Transcript
Gnome Parliament is a voting game in which you are a member of the Parliament of Gnomes, and you're going to work on your procedures and blah blah blah. You're voting on rules. And these rules affect the gameplay, but you want to vote with the majority because who doesn't want to be part of the majority? Here's how it plays. I'm going to tell you mostly the basic rules of the game, and in this game players are going to have their character and they'll have be like this. You also have some lobby uh tokens that you'll have. There'll be some laws placed out here, and you're going to set a deck up. Now, I have the whole deck here, but it will be a much smaller deck than that because there'll be some game end cards shuffled in the bottom six of the deck, and when both of those comes out, that triggers the end of the game. One person is president, so the president will put this there to show you're president. And the president each round is going to pick a law that we're going to vote on.
And each player has a yes or no vote, and you're going to put that on top of your character as to whether you're voting yes or no. You may also place lobby votes on here, and in fact, if you place three lobby votes on there, for every three you get an extra one. So, if I had six, I could put six on here, and then I would add two more lobby votes to this. You're allowed to discuss and everything, and the president can tell people to hurry up who haven't voted yet. Once everyone has voted, you will turn these over, and this counts as one vote, and each lobby cube that you have is one vote. But, before we turn them over, players can also secretly bid a certain These are three lobby votes. Can bid a certain amount of lobby votes secretly in their hand, but these will not have an additional votes added to them like the open lobby votes will.
So, you add together all the lobby votes plus these, and if the yeses win, then this will become a law, pushing any law that's already up there down one farther. If it's a temporary law, this will For example, this is going to give the president an every second known a victory point. But if it goes into play, everyone who voted yes gets a victory point. And you will have spots here underneath your characters to as you get victory points, you'll score them like this and the threes go here. And tens, which you may or may not get, will go here. But anyhow, if you if the law doesn't pass, then everyone who votes no will get the get points for voting no. Uh but there's all sorts of things like this when the law's in play. Like for example, this says the gnome who if you're the only person to vote no when this law's in play, you'll get two victory points.
This one says anyone who had who didn't get honor points, the victory points, uh who didn't vote with the majority gets two lobby cubes. And so these laws will be here, but there will only ever be three laws in play at a time. If more permanent laws come, then these get pushed off, but they affect the game. The gnome who votes the same way as his two neighbors gets two victory points. So those are going to change how the game plays, and then these temporary laws also everyone gets three. And those without lobby votes even get four. So these are going to come into play and it's going to keep going. Once the first game end card shows up, if you vote with the majority, you'll get two points for voting with the majority as opposed to one. And then when the second game card comes up, that ends the game and whoever has the most of these points is the winner.
This game has some clever ideas. One idea in the rules that I like a lot is when you are the president, you pick the law and everyone votes on it. You can then remain president if you want to. If you pass the presidency on to the next person in clockwise turn order, you will get two of those lobby cubes, which are important to have cuz you want to play them out there. But you can keep it. But in the advanced rules, which I think you should play, if someone has lower points than the winner, uh like three points lower than the winner and they're not doing very well, they can challenge that and then players can vote kick you out as president and there's a new president. I I find that to be amusing. This game is very similar to an old game called Democrazy from Bruno Faidutti in which that was a game also where everyone voted on things. The lobbying votes I I I think it's an interesting concept. You can play lobby votes out beforehand, you know, and that for every three you get an extra vote.
Or you can have secret votes in your hand. That's kind of fun. You actually don't know how people are voting, but you're kind of wanting to vote the same way as everyone else. You have discussions, you're not allowed to trade points or or the lobby votes to do that, but you can have all these discussions and that makes it interesting. But it's just shy of being good. It's it's a little procedural for the sake of being procedural. It makes you make rules that are about the rules that you follow. And it just misses that point where you're like, "This was so much fun." Cuz it's not quite there. It There's some cool concepts. It's It's kind of there, but it doesn't make it completely. So, yeah, I I I like a lot of the parts of it, but just doesn't come together in a complete way even when playing with the advanced rules, which I think honestly just add more baggage and overhead. It's probably better with the basic rules as is. So, a six out of 10.
It's not bad, but when it's done, you're like, "I don't know if I want to play this again." And that bugs me. I love this idea and I'm still waiting for someone to make a game like these where it's just whackadoodle fun as you're playing through it. But the laws themselves are like, "No." Yes is when a tie. Oh, okay. Now the only person to vote no gets points, great. That's a little more interesting than the other rules, but Ah, just it just feels like it's missing that spark for me. So, that's Gnomic Parliament.