Skip to main content
Loading video...

Fantasy Brewers Review - With Graeme

Transcript 12:36

Hello everybody. This is Graeme and today I'm going be looking at a game called Fantasy Brewers. Now in this game you take on the role of a dwarven brew master competing to make the perfect brew for this year's annual beerfest. You'll be managing your brewery farm and assistants. And at the end of the game, the player who best managed to sell goods, acquire buildings, and hire helpers will be awarded the Golden Stein at this year's Beerfest. Now, this game is kind of a worker placement game combined with resource management, but not heavily on either one. Each round, players will be placing workers out in front of the different doors of the city, starting with their smallest worker and proceeding up to the largest worker. Everybody has three differentiz workers. When a larger meuple is placed behind a smaller mele in line, the smaller meuple must pay a coin or move to the back of the line. Once all the meuples are placed, they're going to be resolved for each door from front of the line to the back of the line. So, what got me for this one is the idea of brewing the best beer for a festival. I kind of like that theme. Not sure why we had to be dwarven brewers, but I'm fine with that. I was also intrigued by the worker placement piece. The idea that the largest workers essentially threaten the smaller workers to either playing a coin or moving behind them in line should make for some interesting decisions. So, will this be like a refreshing beer on a hot summer's day or more like that flat skunky beer that's been sitting in the fridge for too long?

Let's get it to the table, see how it's played, and I'll come back with my final thoughts on Fantasy Brewers. Here's Fantasy Brewer set up. The board is placed in the middle of the table, and the A and C doors are closed as per the round chart on the side of the board. Now, these doors will flip each round as shown here. The round marker starts at one and each player receives a board with their pawns of their color on their spots. A small, medium, and large pawn. Below the board are five face up draw piles, all with their basic sides up. And besides that, you're going to have three piles of assistant cards with their colorful side up. At the side of the board, shuffle the extension cards and place them in a pile and deal out four, making sure that all the cards are on their non-decorated side up. Do the same for the homestead cards. The statue cards are just placed in the pile because they're all the same. All the coins and VP tokens are placed to one side. Now, for this beginner game, each player takes a brewery card with a single icon in the top right. They receive all the items shown on their card. A random player is given the first player token. Now, a key rule in this game is the rule of three. You can never have more than three of anything. Three copies of each card. So, no more than three growers, three brewers, three extensions, three decorated homesteads, three animals of a single type. But the only thing you can have more of three of is coins and VP. The game is played over five months in this basic setup. Each month has four phases. A worker placement phase, an action phase, an upkeep phase, and a cleanup phase.

During the worker placement phase, players will take turns placing their workers at either a city door or at a tavern. On each of your turns, you will place your next smallest worker at a door. If you place your smallest worker at a door, you'll receive the bonus of that door. You know, get two coins, get a coin, and flip one of your festival tokens over. Get a coin and turn over one of your assistant cards. If you place any size worker at a tavern, you get a coin, flip over a festival token to the white side, and flip over one or two assistants so to their face up side. Now, one key thing about the worker placement phase. If you place a worker at a door, you start from the front of the line, and any other players workers in front of you that is smaller, you demand a coin from this owner. If they pay, the worker stays where they are. If they don't pay, the worker goes to the back of the line. Do this for all these smaller workers in front of your newly placed worker. Now, this does not happen at the tavern. All meuples are welcome at the tavern. Once all players have placed all their workers, we move on to the action phase. Starting at door A and working towards door C, activate the line from the front to the back for the workers. When a worker is actioned, the owner places it into an empty action spot on the door and can perform two actions in either order. The action of the spot they placed the worker on and the action from the door itself. The player can only do each action once, and if they decide not to do one of the actions, they receive a coin instead. If there are no spots left when it's your turn to place a worker, move it to the tavern instead and receive that placement bonus. If any action requires you to pay something, if it's money, return to the bank. If it's beer, grain, or strength, which is the fist, flip over one of your face up assistance cards to pay for it. You cannot use

these assistants again this round unless you flip the assistant card over. The door actions are pretty straightforward. Get a coin, flip an assistant card over, flip a festival token over to the white side, and I will be talking about what these festival tokens are later. Buy a good, pay the cost and receive the good. Hire an assistant. Again, pay for it and then receive one of the assistants or earn a claim. For each one of the symbols or cards depict on this type, you receive VP tokens when you take the acclaim action. Now, there are two other actions which are slightly more complicated, but not much. First is the build action. This allows you to build one extension, homestead or statue. Four coins for an extension, a statue for eight, or a homestead for 10. Take one of the face up cards and place on the matching side of your board. Now, instead of buying a new extension, statue or homestead, you can decorate one of your existing cards. Pay three coins to flip your one of your cards over. Once it's been decorated, it can't be decorated again and flipped back to the first side. Now, extension cards, when you buy them, give you an ongoing ability, but when they flipped, they lose that special ability, but do give you five victory points at the end of the game. Statues, when flipped, will give you more VP at the end of the game.

And homestead cards will give you a way of scoring at the end of the game, but if it's flipped over, it's going to give you a flat 10 victory points. The last dollar action is the sell action. Now, when you sell, you can sell either version of your cards, that is small goats and large goats, as long as they're the same. You're just selling goats. For each card sold, receive the income as shown on door two and return the card to the supply. Also note that the month you're in, often they will give you a bonus for selling a particular good. If you sold the particular type, you receive a reward. Now, you only get this reward once per sale, not per card sold. Once all the workers have been activated, move on to the pay upkeep phase. Every small animal has to be fed one grain. Flip a face down grower or brew master over. If you feed a small animal, you flip it to its larger side. If it's already on the larger side, it's not need to be fed. If you cannot feed your animal, they stay on whichever side they're currently on.

Next, you have to pay upkeep for your extension, homesteads, and statues. And some brewery cards also require upkeep. pay coins or flip over the appropriate assistance. For each icon you cannot pay, flip over one of your white festival tokens to the black side. If all your tokens are already on the black side and you still need to pay, you take a minus VP token and flip all your festival tokens back over to the white side and continue flipping the festival tokens until you've covered all the costs. This minus VP when flipping festival tokens continues until all the costs are paid. Once upkeep is paid, you just do the round cleanup. Move the starting player token. All players return their workers, turn the next door over, making sure to follow with the guide on the board, replenish the extensions and homesteads, so there are five face up cards, and move the calendar marker. At the end of the game, players receive one point for each card that they have. They get points from their homesteads, extensions, and statues. Add their VP tokens claimed during the game. Premium beer and smoked whiskey score points for the more you have. For every five coins, you get a point, and you lose three points for every minus VP token you have. And the player with the most points is the winner. Let's get back to see what I thought about Fantasy Brewers. Let's start with theme and components. For the theme, I thought I was really going to like the theme of this one. Collecting the ingredients to brew several different types of beers, but instead you're really not brewing any beer. Some of your assistants have beer, and you can make some premium beer, but not a lot. But that doesn't seem to be the prime focus of the game and the mechanisms. You do a lot more with buying and selling other resources like animals and houses. And I still don't get why you had to be dwarves. So, for

me, this theme was a letown. It makes the teach a little more difficult because you're really not brewing beer, and you have to kind of get people out of that mindset of that's what the point of the game is. For the components, again, I do have some issues with the production. First, the homestead and extension cards and their placement. It says in the rule book to place them on the board and deal the top four cards out beside the board, which covers up the costs printed on the board. No big deal. Just put them beside the board. The bigger issue is the prices printed on the board. The board is misprinted for the extension and the homestead cards. They have the prices reversed. Again, not a huge deal, but something that should have been caught and again makes the teach a little more difficult because you have to tell people to ignore what's printed on the board. The other issue I have is the rule book. It's not just as crisp enough as it should be for a fairly straightforward game. For example, it says place the extension of home sex cards essentially face up and top four cards are dealt out. So, you essentially see five cards and you can buy any of the five including off the one off the top of the deck. If you purchase a card from the row, it's not refilled, you know, therefore reducing the number of cards available. But if you buy the one from the top of the deck, it's still there.

So, you still have five to choose from, which is just kind of weird. The other components are fine. I don't have a problem with the art, although it is very generic looking, but it's fine. So, although I do have some issues with the components, none of it's kind of game-breaking, and most of it is easily fixed or just accepted and you move on. Now, on to the gameplay. There are bits of the game I do like. Although not new, the mechanism of threatening the smaller meuples is a fun idea. Going to spot with a small worker will get you a bonus and sometimes you really need that bonus and hopefully you also need to perform an action at that door and sometimes you really need to take an action and will pay to make sure that you can stay at the front of the line to actually do it. But this leads to the part that I find very procedural in the game. The only way to get Pete is to sell either hops or pig in round two. So, guess what everyone wants to get in the first month? And the way the doors flip, you need to be planning a month or so ahead to make sure you have, let's say, a cow for the third month. Yes, you can also sell hops, but the purchasing spots are so limited every month that seems like a mad rush for those particular spots. The selling action is the only way to get an upgraded Pete to make whiskey and hops to make beer. So, this game is called Fantasy Brewers, right? You need to be making those beers and whisies, right?

And you also get points for the set collection. But you know what? You don't really need to brew any beer. The Homestead cards will probably get you more points than anything you will brew. And you'll get points for things you're going to be doing anyway, and they allow you to focus on different areas. And if the cards aren't working out for you, just pay three coins to flip them over to the 10point side. The extension cards are a good way to get bonuses. And if you can get two kind of working with each other, like every time you hire an assistant, you get a bonus. And at the end of the game, you're going to be scoring for assistance, that's a a great combo you can get. This means that there are some spots that people are really fighting for. In every game I've played, it's always the same spots. It makes the other action spot seem less useful. And in a four-player game, sometimes you just end up taking a suboptimal action because you're at the back of the line and there's just not enough good spots for everyone everyone's workers.

So, would I recommend this game? No. I don't think I would. But I'm not saying it's a bad game, just one that I feel I have no need to come back for for further plays. I did like the main mechanism of the game, the threatening of the other workers in front of you, and I like that it wasn't automatic. Just because you put a large worker behind me, I have the opportunity to stay in my spot by paying. I like the idea of the changing doors every round. I also like trying to find the combos of the homestead and extension cards that would play off of each other. I appreciate that there were different starting dwarf cards. It alters what you start with, which is interesting and can change up your gameplay a little bit. But with all those positives, I just felt the game didn't come together for me. I felt it was too slight for its game length of 60 to 90 minutes. And at four players, it's going to be at the upper end of that. The actions you're taking are all pretty generic. Buy and sell goods. Everything thing in this game seems to be generic. And that doesn't have to be a negative because, you know, using triedand-true mechanisms can work if there's something that sets it apart from what we've seen before.

And I feel this one just doesn't doesn't do it. There's no twist to this game. Nothing that makes it stand out from the other games that do exactly the same thing. So overall, I'm going to give this one a 6 out of 10. This again is not a bad game, but it's one that I have no real desire to play again. Each individual piece seems to work by itself, but as a whole, it ends up being less than some of its parts. But that's it for the moment. Until next time, thanks for watching.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved