Skip to main content
Loading video...

6 Cards That Made Us Go WTF? (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)

Transcript 39:37

Hello everybody and welcome to another list video here at Playing Board Games. I am joined by Daniel from Quick Learner and today we're going to talk about six cards that made us go what the freak what the what the f you know

uh say the word or just not in the first like 10 seconds. Yeah. Yeah. Given given some space that we'll be able to say that later. Um, but uh I left this one open for your interpretation because I when I when I came up with this, I was actually just sitting on the couch watching uh Canada in the World Cup and I was like, you know what? I think that could be a fun little list video. So, I sent you the message being like, "This is what we're doing." And you you came up with three cards pretty quick and I I also had three cards pretty quick and I kind of went through the whole gamut of the what the [ __ ] reaction. Uh, so I think that that's going to be pretty fun here. We'll let the cards uh come on the screen and uh we'll explain why they made us say this and uh enjoy the list video everybody. Daniel, I'll throw this to you for your first card, which is scrape by.

Mhm. Um I think all of my three cards are chapter 2 cards cuz they're the most recent ones I can think of having a what the [ __ ] Uh you know, just like reading this and saying like what's going on? What am I missing here from the design standpoint? I had a recent video about timely intervention and I think like timely intervention as like the lucky replacement is really welldesigned. It's really interesting. It has some pros and cons and you know you spend a lot lot of time thinking about that card and then they print this in the core set too and you're like

huh?

Yeah. What the freak? what this the reaction I had just like blew out of the water every idea I had that they were going for with kind of balancing the what can survivors do to react to uh skill tests cuz this just says do whatever you want take whatever test you want maybe you'll take a horror but who cares um and that's weird we we had an effect kind of like this in chapter 1 that was uh kind of degenerate so much that they had to removed from the game after it was played. You catastrophe

mostly through the recursion, right? And some particular elder signs. This doesn't do as much as that card did, but it still does kind of 90% of what you needed that card for.

Yeah.

And maybe does some worse things because now you can start taking tests where you don't reduce your skill value to zero, which you Catastrophe needed you to do. Uh, so, uh, yeah, I I don't I don't get how this fits in without some kind of remove from game clause on it, but

yeah. Okay.

I I think UK catastrophe is a great sort of kind of like comparison here. And while I think that you catastrophe has a higher ceiling. I agree with you there, right? Because like uh it has a this one scrape by has a much lower floor because realistically you're playing you catastrophe for one reason. You have a good elder sign, right? Like It's what, three experience and three cost, right? So like it's two cost. So it's like not cheap. It's it's not like a cheap card for your deck. Scrape by is like the one of the most it's almost the most free a card could be, right? Like for its sort of effect. Um and what I really liked about timely intervention in comparison to scrape by was the fact that uh there's really no good way to recur those kind of effects. And as you and I saw in a video that we're going to be discussing soon, being able to recur your um your like lucky style effects is a very powerful thing. But this is an event and there's actually a multitude of ways to recur events in the new uh in the new core set. Timely intervention. I agree. It made sense. Scrape by. What the freak happened here? Like this is a little bit little bit over the top.

Yeah, the recursion from uh this card comes from do or die, which is level zero, which feels like that was a fix for resourceful

and yet it's still picking this crazy card up. And then also uh Hunter's Instinct level two, right? So,

yes. Yeah. Uh the thing about uh Do or Die, and this is something that when we were looking at the cards for the first time with Travis, he was like he saw Do or Die and he's like, "Oh, they didn't learn from their mistakes with Resourceful." And it had me thinking about that. Um, and like it's true that resourceful is very powerful because you can get back your skills which are very powerful in the survivor class,

but realistically uh recursion is always going to grab the most powerful thing it can grab. Right? That's the thing about recursion. You can't really make it worse because it's always going to grab the strongest thing that you can grab, right? Um, that's true. I just think that with say lucky three being so free, you know, fast, zero cost, it was easy to pick that up with resourceful on the very same test you used lucky on that

at least do or die can't pull back the time interventions.

Yep.

But you know what? It can pull back. It's this card.

Scrape by which

Yeah. No, scrape scrape by really should have removed from the game. Like I think it should have it honestly probably should have cost three as well. Like this is a powerful effect that like a survivor should like have to think about running as opposed to just like having and running and just winning very easily with.

All that aside, I also think that it's it leads to a very weird play pattern. Unlike the other cards we've discussed that are kind of that reactive um lucky type uh ability, this you don't have to have any particularly good skill value. I finished off Brethren of Ash

with a basic

fight action because it did not matter,

right? The the fight can be a test of five, six, eight, doesn't matter.

As long as you don't pull the auto fail, you pass. Y

and that is not what those other cards do. You have to be at least within range. You don't need to be within range at all. That That's weird. I think that's

a bit of a design. I don't know. It's a miss for me, not just from the gameplay aspect, but also from the like the thematic. I can pick the weakest action from just whatever like my investigator is doing and you just pass anyway. That That's a little odd.

Mhm. I'm really curious to see how this one evolves for me in legacy play because I had the option of taking this in that silus deck and I still took lucky threes and I'm very curious as to why that is. If it's because lucky three as card draw, if it's because it can help you. I'm very curious to kind of see how this goes in like the legacy uh environment because it is I think it's powerful enough for legacy, right?

It is.

Um but

how many of the effects do you need? Right. You were sitting

I was having four in my deck. Yeah.

Right. Um

and and you weren't using them all the time. That's the thing about this card, too, is that it will sit in your hand for a little while.

Yeah.

And that's fine. Um but

I don't know like you could also play it kind of aggressively and pick them back up. So

Yeah. Yeah, but in chapter two, this card is is an easy like auto include in any survivor deck card's kind of just like nuts. And I think I think to me the it's like what you were saying how because it can be on any test. This card actually kind of ruins like it it limits scenario design uh and encounter card design because they can't be like, "Oh, here's a test eight that scales down as you go further into the scenario to a reasonable number cuz survivors could just be like boom boom boom boom boom I've solved it." you know,

test 100.

Yeah. Which they have done and you know, now it's just like, well, I've done it. I've done it. Which I mean, it's fine if it's like, you know, that happens now and again, but I do think it's it limits design in a way that's not good.

Well, that's the other part about it being level one. I mean, Dianiela can pick this up right away. Why not? anyone who has OP class survivor, even level zero to one survivor events and skills, which was a thing in chapter one that they did a lot. So, it just feels a little too a little too free.

Yes. Yep. All right, let's hop on to my card here, which is Curse of Aons. The card that makes me go, "What the fuck?" whenever I see it. So, when I first thought of this, let me read what Curse of Aons does because as a player, you might not know if you're watching or listening to this video. It's a two cost three experience asset and as a reaction when a second curse token is revealed during a single skill test to your location. Exhaust cursed of Aons. Cancel that token. Thank god. And treat it as if it were a skull token instead. Wait, what the hell? You may choose to remove both of those tokens from the chaos bag after the test ends. Uh this is what I'm considering to be my this card is bad in a way that is mindn numbing portion of this video here for my entries. Um, each each entry is a different uh uh flavor of what the [ __ ] So, I think that's going to be fun. But this one is just the very simple what the [ __ ] were they thinking when this card was designed because uh can can I be real? I'm going to just say it and you can agree or disagree.

This card does nothing, right?

I I mean there's nothing on it that screams here's how you use this card for some kind of good effect.

Yeah. Yeah.

There's just nothing there. It's nothing. It's the text is actually just like it you you play this card and like I understand the concept was this was like the idea that they did this for a little bit and there's a lot of history of this on the channel of being like hey this is a skull token. This is where Jim can shine. But the problem is is that well one Jim's ability is kind of just you pass the test. And as we just saw with scrape by um that like survivor was already doing that really well. Uh and it's like not really a it it's not really as exciting for the mystic class compared to the survivor class due to stat lines, right? So mystics can kind of also pass whatever test they need or cancel whatever test they don't want to take. So it's it's not really that much of an exciting payoff, but also it's like I I just I like this card flabbergast me. It leaves me speechless. I was reading the text again as I was going through my thought process here. It does nothing. Like it's unless you're gym where your skulls are zero. Most of the time skulls are worse than minus twos.

Like I understand the concept is that your second curse token, hey, now it's just like a minus two that doesn't draw and it's like curse protection, but like why why does this cost three experience? Like why does it

Yeah. Why does it only do nothing? Like why does it just like that's the thing that is just like so flabbergasted? Because

my hypothesis.

Yeah. Go for it.

They had this art

and they said we have to put something else with a skull in the text box.

Yes. Yeah.

Yeah. I don't I don't know. So, I mean, you can make a lot of arguments about like, well, drawing skulls is good for your six sense for whatever, but

there's just so many other ways to do this without jumping through the hoops of well, 3 XP, playing the card. And this doesn't just give you any extra benefit if you compare it to Blessing of Isis, which is a legit card, right? Because the elder sign is just you're doing it because you want to draw the elder sign and the skull token does not

do anything on its own and even if you have six cents out or or gym or whatever like you need those other things, right?

It this just doesn't do enough on its own. What if it gave you like a resource

or maybe more than that a card draw if you if you did this? You know, you need a little bit of of a carrot.

That's that's what uh Beer and I because we've been designing cards, we call that a kicker. a this cards needs a kicker where it's just like oh that's why I want to do this you know or like oh that's an interesting thing I can build around right where it's like remove that bottom line about you may choose to remove both of those tokens when the chaos bag ends and give us like a lightning bolt effect we can do with the curse of aons or reaction when a skull is revealed right so it actually also can do something

in so it actually just do something like that's

this card's all kinds of freaked up I originally was going to put um the flute of the outer gods Um.

Mhm.

Because that's like the card when people would look at like the Blood of Thoth of being like this card's unplayable. And like I'm sorry. Like I could tell you're a new Arkham fan when you think that Blood of Thoth was unplayable because we got Flu the Outer Godgs, but more importantly, Curse of Aons, which you actually have to spend three experience to put into your deck. Like you you can't just like put that in your level zero deck and regret it. You have to actively choose. You have to read this card and be like it does something right and then put it into your deck which is I think just not possible. I just don't think that's a thing.

It is funny that they never really gave a payoff for drawing skulls even though they kind of

wanted you to with these sorts of cards but ultimately like ritual candles at level zero just does the curse and skull mitigation better right?

Yeah. There's I think that's actually some design that if this was made like more modern um Arkham I think that Jim would be very cool to see. I mean we'd know what Jim is like now. He's an ally and he's bombastic.

But like uh I feel like if if uh Jim was released today in Arkham, there would be a more of philosophy of being like, "Okay, so then Jim's ability is here. Now here's some skull or symbol synergy effects that you can use in the set." Right. Um, yeah, kind of like

Yeah. How was he released in Dunich with Alyssa Graham, which did nothing for him, and then Olive was released later? Like, I don't get it. Anyway, we're getting off track.

Yeah. Yeah. No, it's I mean, Jim also is kind of here for We love Jim on PBG, but you know.

Yeah.

All right, let's go to your second card here, Daniel, which is

the new Carolyn Fern.

Yeah. I I guess there's multiple levels of WTF here. The first one is the obvious like, "Wow, she's a seeker now. I didn't know they could do that."

Uh, which we had a discussion about that between the two of us uh way back when, and it seemed like, wow, anything is possible now. You get a a yellow uh Carolyn Fern. Okay. But beyond that, I mean, she was one of my favorite investigators in chapter 1 as a guardian. Uh, reading this particular ability has like two things that are I don't know. I I just don't understand what the design philosophy was. Again, after you heal one or more horror from investigator ally asset, discover one clue at your location, learn once per round. Tesla's clue discovery is incredible.

Mhm.

I I've learned that over the years. Um but ignoring Shroud, ignoring, I don't know, uh other treacheries that might keep you from investigating is very very powerful.

Yep.

And it seems like a Rex ability, right? or a um Lucius Galloway ability where you're getting an extra clue sort of um but the reality is you're getting it for doing something else and you don't need to take a test most of the time you can just do this. There are cards that give you a just heal horror. Even her Elder Sign does it and progressing the game this way is nuts. One of the neat things I think about Caroline Fern from chapter 1 was that the resources she gave out, although unlimited, which was very good, allowed her to support the team and also support the team in the horror healing itself. It wasn't making the game go forward, but you were then using those resources to do something that you otherwise might not be able to do as easily, like throw some dynamite at uh a couple monsters.

Um, I think this is just I don't want to say boring, but it's really really strong. And I don't know that she needs that for the horror healing. That's just a a a crazy ability to me. Oh, she's got five book.

Yeah.

Why?

She's got the Mandy stat line. One of the strongest stat lines in the game for a seeker.

Tommy didn't get five punch in his new his new version. Like, why does she have five? I I don't know.

And yeah, then there's also I'm not going to get into this here, but there's kind of rules questions about the way her uh horror healing is worded here is different than the original wording. So, what counts, what doesn't is a little nebulous, too, to me, which I I don't know why they changed the wording, but

whatever. I I think this is just a kind of an absurd investigator, honestly. I know that the um I know that the starter decks, these evergreen decks should be good on the the surface, but like Harvey was good, but his thing was very simple. Draw an extra card and then there was things that took advantage of that, but card draw is kind of a secret thing. Anyway, um I don't know if exploring the horror healing thing makes a whole lot of sense. I'm still I'm not sure about this. We'll see where the class goes, but uh it seems like an odd thing to place onto a starter investigator still.

Yeah. I mean, like I I think the to me uh this kind of hits on something that we requested in previous videos, which is like the support um seeker sort of idea. I'm curious to see if that actually comes to pass in actuality or if it's just a hurt self and then heal self like heal thyself physician type thing, right? Where it's like she doesn't do anything else for other people. She's just like I'm hurting myself with effect to uh heal myself for effect, right? Um cuz Travis is playing her in the Hemlock run and he's having a good time. But I think a big reason for that is that Carolyn Fern is just powerful, right? And Travis is like me where you really enjoy powerful things, right? She didn't need five book. I I understand why in like the the split of all the investigators where like in the core set um Joe only has four but Daniela has five. So here's our fivebook investigator. I don't think five book investigators should exist. I think that's like too good, right? Like I think five fist is okay because of the way enemies work in a scenario of Arkham compared to the way clues work in a scenario to Arkham.

Um, so the only thing I'm grateful for is if you look at her just in the slice of chapter 2, she's powerful, but the secret card pool is a lot less strong than the car like how the chapter one is in comparison to looking at a similar space, right? That's kind of like the only I think the the big thing um because she's also just monoseker, right? Um

Mhm. which is probably better for like powerful effects like this. But I don't know if for example comparison Tommy compares I think if Tommy wanted to truly compare because he has to pay a resource for his ability, right?

He does.

Yeah. I think if Tommy truly wanted to compare to this, he wouldn't have to pay the resource to do that um to do what he does, right? I feel like that's just an example of like I can see the concept of Caroline has horror. That's the cost that you have here, right? Like you have to find the horror to get there. But that's not that hard to do, especially with cards that enable it. Like the Dreamers Chronicle with the the Capbook, right? Like that's a powerful card in Carolyn and it enables her ability, which is exactly what she wants, right? When we were she was spoiled, Travis was like, "Okay, now we just need a card that deals horror." And the next card he saw, he was like that that's all she needs. Right? And that's just the reality of Carol and

Fern. Yeah. It's interesting to me though when you bring up the support seeker part. I don't really know how much she's a support seeker because of this issue of she can just deal horror to herself or is she just healing people so she can get clues? Like is that really support? Like kind of, but it's not the quite the same thing as the Daisy giving away uh cards to really help someone else. Like you're not doing that for any other reason. Um, and maybe this is like splitting hairs a bit, but it does feel less supporty and more of a I'm just playing the game and I need to find a [ __ ] somewhere.

Yeah. Well, the idea of support is the fact that like healing is like what people often will lean on as one of the options for support, right? Not like in the sense of like the traditional support. It's an aspect of it. Uh, and I think for healing to be good, it needs to be more than just healing, right? It's like that's kind of like the concept of this. Um, but I think that uh it's curious to see in higher player counts if that actually does matter or if it's going to be just like um Daisy Walker where it's like sorry I'm just going to use this old book on myself versus Carolyn being like I'm going to go here and start grabbing clues and healing myself and if an enemy comes you have to come save me, right? Like I'm curious to see if that is the play pattern that actually ends up happening.

She doesn't even need that. She's got unflapable. She's got three foot. She She's fine on her own, too.

Crazy.

Yeah.

All right. Why is she number Oh, and I was like, she's not That's the starter decks aren't set. I was like, why is she number one and not Tommy number one? No, it's cuz she's from the Carolyn box. That's how that works.

All right. Let's go to my card number two here. And this one, I found a way to get this card on another list. It's chemistry set.

Hey.

Yeah. So, uh, this is my what the [ __ ] of wait a minute, this card's actually good. Uh, the like the plot twist. Um, I went back and whenever there was a new set, I would do a video where I would, uh, before I played the cards, I would go through and give like a rating for how powerful I think they are on first grasp. Uh, I do this because it's fun to uh, like do that. For me personally, I provided content and I enjoy being able to have a list of things to look back on and be like, "Oh, this is where this is going." Like, "This is how I think the card was. This is where it was. Where was I right? Where was I wrong? Where was I, you know, like so off base? Where did I absolutely nail it?" Like that kind of stuff. Uh, chemistry set on the initial rating I gave a two out of five.

I was like, "This card is not good. You cannot control it." So, like that was a big thing where it's like if you cannot control when a positive things happens, is it worth putting into your deck? And then I put chemistry deck into a deck to try it out because I like to play cards to make sure I'm actually right with my assessment of them as opposed to just like giving them a blank statement and that being that. and chemistry set blew my mind with how efficient it was because it turns out the worst way to play this card, at least in the starting thing, is trying to succeed by exactly these numbers. Like, yeah, you can control it with steady-handed down the road. But the fact is that this card is just a fine tool to put into your deck, investigate, and then get value from. I have seen situations where this can get this gives multiple deductions, multiple cards, marks, multiple resources and I have seen play I'm going to just say it before because I know someone's experienced it where you just always fail by exactly two and then it's gone immediately. Um but the fact is that the most common use case I've seen for chemistry set is it triggers the like succeed by two, succeed by zero, succeed by four one or two to three to four to five times in a scenario. And that's just like a lot of value. I think now I'd give this card like a four out of five, which uh for a level zero card is very good. Um but just like doubling my initial assessment on this card uh because um I was just of how off base I

was was my biggest what the [ __ ] uh in terms of like being wrong about a card.

Yeah, I think I was also looking at this saying, huh? Okay. Um I would add that it's a fun card to play.

Mhm. And that is a design win in my estimation anyway. Just like it doesn't have to be like the results don't have to be amazing, but it is fun to play to kind of think about, okay, which thing might might I get here? What are the chances I fail by exactly two? Um, it does fit into sort of the seeker privilege of there's no boost in this. So, you're just doing this for the the the results, right? You're just doing it to try to get the cards or resources. and there aren't a whole lot of other level zero accessory slots. So, it seems like a pretty easy ad um when everything else is going pretty well.

Yeah, it's a it's a fine card. I I'm not as high on it as you are cuz I have been the person to immediately uh discard it.

Mhm.

But I don't think that makes it a bad card. I think that just is makes it an interesting one.

Yeah. I'm I'm out of the thing where I would put it in every single one of my decks where like my decks would start with chemistry set.

Um I mean I'm a very big valuebased player, right? where it's just like if I can squeeze out as much value as I can from one action, right? Like that's what I strive for. It's why I like perceptions uh so much for my card draw. Like perception two is like my card draw option in my secret decks. Um and anything that gets you like to to do to get something while doing something is kind of exactly what I squeeze out, what I look for in these games. And I think that's a great transition into your next card here. uh your last card on this which is out the door level zero.

Okay, this is level 01. I will mention something about the level one as well. Uh so this one also has a story which is when this was previewed. The card I think right before it that was previewed was Watch this.

Mhm.

And it was like great. They reprinted a a rogue staple to get us some cash. like there hasn't been a ton of ways to get resources in chapter 2 and that needs to change that you need to have some way to pay for all the expensive stuff and rogues like their money. So, a return to a skill that gives you money is nice. And watch this has always been not like mind-blowing. It's very good, but it's got some risk. It has that fun uh rogue gambling aspect to it. And then immediately afterwards, they print this and I'm like, well, wait a second. You know what this card does? Uh, it gives you two resources or anyone actually.

Mhm.

There's some support there. And you might lose them, but guess what skill cards usually do? They help you pass a test.

Yep.

So, watch this. Gives you one icon. Level zero version. You have to succeed by one to get the money. You have to have the money to make the money back. This card, you just need to pass a test. You don't have to have anything to begin with. You can even spend those resources during the test like on a silver tongue or something. And it has two icons.

Yeah.

Going back through level zero cards that have more than one matching icon. And and here the wild is doing the work. Uh there's nothing other than the cards that just give you icons. So you're inquiring mind or whatnot. Uh so there's the neutral skills. They draw you a card. Daring kind of is in this boat, too, because it drives you a card, but there's nothing at level zero that gives you more than one icon and some other effect. This is bizarre. Like, I I think they forgot that there was like the agility icon here or something. I don't know. For for level zero, compared to all these other skill cards we get right off the boat in and level zero, this is wildly powerful.

Now, it is just two resources, but what if you spent one more XP? just one and you doubled that. Well, you don't have to wonder too much because that card exists, too.

Yeah. Yeah, it does exist. Um, I'm not going to say too much because I have out the door one as my last card. I think we can talk about these ones together. Uh, I'll kind of do my little intro spiel to this and then we'll kind of talk about them in tandem. Uh, of of no note of note, this was actually the card I thought of first when I thought about this list video. Um, so I was very happy to see out the door zero on yours. Uh, I had a similar thing. I um I was uh I was looking through the cards um and I had like when I and I saw watch this level zero and I was like let's go watch this. Level zero is back. I love this card. That's great. This is awesome. And then I saw Out the Door Zero and I was like, "Yeah, this is this is like kind of just a better wash this. It reminds me a lot of Burning the Midnight Oil, right? It's like in the similar kind of space as those cards, which are good, but not really like like they're efficient, but not really like gang busters, right?" And then I saw Out the Door One and I said, "What the [ __ ] I think this is one of the strongest cards they've ever made." Uh, this card is insanely strong. Um, like as I was just saying with chemistry set, the strongest effects in my opinion are like so like Fouian bargain is very strong. Like I'm not going to say that it isn't, right? It costs an action to get five resources for two curse tokens.

That's really really good. But the reason why I like watch this is like what if I got uh three resources but I got a clue or I defeated an enemy, right? like that is just actually by definition more tempo than just gaining like like an emergency cash by comparison. But there was a big difference between watch this and Fouian bargains. Three and five is a notable difference in resources. It's about an out the door zero level worth of resources between the two. But out the door one is four [snorts] resources. Like that's an insane amount of resources to just get during a test. Like that's it's like I I can't even like put it into words about like why this card is like as good as it is.

Apart from the fact that just saying four resources is a lot of resources like to just get without like without even like like needing an extra hoop to jump through, right? And yeah, like you could lose those four resources if you fail. Like there's this idea of yeah there is some risk involved but it's just the autofail but that's kind of like the risk that exists for every other skill like in comparison to what you were saying for watch this zero right there's the autofail risk in that as well but you have to pay upfront right without the door as long as you don't spend those four resources which I do like the idea of like a a Preston Fairmont deck that spends the resources so if he loses them he doesn't care right like as like that kind of thing I think is really cool

but like That's not the play pattern that this card is going to have or has had in the the time that I've seen it. Um,

doesn't Preston just keep them anyway?

Yeah, cuz they go on his uh his uh inheritance. So, it's like even less of a risk associated with him.

Um, but like this card when I just saw it, I was just like, what the hell is this? This is I was like, this is insane. Like this card is just it's everything I want in my play pattern. And like the level zero version is also very good. Like not to like talk this one down. Like two resources is is is a good amount of money. It has a wild icon so you can use it for anything on any one, right? Like

yeah,

realistically out the door zero probably should have just been a foot,

right? As opposed to foot wild. And then maybe the wild comes on this one. But this one also gaining four resources. That's a absurd amount of money for a card to give you while you're also like evading an enemy, investigating, fighting, or passing a mythos test, right? Like whatever the hell you want, just get four resources on top of it. That is so efficient. So, here's the comparison to a chapter 1 card. Cheat the system. This is a card that is rogue um and lets you fast, which is really the important comparison. uh gain resources equal to the number of different classes you control. So probably you have rogue if you're playing a rogue. That's going to get you one. To get four resources, you need to have played maybe four assets, but maybe it's less than that with synergy cards. And that is something that takes a little while to do.

You know what cheat the system doesn't let you do? Doesn't actually help you pass a skill test.

Mhm. this just gives you the money and gives you a way to pass a skill test on top of it. It's crazy. Like it's everything you want. And um that's why I think like Fouian not being fast and not giving you a skill boost is uh I don't know. I mean that I don't want to say that's a fair card because I think it's also over the curve, but this is just that much better for just one measly XP.

Yeah. Yeah. Like in Legacy, Fouian is always going to be goated economy, but I actually don't think it's the best resource card in Rogue anymore. Out the door is it's it's it's insane. It's an insane card.

It's also weird because you think of the other um resource generation or even so I think it's like the other skills that came out in the same deck that ask more from you.

Like you spend resources to get the skill value. It's like level three. I think this is a level three card,

maybe two, but level one making it that easy to get after scenario one. And I know some people are going to say like because of the cards I picked, like I must hate good cards. Like that's not really my opinion here. Um I think I'm just skeptical when things feel out of place from the earlier designs or even the designs that exist in the current card pool and just say that well this just sticks out. And I think that rogue should have better economy than other classes. Like that's definitely the case. Um, but there's a line to draw somewhere, right? Like I'm not going to make the argument that just because they should have good economy means that they can gain any number of resources they want. Like there's there has to be some some design philosophy about how much is is too much and and what is the right for amount for the card at the certain level. And I think this is out of proportion with what we've seen in the rest of the card pool.

Yeah, I would love to have seen a version of this card that was like after it's committed, the performance investor gains four resources at the end of the round that investigator loses four resources.

So like you have to like spend the money

and then cuz like but the reality is that this card does help like a lot of rogues as well. Like Skids likes this card. It's during a test he gets to like during an action he gets to gain another action, right? Like, but it's also like cascades down into off-class rogues. Like Leo Anderson loves this effect. He uses it while fighting and then is able to buy like a beat cop. Like this card pays for a beat cop, which is like

right

that's like a that's a crazy amount of economy that exists in one card. Um, and I agree this probably should cost two, like two XP or it should have been an emergency cash because that still would have been I think in a perfect world this would have been a foot icon and two resources. This would have been as printed but three resources instead of four for its icons. Like icons printed but then three resources instead. And I think then we'd be looking at being like, "This card is very good." As opposed to, "Uh, what the fuck?"

Can you imagine if Silus could play this?

Yes, I would love to imagine that.

You just return to your hand.

Oh, is there any way I can get this? I mean, I could like honestly though this in Silus with like a versatile like like um

yeah,

honestly wouldn't be terrible in the right deck, but like if I could do that with Silus, oh boy. That's why traits matter, kids. That's why traits matter.

It does. But even like the skill type of recursion we talked about earlier, um you have to pay attention to cards like this at low levels at,

you know, like it skills are tough to design. They are fast free cards. So yeah.

Yeah. And I think this is an example of one that might have slipped through. I So I also will say I don't think that it deserves to be tabooed. I think that there is um I think it's too soon to say stuff like that. Um, I think it's just that I mean my hope my hope is that because these investigator decks and the core set are designed to be evergreen that they don't feel compelled to make too many more like economy cards because I I would rather if player card boxes both big and small now focused instead on how can we explore the class as opposed to how can we build the class foundation because as far as I'm concerned, I think the class class foundation for the most part is pretty comfortable with these these this evergreen pool.

Mhm. Like they can say you have your unconditional money. We're not going to print, you know, bank job or something unless it makes sense with an archetype.

It also it's a little bit strange. It definitely feels like the rogue class are kind of signposted to be skills. Um, well, with Andre and like though I think like they'll out the door and they'll watch this. It might I'm hoping they explore that further because I think that that could be kind of cool. But this card's crazy. This card's crazy.

Yeah.

All right. Well, those were six cards that made us go, "What the fuck?" So, thanks for watching. Thanks for sharing your perspective as always, Daniel. It's always fun to chat Arkham with you. Um, it's it's always strange to say this and then we stop and it's like, "Okay, let's record another video." And it's like the first time we talk today.

Yeah.

But, you know, that's that's the content creation grind.

People can just press, you know, the next button on their device and watch the next one cuz

Yeah. It's like it's like we've never left. It's like we never never stopped.

In this room anyway.

No, I mean that's that's kind of what YouTube is, right? We're stuck in the prison of this uh on their TV screen. So, we're always on your TV. We're always on your phone if you want us to be. Please let us free. Go outside and touch grass for a little bit. Uh, all right. Thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this. If you want to support the channel, like, comment, subscribe, join our Patreon, our members, all that would be really appreciated. In the meantime, you can let me know in the comments what you think are some cards that made you go, "What the fuck?" I always like hearing your perspectives on that. Have a good one. Thanks for watching and as always a GG's.

Progress saved