Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Banishing Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 19:28

welcome to John gates games today I'll be reviewing it in the banishing this game was designed by Sean Rumble and it is a fully cooperative game where each player takes on the role of an asymmetric hero and they are trying to figure their way through this grid like puzzle trying to eliminate as many Undead as they can while activating their asymmetric powers to do all sorts of interesting things first I'll explain how the game works and then I'll jump in in my review the first thing everyone gets to do when playing a game of the banishing is figure out which one of the eight asymmetric characters they're gonna play for that game and there are no specific rules for choosing one or the other so for instance in a three player game we might go ahead and do the healer the witch and the brute next up we take this deck of symbol cards we shuffle it up and then we're going to deal out three cards to each player next up we have to fully prepare this a draw tech right here at the moment it only has the similar cards in it but now we can set the difficulty by choosing from these three different types of items there are six of them total as you can see and for a normal difficulty game will shuffle these up and we're going to pull four of these out and these get put into the deck and now we have to take the enemy cards and put them into the deck you'll see there are one two three four and five value enemies we're only going to start with the skeletons the zombies and the goblins for the beginning of the game we're gonna go ahead and shuffle this up really well and these werewolves and vampires will come out later on finally we can finish setup by building the void in the middle of the table which is a three by three grid of cards from the top of our prepared deck it's going to involve some symbol cards some undead cards as well

as the item cards that we shuffled in there during your players turn they will do essentially two things the first thing is they're gonna grab a row or a column of cards from the middle of the void and then they can optionally take one action using the cards they have in their hand or doing some general-purpose actions now it's important to note that you're not allowed to show your companions the cards you have in your hand but you aren't allowed to tell them what you have in your hand so they cannot necessarily dictate what you should do they just have to remember the cards that you have of course you can talk about this as much as you want and when you look out to the various cards in the middle it's definitely good to try and get three of a kind when it comes to color and specifically a three color of a kind and three symbols of a kind so if the healer player was to look out right here they see well there are currently no red squares there are no green triangles and no blue circles so instead maybe they just grabbed a couple of colors that match up by grabbing it this column here when they take it this undead skeleton it doesn't go into their hand and instead goes to the right hand side of their player board showing that they have now taken one damage with that one health Undead these now come into the player's hand and they could take that optional action but even before that you always immediately refill the void after any cards are taken from it when it comes to choosing an optional action there aren't nine different options for each player in the top three of these actions are identical for all of them the first one says you could swap any two cards in the void essentially changing their positions in that 3x3 grid the next one says you could trade a card with another player and the last one says you can rest by getting rid of the lowest value that you have now it comes down to these

six down here which are asymmetric and different for each player but every player has two red to green and two blue the top one just says you can discard 3 cards that are the same color in order to do that effect and the second level is three cards in the same color and the same exact symbol which lets you do a more powerful effect that's the same for all three of these layers in general the red cards are offensive and allow you to do things to mitigate the amount of undead and perils you have on the void the green cards are usually support and they allow you to either heal wounds off yourself or make situations better for your companions and lastly these blue cards in general have an interesting effect for the weaker one and the stronger one is always a way that you can actually banish cards from the game in this case you can play two blue cards from the void directly into the banishing that last action option is of utmost importance because the way you win the game is by banishing ten cards so let's say for instance that we had these three blue circles in our hand we could go and discard these cards and then we look out here the ability said we could take two blue cards from the banishing and we could banish them so we could go ahead and put them up there and just like that we have two out of the ten and we need to win and the moment you get that tenth card banished you went immediately let's now take a look at these two numbers in the top right corner of each player sheet the smaller number is a stamina level and if you meet this number of wounds then you are going to become exhausted so for instance if the witch player took this one skeleton right here they'd be fine because that's one but then if they took this zombie they are now at three they become exhausted and what happens is you flip this player board over and the main difference that you'll notice is you no

longer have access to any of your asymmetric abilities while you are exhausted fortunately if you ever have these wounds healed off you'll be able to flip your player board back over again but for the time being it becomes much more restrictive as far as the actions you can take now let's look at the bigger number this is the amount of health that each player has so if they ever take wounds that meet or exceed this number then they immediately die and everybody loses the game let's now take a look at the last type of card which are these items there are three types of them in the game and when you take a column or a row with these items to get you have access to them the wand is simply a wild card and letting you use this in a place of any other card which can be really good to match up and do those asymmetric powers the shield you can store and discard it too and not take a wound or the moment you take it if for instance we grab this column right here we could discard the shield and this undead right here in order to not take that damage and lastly we have armor which simply adds a one to the stamina level for character which can be very important and it's also worth noting that none of these items can ever be traded back and forth between the players because they never actually exist in their hands once you've run out of cards in your deck the first time you're gonna go ahead and take your discard pile and you're gonna shuffle into it these much nastier werewolf cards with a value of 4 you will then go through this entire deck and once you've depleted it you'll shuffle these vampires in if you ever in a situation where you've gone through this deck 3 times and you still have not one and you immediately lose the game there's one last way that everyone can lose the game and that is if everybody becomes exhausted so players will keep

playing taking cards from the middle of the void and taking actions until they have banished those 10 cards or until one person dies everyone is exhausted or you've gone through that deck three times let's now begin the review for the banishing by starting with a few positive points and the first of these relates to the great collaborative effort that goes into solving the puzzles that are out there on the table between every single person's turn now in this game you're not allowed to show the cards you have in your hand to all of your Patriots around the table although you were able to freely talk about what you have in your hand and what this means is you can't you don't necessarily have situations where one person can dictate what everybody else should do it does mean that you're gonna be talking a lot about the situation in the middle you're not only gonna be talking about on your turn like what can you do to kind of work your way through and do something effective but if it's not your turn you might look out there and say listen I would really love for you to not take this one particular card right here because if I take that card I have two of those other ones and then I could do this really good ability which will let me do that really cool thing over there and it just ends up being a nice discussion around the table trying to work your way through a bunch of different iterations of what you can or can't do because realistically there are let's see 1 2 3 4 5 there are 6 of different options for you on the turn of grabbing those cards from the middle of the table and in general you probably can have several of them which are at least potentially viable and then one or two that are quite good and I just really enjoy talking through each and every turn with my people with my friends around the table trying to figure out what the right thing is to do for this current turn as well as how it's gonna set up for everybody else around the table on their subsequent turns so that we can all win

together for positive number two I want to discuss the asymmetries between the different characters that you can choose when playing the game now on the one hand well I just like asymmetries in game games in general whether or not it's cooperative or competitive I like having a thing that I can do that nobody else can and I think for the banishing they do a very good job of at differentiating out new characters so they do feel different for one another but I also think they do a pretty good job of matching the mechanics of what their actions due to the theming of what that character is for instance you have the fighter who is you know in general that's gonna be the kind of character that's out there with a big sword you know kind of taking damage for others and they have actions that could do lots of damage to the undead as well as they can take wounds from their friends on the table and put them onto their character you have more complicated characters for instance like the cultists who can just grab an undead from the middle of the table and use it as a servant and then that some of their spells are do various levels of effectiveness based off of how powerful their servant is and then they banish their servants into the banishing and that's what you need to do to win the game is get a certain number of cards banished and that's another interesting thing like I was expecting that all these characters would just banish undead because they are the bad guys so obviously you banished them but actually many of these characters banish these symbol cards and different varieties of them so that means you're almost doing a bit of deck deconstruction with the game or you know deck building but kind of in an inverse way because that deck of cards that you go through you'll do it three times and as you cycle through the discard and then do it reshuffle you're

gonna bring in more bad guys but as you're banishing things out of that deck or keeping them in your hand they're also not back in there in the deck so you're constantly thinking about well you know if we only have characters that only banish non Undead things we might be in trouble because the undead earth is always gonna keep cycling in and out and they're always gonna keep coming out there and we need to pull them out into the vanishing and that's just it's just neat I wasn't expecting that amount of variety specifically I have like the bard who can only banish the green circles and there's only six of them in the whole deck so I guess the bard character is not going to be banishing that much compared to you other characters they could banish a wide variety of things like well the in general so either way I just really enjoy the asymmetry and the game they impressed me more than I was expecting for positive number three I like to discuss the tension that rises as you're playing the game and I talked about this a little bit already and positive number two but as you are playing through the game you get to that first deck reshuffle you'll probably feel pretty good like you don't have that many wounds on the people around the table you've probably banished a few things already and it seems like you have this game in hand but then you start putting those werewolves I know the deck you shuffle that up and put those out and once those where will start coming out things get a lot more difficult and if you still haven't won the game or lost by the time you reach awful that deck again having those five value vampires come in is gonna end you very soon for what I've seen it's many of the games we haven't even gotten to that third reshuffle either because we lost or because we won and I enjoy that tension it seems like everything is going good we're kind of feeling out our characters you know talking about what our abilities are and like discussing how they can interact and then you're

growing you're learning how to work together in this specific asymmetric a setup as the game ramps up and I never want a co-op to feel easy and this one has certainly not felt easy I've lost several times now and then I like feeling like our back is to the wall we just have to do this and this and if we pull it off then that's great and if we don't then we lose but it's just a good feeling and that every good co-op needs and I think it's definitely here it's now time to cover a couple of neutral points and the first of these has to do with luck of the draw this is a card game and it's hard you know it's a small box with a big deck of cards you shuffle those up and you play those out and that shuffle is gonna present you with constant puzzles from every single turn to turn and there will be times where it seems like good luck of the draw is just really bad it's just out to get you and there'll be other times where you feel like you are absolutely saved because you just happen to pull over those three perfect cards that work out exactly for this ability that you need to clear this other stuff out and all those things are fun honestly like they keep you in the game they keep it tense you can't necessarily say okay we're definitely fine all the time I mean you could definitely say that earlier in the game but you want to have that sense of tension and it seems like in general the luck of the draw bounces out to a certain extent I felt like the losses that I've had have been what games that we published into one maybe we should have planned a little bit better and we could have maybe done something to actually pull out the win or get a little bit closer than we did and it felt like the games that I've won well we've done a good job and perhaps you know a couple of those werewolves really did stay down there at the bottom of the deck and if that had not happened we would have lost but you know that's just the way the

game it shakes out and it usually plays in about an hour so having a reasonable amount of luck of the draw in a game in that timeframe I think he's very understandable and I have no problem with it in this game but it's definitely something you should know about going into it for neutral number two I just want to briefly state that the graphical presentation of this game is definitely form over function and in general that's probably a good thing and that's why this is a neutral point not a negative because on the player boards there is a ton of text and you need to know that text and there's no way they could have done this with just icons so it's good they kept them relatively plain so you could look down and see what you need to know but it also means that it's a bit drab looking it's just you know some kind of big blocks of color and some lines and a bunch of text the other thing is the front cover of this box while it looks okay and it's nicely put together it speaks nothing to what the game is actually about and it really is very generic looking so it's a bit of a nitpick I know but I figured it was worth mentioning that the game functions very well and the actual deck of cards I think the silhouettes for the undead do work very well but I also wouldn't have minded having a little bit more art on all these things to pull me in a little bit more but it's not that big of a deal we've now reached my one negative point for the game and that has to do with the stamina levels for the characters that you're playing now if you remember once you've taken enough damage to equal your stamina level you flip your player board over and you lose access to all of your asymmetric powers and I found that that kind of takes away the fun of the game to a certain extent and of course that feels intense like it feels risky like

you need those powers to win you can't manage cards without those asymmetries so you can't be exhausted and banish cards at the same time but I feel like from a design perspective they're kind of taken away the cookie of this game and it's possible that you would be a bit of a sacrificial lamb for one particular play and just take a lot of damage especially if you're like the fighter or the brute and flip it over to the exhausted side and never get access to those asymmetric powers again and I just don't really like this entire mechanic I feel like I would rather not have the stamina level at all so that you always have access to all of your really cool abilities let me just make the game a little bit harder to to compensate for that so this is obviously a design decision thing we're making but some of these characters hit stamina hit exhaustion at three wounds which can happen easily and often and these characters do very cool things and it is another aspect to the puzzle that is enjoyable when you're actually crunching through the puzzle figuring out how best do we do this turn we have to clear this out because if we don't then the next person takes that thing and then they be kind of become exhausted and then they can't use their cards but I want to use these abilities I want to activate all these card abilities and I feel like that maybe the stamina levels couldn't be kicked up a notch so instead of having it be had three for a character that had seven health maybe have it be at five or something like that so you're almost dead by the time you actually lose access to these things but again that would change the balance of the entire game as well but it doesn't hurt the game overall I just I don't like being exhausted and thematically that makes sense but mechanically what I'm actually playing I want to play with my toys let's now discuss the variability

for the vanishing and I found it to be a little bit better than I was expecting going in I knew that there were these asymmetric characters but I was not expecting eight of them and I was also not expecting them to play as differently from one another as they do now that's not to oversell a point like when you're playing the game as the witch versus the game as a healer you are doing largely similar things you're gonna have similar discussions about how you can evaluate that puzzle in the middle of the table but the actual actions that you're gonna evaluate do feel quite a bit different like you know the healer is doing a lot of healing they're banishing completely different cards then maybe the witch who needs to take damage before they can actually banish that damage from them into the banishing which is the way you win the game so yeah I expected it to be a reasonable amount of variability but it exceeded my expectations a bit the banishing technically plays three to five players but I have played it at two three and four so I don't have any experience with the five player game and I have a funny story about the two-player game the first time I ever played it was with my wife Jessica I got it in the mail and I was like hey let's play it tonight so we set it up and we just played an entire game and it wasn't until the very end that I was packing up the box that I looked on the outside and saw that technically it's only supposed to play three to five players so I can tell you that it actually played pretty well at two I don't see a reason for it not to be a accepted player count on the outside of the box it was maybe a little bit easier because of that player count but you could probably counteract that by putting less of the items into the deck so two player definitely works but I think that three is likely the best way to play this game just from a downtime perspective like downtime isn't that bad because you're collaborating together even when it's not your turn

but the four player game definitely took a little bit longer than that three player game did and I enjoyed it at four and I feel like five probably works but that is also probably just more people than you realistically need around the table like I feel like it's probably gonna be a little longer than I wanted to be overall even though it likely will work so yeah I think three is the best way to do it but feel free to give it a shot at two we did and it worked fine in conclusion I played the vanishing four times at this point and that my expectations going in were that this would be a good somewhat simple small box cooperative game and I'm happy to say that those expectations were met and exceeded because the collaborative experience of trying to figure out how to deal with every single puzzle on each person's turn turned out to be more fun than I was expecting there is less quarterbacking going on than I thought there would be because you're not showing the cards you have in your hand so you have to say no doesn't anybody have any green triangles or you know what what blue cards do people have and so that keeps you talking back and forth as opposed to just having one person dictate what you're doing and then I also like the emotional rise and fall of the actions that you're doing through the game with the really cool abilities on the asymmetric characters you have you will definitely have moments where you get excited to have that three of a kind with the symbols of the colors you play it down and you wash away all of the undead for the board or maybe you do something risky like drying cars on the top of the deck and it happens to work out perfectly and you banish those cards those are really great moments but then you also have the lows of the tension just building and building a building as you flip over that one werewolf and the one worst spot on the board that was the one location that couldn't be a werewolf and that emotion is what you need in

cooperative games because you're not playing against a smart competitor the game itself is the thing you're playing against and realistically the luck of the draw is why you're playing against and I think all the stuff comes together into a really good package there is more game than I expected in this tiny little box which honestly seems like you could travel pretty well like I bet you could play this game on a plane without too much of a problem and you could ditch the box and just have that deck of cards and the player sheets that you could talk somewhere in your backpack and I really do think that this would be a great traveling style game so hype all the stuff up I've enjoyed the game but I will admit that it does not excite me and I don't think it ever really did I will likely play this game several more times in the future but I'm not super jonesing to get it down onto the table and I think part of that is mostly because while cooperative games are fun in general I prefer competitive experiences but this does mean that I strongly recommend the vanishing I think that it's a really good package as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to support the channel and everything I do here please go to patreon.com/scishow against games and I'd really appreciate it also if you like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved