Wild Gardens - Board Game Review - If You Could Taste Artwork
Transcript
hi everyone I'm Luke K and you're watching the broken EV a show where I rant and Rave about board games but yeah there's usually a bit more ranting involved that's putting in mildly 007 so I got something a little bit different for you here this is wild Gardens from Rose gner entertainment this was a Kickstarter but I don't pay attention to Kickstarter so I never saw it in that phase and I know nothing about this publisher other than the fact that they made a game called Keystone which I've never played or seen ever on the table in front of me in the UK I'm not even sure if you can get it in the UK easily enough but you know by all means let me know in the comments what Keystone is likee so I'm coming into like you know these designers this uh title and this publisher completely blind something new and you know what I'm actually kind of feel I kind of find that a little bit refreshing actually to find something just brand new that I've got no idea or preconceptions about and thank you very much for the review copy as well this is the game where you are foraging for food and then with these food resources so berries and uh nuts and stuff like that you are cooking recipes that score your victory points and these recipes that come in different types can be served to guests which give you some special abilities or some endgame scoring opportunities the locations that you're at uh vary twice in the game and and there are location bonuses for those ones but you use action markers in order to move around the board and you can upgrade your skills throughout the game and aside from that there's not a huge amount to it you forage the food bake the recipes serve them to guests and score victory points in a multitude of different ways so going in totally blind it certainly looks pretty but do the mechanics match the way it looks in Wild
Gardens you play through two trips or two rounds Each of which consists of three days or three phases the trip requires you to go to a specific location which has a start of day power for everybody as well as some end of round bonuses that you can grab you have five action markers numbered 1 to four and a single one that's one to four essentially so 1 2 3 4 and 1 to four and you have a player board with three separate skill sections on one for foraging one for cooking and serving and one for studying and reserving cards and a couple of little free skills to convert X resource and DWI resource at a moment's notice but on your board which is two-sided you have the source token dotted around the place that are randomly selected before the trip starts these consist of the various resources from what I can only guess is kind of like you know seaweed and Barks and flowers and mushrooms and berries and all the sorts of stuff that you might put in really weird recipes I guess I mean certainly the the one that's like kind of wooden barks is a little bit weird but you know I digress I like to cook but maybe there's some exotic cooking out there I'm not aware of that uses that kind of thing but the idea is is that your character will have starting space and you will choose one of the fruit three skill sections that you have on your board to use your marker WID so if I use the four and I decide I want to go foraging I have to follow the arrows on the board and I must move four spaces not up to it must be exactly as per the marker so 1 2 3 4 and then where I am I mean let's say I started here and I moved to here for example I could forage mushrooms and berries here you know but if I'm in the space next door I could go for mushrooms or seaweed or in this one I could go for barks flowers maybe even leaves you know
so there's different choices depending on which space you land on if you want to cook you essentially have to spend the resources of which there are all these little pieces here effectively of the different resources you spend them to cook recipes and a bit like in games like Splendor the recipes have got requirements like I need five flowers or I need five mushrooms one nut and one flour and then you take the card and now you score some victory points and it's a type of food drink dessert Etc but then when you serve recipes you can then serve them to various guests and they do come in all sorts of weird gues here something out of studio studio gibl movie I suspect where you know I've got like a pig here literally windy the pig but then I've also got what looks like Frankie Frankie and lulando which basically looks like my neighbor tooro and then you got am junit mips and Mill Abby Lawford you know there there's all sorts of weird characters that you've got in this game and there's some expansion packs to add like you know ones from the metor and outside but these different guests that you can serve to require different recipes and they have abilities such as discard to do some really cool effect or keep at the game end and score victory points point in certain way ways sorry when you get to the end of a day then you have what is essentially a location board with the location on it and spaces for your action markers what you have is that you'll have the location on here where you can choose one of four different bonuses but you have to give up your action marker permanently for that trip before you can take the power so I decide I want to use this power here I have to sacrifice for a free
marker and then when we do day two I no longer have this free marker I have to use the other four that I've got when you finish day two you do the exact same thing all right I'm going to grab this bonus instead well now I've got to sacrifice my one piece so you essentially have three days where you do five actions then four actions then three actions and then you rinse and repeat a different location five actions four actions fre actions now these skills sound very basic but you can upgrade them with the use of skill tokens you have a little sideboard with these cool little books on there and essentially when you do the study action you take one of the books you only carry two at a time and you take one of the respective skill tokens that are need buy and there's tons of these little tokens that you draw out the bag you could get ones like uh you know forage extra times like maybe every time I res reserve a card I also get to forage uh every time I land next to strawberries I get two more strawberries every time I land next to seaweed I get a victory point in there's all sorts of these different skill tokens you can get and you can upgrade each of your skill sections up to three times so you can really customize your board to such an extent other than that there's not much to explain you go through two trips of the three days each and once you get to the end you see how many victory points you've gained on the scoreboard so far you see if there's any game end scoring from your various cards and there's a few pity points for leftover resources and of course once you've toted them up the most is the winner of course all right let's start with the obvious one here cue the meme you good looking hot hot indeed this is one of the prettiest games I
have played this year or Hell in a while longer than that this game is Drop Dead Gorgeous the artist was it artist the Lis manold I don't know if that's how you pronounce it I apologize if not but you deserve credit for this this game just oozes charm and likeness in every bit of color that is within it the artwork is stellar and gorgeous look at that cover my eyes would you not pick that up off the shelf if you saw that on in the game store you so would and the artwork continues around the side of the Box the board look gorgeous the pieces look gorgeous and bear in mind that I have got upgraded pieces here we'll talk about those later but even the cardboard ones still have nice artwork on them as well but you've got big chunky characters your wooden player markers the cards are decent you know they're pretty sturdy cards actually you know so I don't think you actually need to sleeve these I think they're pretty strong but they've got you know gorgeous unique artwork on the back of them and then they've got all these unique recipes that honestly I mean some of these look like they could be real I don't know you know I think most of them are but I just want to cook some of these I mean I fancy a bit of spiced iced tea I want some uh you know Hunter's pie some Mom's Apple Pie hell I want a stinging spanakopita which I had to Google and find out that was apparently a Greek food but yeah I'm not familiar with it myself but oh man everything here just
looks delicious and even the guests you know they've got all sorts of weird pictures on you've got the different PL like different people but then as I said there's one that looks like a pig there's something that looks like you know my neighbor tororo on here there's a dog there's a cat somewhere and all of these just feel like it's own its own little universe or something like I could see this being an animated movie but yeah there is nothing in here that looks bad you know the cardboard tokens are standard cardboard tokens but everything else here feels premium and given that the game cost about £56 to pre-order off their website it kind of needs to be 56 quid is not the cheapest game in the world but man you are getting some solid quality for it now I do have upgrade tokens and these are obviously not in the box so if basically I think you still get the really cool little books with you know screen printed designs on them I think they're normal but what I do have is essentially two boxes for premium wooden Source tokens and premium wooden ingredients now the source tokens are these big ones that you shove on the board to say where everything is and of course the little ones are this massive collection of little pieces and like I said you can get quite a lot in here which represent all the different ingredients that you can grab I believe it cost you about £16 or so to buy the sauce tokens and about £26 or so to buy the wooden ingredients now of course that's not cheap you know you I mean £56 for the game and in those two upgrades you are likely to spend
nearly £1 on this by the time you've really pimped it up I would suggest find out if you like the game first before you go for the upgrades but I will say the upgrades are really cool I like these little resource tokens a lot I mean they are really thick wood with screen printed designs on them you've got no stickers or any nonsense like that and these Source tokens really pop on the board because they are these really you know chunky discs as well so everything is clear to see not to say that the cardboard tokens are bad okay the Caro tokens are perfectly fine and you still get drawring bags and all these thick markers without having to upgrade but yeah if you've got the spare cash and you want to treat yourself and you think this is a game for you these tokens are definitely worth it I can't stress that enough it is just that the luxury edition has so much more Eagle this game is frightfully simple to play the rule book is pretty easy to follow and you know it may Fe a large book but it's really clear you've got a good reminder sheet on the the back there's a lot of pictorial examples which I swear take up actually most of the space in here but there really isn't a lot of rules to learn and if you've played a fair chunk of games a lot of these rules are going to be fairly straightforward to you the idea that you collect the resources to trade in for recipes well it tells you what the recipe needs it's on there it scores your victory points nice and simple the abilities on here I mean there's a lot of different sort of combinations that you can grab for strategies but these abilities are not cicad they don't really require much of an FAQ mode they're pretty simplistic to
do but your turn sequence again is very straightforward you pick one action marker you choose one of those three sections you move your character and basically do what the action is and it could literally just be grab some resources grab a recipe grab a guest or study and grab yourself a particular skill token turns are not particularly long in this although not perfect you know there is still the element of AP that can be generated from trying to think well I could go this way and do this or I could go that way and do that ah you're now standing in my way how do I do this because players literally block the spaces so there is an element of interaction there but yeah this this is a game where even though it says like about 90 to 120 Minutes on the box you can teach this in about 10 minutes it really is a nice quick rules learning experience which is you know a nice refreshing change but for a game that says 90 to 120 Minutes on the box I was surprised of just how few rules you actually did have to learn making it bigger doesn't make it clearer the game has a relatively linear progression throughout and even though the rules are simple there is still enough depth in this game to keep Gamers of wide different levels you know engaged and involved yes the rules are straightforward you move your guy use an action marker and trade in resources for cards that's nothing especially new but where this game comes into its own is from a few factors firstly as I said the interaction element there's not a ton of player interaction I'm not completely messing you up but you do block spaces and you can kind of gu where players want to go and might make life a little
bit harder for them especially when you start giving up these location mark sorry these action markers on location bonuses which is a nice cool feature because then you know if the player can move fast or not because they're on public display but the idea with the different recipes you know there are recipes of different points values and different types because the guests require different recipes so you know this particular combo here needs just a drink this one needs a dessert and anything else this one needs a a salad you don't WIS with and these give you a lot of really cool abilities when bought or when you discard a card or open up quite a few number of a game end opportunities so you know you might think well I don't desperately need to reserve a bunch of cards but then you find one that gives you points for having reserved cards it's like okay that's a nice shortterm plan to get a few extra points here some want you to hog a ton of a particular resource some want you to just have a bunch of recipes cooked because when you cook a recipe you keep the card but then you discard it to get the guest well one guest might want you to have a bunch of these recipes Sav so you go well okay I'm not going to take a any more guests because that will mean I'll use all the recipes I'll just spend the rest of the game cooking up a bunch of these there's quite a few different little path to victory that you can go down and what really elevates this is the skill tokens you've got nine slots on your board to upgrade three for each section you can do quite a lot of cool combinations with this you know you could literally just get three of these hand symbols put it on the forage section and suddenly you have forage five so every time you
forage you get five different ingredients which is kind of insane of course you only get four of them a PA at a time so you do have to you know see if they come up it's a bit more tactical in that respect but we've got ones here to increase your speed let you trade in recipes for points that you trade in recipes to trigger guests more often you've got ones that get you extra resources of a particular type if you go stand next to them and you can do so much customization here yeah I could put all my forage bonuses on the forage action but then maybe I should put it on a different one maybe every time you know reserving a card I get a couple of victory points that is using up my action to do so well okay I'm going to upgrade that action with a bunch of forages so now every time I reserve a card thinking I need to get this mushroom ravioli so you can't Nick it well now I also get to harvest a couple of things well I need a couple of mushrooms anyway so fine two mushrooms boom and it opens up you know lots of different little paths and lots of little cool quirks that you can do with these skill tokens and it increases the variety in the game as well because you've already got quite a decent size you know deck of these I mean this isn't even all of them this is just a handful and you've got a decent amount of recipes as well but all of these skill tokens that will come out differently each game because you certainly will not go through this whole bag of them it's just physically impossible plus you've got the different location bonuses which I kind of would have maybe liked to have seen you go to more than just two locations in the game too just doesn't seem like much but you do have a decent amount more in the in the bag so yep here we go got quite a few here so there's a decent amount of variety with
those bonuses as well and again beautiful artwork A there's one with a little otter in it Vancouver Island love it as I said the game takes 120 Minutes Max and it didn't feel like it outstayed its welcome too much for a player is a kind of on a tight rope where it's almost outstaying its welcome but not too much there is AP potential in this game certainly that you can you know be trying to think well I could go down this throughout or you've blocked this now I need a plan B but it's not that hard to think of a different plan in this game and certainly you know when I played this with a free player the other day in fact we took about 90 minutes to play it after the teach and you know it felt like you know okay n 199 minutes that's not too bad I asked the other players they didn't think it outstay it's welcome and I think most games tend to do better when they are about 90 minutes to 2 hours max it's a good kind of midweight range here you know it's not too short and it's over before you can really get started but it doesn't drag on forever so that you can't ever like you know fit this in a typical game night this is one that shouldn't take you more than a couple of hours to teach and play with most players who aren't going to freeze up over the choices and it's not like you're you know these choices are that hard to figure out you shouldn't be there completely brain dead but you know you've got enough recipes to go after enough guess and enough different skill actions to do whether you're hyper efficient that's down to you but yeah I was quite surprised that the game length for once and yeah I don't say this very often actually feels about right I don't think any of us
expected him to say that the game also comes with a solo mode and the solo mode at first I thought okay they've just thrown in the solo mode because it's Kickstarter it's what they do it's just going to be beat your own score and do what it is you normally do wow was I wrong on that I mean yeah it's beat your own score you know you're trying to do the best but I thought it would just be that and generic nothing else but wait D these guys actually put effort into the solo mode I kid you not they have this book here which is thicker than the main rule book and it's a solo scenarios book and it's like scenarios how does this work I kid you not there is basically seven odd scenarios in this book ranging in difficulty and the idea is is that you have these Milestones that you've got to complete as well as beat your own score so that you know you have to feed specific people or you need to achieve this particular condition but each scenario has story book elements yeah it's like playing something by Red Raven games Ryan lucky you know something like near and far or above and below so you have an intro you have the setup um I think this is the scenario 2 the yeah a casual one for example it's not they're Charming stories but it's a bit like watching something like Kiki's Delivery Service of Studio gibli It's A Slice of Life movie it's not like you got to worry about spoilers it's just nice and Charming but they have different milestones and they'll have like you know complete milestones and get the standard epic or legendary achievements so as I say it is technically beat your own SC but you start off with a particular different setup and then when you serve a guest they've got story
markers on the top corner so it tells me to read paragraph 130 now some of these paragraphs are just the same in which case it's like a it's the same exer it doesn't matter but you'll start off with a couple of specific characters like this one I start off with an old granny and so all right I've got to serve this granny well I've done that a couple of turns I've served that Granny a recipe then I go and read her a particular paragraph and then it tells gives me a reward might give me a new milestone tells me to find new stuff out of the deck and it basically just walks you through this very nice almost kind of like children's TV episode drama and you know the fact that they went to the effort of making a book with all these different story entries and seven different scenarios proves that they actually took the time to think about this they didn't just throw it in it wasn't just a stretch goal to say oh well uh fine we'll just put in Solo mode as long as he get us to 70 grand it's fine what's the solo mode oh you just play it as normal and see what your score is you know there's so many examples of that on Kickstarter this one felt like they made some effort and I got to give respect to that now does it mean that it's fantastic and I want to play the solo scenarios all the time not necessarily but I've played for a few of these already and they are good fun and it's good to try and you know vary the branching path a little bit it's not like there's that many branching P you might have like two in per scenario but you know trying to beat your own score is cool the game itself is already fun so playing it solo is not a bad thing but just the fact that this kind of almost feels like playing something like takoo and taido where you've got that
Charming aesthetic and that Charming feel but you know with a nice little bit of a story to go with it and the game doesn't take that long to play it solo honestly I'm just shocked they put in that much effort and they deserve kudos for that ah smug mode the game doesn't necessarily scale for players at least not properly the board doesn't change whatsoever with two to four you have the same number of spaces and that's it with two players you can kind of avoid each other and just have a Charming little game but when you play this with four oh my God this is get evil because you block the spaces entirely and you don't count their spaces for movement so four players you could pretty much be traveling around the whole Board of big loop to Loops if you really want because so many spaces will be taken up but it also end adds this little chaos Factor because you might be trying to go for a particular space or a picnic site and hm Okay so red has gone past Nick that picnic site blue has gone past Nick that picnic site I could go get those berries there and green just nicked it and you know it does create a nice little bit of turn angst but certainly in a four player game especially you are going to have to accept that sometimes your best leg plans you know don't always go the way you want and you do need to play this in a bit more of a tactical you know way free players definitely feels like a sweet spot for the game a little bit of blocking but not you know too much freedom and that seems to be the sweet spot but I found this worked pretty well as a nice two-player game as you know as it is and it's not that the game is bad at four players you just need to accept that that is the case you know it's going to take you to the 2hour
Mark if you play this with four players and you are going to have to accept that there is a bit of blocking involved which is mostly involuntary because yes you could see what action markers people have but unless you know for certain that they're going to try and cook something there's only so much you can do to physically block them you just happen to go and do what you do and it gets in the way so there's a little bit of interaction but not a ton and there just ain't room enough on this planet for the two of us there is a little bit of a random element to the game in some respects but not too much this isn't like oh it's a luck Fest you know these cards will come out and you may or may not have the ingredients for them but somebody else might just conveniently do I do like the cool thing that the back of these cards tells you what the predominant ingredient is for the recipe that it's on that's a really cool feature I think more games should try doing this but the back of the card also has uh an ingredient on it for a particular mechanic that lets you get the main ingredient well you might be thinking well the Main Ingredients leave so that's great then somebody comes along and Cooks a recipe oh well main ingredient seaweed now I hope you liked it it's like it's it's cool that it's there but yeah this one is quite a chaotic part but you might be gunning for a particular guest who wants you know certain types of recipes that you've cooked and they just don't turn up you know the the recipe selection might end up with a selection of drinks and not much else and you're really hoping for a dessert recipe you know occasionally those things are happen but I've never seen it go out of control there is a variant in the book though which is sort of mandatory really but also kind of needs a little bit of a
tweak normally there's nothing you can do to shape up the display if you get a display full of nothing but drinks dead tough that's all the display is there is a variant in the book that allows you to basically go right is there three or more of the same guest or recipe that has the same type in which case I want to Chuck away the entire display and say that's it that is good and bad though it's good that it keeps the display fresh and doesn't get stagnant but what it does do is sometimes introduces a bit of a tape that element where you know somebody is going to cook a particular good recipe here like I know my friend is going to cook this water Min sbet it could be worth lots of points and it's like hm well it's a dessert there's a lot of desserts there I don't want desserts I also don't want them to cook you know what I'm just going to refresh the display because I can because it doesn't cost anything that just feels a little bit mean you know the fact that I can go well you're about to cook well tough luck I'm refreshing the whole display and it's not like you can plan ahead for that I mean it might be that there were only two desserts there then somebody else goes and Cooks oh a dessert just came off the deck oh there's fre there well I'm going to wipe the whole display sucks to be you it's like H that uh felt a little bit mean in fact I had the opportunity to do it in one game and I chose not to because I just felt that F that just felt wrong so what I'm kind of thinking you need to do with that variant is have that variant in the game that you can refresh a display but have it a bit like do an Imperium where you only have one opportunity to do this so you have like a a token that you could flip over or just something to remember that you've already done it once and so you can in
that scenario refresh the display once but once you've done it that's it for the game you can't then do it again it stops you being able to constantly attack other people for you know cooking a recipe just because there's a lot of it in there you might think well okay you knew the risk when you did it but again it's not like you can plan ahead for the card flipping off the deck and suddenly putting you in that situation it's a variant that I think is mandatory but it does need a little bit of a tweak and you know when you start getting into that situation of having to house rule a game it is a bit of a problem you know you can only forgive a game so much when you've got to do that but you know it is a variant in the book I just think it needs a little bit of a tweak wild Gardens is been a big surprise for me I came into this completely blind not having a clue what it was only that it was drop dead gorgeous I then read the rule book and I thought it seems prettyy simple but I mean there's something that sounds pretty good here let's jump into it and I was pleasantly surprised by how much fun this game actually can be it doesn't outstay its welcome at anything less than four players and even at four players it's still reasonable depending on the players that you're with you know the random element is there but not too much that they could get in the way of you know the the Crux of the game it never felt like oh you know you only won because this fluky thing happened that never comes about all the components in here even the cardboard tokens are great the artwork is absolutely Stellar it just oozes This Charming feeling when you play it like you can't help but feel a little bit relaxed even though people
could block you and the fact that they put so much effort into the solo book you know solo mode to give you story elements are much like a Red Raven game you know this is like Ryan lockit territory I'm not saying the writing is Stellar like tinted gray or novelization here but they could have literally just not bothered and instead they gave you this entire book that is good going but will they release more in the future that remains to be said it's really easy to learn it's very smooth to play sometimes you might forget to trigger a day ability from these locations now and again but uh that's a minor thing and the customization you have for your skills with the skill tokens leads to some cool bonuses and cool Combos and some cool little you know strategies that you can follow which as again this game is kind of more of a tactical game rather than a strategy game but it just it gives it that amount of De depth that it needs and doesn't just make it like a linear tiny little game that doesn't have much fa required it really has surprised me and if you're willing to pay the extra for these tokens it's going to look absolutely fantastic on the table and you can add to the variety by grabbing these little packs they they basically release them in eight quid packs it's a bit like the dog park uh dog packs that I did in that review well it's the same here although I will stress as much as they do add to the variety of the guests some of them are basically portrayals of Kickstarter backers which I can kind of go by and another pack is medor like content creators not a fan of them because when you look at the characters that appear in a normal game when you suddenly get
like Rodney Smith watch it played as a character it's like what and you know some of these just kind of feel a bit jar when you when you see them not to mention that if you do get something that's basically a bunch of content creators not every single one is going to be some of that you want to see so it's that's a pack I probably might avoid but you know I've got all three mixed in here just gives me a bunch more cards there's not a huge amount of negatives to say a little bit of Randomness here and there game length can be a bit long with four uh the variant in the book does need a little bit of tweaking and I do think it's something worth considering but all in all it's just a pretty salad Gabe I'm giving this one a nine out of 10 a distinction level because I think it's deserving of it it's got the lightness for you know being a light game that most people can enjoy it's got the looks it's got the charm it's got the easy you know rules to follow it's got the rule book to go with it that isn't very confusing it's got the customization with skills a bit of variety but it is still just a nice simple you know game with some cool little decisions and combos to make you know does it scale well not particularly that is a flaw you know well I say not scale well but you know you got to accept that four player is going to be a little bit more chaotic and a bit meaner than a two and a three but you can play it solo and I find it perfectly Charming then it's just a nice solid game you know not the you know best in the world but I think it's definitely if you want to compare it to another game think of flamecraft flamecraft is another game that came out which was meant to be sort of very cutesy artwork good for light Gamers and
that but honestly flamecraft is okay but I think flamecraft is far too fiddly and convoluted for what it's trying to be I mean once you get a bunch of those dragons out and start comboing things it gets really convoluted you know too many things going on too much like chaos happening and for Gamers it just seems like too much this one though doesn't have that problem you know even when you got a bunch of skill tokens keying off it's pretty easy to follow what's going on and I feel like this one is much better suited to that target audience than something like flamecraft is I mean certainly if you were to put the two next to each other I choose wild Gardens without a second four I think this is easily better than flamecraft for that purpose so yeah by all means give this one a look when it comes out see if you like it then if you do like it consider these upgrades cuz they are really nice upgrade but yeah nice simple you know simple rules but with a decent amount of dep few little niggles here and there but overall a really solid surprise so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Bor Game Geek when he goes live on the page check out the rest of the content I've been making recently including the new Terminus review from inside up games let me know in the comments what you think did you follow this through the kickstarter have you played their other game Keystone do you want to tell me a little bit about that one have you played this do you agree with the fors this agree um the solo scenarios the packs I don't know let me know your thoughts I always like to read them take care and remember regardless of whether you fancy a nice uh pine nut pesto Pizza hickory nut milk or uh you
know let's see what else we got a a mermaid tonic for dinner tonight it's still only a game so bye for now