Ranking the 2023 Booker Prize Shortlist
Transcript
hey Gamers or should I say readers today uh this is Liz Davidson for beond soliter and I'm making this video because I said I wanted to read all the booker prize finalists this year before they announc the winner on uh on November 26th and I succeeded in doing so so here are like my quick thoughts on each of the books I'm going to do it in order from the one I liked least to the one I like the most I don't really think I can predict to a win because I think Awards panels are strange I honestly think it's a little this short list is a little weird like I'm not actually convinced these are the best six books published in the UK this year but you know I could be wrong uh so we're going to go through them and we're going to talk about them and we're just going to kind of see what I thought so starting with my least favorite and again none of these books were bad it's just that some of them were more and less for me or compelling to me so I think my least favorite was this other Eden by Paul Hardy um I'm not saying it was bad it was beautifully written this guy is clearly a really talented author and I'm not going to try to take that away from him but I think that there are two things that are wrong with this book so just to start the subject matter is this is like a very literary novel but it focuses on a historical situation which is there was an island called Malaga Island like off the coast of Maine that had a very small community of people who were mixed race and the community was so small there's also kind of a lot of inbreeding going on in the on the island and so the outside world eventually decides to intervene and kicks them all off the island but it's not really clear where they're going to go or if their lives are actually going to be better as a result of being removed from their homes so this book is about the people
on the island and it's also about The Outsiders who are kind of of the opinion that they should be removed and the main person who is an outsider who's characterized a lot in this book is the teacher who comes to the island like seasonally and tries to teach the kids to read and like wow you know for mixed race kids these kids are really talented wow and like tries to convit other people that is so but he can't actually help the people in the island and just kind of looks at the mess he made and tries to tell himself it for the best so you know it's kind of a rough plot line uh but there are two things wrong with it in my opinion one is that I think that the focus might have been different if somebody who was actually mixed race or non-white had written this book uh as far as I can tell Paul Harding is white and it feels a little gross to see him like mining the suffering of the people on the island and kind of putting their stories into like very biblical terms while also presenting them as these like extremely poor countryfied incestuous people um it just just feels a little exploitative and the other thing is that because so much of the way these people are understood comes from the point of view of the teacher I couldn't help but feel there's like a little bit too much focus on the outside and how they would perceive the people on the island as opposed to the people who were actually there I'm sure there are be people who disagree with me about this but nah the story itself wasn't that compelling I think it wasn't that compelling because
a lot of it focuses on a boy who leaves the island to become an artist and um you know there's just kind of a tendency to want to get away from the place where I think the core of the story is uh and also I don't think that Paul Harding was the person to write about this island the next one towards the bottom of the list for me is the beasting by Paul Murray there a lot of Paws on this list as you're going to discover so I actually really enjoyed the book while I was reading it however this thing is a chalk this is like 700 something pages and honestly I felt that and that's not because I don't like long books you know lome Dove was is like the quickest 800 pages I ever hked up in my life so I'm not saying that a long book is bad I'm saying that maybe the beasting needed to be a little shorter uh so it is kind of a book about people making the wrong decisions and ending up like very much on the brink of Despair people's lives go really wrong in this book there's not a whole lot of Hope offered but you also do really end up loving people in the family and maybe there's like a kernel of of hope that things will work out for them in the end but basically you get chapters from different family members viewpoints starting with the kids and I will say that this author does a very good job of kind of getting into the minds of children and explaining their reasoning and how they see the world and it was cool uh I was actually more interested in the parents when we get to them but so I don't want to give away the plot line entirely but there were reasons why this family was the way it was that when I learned about them really pissed me off uh I just don't like certain things to be used as a plotline um so basically I don't want to
give it away you'll have to read it if you want to find out or just message me and I'll tell you if you want to spoil um but for me uh this was a book that went on too long it was like a little too upsetting because everything just felt like it was piling on wrong with I didn't really like the direction it was going and then when I found out why this family had ended up the way that it did in the first place and like there are little Clues throughout the book but like there's a really big one once you get to the later stages um I ultimately just felt kind of disappointed um I can see people really loving this book it's very well written it's very engaging um but for me had a plot Trope I really hate all right so now we're gonna go to my fourth on the list so we've gone 654 um this book I thought was good but I didn't think that it was transcendently good and maybe it could have been and that was Western Lane by chetna Maru so this book is very very short it's like a snack it's the first one I read because I knew it would be quick and it would get me going on the booker prize finalist this is about a little girl whose mother has died and her father is dealing with his grief uh by taking her and her sisters to the squash court but it turns out that she happens to be very very talented at squash and it becomes like her and her father's Obsession kind of in the absence of her mother as balancing force and this alienates her from her sisters and it also causes like fractures in her relationships with the other members of her family and with her community so part of what makes Western Lane very interesting is that it's very much condensed into the Viewpoint of
this little girl she's like 11 years old in this book and so she sees the adults doing and talking about things that I mean for to make the fiction good she doesn't fully understand uh but you as an adult reader are able to like perceive more so so this is about a non-white family operating in British Society so there's some racial lines that this girl is learning how to navigate her family has traditional expectations of her that it's not totally clear that her father has of her or that she has of herself there are definitely some conflicts about what it means to grow into a proper woman like her mother would have wanted and what it would change if she was going to be a squash player uh her father can't clearly take care of all the girls and there's some like discussion about whether one of them should go to live with other family members and all these things are really dramatic they're a big deal but they're so quiet like as refracted through this 11-year-old's Viewpoint like one of the things about this book I think is I really like very understated pros and I like being forced to kind of figure out what's going on from Clues and the context but this book was kind of like listening to something in snow like it was just so quiet it was so muffled in a way and I think that maybe it was too quiet and too muffled and that um the restraint was a little too much it would have been it would have need to let go just a little bit more to go from being a really good book to being a great book that said I thought it was a really enjoyable read I thought it did a really good job of kind of focusing on a little kid's Ambitions and then kind of placing her within the larger culture around her in a way that was really compelling third on my list and I'm not sure that it's third like
it's a book that that I kind of love and I kind of hate and for that reason I'm putting it right in the middle so my number three on the list is study for obedience by Sarah Bernstein I in a lot of ways don't totally know what to say about this book I probably need to read it again actually I'll probably read it again before I trade it on because it was just it was weird but like in a cool way so this is a classic setup where you have a very very unreliable narrator so this woman is going to live with her brother she makes it very clear that she spent her life being very self-sacrificing for members of her family and that's something that she's like proud of but maybe resents a little bit uh but you can't really tell because she's so unreliable she's just like this person who's very difficult to read even if you're reading the book that she's narrating and so what's weird is that she's in this town it's clearly in a place that is foreign to her but where her family used to live in the past so she has a historical connection to the location where her brother lives but culturally she is an outsider um she is coded as Jewish as you'll notice through the book but it's very very understated and you have to like find the clues that get you there but there's definitely something more going on than just like a racial or religious divide it's pretty clear her brother has assimilated fairly well to the town but when he goes out of town and she tries to interact like the feelings of alienation and nobody liking her and just totally not fitting in are so intense that it's like almost embarrassing to read and it's also hard to figure out what the hell this woman is doing that makes people hate her so much like we're talking like parents covering their baby's eyes like running
away from from her as if she's some sort of witch and she like definitely does things that are super socially inappropriate like she makes these little figures out of grass and like leaves them as a gift on people's doorsteps and like freaks everybody out like Blair Witch Project Style U but she like doesn't realize that that could be a weird thing and then I don't want to give any more away because I feel like you have to piece this book together yourself and draw your own conclusions I'll be super interested in hearing from anybody else who's read this thing because it's weird uh but you get to the end and you start to realize that you know she's pres been presenting herself as this nice helpful person the whole time and there's some very creepy stuff that happens at the end of this book nothing it's one of those ones where like nothing happens but also so much is happening and you don't really get a conclusion you just have to come to your realizations about who you think this narrator is and what she is doing and then like go from there it's weird I liked it I hated it I don't know like is it is it just too overwrought is like trying to be the lottery but doesn't have the same satisfying conclusions of the lottery like I don't know um but I feel like what Sarah Bernstein did here is so ambitious and it does succeed well enough that it warrants a higher place in the list if if even if I don't really think that it should win I respect the ambition and I think it's worth attempting to read it if you like to read like strange mysterious things all right so now we're up to my top two my number two I actually had to have imported from the UK cuz it wasn't published in the United States on time thanks everybody
uh but it's Propet song by Paul Lynch told you there were a lot of Pauls in this list so prophet song is a wonderful story for this time so this one's kind of like a handmaid's tale sort of warning it's said in Ireland but Ireland has gotten really fascist and it's starting to really restrict people and there's creepy secret police everywhere people are being detained for no reason and everybody's trying to figure out what they want to do about they got to fight back or they going trying to escape and this woman is a mother with a whole bunch of kids and she's now a single mother because her husband's been picked up because he was the leader of a teachers union which kind of hit home for me as a as a teacher so the book is about her deciding what she's going to do her father has dementia he's going to be hard to move her sister's already in another country maybe she can go to her sister but they're like a little bit not close her kids are torn over what to do some of them want to stay in fight you know she's got little ones who maybe need to be gotten out of there but she's also seeing if she can find her husband before she does anything because if he gets out and she's not there then what will happen then and so so she's got this really tough situation on her hands and really brutal things happen throughout the book like this is not a book that like gets better and better it's a book where everything just gets worse uh but I think that's probably realistic to its to its premise so I thought the book was really good I also think that the book's writing style sometimes was a boon to it sometimes got in the way so you can tell that Paul Lynch has read a whole lot of K McCarthy there's a lot of kind of interesting word pairings and like pushing at the edges of proper grammar and you know
kind of stream of Consciousness stuff going on in here it feels like blood merian set in fascist Ireland uh it's not that violent but it's got that same kind of almost confusing flow until you get into it and there were times when I thought that was really beautiful because it kind of expressed the jumble of thoughts the mother was having how confusing her situation was how brutal everything was and just sort of the shock of seeing horrible things happen in a place that you thought was safe in a place that you thought was your home there were other times when I felt like the writing style was a little bit overwhelming and it got in the way of some of the more Punchy things that were happening in the book because having to process that something really gut Punchy was happening sometimes took away from the gut punch so I thought it was really good see this is what I'm saying like I'm not really sure I don't think that this is a short list of absolute masterpieces but I do think that the books on here are good and every single one of is doing something interesting and profit song definitely is I really enjoyed it um I felt it was timely and so it's my number two and then my number one I don't know if this one is going to win because it's the one that's the least novalish of the group but it's if I survive You by Jonathan es scoffy I thought this book was great uh it's kind of a collection of short stories but it's also kind of an extended narrative about a family so it has to be a long piece of connected Pros to be nominated for a Booker so I think that there might be some dispute about whether this really counts but hey it's made the short list so I feel like it's cross that hurdle right like it's sort of like well we've been talking about whether or not it's a war game but it got nom nominated for a Charlie so here we
are so I loved this book though um so this is a book about a Jamaican family that moved to the United States when things were really tough in their home country and the kids are kind of trying to figure out how to assimilate to the United States and the parents are trying to figure out how much they want to embrace their new home so there is a chapter dedicated to various men in the family this is definitely about fathers Sons brothers and cousins and their relationships but I found it really really moving so kind of the main character is the younger son who is not very traditionally masculine he's highly intellectual he feels constantly othered in American society and he also very very much wants to fit in and so he struggles with his identity and he also struggles with his family so you know he's got a brother who is dad's favorite and that that causes a lot of emotional Rifts he's got a father who is kind of distant doesn't know how to emotionally connect to his child and makes some parenting decisions that further arrange their relationship uh there's a cousin who has probably the saddest chapter in the entire book but it was fantastic uh and you know basically you're just getting in touch with these men who are figuring out how to emotionally relate to each other about their jealousies their feelings of Abandonment their inability to apologize and a lot of it is centered around this like family home that they move into that's like the childhood home for the boys but it's a crab hul that like gets restored but it's still on horrible land it's like sinking into the ground and still all fighting over this toxic house and so this book was
wonderful because every character was super engaging um you do have to read some chapters that are in sort of a pis but I thought that was fine I really enjoyed it actually it gave the book an extra spice and like an extra way to see through somebody else's eyes so I was personally here for it um I know some people complain about it but I don't care there were like there were there were several parts of this book that just really punched me in the heart um because I liked watching these different characters try to find each other um even though they're so close like how hard it is for them to connect and the way that es scoffy creates that tension and creates emotions surrounding his characters is just really really good I would read anything this guy writes I think that his story I think that his Pros was the most addictive of the bunch and I think the things that he did with it were the most emotionally engaging of the bunch so this is definitely my number one pick and I hope it wins a Booker I don't know if it will but I hope it does so just some kind of final thoughts on the list now that I've gone through them all I can't help but look at them and think why were these the ones made the short list um you know I did this a couple years ago in 2021 and discovered one of my favorite authors Brandon Taylor and so I think it's definitely worth it sometimes to just like read the top books on a prize list and kind of see what you see but you're not going to like everything and this is one of those years where I felt like the books that were chosen were picked because they did some sort of interesting literary gimmick but I didn't necessarily think that they were great books they're all good all the writing was really solid some of it was great um and a lot of the
things that the authors attempted were ambitious I'm not saying any of the books in the list are bad exactly but I didn't really they're I'm going to forget them so like there are books that I read and I'm like yeah it's pretty good and I kind of put it on good reads make a note about it but then a few years later I'm like what was the PLT of that I don't remember the only book on the list I think is going to stick with me really hard is probably if I survive you U because it was the one that emotionally meant the most and the one that I was just the most swept up by while I was in the process of reading it so who knows what will be rewarded by the awards committee I would say that if I survive you is not the most ambitious book in terms of like literary pretensions I do think that it's the most ambitious in terms of pushing what a novel is so maybe that counts um in in in this particular list uh but we will see what the awards committee wants to promote this year I guess but those are the booker prize finalists uh they were all very good so if any of them interested you should read it but I thought that if I survive it was Far and Away the most moving of the lot uh and that I would read anything that that author writes in the future so the holidays are coming up you should absolutely take some time to read get a book for a loved one uh maybe this gave you some ideas and I'll be doing some more book videos here on Beyond solitary in the future thank you so much for watching uh please like subscribe comment ask questions comment if you've read any of these and most of all happy
reading