Arkham Horror investigator decks review (review copy provided)
Transcript
Hey everybody, this is Mike with the One-Stop Co-op Shop and today I'm doing a different type of review. I'm looking at the five new investigator decks that just came out for Arkham Horror: The Card Game. And disclaimer that I was sent review copies of these. And if you like the content on the One-Stop Co-op Shop, consider supporting us through Patreon. You get early access to our videos and exclusive videos every month you can't see anywhere else. You can also listen to our weekly podcast for reviews and design discussions or join the conversation and say hi on our Discord. So yes, we have five new standalone investigator decks kind of like the ones that Fantasy Flight had uh quite a while back for season 1 or chapter 1, what whatever the uh new and old Arkham stuff are being called. These contain a full 30-card investigator deck uh with some new cards and some repeat cards, although more new than old from what I saw. And they also include a bunch of experience cards for the investigators so that basically this is a one-stop shop if you want to play this and a scenario or campaign, you can just use these characters and be good to go.
I'm going to do a brief conversation through each of them. I'm not going to show every single card. You already have uh online databases with that information. But I'll talk through some of the things that stand out for good and bad and at the end I'll give my review for which ones I like and what I think about these for veterans and for newcomers of the series. So let's start with the new version of Tommy Muldoon. He's got pretty good stats, especially focused on the combat, and his ability is that he can play weapons with more ammo on them. So he just pumps out guns and shoots a ton with them. Now he only starts out with five guns in his deck. I could probably go for one more or two. Uh he does have Becky again, a slightly different version from the original Tommy Muldoon deck. He's got the basic M1911 that's been there since I think the original core. And he's got a nice service revolver which gives you a reaction shot back uh when somebody attacks you instead of you attacking them first, kind of like what is it, the survival knife from the old sets. But still, when his whole power is focused on playing weapons with more ammo, only having five maybe means it's not as consistent as I'd like. Though he does have this protective vest card which can take damage and also lets him tutor down into his deck a little bit to look for a firearm. Now in his XP cards, he does have a Thompson submachine gun for five experience and six resource cost uh if you ever get that far. Uh that's the only option you can add to give him more firearms in his deck. Besides that, he's got some solid stuff. He's got this uh police dog that can give plus one to an investigation or an attack once per turn. Rookie cop who dies and gives you a clue. He's got some other ways to get clues like make them sing. And as you might imagine, he's got some upgrades
for his gun, a custom grip that lets him play another one more quickly which goes well with his ability. Iron sights which lets him spend an action to get plus three to his next skill attack. I'm not sure if I like that one very much. And then for one XP in his deck, he can play this one cost fast and it lets him give plus one skill value to a firearm when he's attacking with it. That one's super good. But yeah, it's a pretty basic survivor character just focused on weapons instead of other ways of attacking. Uh nothing too spectacular here, but also pretty solid. Next we'll look at the new version of Carolyn Fern, our seeker. Great great stats. Uh love when they have five in intelligence. And then she's got a solid agility and willpower as well. Strength is her dump stat, but pair her with somebody like Tommy and she'll be fine. And her power, much better than the old Carolyn, is to get a clue at her location every time she heals horror from somebody, which is pretty crazy. Now the biggest problem with that in her entire deck and in fact in all five of these decks is that nobody has, that I saw, a single card that lets them take horror for an effect, which would be awesome because then, since she has tons of ways to heal horrors you can imagine, she could hoover up clues really effectively. Now she does have some XP cards that cost her horror, which would then let her heal herself, but they all cost five experience, yikes, and most of them are scrolls you have to upgrade from this basic scroll of the Pharaoh cards, one of those uh researched ones they've done in the past. But it's not like the game is shy about giving you horror in general, so she's still fine. And I will say she combos super well with Isabella from the new core set because she has the ability to take a horror to get a skill card back from her discard pile
and then Carolyn can heal that horror away and pick up a clue for free. Heck yeah. Oh whoops, I lied, she does have an expensive item that lets him get two clues from a location with one investigate action. So that could get her three clues all together, pretty amazing. But besides that, pretty standard stuff. She has some horror healing abilities. She has a new ally that lets you hold an extra tome, pretty cool. And then she has event cards that let her fight and evade with intelligence. Those are always nice, especially when she has five. So solid solid character and if you can pair her with somebody who uses horror more frequently, then she's going to be amazing. Next is Miguel de la Cruz. This is the new survivor and he's kind of goofy. That seems to be what they always do with survivor characters. His stats are fine. You know, he's not good at investigating, he's not really good at fighting. He can evade decently well. Uh his special ability is pretty cool. It says he gets a fourth action every turn just to play events, which is going to be great for deck construction, but kind of oddly he has 12 event cards in his starting deck and six of them are fast, meaning that he doesn't need them for his special ability. So he only has six cards in his starting deck that can actually benefit from it and not that many more from experience. So this is one that I don't think is too great uh out of the box. I think you do want to do some deck construction here. But besides that, his key thing is kind of weird to me. He's got a lot of traps where he can like lay things down to evade enemies automatically or even like a bomb in his experience cards to hurt them afterwards. And sometimes they let him like teleport to where the enemy is.
So I guess he's supposed to be leaving traps just as he goes around or evading the monster, running away and then like leaving a trap for when they follow him. Maybe.
It's very much an odd uh character. Maybe I'm just missing the synergies here. But they seem to want him to fight enemies. He's got this hunting dog that moves him toward enemies when they appear on the board. Again, he's got traps that teleport him there. But the only weapon he's got in his deck is a pocket knife that doesn't deal extra damage and he's only got three strength. So he's just kind of a weird guy. I don't really know what his deal is. I guess in a multiplayer game with a bunch of characters, he could lay down traps to help everybody. But besides that, I find him kind of the oddball of the bunch. Next is our mystic, Marie Lambeau. Great stats again. I love when strength is a dump stat, especially here when she can use her willpower to attack instead with spells. Her ability is interesting. She is a damage-focused mystic. She wants to take damage. A ton of her cards make her take damage and when she does, she can get more card draw to use more events and take even more damage. So yeah, like her special So yeah, her unique card lets her take damage, put more charges on spells.
She's got an offering bowl that lets her take damage to get resources. She's got the sacrificial doll that lets her take damage to redraw from the chaos bag. But don't worry, she does have several cards that let her heal including a cool one that attacks and heals. So she's not just going to uh take herself out with all of that. She's also got, as is pretty standard, three spells that let her use her willpower in place of other tests. And they all let you use a charge to do something extra like getting an extra clue, dealing extra damage. But if you draw the wrong kind of token from the chaos bag, it does something negative to you. So pretty solid, pretty basic stuff. And honestly, that's how I describe Marie even with her damage ability. She's a pretty basic mystic. She gets the job done, nothing uh special, but uh still a solid entry in the series. And last we've got the rogue, Andre Patel. He's uh got again pretty good stats. Well, I don't know.
The five agility is great obviously for evasion. Then he's got a little bit of intelligence. His ability though is great. After he succeeds at a skill test by two or more during his turn, he can take an extra action that turn. And uh he has a lot of things that boost his skill test as you can imagine. So he's pretty much going to be getting four actions almost every turn. His three unique cards are pretty cool, at least visually, cuz they're all in black and white cuz he's supposed to be a silent film actor. But yeah, they give him uh one wild or three wild for a specific type of test. So again, helping him get that uh two over for an extra action on his turns. But those are his only unique bonus cards, so he doesn't have any cool assets or anything. He's got a few other assets for getting bonuses to test, for getting resources. They seem a little expensive for me. But he has a favorite of mine, lockpicks, a great way to investigate better. Once he gets these out, he's investigating with five. And he has a lot of ways to again boost his test, so he's probably not going to discard them. And he does have the classic better lockpicks for one experience later. But the rest of his deck is just really solid. He's got this guy that lets him get two resources every turn. He's got a cane attack consistently with his agility. And after he does damage, he automatically evades them. Great action economy there. Then he's got some ways to auto-discover clues and even more ways to auto-discover clues. So he's just going to get tons of actions, evade lots of people, get clues pretty easily with his lockpicks. Very very solid character, although again, not as unique as some other ones in the past. So that's a brief look at all five of these new character decks. And what do I think of them overall? If you are a veteran of the series, I don't see any need to have these, honestly. If you're like me and already have a billion characters, uh some of them are pretty cool. Like I think Carolyn is a much better version
than her previous one, which had a much weaker ability. But you know, I don't know. I feel like I have characters that do almost the same things as all of these characters in my options. So they're fine, but yeah, for a veteran of the series, a collector, unless you just always buy everything blindly, I don't think these are going to excite you too much. Now for a newcomer, somebody who just bought the new core set, I think these are nice because having more investigators increases your options quite a bit and these people are doing different stuff than what the investigators in the base game did. But some of them definitely stand out more to me than others. Carolyn I think is a ton of fun and again will combo really well with Isabella. Andre Patel I think has great options and just has a ton of actions, lots of cool powers. So those are probably my top two from this set. Uh Tommy and Marie are fine. They don't feel like they're doing anything too unique, but it's a solid fighter and a solid all-rounder as a mystic. And then definitely the oddball that I can't really recommend unless I'm just totally missing some cool things. Miguel seems actively weak with his deck and if you're a newcomer, you don't have that many deck-building options to make him stronger. So yeah, I think he is eminently skippable whether you're a newcomer or a veteran. Thanks for watching everybody. Hope that was helpful for some of you. And a special thank you to our biggest Patreon supporters, J William F, Steve Wren, Casey W, Andrew R, and Chris C. We'll see you at the next stop.