Before You Buy Carnegie…
Transcript
hi in this video i'm going to help you decide whether or not it's worth it to buy the game carnegie to do this i'm going to give you a brief overview of how the game is played with a special focus on the unique characteristics of this game and then i'll talk about why i like it and i bought a copy for myself as well as some reasons that i'm aware why people might not want to buy the game carnegie is inspired by the life of andrew carnegie in the game the objective is to earn victory points by growing and efficiently running a company and making charitable donations in other words like a typical euro you'll use resources to expand your engine so you can get more resources and achieve objectives to get victory points so yes there's really nothing noteworthy about this theme but rather this game is all about its fairly unique mechanics in carnegie actions are departments on your company board to access these actions you will need to buy the department assign an employee to work there and pay the associated cost to activate that employee once an employee is activated they don't have to be paid again unless they are moved to another department players start the game with identical company boards with some departments already built in and some employees already staffing them before we talk about what these departments do however let's focus on the core of the game the real game is going to be focused on this area this is the timeline the timeline has four
action markers and you'll notice that the action markers correspond to the department types essentially to play the game players will take turns being the active player to choose one of the action markers in order to perform that action whatever the active player chooses every player gets to do after everyone has taken the management actions the action marker moves one space to the right and the active player passes to the next person in turn order and then they get to select an action for everyone to perform what makes this so interesting is that if the active player chooses an action and another player doesn't have staff departments of that type or doesn't have the resources needed to utilize those departments they don't get to do anything for this reason sometimes a player won't necessarily choose the action that is best for them but instead choose an action that is okay for them but causes unprepared players to effectively lose their turn as i mentioned earlier a department is staffed when it has a worker on the space and the worker has been activated by paying the cost that's not the only thing employees are used for however the other use for employees is represented on the spaces underneath these action markers employees can also be placed on different regions of the board aside from the donation area where players will invest in their scoring objectives the board has cities mission areas and transport tracks focus on the mission areas and cities during the game one type of action players can perform is the construction action for the construction action a player takes one
of their active employees from the construction department and puts it in a mission area for each employee placed in that area the player may spend resource cubes to place a disk from their player board in one of the cities so if i placed my employee in the east i could put my factory disk in one of these places if i placed my employee in the west i could place my factory disk in either of these two places or also any of these places since these other cities don't specify a specific project type notice that once the disk is placed an icon on my company board is revealed furthermore there's also an icon underneath my player token on the transport track okay now let's shift our focus back to the timeline the timeline is how players perform actions and it's also how they collect income so when a player selects an action before the action is performed every player will also have an option to collect income in that region so if i select this manage action every player is going to be able to collect income originating in the midwest to collect his income players must have a worker in the mission area and a player must be willing to remove that worker and put it back on their company board in the lobby if they do that two things are going to happen first they're going to collect income for each employee according to where their player marker is on the transport track i can collect this income once for each employee i remove from the mission area secondly i can collect all of the income
represented on the icons on the exposed tracks on my company board it doesn't matter where these disks are located i collect all the income once every time i remove at least one employee from the board during income so let's recap on each turn one player is going to select income and an action that is going to affect every other player players will take turns collecting their income and activating their departments if a player can't or doesn't want to remove a worker from a mission area they don't get to collect any income if a player doesn't have a staff department or the resources associated with the action they don't get to perform any action so on two counts income and action players can be affected negatively if they aren't prepared but lastly you'll notice that there are some spaces that don't have a region when an action marker is selected on one of these spaces instead of collecting income players will take turns making donations in the area at the top of the board only one player can be placed in a space and each space provides unique opportunity for earning victory points selecting actions in this manner continues turn after turn until all of the action markers have reached the end of their tracks therefore the entire game is always exactly 20 turns long if an action marker is at the end of the track and a player wishes to perform that action again they may do so but then the track underneath it gets advanced so while a single game will always have each of the identified regional incomes the action choices are
dependent on what the players select until now i've been pretty explicit about all of the rules concerning what happens on a player's turn however to keep the explanation short i'm going to have to cut corners when explaining the departments there's a lot of them and a description of each department can be found in the rules but generally what the departments do is in line with its category human resource actions are always for players to move their employees within their company management actions are ways for players to collect resources or build new departments construction actions are the ways that players get disks onto the board and research actions are ways for players to gain access to more disks or advanced markers on their transport tracks also note that while the construction action is probably the most common way to get employees into mission areas each of the other categories of departments also has additional ways to move employees into mission areas this is very helpful when strategizing how to get enough employees on the board so that you don't miss out on income the end of the game they're going to be a lot of ways for players to score victory points they get victory points for having active employees replacing departments for pulling out their project tracks connecting cities and of course the objectives associated with their donations this is a game i really enjoy in fact earlier this week i made a video talking about how i was obsessed with this game however the purpose of this video is to be a little bit more objective and as i look at why i like this game i find that a lot of the reasons i like the game are the same
reasons why somebody else might dislike the game but i'm still going to stick with the format and talk about all of the positive things in one go and then i'll look at the other side of that coin and why the game might be something you should steer clear of first of all i've played the game about six or seven times already and i've won several times as well at this point from my experience of the game it's pretty much a given that if an opponent is in a position where they aren't prepared for a certain income or they're not prepared for a certain action you should choose that action so that they will effectively lose their turn i take that as a given and so as a result the corollary is if i'm ever in a situation where i'm not prepared then my opponents will choose that action and put me at a disadvantage so what that does for me is it means that the challenge in this game is that i must always be prepared everywhere make sure i have all my bases covered that i have a worker in every single region for taking income and that i have the resources and the staffing on my company so that i can always do something and never be caught off guard i really really like that about this game and even though it's a bit puzzly i find it really engaging the next thing i like about this game is that there's no luck in fact the only randomization happens at the beginning of the game during setup other than that there's no cards or dice to surprise you it is just players playing against each other and the whole strategy is planning and trying to anticipate what other people will do
that being said a strong player will always be a weak player that's that's just how it is in fact the first time i played i played against a strong player and i was playing online on board game arena and i was just absolutely destroyed now the thing i like about that when that happens to me in a game my attitude is normally oh my gosh wow this i get it now i understand the game i want to play again like i i was so wrecked in my first game the only thing i can think of is well let me try again let me see if i can do a better job i immediately understood the puzzle and then all i wanted to do was see if i could improve i i liked that and then lastly i really appreciate the cleanliness of these mechanics i feel like everything is there because it needs to be there and there's absolutely nothing extra sometimes i play a game where i feel like there's kind of like additional point things that are on the side and you can question whether or not they're really necessary i feel like everything in this game is just beautifully balanced it's got this elegance to it and i've really appreciated that but it's now time to talk about the reasons you might not like this so immediately for the reason i love it because of the competition factor you might feel like this is a euro game where people are constantly picking on you as soon as you let your guard up as soon as you make a mistake and you know leave somebody off the region or you don't have the resources someone's going to see that they're going to take that action and you're going to lose a turn and that can be frustrating not only that but whereas i was gushing about the puzzliness of the
challenge of always being prepared this is also a game where if you make a mistake you can really be punished for it not only that but because there's no luck involved there's also no catch-up mechanic this is not a very good game to play with anybody you definitely want to know your audience here if you've got strong players and weak players the weak players might be frustrated about learning a game that's really complicated and being absolutely destroyed by the strong players and then lastly and perhaps even most importantly this is a game that no matter how much you read the rules you will not know how to play until you have finished playing once you can you can understand exactly how everything works but you're not going to understand what's really important until you play the game and you will probably lose and then you'll go oh okay now i get it if you're not the kind of person who's engaged by possibly losing your first game and willing to try it again then just don't get this game don't even try it but if you kind of identify with what i said you know it might be for you as long as you're willing to kind of learn through trial and error that's my analysis of this game whether you'd like to purchase it or avoid it is up to you i hope you found this review useful don't forget to subscribe for more thank you so much for watching i'll see you next time bye