Aquatica: Coral Reefs Review : The Best Expansion For Aquatica?
Transcript
hello everybody Welcome Back coral reefs yeah the coral and a new expansion for quaa called all right I don't know the coral re it sounded okay to me but when you said it can't talk today hello everybody Welcome Back to board game Buzz today my name is Carly and I'm Kim and today we're actually going to be reviewing a brand new expansion for a game that I personally really like do you like Aquatica yes okay okay so we both really like the base game Aquatica this is the brand new expansion for that game and it is called coral reefs so throughout this review today obviously we're going to be talking about coral reefs but this expansion it also like it's kind of interesting because Aquatica has another expansion called the cold Waters expansion and so both of these expansion you can actually kind of mesh them together and do them both at the same time while playing Aquatica so again we have coral reefs we also have the cold Waters expansion which this expansion what this one offered was it gave you the fifth player board so you could play this game with up to five players and it also introduced the tribe module which in the base game Aquatica when you are playing the game there are like four or five goals four goals at the top of the board that you're kind of racing to accomplish but but the tribe module actually
replaces that and instead gives you cards at the top of the board that you can acquire that essentially some give you like you know little bonuses some give you different ways to like different individual goals that you're kind of going for so still goals to some extent but it kind of makes it more individualized instead of group like everybody's going for the same ones so as we're going about talking about um the coral reefs expansion today just kind of keep in mind that we also might be talking a little bit about the cold water's expansion too all right so having said all that let's go ahead and dive into the coral reefs expansion and kind of talk a little bit about what it has to offer normally when I do reviews we kind of dump jump into like an overview of how the game plays we're not going to be doing that this time so we're just going to be talking and assuming that you personally know how to play Aquatica and we'll just be chatting about what this expansion offers so this expansion offers a few different things in my opinion one of the biggest things that it offers are these that are down here at the bottom of the board essentially what the reefs are doing is you will when you are purchasing they're like character cards I that's what they're called when you're purchasing character cards you also get the reef that is directly underneath it now these reefs are cool because you can actually slot them in or onto your personal player board on top of every single place where you're actually slotting your locations and these reefs are interesting because once slotted onto a location they kind of change up how that particular location interacts with the
cards that you're slotting underneath it I Loved These you like yeah I was thinking those out of all like the things the expansions have to offer my favorite thing are the reefs gives you a little bit of direction in like which locations you might be trying to go for and then like where you place them like some of them allow you to get extra money based off of the if if you put a card yes that has money and a money ability on it it like doubles it it like doubles it or like added a one two or three bump up to this location like for every ability on your location that allows that so I liked that like it gave me like this extra goal and Direction and I would not play the game now without the like coral reefs extension I I agree I can't picture playing this game with those because without it your board it really doesn't matter where you're sting your locations really doesn't matter but with the reefs it adds just like another little puzzle that you're kind of doing is how can I further maximize my board and again it yeah gives you that direction when you're getting location you're like okay this particular slot allows me to double my money so I really need to try to get that location next so that I can get four coins so that I can purchase that really expensive card just adds another level of crunchiness to a game that I feel like was you know pretty thinky I mean not super thinky but it is a thinky game it makes it even
more crunchy well then the other thing is that fact that you get it with a character card yes and they're like paired together so I feel like it kind of most of the time I feel like the character cards are all I mean they all have decent ability so I'm like I'll just take this zero one because I don't have to pay money for it and it will enhance my deck but having the different reefs that might incentivize me a little bit more to be like actually like you know what I really need that re yeah I want that wreef so I liked that the pairing between the two something else that this expansion offers are these little coral pieces and there's a term that they use called seeding and so there's times in this game where you're able to literally grow coral on the locations that you have on your personal player board now the very first time that we played this game I played that wrong cuz first time I was playing I thought that you could only grow one coral on each location so as I was playing I was like this doesn't really make like I don't really get like it doesn't really add anything to the game I didn't really get it until I realized that no you can actually grow and Seed as many Coral as you want on a particular location and once I learned that I was like oh okay now I've got to play this again and refigure this out because that is actually really nice too cuz there's lots of abilities and characters and things that you can unlock that that allow you to seed and that is basically just racking up points for you right just keep getting more and more points and I I enjoy it because
sometimes your locations can feel a little stagnant like if you're struggling to ra like fully rise them so I like the seating thing because even if it's taking you a while to to fully rise your location you actually can just keep seating that same location right just getting it worth more and more points so it it kind of feels like a nice tradeoff location taking me a but it's going to be more points in the long yep in addition to the coral that with the seating ability one of the other ways that you can get Coral is if you purchase a card from this this row I don't know what this was called I'm just going to call secondary location secondary location roll like in the previous in the original game it just they made it like less expensive to get in this game you actually get to take the coral and you don't have to seat it just automatically get to grow it get to have it and put it into your supply um so that's one thing that I think is is just like oh yeah free free points when I get get this card this kind of touches a little bit on the cold Waters expansion but I really love the tribe module and I prefer the tribe module over the basic the basic goals that people can use um I personally would never play Aquatica without the tribes module because I like trying to get these cards and trying my best to get the certain goals that I personally need in order to maximize the locations and kind of what I'm actually going for yeah
and the coral reefs expansion adds additional additional tribes tribes like one of the ones that I had when I played it was get an additional point for every Coral that you have and that's not going to be in the cold Waters expansion something that I really did want to mention is I always felt like in the base game Aquatica the characters that you could purchase were pretty limited there were only like a handful and there was a lot of like duplicates of the same card so it didn't really feel too interesting to me yes there were cards that were helpful but it didn't really feel interesting to me I guess you could say and that's kind of a big part of the game is getting characters so I love especially if you have both of the expansions the coral reefs and the cold Waters I love the variety that ends up kind of coming out from this character deck there are a lot a lot more characters and it just helps me making purchasing cards more interesting and it makes it less likely to get the ones that you really need so when the ones that you really need come out you're kind of like fighting over those those kind of better cards in my opinion well then I also think that it just adds more replayability too in the sense of like it's not going to be the same pool every game there are Parts about this game that I don't I feel I wish they would tweak a little bit which we'll talk in a second but something that I loved in regards to components were the setup for the reefs because when you set up the reefs or when you're setting up this game you use all the pink ones Y and then based on how many players you're playing with you just grab those like a
different number of corals or the different color of corals so like if me and Kim were playing I think if it's just two players you just use the P you just use the pink yep and then you'll pull out like all one for like the endgame pool so like once all the coral is gone that could be an end game trigger and then that way then you put the other t to the side and then you can still get it it made it so nice I wish there's so many games like the one that keeps coming to mind is like Cascadia I hate when I pull out Cascadia and I have to sit and count out like 40 tiles I wish the backside were just all colored and so it's like if you're playing with two players pick two colors that's how I see how I feel about um Aqua about Aqua okay yeah I really I really liked that a lot yes one other thing that I also liked about the expans and Cari said that she probably wouldn't ever play it without the tribe module but I you like the goals I do well I like both like I like I also like the goals especially like if I'm playing solo which I did play at solo I don't I'm going to want the goals if I'm playing at solo I agree with that and I appreciate it I feel like I said solo weird but solo I don't okay sorry I also so I appreciated that like the the the I appreciated that Aquatica coral reefs like I can't speak right now I'm rubbing off on you yeah Aquatica coral reefs also added additional like new goals and
those goals that it adds to the game also incorporate like the the the corals and the reef so it's not just so that way I can still play with the reef expansion because I want I like the reefs and that one I wouldn't play with without it without it but I like the goals especially in terms of like I liked like kind of the I like the racing aspect of okay like I want this one first or can I do this guess it is nice to have the variety that you can choose so yeah so that I really appreciate it that like I feel like the expansions make this game really like you can just really like adds to the replayability because you can really change up the way that you play the game I even telling Carly I'm like you could play with all of them like you could do goals and have the tribes and have this because you probably could because the uh the cold Waters comes with them mat mat yeah so you could just put that right under or Flip Flip this board over cuz it's double-sided that was something I wanted to quickly mention is the cold water or sorry the coral reefs expansion adds this board which is double-sided one side playing with the tribe module the other side playing with the goals so you technically I technically could throw away my the mat that comes in the base game I loved this mat I loved how it came with the game and it was double-sided makes yeah just choose what side what you want to play with yeah back to your point where you could you could switch out you could just really like um yeah just kind of really make it
make make it to like what your style and like what you enjoy playing with the game and and then adding on to that and I I'm like woo all these exciting things adding on to that it also has new King cards but then there's also the the man yeah so the keing cards kind of help determine turn order in the game the Manas do essentially the same thing you basic everybody gets an extra manay um and on the back of the manay it shows you the turn order so yeah you could either play with the King card still or you could do the manay in regards to turn order it's just it's it's fun I like I like yeah I like this element of like oh I can play this way or this way and then you can also like cater it to the crowd like the kind of people that you're you're playing with definitely okay so clearly we've talked a lot about this expansion I think we both really enjoy this expansion there were a couple things that I kind of had a little bit of nitpicks on or stuff that I kind of wanted to touch on first that I want to mention is I think if you get this yes you could play the base game and I think it'd be fine I do think you would miss out on the cards from the other expansion though I don't want to go go as far as to say I think you need the both of the expansions but I think if you got this I don't know I I I I kind of feel like you need both expansions a little bit because I I again this introduces the reefs and the coral which you definitely could just play with that but
I think you would miss out on a lot of the tribe cards and also a lot of the character cards so I would kind I kind of think I would personally recommend getting both of the expansions for this game in order to kind of really feel like you have everything I would agree with that especially like with what I was saying and things that I liked of like really being able to like mix the game the way that you want you could do that a little bit like how many how many I was just going to try module cards yeah so the tribe cards it comes with so it comes with eight so you could play but you would only be able to play with those cards you wouldn't be able to switch out the cards and that's what I really liked I liked having the different tribe cards so every time you're playing with the tribe module you're doing something different if you just had the eight cards here it would there'd be no difference game to game you know what I mean so I think I would personally recommend getting both expansions yeah I would recommend both expansions too that being said I do if you were just going to pick one I would pick this one I I agree with that too I think if you were just to pick one do this one but just be aware that there's not going to be a lot of variety specifically with the tribes yeah another little nitpick I had was I really like how you can switch everything out in this game I do think especially like if you're a new gamer and not kind of like established kind of having to go through SE three separate Rule books oh my goodness yes and trying
to figure out like especially like when you're mid game and you have a question trying to find the answer I mean it gets a little messy if you're an established gamer you can work through it we work through it but if you are a new gamer that's something that you just need to be aware of is it's I wish there would have just been like a one rule book that they would have come out with and made it a little bit easier to okay do this if you're playing with one expansion do this if you're playing with both both expansions do this if you're playing with just base game I mean it it was a little messy sometimes like not knowing what some of the iconography it was and some of the cars that showed up and then I couldn't I didn't couldn't know I don't remember I'm like is this part of this expansion or is it part of this expansion so flipping through there should have been a sheet that had all the iconography for all the expansions in one spot and well like Kurt and I when I played it with my friend Kurt the the magnifying glass one too like I remembered what this one did because we when I played it with Carly we spent forever trying to find it but the the magnifying glass never showed up I'm like wait what does this one mean and yeah I had no idea which like how to find it and I finally found it I was like like oh okay but it took way longer than it should have yeah well and I almost wish um I know I wasn't like the biggest fan of the art project but I loved if you're familiar with that game I loved how the rule book you open it up and there were tabs on the side so I almost wish they would have done something like this and had tabs for base game tabs for cold water tabs for
you know like it it just would have made it a lot easier to go through to have that level of organization so this kind of comes back to a little issue I have with the base game Aquatica that I wish they would have fixed well there's two things so the first things I've always struggled with the manies let's talk about color first the colors on all of them are great except the purple the purple is so hard to see it is such a pain and I wish I'm sorry I'm like getting like all riled up I just wish that something that I wish that they just would have come out with especially with this expansion all just new replacements for the pur because it just it's it's it's it really is hard to see even when they're like right in front of you I'm just like it's hard yeah so I wish they would have changed that but something else and I know this is probably just a me thing like I get over it when I play it like it's fine when a manay it it's always driven me crazy how when a when a manay is ready it's like on its belly facing up when it's oh no sorry it's opposite when it's it's ready it's on its back but when it's exhausted then it's on its like belly like it always messes me up cuz when I think about like an animal if it's on its back then it should be exhausted like it should be it should be done but then when it's face up then that means it's ready right so for whatever reason that's always messed with me so I wish they would have just
come out with all new like replacements for the manta rays having the color altered and then changing the direction of the I know that's like a silly thing but that's something that I've always that's always bothered me about Aquatica should be exhausted like on their back so because it's the opposite it always throws me off but the color is more important the color definitely needs to be Chang that was like my first complaint in the game I think it would be nice if at some point they came out with like a a big deluxe version that just included all three yeah um so you could just get it all together and have one box because man I pulled it out multiple times and each time it was just like it's just such like a it's such a chore like like I want to play it with the re expansion but sometimes I'm like I don't want to have to like dig through everything well the thing is it can fit in the base box but you have to take out the insert and then it's kind of like a mess it's kind of a mess to get it all in there no one wants a mess yeah nobody wants a mess I mean obviously you could probably go and buy a custom insert at some point I'm sure somebody would have that but yeah like I and and especially when you also think about like price point like getting a base game along with two expansions like it would be nice if it was just all put together at like a slightly discounted price just to get all just get everything just to have it all in one box yeah let's go ahead and kind of dive into kind of our ratings for this expansion now I I do want to make something clear it's always
hard for me to rate expansions because inevitably how much I like the base game kind kind of factors in if I like the expansion and sometimes expansions are like yeah it's good but you don't need it or it is good and you do need it or it's not good at all don't even bother so it's like it's it's hard to kind of put that into a reading having said that I'm going to be giving this um an 8.5 out of 10 I do think that if you like the Bas came Aquatica this does nothing but add more good things it makes it more crunchy more thinky I don't if you hated the B Aquatica I don't think this is going to change your mind but if you think base game Aquatica wasn't quite crunchy enough didn't quite hit maybe you liked it but it didn't quite hit I would recommend you trying this because I do think that especially I just keep coming back to the reefs I really like how the reefs change your individual player board and especially when you're able to yeah combo them with the tribes module and all the new cards new characters that it brings I think it does nothing but enhance the base game so if you felt like the base game was missing a little touch I would absolutely recommend this along with the cold Waters expansion I personally think both is really kind of hits that sweet spot but if you were to choose one I would pick this one over the cold water's expand or yeah over the cold water's expansion I agree and I actually super agree because I'm also coming in at an a oh my goodness yep feel like it's been a while since since we've been
at the same spot on um because yeah like like I said I would not play the game without the The Reef expansion at this point I'm like it just like there's no point like if you have it of course I'm G to add the reef expansion like I'm going to play it with the reef expansion every time because I really like yeah just being able to place those reefs and what they add to the game and the direction that they give me in placing my location cards and how they can get me more points or the corals and plus like the corals are fun and I like that they um you can rack them up and get points but they're also just like the game itself doesn't have too much theme but the corals like give it give it a little bit more of like a tactile like theme and so they just it's just fun like it adds to the like the the presence of the game as well I feel like all right so this very rarely happens where we're exactly spot on but we're going to be giving the um oh my goodness I'm getting mixed up the coral reefs expansion to Aquatica an 8.5 I do happen to know that this game is going to be available at Gen Con I know for sure to demo I think to purchase as well so if you are heading to Gen Con make sure you check this out check out the Arcane wonders Booth because yeah I I again this is nothing but good things for the game in our opinion so yes if you like Aquatica definitely make sure to check this one out I wanted to give a huge thank you to Arcane wonders for helping send us kind of this early copy of the
game to review for you today and if you enjoy Aquatica please let us know kind of your comments in regards to to this expansion and if you think that yeah it's one that you personally would like and what kind of stood out to you during this video we hope you enjoyed this video today if you enjoyed this video and you haven't yet subscribed to the channel it means so much if you could do that really help support us in everything that we're doing over here push that like button push that like button push subscribe but until next time I hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you later sorry no you're good I feel like these need to be here oh there you go perfect Janet says that either once the whole pool of the P like the pink the pool of not the pool of the reefs or the cor I keep looking at my diet coke then no no but in my mind the microphone is my Dio and I was like you wanting to pick it up you want your no it's I'll wait till we're done here let me get you your done are you refreshed now yeah