Bebop Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
At number five, I have Bbop. So, Bbop was a game that I was quietly excited about because the designer of it openly said that he was directly inspired by the Rhina Canonitia root building style games that I am very fond of. You know, think of games like, you know, Rebirth, Samurai, Through the Desert, Blue Lagoon. All those games just hit that sweet spot for me and are the style of game that I really enjoy. So, I was excited to see a new designer's take on it to see what they could add to the to the mix and to the recipe really. So, the difference between this one and those other games I've mentioned is that this one does not use tokens to spread your influence on the map. It you actually use dice. So, there is a random element where you're drawing dice from a bag. You're rolling them and they're going to be the pool you can draft from or of course you can just do a lucky dip. But you are going to have a I think a display of three in front of you that you can play with at any time. Kind of like your hand, but instead of a hand of cards or a hand of tokens, they are a hand of dice. Now, what you're trying to do here, and the theme is a little bit jarring. I'm not sure if it works too well, is that you are trying to get these matching instruments um surrounding these matching stages. So, the the idea is that we're at this jazz festival. Um let's say there's a band with a with a drum and a keyboard. You want to try and get your drum and keyboard people close to that stage or at least chaining from that stage to get I points in one of three different ways I believe. So the first way you can get
points is that you can kind of compound the same logos together. So again think of something like um Havalandi or rebirth where once you put one token down it's worth nothing. You put the second one down it's worth two. Next one's worth three. Uh, so it builds up and compounds on itself and Kit's used this mechanism several times in the affforementioned games and also games like Millie Fury. So I tend to really like that because you know you do you want to go for the quick grab or do you want to go for these slower strategies? So the slower strategies are mainly due to creating clusters of the same instruments of of certain colors. So, for example, you want to have the um the biggest or the the most of your pieces within the biggest blue cluster. And if you do, you're going to get some bonus points um at the end of the game. But the the third way you can get points is to completely surround the stages where the um the tokens on those stages will go to the player with the most pieces touching it. So, much like Samurai or Babylonia. So again, you can certainly see how directly this game is inspired by those other Kitian uh classics. Now, a bit of a nitpick. The game I think looks a little bit too busy for me. You know, there's dice everywhere. Um some zones are in play, some are not in play based on the player count, which is fine, but it would have been nice to have a bit more of a hard line drawn um on the board. And it's just a little bit
daunting and overwhelming when you look and scan at the board with all these iconographies and dice of different colors and also markers of different players pieces. Also, as you'd expect with a dice driven game, luck is a huge factor in this one. And unfortunately, I think it played a bit too much of a part in who does well or not. Um, there are mitigation tools where when you claim a seat, then you can roll one of your dice in your pool, which is fine, but often you don't get what you want. Anyway, so that was a little bit frustrating. And you know, for me, although Kitia does play with some random elements, he normally makes the pool of resources you have balanced so that everyone has the same amount or roughly the same amount. At this one, you could just get shafted based on the the roll of the dice.
Now, my biggest issue with this game is that the game actually adds one phase too many for me. And I understand this is a difficult thing to overcome because of the game. So know, as I mentioned with those most classic Canian games, you just take a token from your pool and you place it on the board and you move on to the next player. This one you do not do that because of course the dice roll neutral. You have to have some way of showing that the dice are are yours. And in order to do that, you basically take one of your little cardboard cutouts and you reserve your place on the board before you place uh the dice in it. And although that sounds like a very minor step, um when you think about it kind of mathematically, it actually just doubles the overhead on the fussiness of the game because instead of doing one thing um in the game, you're doing two things which kind of completely kind of throws the flow of the game off because generally speaking, once you've reserved your spot, it's yours anyway. Yes, you can hold off on what dice you're going to put in there.
Um but kind of that decision is not there anymore. It's reserved. safe and you don't have to worry about it. And it just adds a little bit one step too many in a two-step game, which is kind of saying something really. Um, so I would have liked to have seen maybe each player have a their own personal pool of colored dice and play around with the cutters that way instead of having an extra step to reserve where the dice will go. And for me, it completely kind of drew the or cut the legs off from under the game. Um, I found it a little bit laborious, a bit tedious. And there's kind of under no circumstance would I rather play this one uh over any of those other games I mentioned. Again, if you like the look of this one, try The Canitians, try Babylonia, try Through the Desert, you know, try Rebirth, Havalandi, Samurai. This game doesn't do anything better than all of those games do on their own. So, yes, sadly, it was a bit of a dud for me. I mean, in its own right, in a vacuum, it's fine, but again, a little bit too fussy and a little bit too busy for my liking. So, sadly, a bit disappointing for me. That is Bbop at number