You don't need rules to play D&D
Transcript
Here's my Viking.
Hey everybody, this is me, Lance Meister, yourster Viking. I am back with another video here. Um, remember last year when I said I was going to try to do a video a week and then I did it for a long time and then I fell off. Well, I'm going to try to do that again this year. Um, to the tens of you out there that watch this stuff, I appreciate that very much. Obviously, this is a lot more for me just to talk about stuff that I like. Um, but if there's something you ever want me to cover or talk about or whatever that's in the gaming world or in life or whatever, you can always uh reach out to me undeviking videos@gmail.com. Uh, I know it's probably p to give that out, but if you click on the YouTube information, you can find my email anyway. So, what regardless, email me, give me a suggestion or leave it in the comments. Comments work even better. So, uh, and I do read every single comment. So, if you have something to say and you want to leave that, I will respond to it. Um, unless you're being a jerk, which then I'll just say you're being a jerk and then I'll, uh, that I guess that's a response. But anyway, so the premise of this video is to talk about rules and DND rules. Uh, and I'm going to want to make this kind of a quick video. Yeah, I don't want it to be super long. Uh my buddy Joel, who I've been playing D and D with now for 30 some years, um once said, uh the rules don't even matter.
Who cares? Who cares about the rules? Uh and he didn't mean that like, oh, like it doesn't matter what we do, what we say, whatever. We're just going to still play the game and it's just going to have an outcome. Um, that's an idea I've often had where this there is this implied redaction of reality. Like, uh, I I I've talked about this in the past, but I've had actual players say, um, we should just go ahead and like charge the castle and attack it front on because Lance isn't going to kill us anyway. uh you know and I remember hearing that and thinking oh my gosh you know uh the the removal of of the reality of the situation like the the tension is gone what what what's happened right and and then sometimes games like that exist right where you're just not fully on board with the idea of you know we're we know the players are going to win but we just want to you know go through the motions and have the story and that's fine too I mean if you get if that's the way you play and that's the way you like um you know then then then fine but I've always appreciated the fact if there's actual tension uh what's going on maybe that's one of the reasons why Ka Cthulhu seems to work so well because Kathulu lends itself to one shots and when you run a one shot with Ka Cthulhu you tend to um the stakes are are much greater because if your characters die no big deal
and I realize I'm getting off point here oddly I don't enjoy oneshot D&D games. I find those to be um because the narrative isn't there. And in like Call of Cthulhu since you you're you know if you get into combat in Kthulu, you've done something wrong, right? Um the investigation is supposed to lead you to the idea that you are able to solve the problem without putting yourself at risk. Whereas, you know, in D and D, the conflict resolution is almost always swinging axe at something. I mean, that's just the way it is. And what happens when you have those situations is people don't have like this belief that they uh the self-preservation, I guess, isn't there. At least that's been the way I've experienced it. Anyway, backtracking. Rules. Rules don't matter.
Uh what Joel was getting at when he said that and after I asked him a few questions he kind of explained is that the core of Dn D exists and and it it's just there. Um we have six stats. We have a saving throw or saving throws depending on the system. Uh and we have our abilities. Fighters are going to swing a sword. Thieves are going to backstab. Mages are going to blast things with spells. clerics are going to turn undead and heal people. And I know that's very simplified. Uh and I and and I did the simplification on purpose. I mean, um but for the most part, that's what happens. Right now, if you have a different rule system, you can absolutely like play with that a little bit. Um, you know, D and D has obviously uh gone through multiple uh editions and and and you know, everybody seems to be wondering what the next edition of DN D is going to be, if there is going to be like a a D and D 6th or whatever. Uh, but and everybody has things that they loved about this edition, loved about that edition, or or their favorite version. And obviously there are a ton of rule books out there for D and D clones of some sort and a lot of them are OSR clones, right? I mean, so and and this is why I'm bringing this up is like I got this book, fabulous book
by the way. Uh I backed this on Kickstarter and um I actually backed at the at the like top level. So, I got the really nice quality book, you know, that that said, you know, the real stitching instead of a a print on demand thing. Um, which, you know, I was I was I'm very happy to own this. But ultimately, what is this? This is this is old school DND. This is based on uh the old white box rules, which um well, I have my box of white box rules back there. You can't see it right now, but you know, hermetically sealed, you know, but um you know, and ultimately what this is, it is it is a it is a onebook set of rules. It is old school to a fault. You die at zero hit points. You uh you know, very very every every every weapon does 1d6 plus some modifiers, you know, I mean, it is a very stripped down rule set. I don't think I'd ever play with this kind of a completely stripped down rule set.
But I like owning books like this because I like reading them and I like being able to steal things out of this book or other books as well. So we can then implement them in this edn, the players guide. Um this is um and as you can see right there, it is the 2025 edition. Um we've uh myself, Craig, and Jason uh the co-authors of that. That is the that is the version of D and D that we've been playing since we were are in high school and it has had uh multiple revisions, dozens of revisions as time has gone by. So, we don't even really play D and D anymore. We play our own version of D and D. And I think a lot of players and I think most people play their own version of Dn D. And by that I mean they don't have a a thing that they've written out and typed out and and keep on file to play.
But what they do have is their own house rules and addendums and changes that they've made and which is what how Dn D was supposed to be played in the beginning. Can I brief segue? I am so tired. I am so tired of seeing yet another person's YouTube take on rules not rulings, you know, or rulings not rules or whatever. I'm getting it backwards. Or or what did what did Gary Gyax think about, you know, changing the rules in in in the game? And and the thing is is that I guess it's it's a retread of the same stuff over and over again. um ultimately uh and and it exists to this day, right? I mean like and then which is why I think addition wars complaints are are absolutely ridiculous. You know, you're like, "Oh, I hate 5e because of whatever." Um and I'm not talking about somebody being all like, "It's so woke or anything," which I think is uh Make it more woke. Make it so woke. whatever woke is, make it so woke that uh all of the OSR uh grogards just like spin themselves into the sky with with with with anger over how woke it is. I I I hope the next edition of Dn D is rainbow bright, you know, people riding multicolored ponies uh all talking about happiness and and forgiveness and and
saying why your seventh level wizard bard barbarian. It's fine if they are a pink teddy bear uh that has a balloon crown uh that that that squirts out uh sleep potions. You know, I I I hope I hope that is that is an actual thing. I and I and I and I would just nothing would make me more happy than all of these old old and I mean I don't want to go on a rant. all these old white cranky dudes just their head just explodes over over how uh they hate hate it and how Watsi and Hasbro are just the wokest of the wokiest wokest uh garbage. Anyway, anyh who my whole point in all of this is that everybody plays with their own rules and everybody adopts the game to play by their own rules. Right now, you would if you play D and D, you would never have to buy another rulebook for the rest of your life. You you could you could sit down and and you could play D and D without a rule book. You could just all you need is a set of dice and a piece of paper. I mean, obviously having a rule book and having some sort of guideline, having some sort of structure there to monkey with is is ne is necessary or it isn't necessary, but it it helps. It helps a great deal. But for the most part, it doesn't. And it doesn't have to be in place, right? You don't have to have uh you know 700 splat
books to play uh second edition D and D. But by God, we all had them. Uh because we loved them. We loved reading all the cool stuff. Why? Why did I mean I think I had a I remember one of my absolute all-time favorite characters in second edition Dn D was uh uh a a ooze lord cleric or whatever. I I just I I freaking loved the fact that like he worship oozes and it was like that was something that was in one of the uh uh splat books. Maybe that was a 3.0 thing or a 3.5 thing. But yeah, that was like one of my cuz it was just absolute ridiculousness. But anyway, I'm backing up and this is going way longer than I wanted to is that rules don't matter. They just freaking don't. And and all you need is what are my chances to hit?
How much damage does my sword do? And what are my stats? That's what you need. I mean, obviously you need spells and stuff like that, but you get on my point is you you need a list of spells. You need a list of uh uh you and you but really you need you need an armor class, you need hit points, you need stats. That's all you need for your character. That's all you need. And then and then depending upon the class they take. Are you the cleric? Here's your healing. Here here's your spell list. Are you a thief? Here's your here's your skills to to find traps and pick logs. Are you a fighter? Well, you took the easy route, but here's your sword. Roll higher than a 17 and you'll hit most of anything and you get to do 1d8 plus four damage because of your strength. Go for it. You know that that's all you need. And the rest is just details. The rest is making the game taking that piece of clay and turning it into what you want to turn it into. And I think we forget about that.
And I mean, and and do I need to buy another rule system? No, I don't. But I did. Why did I buy this? Well, one, uh, it was published by Gallant Night Games. And the guy who owns Galla Knight Games is a good friend of mine. Uh, and, you know, I I, you know, I think very highly of the stuff that he makes. And when I saw that he had a crowdfunding campaign, I I I backed it because I wanted to support him. But also, I like having books. I like being able to read them. I like having those things. I mean, I have too many RPG books as it is. I mean, like, I have bookshelves of RPG books over there. I have a closet full of RPG books over there. all of those cupboards behind me full of RPG books, you know. Um, need to get rid of them. Anyway, but my whole point is that it is uh it is it is the whole situation there is that uh they aren't needed. They aren't needed at all. You don't need to buy a single D and D book ever. Um, but you know, you uh you you that on that was great. Apparently, I had a question. Uh, regardless any of those things, you you just need to have fun.
And And if you're going to argue about the rules, I mean, you know, frankly, get the out of here. You know, who cares? I've I have become that that with with when I've when I've been running my games lately and I've been I'm running a fabulous D and D campaign right now. I I I just look forward to every session. Uh but I've definitely just gotten to the point of like I am I am I am harsh but fair with the players, but also when my players come up with an idea that I know will make just make them happy if it works, I just make sure it works because I want them to be happy and I want them to have a good time. You know, I got I got I got a I got a I got two guys in my group that they're they're forming a village right now. They're they're starting a village and they're like, "We got to set up a bank. They've had this for like three campaigns. They've had this idea of starting a bank and I'm just going to let them do it.
I mean, it's going to get robbed. Absolutely. I'm going It's somebody's going to tunnel into their vault and steal everything that they have, which is going to be amazing. but I'm going to let them have their bank and I'm going to let them enjoy it. Uh, so just do that. Don't care about the rules. Give the players what they want, but make it difficult for them to get what they want or at least make it seem like it's difficult. Anyway, that's that. Got any questions? Got any comments? Leave them below. Tell me what your favorite Hey, if you made it this far, tell me what your favorite rule is from a rules set. I would love to hear that.
I would love to hear that. Like one of my favorite things in this is that it just has a single saving throw. Each each class has a single saving throw. That's it. It's like, and if you and if you meet or exceed that when you roll on a d20, you you succeed. And and it doesn't matter what it is. It doesn't matter if it's uh a fireball or poison or a finger of death spell. You you you you roll. And there's modifiers, right? I mean, you you your your stats will give you modifiers to that roll, but that's just the number you got to hit. I love that. I love how simple that is. I'm absolutely going to steal that and I'm going to put it in ED and D when we do our rewrite this year. Anyway, uh let me know what you think. Tell me what you think. Sorry about the clutter behind me. I'm I'm I'm I'm cleaning out that closet right now with all the RPG stuff in it. Trying to get it all situated. Um, so, uh, until next time, I'm the Undead Viking. Uh, have a good time gaming, whatever it is that you game with.