Nature Preview and Evolution Mini-Review
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I'm going to preview the new 2025 Kickstarter nature which is a reimplementation of the old 2014 game Evolution so it's by the same designers as you can see here Evolution itself is a 7.1 out of 10 onboard Game Geek so not too bad of a game overall ranked 654 and just a few caveat before we get into the episod epode so nature the game is available for demo and it's in beta right now for mobile devices for iOS or Android what have you and so I was able to De demo a few games of it on nature and you are too if you want to try this demo version of nature which does not include a lot of the cards or modules that are slated to become available I'll include a link to it uh in the description below and you can also follow them uh Northstar games uh at their Discord Channel where I found the link to try it uh in beta on my phone but evolution is available to play on board game arena as well so you can play the original game there for free and I have as well I've I've tried out Evolution I'm currently playing it right now to have this perspective and the differences between these two games so let's start with nature first nature is obviously a reimplementation of evolution which simulates an ecosystem of animals that you are trying to build up in the style of a card
competitive card game now to highlight some of the mechanisms that are key to both games and I'll show some footage here of gam play first let's talk about the cards so this game features multi-use cards that can either be used to build up your individual species with different traits that allow it to do many things such as evade Predators or to gain more food when you go to the water hole or pray upon other opponents more on that later and so a lot of these traits are individualized these cards are individualized and there are many different types in the deck that you draw from especially taking into account all the modules that you get with nature as well as all the content available for evolution but these cards are not simply just trait cards you can also draw you so you draw a certain hand limit of them per round and you can discard a card to increase your species size which allows it to be less vulnerable to attack from other players you can increase its population size which allows you to eat more food when it's your turn to do so or you can discard the card in nature at the beginning of the round it's often dealt uh with from a random card from on top of the deck but you see the watering hole which tells you how much food is available in the certain round and so a lot of these cards have different ways to make decisions tough on your turn where to to allocate your resources as it were in
the form of these cards next the building up of your species so I mentioned that you do use these cards to make sure your species are either really big or have they have a lot of population so they can eat a lot and gain a lot of these food tokens which are points at the end of the game and you develop them out with traits as well the the integration and and interaction that you have with your species in in nature you start with one species and you per round gain an extra species as you go along and so as the game starts pretty basic you know you have one species versus all of the other opponent species but then that slowly starts to ramp up and you're you have to manage all of these species that you have making sacrifices as you go allocating those those cards from your hand as resources to support certain species in a certain way and to potentially sacrifice them in in another way as well and so so uh you do this over four rounds as well and it leads to a lot of tough decisions as well not only to you know how to use your multi-use cards but where to allocate them uh per the different species that you have in front of you then finally the Thematic integration so this has to do with the interaction that is uh seen in this game uh the way that you can interact directly with your opponents is by making some of your species or all of them predators and in this game there is a separate deck of Predator cards that you can assign to your uh species for free uh this is a
difference that we will talk about later with Evolution but if you do so then you must attack another character or another species to be able to feed that that population now that can be your opponents or you can if if you have to attack your own species that are of less body size and reap those benefits there and so there I I feel like this is a great point of thematic integration where it really does simulate this scarcity that is found in nature where sometimes in order to survive there must be some fighting within a population for the fittest to survive and so uh whether your species are herbivores trying to communally you know uh grab the resources from The Watering Hole or if they're attacking each other to survive that is kind of the basis of this game and I think is part of the reason why this was created was to be an educational tool as well uh for uh how ecosystems work and how animals work so now let's get into some game comparisons I will make more comparisons to Evolution a little bit later so let's go into some of the other games that I thought of which were some trading card games like lorana and Magic now obviously this nature game is not a trading card game it's not a collectible card game uh I mean you can collect all the modules I suppose but it plays in a somewhat similar way utilizing a few different mechanisms but some of the them are the same like in lurana you have to choose which cards you want to
utilize as lore or pardon as ink to be able to play other cards from your hand so deciding which cards to use in that way which cards to play face up instead is a big point of decision that you make in that game and a nature that multi-use decision space is also present in Magic as well where there is direct interaction trying to compare the sizes the attack power as it were in magic versus the you know body size and population of of the cards in nature you're making these comparisons consistently across the board with your opponents and in some cases with your with your own species making sure that you have enough power or science comparison to be able to do what you want to do and so there's a lot of back and forth a lot of ramping up from here there that I found had similar Vibes among the trading card games that I played in the past especially these to uh when comparing to Nature some other games that players have uh mentioned that felt you know that they compared pretty well to evolution in particular which I think would would directly compare to Nature as well games that I haven't played I haven't played munchkin in a long time but a lot of people mention the interaction felt similar in that game as compared to Evolution and nature the kind of random card draw and and you know multi card card use uh situation that you have is very reminiscent to other players with glory to Rome and
dominant species is another game where there is a lot of you know thematic comparisons that you can make building up your own species and making sure that they have enough food and and power and and presence to be able to dominate over others I have not played that game it's obviously a as you can see a GMT game which are typically more heavy in nature and so it I've heard it's a really long game mechanically very different very complex compared to Nature and so aside from theme and perhaps a few basic mechanisms there there are some big differences there but uh for folks who do want a similar theme of animals fighting to survive in a more in a heavier situation might be more drawn to dominant species so for the peer review obviously since Evolution or nature will be kickstarted later on this year for a 2025 release there aren't a lot of comments on it yet and so going back to Evolution just to look at the comments there over the past 10 years to see what people had to say about this game they said that in Praise in particular that this game features a lot of dynamic hardplay you know there are a lot of different cards that you can play with not only in the base game but considering all of the expansions that have been put together there's a lot of different things that that you can do it UPS the complexity a little bit from the base game as well as you might imagine and so there's a lot of different things and the game can feel very different from game to game because there's also
an element of Mastery where once you understand the basic rules of the game and perhaps understand what the different modules are adding to the game as well you start to get better at predicting uh what is the best strategy with the cards that you're given but also what other players are trying to do as well one thing that I didn't mention in the mechanisms or the game highlight portion of this video is that when you do play cards out you do play them face down if they are traits and so everyone reveals those simultaneously you get to know how many traits other people have played but you don't necessarily get to know what they are until everyone has revealed at the same time and so there's a little bit of a guessing game going on from round to round what other players are trying to do you can see how big they are making their species both in population and size but you don't get to see what they might do that's a little bit more unique based off of the trade cards and so there is an element of Mastery to predict what other opponents are doing as well as to adapt to what is given to you in this game through the the draw the card draw it's relatively easy to learn uh I would say playing the tutorial on uh on the app for nature was pretty straightforward and I was able to learn it in about 5 minutes or so and with a game or two it became a lot more clear on how to play it which was pretty nice and so it's a game that can be widely distributed among uh players whether they're hobbyist Gamers or not I think that some people mentioned that it was easy to to teach
children or teenagers this game to potentially get into the classroom for example and and teach Evolution or the you know how ecosystems work in a in a different way and obviously this game is well supported with plenty of expansions in the 10 years that it's been available there are some concerns though a lot of people as the you know the opposite side of the element of Mastery there is is the fact that if you do play a game as a new player and you're playing with those folks who have played the game a lot understand the cards understand the rules very well and know how to predict the game as it progresses it becomes very punishing for new players to play I experienced this as well when I you know di my toe into magic or you know last year is when I learned how to play Magic and you know I'm sitting there at a table with uh folks who have been playing for many years and decades who understand all the cards that have have come out and what's in their deck and I'm trying to learn the cards as they come out and so it's the the basic rules are easy to to learn but sometimes especially I feel like with the added modules and and expansions with Evolution it might up the complexity enough where if you if you are playing with a lot of those modules it can be kind of confusing for a new player and it's not only confusing but they are at a disadvantage because of the take that element that some of these cards do have some of the trait cards really benefit you from you know being a carnivore and going after another player and it's very similar to the situation that you have with Through the Ages where if your
military strength isn't as high as everyone else's everyone can pray on you when you know certain political cards and Wars come out and they will take advantage of your weakness and take your resources and it becomes a very hard game to come back from when you are behind in points and so it's it's really punishing for new players who don't understand the game to be able to be competitive with those who have mastered the game but there's also the element of the luck of the draw even if you understand the game perfectly sometimes the cards don't align and some of the card the traits that you need to be able to play you know the species correctly that you want to you know pursue if you've already committed to a certain strategy and you don't you know acquire the same pieces that you need to continue to perform well it becomes a difficult you know case to come back from as well and so those are some concerns that a lot of people have made when playing Evolution so let's go into some comparisons now some quick mechanical comparisons between nature and evolution obviously the the game play itself is very much the same uh the way that you play cards from your hand the species you know the building up of your species the interactions and and so forth are very similar I would say that the biggest differences to me when compar comparing these and obviously those you know folks who have played this game a lot more would probably understand some more differences too perhaps in the balances of certain cards and whatnot but one this game is considerably shorter than
evolution in evolution you play until the deck is gone and then you get you know a round extra or what have you and so as you might have seen at the beginning of the video the play time for evolution is longer than nature because nature is limited to four rounds and so you can play this game in kind of kind of like the a basic trading card game length right you you can pull out a game and and play it in about 15 to 20 minutes or so and it's easy to reshuffle and and redrawn and play again and then second the way that Predators or the way that you switch your species into Predators because they are naturally plant you know herbivores and they eat the plants from The Watering Hole instead uh without any uh traits or anything like that but you would have to draw into those carnivore traits in evolution to tr to make them into a predator to be able to interact with the other uh players on the board in nature these cards are essentially free these traits you can assign if you have a spot for it on your species you can assign them the Predator trait as you know many times as you can across your board right if you want to make everyone a predator then then you can essentially you don't have to sacrifice a card from your hand to do so and so there are probably some other comparisons here that you can make as well um but in some to kind of reflect on my experiences with both games yes I do see the point of view where other people who have played Evolution can see that this game is very
competitive very take that in nature there is an element of targeting the weakest player if you want to play correctly or play um by you know maximizing your efficiency you want to Target the species that are you know of less body size than you Etc and and so you that situation might lead you to attack the new player more often it doesn't have to happen that way and I think nature itself with the mechanism of being able to make any of your cards as Predators is one way that it may level the playing field a little bit more I have seen comments for evolution that the carnivore strategy is a little less um viable than the plant strategy and vice versa so I don't know what the right strategy is for evolution and that obviously is dependent on what modules and expansion you have but I think that there is that element of of negative interaction of that take that mechanism that is seen in this game and so that might turn some people off and I don't particularly uh go for that type of experience very often but I can see the Thematic integration and why it makes sense that you know it happens in nature where animals attack other animals and you have to pre upon the animal that is weakest to to survive the resource resources are really scarce in this game you don't get a lot of cards especially at first to be able to do what you want to do optimally and you have to you know sometimes attack your own species to
survive as well and maximize the amount of points that you have but often times you're targeting other other players and and that's just kind of how it happens in nature and so I I do appreciate the realism that is trying to be portrayed in this game whereas mechanically it might be a turnoff for some I do enjoy the variety of the cards that are offered obviously the demo version of nature uh as an app as a free app is is limited and so I'd love to see what other kinds of cards are available and I think playing the base game of evolution might be a Peak at what is to come uh there were a lot of comments that the the powers of the cards were pretty basic in nature you were on the most part just altering how much uh of a attack that you might be able to make as a Predator versus how much you're able to evade a predator as well and so it's kind of a back and forth uh type of deal as your playing traits onto your species and for some that was not as uh intriguing or enticing for multiple rounds of play which is once again probably solved by additional expansions and modules you know with the way that you play the game and I think that is what nature is set up to be with I think 30 plus modules that are slated to be released with the kickstarter and so I think a culmination of a lot of those different uh ways to play the game that were successful and made it a little bit more variable and a little bit more complex and and thinky is going to be
included in the kickstarter and so more information on that when it does launch I'm not sure when it does but I'm I'm hopeful that it does provide that experience that variable experience that a lot of people enjoy and I think if you are if you do enjoy games of like hard games with a lot of variety a lot of interaction as well if you are a fan of Magic the Gathering lorono and other trading card games which puts interaction ahead of everything else or is at least plays a big part I think nature is a good game to just purchase and you know have all of the cards integrated you don't have to worry about collecting all of the the different cards in in random booster packs or anything like that it's one of those games where everything is all inclusive and it does provide that really quick experience and I I I really do appreciate how uh limited the round structure is versus an evolution which can be a little bit variable and longer uh for a lot of people that the length of the game time in comparison to the uh rules complexity and the complexity on the cards was not uh optimal for them but with nature you can play a game in 15 20 minutes and reshuffle and or you know pick and choose different modules to experience the game as well and so I I really do like that change to make the game feel uh Tighter and more I guess constricted for time but also uh to increase the the the sense that every decision really counts when you're allocating your resources your cards onto your board and so I'm really
hopeful that nature does do well on um Kickstarter and I've really enjoyed my plays of it and my demo plays of nature as well as my plays of evolution on board game arena um it's not been a bad game at all so that's where I stand and that is my preview of Nature and my small review of evolution so thank you for Consulting with me today hope that was helpful and hope that you schedule an appointment with us real soon and I'll catch you on the next one take care