Mass Effect: The Board Game - Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about Mass Effect the board game and our copy was provided for review but the thoughts in this video are all our own and Mass Effect is a one to four player Cooperative game that is designed by Eric m lang and Calvin Wong Z loon and it is obviously based on the super popular video game series of Mass Effect which Sean and I have played a little but it's been years all we' played is the very first one and like I could not do one of the driving stages so I just gave up so we are primarily looking at this just from the board game perspective but before we talk too much about it let's look at how it plays in Mass Effect you'll be taking on a campaign of three to five games with your mission handily laid out by the mission book on your turn you roll all available dice then choose three to place on your board and activate Powers these Powers will include things like moving hacking turrets and doors completing mission objectives Reviving down teammates and attacking which is adding damage tokens until enemies die you will also gain character specific powers for any stars you roll and you'll get a bunch more Powers as you gain gain experience from destroying the enemies or from other game effects then at the
end of your turn you flip a hazard card which will activate and or spawn bad guys you win if you do whatever the mission asks you to you lose if you either flip too many escalation cards and run out of time or if Shephard gets ko'ed after three missions or five if you do the optional loyalty missions your campaign is over and you see how close gamed is saving the universe so first of all this was a lot easier to learn than I thought it might be cuz sometimes when you get to games that are like Dungeon Crawler games there's usually a whole bunch of rules overhead but I think it did a pretty good job of laying everything out pretty clearly yeah it's it's surprisingly super smooth and I really like that action selection system of just you've got a whole bunch of dice you're choosing three of those putting them on your different action and you've got kind of a growing number of actions as you go but I like that because like you don't have all of them to kind of spread around you're going to take those three you're going to take those three you're going to take those three you take you you just choose from your pool then you pass along the pool then they're rerolling that pool and choosing from a new pool so I think that does a good job of kind of taking out some of the quarterbacking too and I think it helps that you only have two or three actions available at the very beginning of your special actions as well as the basic action and then by the time you are unlocking more of those you're more familiar with the game so it does make it easier to be
able to play your characters and get to know them as well and I think part of the ease of like the onboarding of the game is that there are only like the two types of enemies so you're either playing with the one deck which is Cerberus or the other deck which is the reaper deck and so for setup that makes it really straightforward because it's the one deck of cards you need to find or like the three types of enemies that get mixed in the bag yeah I really like that cuz one of the things that kind of started to bum me out about like frost Haven was I was just like I don't need all these enemies like four of these are basically the exact same enemy I don't I don't want a 100 different chips to go through and so I really like that it's just it's that blue deck or the orange deck three with each one and those decks do play like a decent amount differently too like the one deck is a lot more they're just kind of ranged and they're shooting and they've also got turrets and the other deck is like I it's got like cannibals in it and stuff I think that's the reaper deck I'm not sure which one's which but they like are rushing you and attacking you and so they do both feel different but there's enough variance between the the missions as well that having those two decks is really like it feels like plenty yeah and they're pretty straightforward too cuz all the those enemies only move two they all have the value printed for how much you have to hit them and how much they hit back and then they might have like one special thing and that special thing is still even like pretty straightforward to understand yeah there's only four special things and I think they're like a like I'm going to
shoot you I'll run at you if you shoot me I'll run at you a little bit faster and I don't know and a fourth thing but there's there's really it is really easy to to get on boarded onto this game and that's going to be great because there's going to be a lot of folks who just know the video games who aren't that into board games and I don't think this is going to be too big of a hill for them to climb even if they haven't played that many things but that kind of brings us to the um to the replayability as well the variability cuz we were talking about the different bag guys and so what what are kind of some of the points that stood out to you for that well I think one of the key things is it is a campaign but it's a campaign that's made up of at minimum three missions but those missions are made up of like 10 possibilities so you can start off with like one of three options and then that branches to which one you choose next and then that branches to which one you choose next so already if you complete a campaign the most you would have played are three of those missions so that definitely makes you want to like play through it again choosing different branches and then on top of that the outcomes you can choose as well because you can choose like to do a paragon which are the harder ones and will get you more points or Renegade which means you still complete it but you're getting fewer points yeah you kind of w out it's like you can do like the hard thing which is quite a bit harder or you can do often it's like kind of beat the bega and then just run away so it's it's like the much easier thing and we definitely did the easier thing a couple of times yeah so just
even that if you were to play through doing the easier option which you'll probably want to do your first time playing you'll even want to take the same path but try to do it with the harder option too and then there's the Loyalty missions too so between each of the core ones you can pick a loyalty Mission meaning you can only play two loyalty missions if you choose to do both of them right and those ones connect to the different characters and there are five different characters in this game and they all play quite a bit differently so there's a Shepherd who's like the main character and that one you can gender swap or whatever you feel like but their thing is that really you just you don't want to die if you die with Shepherd you lose the game so whoever Shephard is going to be kind of team leader and they've got pretty basic they can heal other people that sort of stuff then you've got um tally who does some cool like hacking stuff has this little drone that flies around and and can attack people for you or hack stuff and her big thing is hacking doors but she can also do this thing she was probably my favorite one to play where you can hack other bag guys it's one that you can like work your way up to and get them to shoot different bad guys and I really like doing that yeah and then I played a couple of them so I played Rex who's like just a huge puncher and I always like taking the big punching ones in these kind of games so you just get close and then you try and hit as many things as you can and then Garis who is further away so he's a shooter and a little bit weaker so right he he spent a lot of time uh needing to
be revived I think you can play him well if you like keep him back but I just kept getting him in tricky situations yeah I was able to unlock some pretty neat things he has these proximity Minds that damage people if they come closer he can like walk away from people without triggering an opportunity attack and we did his loyalty Mission which meant that his basic attack was just stronger overall and the one person we didn't really use was Liara and liara's thing is peing ahead at the hazard card so you kind of have can be able to plan ahead as well as using the biotic effect and the stunning which are both things we didn't get to use too much so that would Again Play quite a bit differently and I would love to use your characters next time we play through especially Rex yeah Rex was a lot of fun and another point of very ability are the missions themselves because they do feel different some of them you're rescuing people other times you need to use like the hackers to get into the computer systems and like mess with them sometimes you're just trying to like collect a whole bunch of Loot and you're always just trying to kill tons of enemies but some of those missions definitely feel a lot harder than other ones and some of that is just the the third one that you come across is meant to feel harder and it does very much but there are also ones where like we just felt like we could kind of walk around and do what we wanted and ones where we felt like right at the start like holy cow we are in big trouble but there were some as well that felt like like we were
going to lose and then we managed to pull out a win and I think that's really The Sweet Spot and that was quite a few of them as well but let's talk about player count so no matter how many players there are you are always playing with four characters so we played through as two players so we each had two players and I felt like that worked well I didn't think playing with two characters was too overwhelming or too much to keep in my head I do wonder when you're solo and you're all four of them if that would feel like a lot yeah I think it probably would cuz each one is fairly simple and like like you said earlier it kind of it builds up nicely where you have you don't have that much to to learn at the beginning of the game and then you are learning more and more as you go but it doesn't feel like you're ever learning that much all at once but even still having those four characters and having to kind of switch your head from this to this to this to this I I think would be quite a bit for me I think some people if you know that you are good with Dungeon Crawlers and with playing with a bunch of people great you're not going to have a problem here but if you're not sure about that it it would feel a little bit much to me but two players I thought was maybe even The Sweet Spot the tricky with four players is we had a couple missions where someone got knocked out early and they just kind of stayed knocked out for a while I don't know if we were playing with four players would we have run over and tried to revive them quicker but it could be that you're sitting there for a round or two being like please please someone help someone come because you can't play till someone else comes over and heals
you yeah because if you're knocked out then you just skip that character's turn and it actually worked out all right when we were down to two players to just be playing with like the two living players cuz the enemies took a while to like make their way forward towards where we were yeah we kind of had them Rush two people they were kind of sacrificed in and we did our thing over here while they got back cuz they don't stay at the bodies they come for the alive people but Shepherd is the most important character so I think Shepherd's a good one for somebody who's played the game before who or who can easily pick up games to be but it will mean there is kind of an MVP of the group because the goal for the shepherd is Shepherd can't die everybody else can die tons of times so you definitely want like shepher to be a strong player yeah and someone who's gonna play kind of smart and as they build up as well like Shephard gets really strong by the end of the game and has like a lot of ways to to take out enemies but also is like your healer for the team so it is kind of a big responsibility and just a note Jess made me be shepher every game we've played so far well and you did a very good job thank you so that does mean that no matter how many players are playing it should take the same length mhm yeah it won't it won't affect anything else other than like how how much do you have to split your brain between players moving on to components I think this does a really good job of using like minimal amount of components in a
way that makes it feel bigger than it actually is yeah I think so and this is going to be a plus or minus depending on who you are so for us we love it because it's a nice slim box it wasn't too much stuff the setup is surprisingly quick for this kind of game I love that there isn't like a big deck of items I've got to go through I'm just kind of checking things off on a board but there are definitely going to be some players who are like I I want a giant box of minis I want all this stuff I want all these enemies I I want a box of items that I'm going through that's not going to be here but I don't think you're going to miss it as much as you think you are and for the players who don't want it like us and who want a box that fits on their already overpacked shelves I I was very pleasantly surp urised by that yeah cuz I think the game typically takes maybe about an hour to play so it's nice that there isn't like a setup that overextends its welcome so for that kind of length of game which is I think a really nice length you don't want to spend 20 minutes setting up and this does it really well and I think the map board helps a lot with that cuz you're just able to flip to the mission and then it has where everything goes like right on the board as well it's like the jaws of the lion situation yeah and then the character sheets are are all using uh like dry erase markers to Mark things off and we found that did the trick we were able to save it between plays and still like erase it easily afterwards too yeah even like a few days later we erased it wasn't a problem at all and
the few Minis that you get so you do have uh six minis of the five characters including both genders for Shephard and I thought those were all pretty solid um I again we don't know the game that well so we don't know how much they look like what they look like in the video game but I thought they all look pretty cool the like the character boards are fairly plain and a lot of the stuff is a little bit plain again that might just be what the video game is so it's it's really hard to critique that but it all did its job I thought pretty well and the bad guys are all just pogs um so they're very simple they're simple to find they're simple to put out U the big bad guys all look like they all look video gaming they're all taking the thing from the video game so if you like the video game it seems like that stuff's all there yeah I you did reference the like you won't be drawing from a big deck of items and that might be something that if you like the video game because in the video game you are constantly like raiding crates and getting new types of weapons and switching between the weapons and you don't have that you don't have to like equip yourself with this weapon or that weapon which we really like cuz we find that's a lot of upkeep but if that's a part of the video game that you really enjoyed was having a selection of weapons and choosing the right one for the right mission you aren't going to get that but where that comes through is the various abilities you unlock so I do feel like you're getting something similar in an easier way yeah it's going to be a bit of a give and take and it's going to be some people are going to love it some people are not and they're going to wish there
was another thing I will say though that its name suggests because this is Mass Effect priority hagalaz which I'm almost certainly saying wrong but that priority hagalaz suggests to me that there are going to be other missions and other stuff that's going to get mixed in here I don't know that that's true for sure but I got a feeling like it is and the other part that ties into components is the narrative book so this is where you are directed to read a bit of the story and it's usually just like a quick short paragraph within the important bits that affect gameplay so if you're like Sean and you don't like reading story you can easily just I like I like reading I don't like reading Bor just so everyone doesn't think I'm a dumb Dum I just don't like reading within board games it tends to not be the best of wrri and here again it it didn't grab me but I love that I could skip it and you can just read that bottom part and that is all of the text that you need for the actual game and if you want the mass effecte stuff it's there you can read it you totally don't have to though and I thought they did a really good job of separating those definitely but one thing if you're familiar with the video game is in the video game you get to like build personal relationships with the different characters and all of that as part of the story this does not have that this is focusing on the missions and the combat bat so you won't get to chance to like befriend different people at least in this Ford game maybe in the future ones and that brings us to final thoughts and I think for me one of the most important things is that if you're
going to make this kind of game bringing on the designers that they did especially Eric and Lang I think is just like kind of the perfect choice he's done a whole bunch of this sort of Ip stuff but making it in that sweet spot that new players can can get into it but experienced players are still going to find something to enjoy I thought he killed it with the team with um Marvel United and I think does a fairly equally good job here even though this is a little bit higher level a little bit harder than that and this does have a few more question marks cuz Marvel United I don't think we've ever needed to look up something we've never thought I wish there was an FAQ here there were a few times where there was stuff that I'm still not sure that we played totally right and once this is fully released it will be interesting to see how well we did with it but I think a lot of people are going to have those just those little bits in there but generally this is a pretty smooth game that does quite a bit without too many components and too much overhead yeah so I think it works pretty well for people who are fans of the video game particularly if you like the combat missions as well as people who like Cooperative Dungeon Crawlers cuz it is a Cooperative dungeon crawler set within this world and you don't have to know about this world to be able to enjoy the game yeah I know very little about Mass Effect and I'm usually not that into Dungeon Crawlers but this one did win me over and I think a big part of that is
it just didn't fall into some of the traps that the like huge Dungeon Crawlers like frost Haven have that just made a lot more fun to me there's a lot less admin there were a lot fewer just like extra extraneous things it just kind of got to the fun gave me progression and I enjoyed that and that progression did feel really rewarding cuz you definitely felt like you were getting stronger and if you are finding like it's too easy I think one of the things that can make it play harder is if you skip the Loyalty missions because doing the Loyalty missions just means you're going to be able to upgrade more characters so if you play through and you're like oh that was a bit easy then try without the loyalty and the third one's going to feel real hard especially if you do neither of the Loyalty then going in like basically just above a rookie and fighting the big guns and then and then we're going to see who's a big shot and this is one I'm definitely interested in playing back through with different characters and different missions and that is it as we record this this is just going out to pre-release right now so you may not have had a chance to play it but if you are watching this in the future let us know how what you think about the game how well did it capture the video game what are other video game board games that you've enjoyed thank you so much for watching as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game