Skip to main content
Loading video...

Diatoms Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:21

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at diams which is a one to four player kind of abstract puzzly board game that takes around 40 minutes to play this one is a prototype version of the game it has been successfully funded um on Kickstarter and because this prototype was provided to me I'm assuming is going to come out at retail sooner or later but before I get started on my review of diams I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor ker.com retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so diams is going to look somewhat like this when it is set up so each player is going to have their own player board that looks uh like this where you will be throughout the process of the game slotting in these different diams that come in five different shapes you got the circle ones all the way up to the star ones um like like so now you can see that this board is kind of broken down into different areas you've got essentially three different Rings here you got the outer ring the middle ring and the inner ring uh and you've also got these lines that go vertically diagonally in both directions as well as horizontally which is very relevant when it comes to the scoring objectives that you are trying to aim towards now uh the game also comes with a bunch of these tiles there's going to be a kind of a a communal display of tiles the starting one is going to go here then you're

going to be building around it by matching uh colors and this method here through placing these tiles is how you acquire the dams to put onto your player board um each player is going to have their own little reference sheet which shows you how to get each different shape of diam as well as a personal judging sheet which which is where you will record your final scoring now at all times each player will have two of these tiles in their hand and at the start of their turn you will draw a tile from one of these two stacks and depending on the player count um these Stacks will be bigger or smaller I'm just to make sure that the game is ticking along at a good um pace and on your turn once you've drawn your tile you will place one of the tiles into that communal um bunch of tiles in the center there so let's just say for example I wanted to place this one in here bearing in mind that you have to match color to color so you can see here this is perfectly fine because I've matched the yellow to the yellow and the red to Red you can see that some of the areas are kind of um blank which just means you can match anything to it so I could actually do that even though it's not um a color match now as soon as you have this kind of triarchy of shapes here and create a circle what you're going to do is you're going to put this little Mark on here to show which diems you will collect now you're going to look at this like a a pizza basically and have a look at the different segments so you can see here that I have four of these yellow segments as if I was breaking this up into into six pieces um and two of the red segments

and referring to my player sheet like so you can see that when I create a group of four um like this I going to get a square so therefore i' would get a red sorry a yellow Square because I get four yellow pieces that means a yellow uh Square I've got two of the red pieces the two relates to this kind of little oval shape therefore I will get a red oval again matching color um to color now breaking this down further you can see that if you got one segment is going to be um a circle uh two segments is the oval three segments is the triangle four segments is the square and five segments is the star now if you get all six segments of one particular color you can break it up into different um different categories basically so you you can take two of the diatoms as long as the total value goes up to six so you could take a five and a one um you know a two and a four or a three and a three and once you've placed your T and potentially got some diatoms then you are going to be placing these on your player sheet trying to um get as many points as you can or with the aim of getting as many points as you can so without thinking let's just say I'll put these um here and here and you can see on this playboard that every single slot can take two different types of diams and because of the kind of spatial fit here and you cannot physically fit another shape in there so it's quite nice that it actually fits quite snugly like you can see here that this spot has a square and an oval this is a star and a

triangle but of course if you're having one and you cannot have the other so what are we actually trying to achieve here so there's always going to be um three um kind of regular objectives that you're trying to aim towards the first one here is the matching colors where you're trying to get as much as a certain type of color as you possibly can you know if you get three or more of the same color you get Five Points five or more 20 points eight or more 40 points so a very simple scoring category there and the second one is going to be the symmetrical pairs on lines which is probably the most um Advanced one where you want to be getting the exact shape um the exact color or preferably both on your player sheet here so let's just say for example I ended up placing an oval here and this would be a great placement because it is on the same line and it is mirrored so this would actually get me um 15 points now if I managed to get say the same shape but not the same color or the same color and not the same shape then You' get Five Points so in this example because they're both squares I would get Five Points even though they're not a perfect color match and the final category is a bit more simple again where you are simply trying to get the different shapes on the different rings of your player board so if you have say five of the different shapes on the outering you'd get a massive 40 points if you only get four you'd get 20 points and if you only get two you'd get a Mega Five Points now there are also some guest judges that you can choose to use now I would suggest using them each

game um and these come in two different modes you've got like the easy mode or you have the P pnik mode which makes it particularly difficult to get points or at least it gives you an option to get points but it will come with potential um negatives or a downside to that so for example in this one the edge Enthusiast is going to give me five points for each diatom on my outer rim um or outer ring which may give me another incentive to get points um but on the picity mode if I have the most um diams on my altering I'll get a mass of 100 points but every time I have a um a diatom on the outer room connected to one of the same color I'm going to lose five points again you can see that there's a potential massive upside there but you got to be quite careful because those points are going to quickly get chipped away if I keep on breaking that restriction and the game does come with a ton of these guest judges for variability so um you're always going to have a very different game each time you play and that is essentially how the game works you're going to keep on playing until each player has run out of tiles um you're going to calculate all the points on your board based on those scoring categories from those judges and guest judges and the sheet here does a really good job of breaking down all the different scoring categories you know the matching colors the symmetrical pairs as well as the different shapes and of course if you want to use a guest judge you can use that you're going to calculate all your subtotals create a a grand total and of course the player with the most victory points uh will be the winner okay so let's share some

thoughts on diams I want to start off with how distinct this game feels it does have a unique identity I can't really think of anything else quite like this one the game is essentially a hybrid it's like a tile placement game a relatively simple one matched with a kind of a little restrictive um puzzle here of course trying to get as many points as you can um abiding by those scoring um categories but within that kind of simple hybrid mechanisms or hybrid of mechanisms um you do have a distinct feature here and that is this kind of fraction um mechanism I really like this and you can kind of utilize this to your own benefit you know do you want to try and work towards all of one color and break that shape down um or break that color down into different shapes do you want very particular shapes particular colors and of course that all comes down to the available pool here so there's a good amount of interaction here where the shapes in the center are constantly changing and of course you are trying to manage your small um so therefore manageable hand of tiles to um try is get not only as many of items as you can but also um the you know very particular items you need um for your player sheet to get as many points as you can but I do like how satisfying it feels when you get that perfect or optimal place um on the board here and something I didn't mention is that if you do manage to pull off um a great maneuver now I'm not sure if I can do one here but let's just say if I um if I manage to do something like this which I think is okay um you will calculate you know several other items

at once so you know You' not only um do this ring here You' also do this ring over here as well because again I've completed two um kind of trifectas of tiles so sometimes you can get completely flooded with the items and therefore just kind of mix and match your little puzzle um as much as you can and it has that good kind of a mechanism I tend to like in all that feeling in these puzzly games of almost managing your ambition it kind of reminds me of a game like Calico where sometimes you might maybe be a bit too optimistic about what you can achieve um because you're trying to get the exact right tiles and the exact right places but because this game works at a pretty fast pace you will find yourself running out of options or running you running out of time to pull off the ideal placement and you might just have to kind of um deal or or settle with what you can get maybe you're not getting the perfect matches but matching um shapes um and not the colors or colors and not the shapes so you know do you want to bite off more than you can chew and maybe or you know maybe pull off a great um feat of strength or do you want to just kind of Bank yourself some points so I really do like that and again it's all about managing your ambition and how much you can pull off and kind of touching on what I've already mentioned I think this game does a fantastic job of weighing up the kind of stuffiness of an abstract Style game with the breeziness of a family weight game and because you are restricted to only a couple of tiles in your hand um you you aren't paralyzed with options and sometimes it can be

more than viable just to get a you know even if you're not particularly thinking about which colors you're getting just trying to match as best as you can with the player with the um tile layout and getting a bunch of items and trying to fit them best onto your sheet um without being too without paying too much attention about which particular shapes you want so I think you can definitely play this game more approach this game in many ways you know do you want to be very um very particular about what you want or do you want to just you know play place a tile match a few colors get flooded with the items and hopefully work with what you've got so again it really does strike that nice balance between being um almost a pure abstract game um with that breeziness of a family game the player engagement of this game is fantastic there's very little downtime um because once your opponent has placed their tile they can kind of work out their little puzzled items as they like as you continue with your turn so again you're not really waiting on your opponent to place things because that's not really um your concern but at the same time there is still a good amount of play interaction because again that communal um tile layout was always changing opportunities are always arising and going so you need to um consider uh that um you've also got you know your head down in your little puzzle and it's quite satisfying when you pull off these really impressive looking mosaics and something I really want to mention is how perfect the game length is here um you know you know depending on the player count you are going to have quite you know well a few or or not many tows if you are only playing with say two players um and it really does feel like a Brisk and Punchy

game you know not once when I've played this game have I felt for a second that as outstay as welcome Ian is really sharp and again it does not drag its heels um one bit so you get quite a lot of game here for a very short Small Time investment I think the replayability is solid because again you're always reacting to the layout um of the tile State here so it does have somewhat of a tactical nature to it but the sheer variability of these um guest judges it does totally change um the feel of the game you know sometimes you have to consider a whole different dimension of the kind of tall placement that you wouldn't even consider um before so again I really am impressed with the amount of um considerations that's come in to these different guest judges and of course you can play with a simple mode if you're playing with a more casual audience or you can can go through these really difficult restrictive puzzles um that are quite difficult to overcome and will certainly um increase the brain burner nature of a game like this now this is a prototype copy of the game so it is quite difficult to comment on the production but it does look very impressive when it's all set up you know it's a very attractive looking game and I love the fact that these player boards are dual layered and the fact that they are you know very precisely cut out so you cannot physically fit the wrong shape in the wrong hole that's a really nice little touch there now I do have a slight issue with it and that when it that is when it comes to the color blind um unfriendliness um of the game you know I am quite severely color blind and

I have quite a few issues with some of the colors here now weirdly the actual tiles themselves do have different patterns on them which really help differentiate them but those patterns do not match the tiles which is where the problem is so me personally I have a big difficulty um differentiating the red and the green ones um but for some reason the Reds and the green tiles don't have the same patterns on them so you can see that these ones have this kind of honeycomb pattern on whereas these do not so again very difficult for me to um cross examine them um but hopefully that will be addressed um you know it's workable but it was a bit of a shame and a bit of a missed opportunity um but you know again this is a prototype copy so I can't fully comment on it um but let's just hope that that issue is fixed okay so let's share some final thoughts on um diams and I knew very little about this game if not nothing about this game um when the designer approached me asking me to review this on my channel um and I'm so glad I took her up on that offer because I really enjoy um this puzzle game and you know over the last few years maybe you know four or five years ago there was a big influx of these styles of games you know thinking games like um Sada thinking of games like Calico and you know there was a lot of them flooding the market and the best ones kind of stayed around and the rest of them um didn't this one I think is right up there with those aformentioned games and I think if you like those games then you are almost guaranteed to like this one again the puzzly nature um is is really

strong that spatial awareness mapping things out very satisfying and beautiful um looking games but with some good strategic and some good tactical decisions so again it really does walk that fine line and strike that perfect cord for me um between being you know a very a me game in terms of you know what you can do in the decisions you're making with the breeziness and most relaxing nature um of it as well but you're not sacrificing the decisions you're not sacrificing the interaction for that which I really do appreciate and it's you know I don't play a ton of um prototypes because not a lot of them are sent to me um but this one is one that I'm I'm super looking forward to playing some more and I'm very hesitant and reluctant to give this one back because I'm going to miss it so um yeah if you if you like the styles of games I'm pretty sure in fact I'm confident that you will like this one because there is so much to sink your teeth into know tons of objectives to work towards um and it's just an absolute blast to play so um yeah I really do um well recommend this one to those puzzly style of Gamers because I think you're going to have a great time with diams

Progress saved