Core Comparison: Rogue Revised Core vs Core 2026 (ARKHAM HORROR: THE CARD GAME)
Transcript
Hello everybody and welcome to another Arkham Horror video. It's another core comparison where we are going to now our fourth class comparing the original revised core. It's not really the original core, it's the revised core. You know how it is to core 2026 which is coming out in a few months time actually even shorter like a month's time from the time this video goes up which is kind of crazy. Uh I'm going to look at the cards in the OG core set. Uh, then I'm going to talk about the cards in the new core set and kind of see where we think they are going to be for giving a good foundation for the rogue class individually. So, we're not going to look at like specifically Trish Scarbor who can play with rogue and seeker. I'm looking at just like the health [clears throat] and power level and usability of the rogue class. So, we have staple.
These are cards that are like always always good and are very rarely replaced or priority upgrades. So, you're just going to see them in a lot of decks that you play. Um, strong universally used are close to staple, but not on the same level in my opinion, which is my opinion of of the the don't hit that staple level, but they're still very, very good cards. Good cards are good cards that are good. Exactly what it says on the tin. They'll provide a good impact when they're played. you're going to want them in your deck, but you're not going to make it like a priority in your mulligan or like they might be part of your deck's plan, but not like the things that are like the star of your deck. But they are just good cards that provide a very good base for your uh for your deck. Strong, narrowly used are cards that are strong, but they're not used like in a lot of decks. They might be used in like two or three decks or alternatively like a good example of this is Old Book of Lore, which is an incredibly powerful card, but like pretty much only in Daisy Walker and sometimes people play it in Mandy Thompson, right? But it's so strong in that deck that like the card is not a bad card by any means. Um, so it's kind of like one of those things where it's like fine but good for other people. So that's where why it's between like good and fine. Fine. These are cards that are fine. These are cards that when you're building your level zero deck, you're going to use them to hold space. Or they're going to be cards that are good at the start of your collection, but as you start getting more and more
packages, uh, and more and more boxes, more and more player cards, they'll eventually fall out of grace and power, and you're not going to really play them anymore. And then we finally have space waster. These are cards that waste space. They just fill take space in your binder. They are there to just kind of like no one really knows why. They're just kind of there to be a paper weight. I mean like they are the weight that they are the paper that the weight is on, right? Like they're not really anything. They just like literally waste space. Before I get into the rogue class individually, I think it's only fair that we talk about the rogue class and how they had a very rough go of it in their uh OG core.
And they had the biggest room for improvement compared to all the other classes that existed in this game when it came to this new core. Do I think that they've improved? Yes. it would be very hard for them to not improve, but I think they did not improve as much as I was hoping they would. Um, but I'm going to withhold that judgment until we get to the end. But I do think that overall we can take a moment and we can laugh at the old rogue class and be like, "Haha, you stinky." Right? Let's take a moment and do that everybody. Haha, Rogue, you used to be stinky. And now let's do this. 41 Daringer uses three ammo as an action. Spend one ammo fight. You get plus two fist for this attack. If you succeed by two or more, this attack deals plus one damage. So I'm not going to talk about Tony Morgan here because he changes these. I'm going to talk about these specifically to the rogue class generally. And unfortunately the Daringer was a space waster.
Um, so what makes this card bad? Because like I've I know people have played this card and like Tony Morgan and also Michael McGlenn and they've been like, "It's fine until I get to the upgraded version, right?" Well, succeeding by two or more was actually pretty difficult in the early game because you had to spend a lot of resources or cards to get there and you honestly would just want to play the machete instead. even in Skidzo Tool which is not advisable um over playing like you know like Roland Banks with a machete but like even Skidzo Tool is would want to bring the machete out more to the point where like even this 41 Daringer the level zero version you're really only playing it consistently in Michael McGllin and Tony Morgan and that's just because they are rogues with five fist right like even Leo Anderson who plays rogue guns isn't going to be pulling out the 41 Daringer rogues had such a like a a choke on their weapons that like the Mouser, which is a very good gun. It's a very good firearm, was like a breath of fresh air to the class. They were like, "We could shoot. We have a gun that isn't ass." And I think that um the level zero 41 Daringer unfortunately just wasted a bunch of space.
The upgraded version, the level two version is not a space waster. As an action to spend on a fight, you get plus two fists for this attack. If you succeed by one or more, this attack deals plus one damage once per turn. If you succeed by three or more, you may take an additional action this turn. So, um this one um is not like glowingly better. Like to me, it's between like fine and good. So, like this is gonna sound really mean for 41 Daringer. Uh if this was good, narrowly used would be the most perfect place to put the 41 Daringer. Um [snorts] cuz that's where it was for like the majority of the time and it still is kind of there. It has improved a lot with the card pool and like more investigators are able to tap into it.
Uh, I think that ultimately though, just because Oh man, but it sucks so much to only succeed by one. I'm gonna put it in fine because I'm I think I'm getting slightly tainted by Tony Morgan and Michael McGlenn, but I think as a whole this like the 41 Daringer didn't really make a lot of noise in the card pool until we started to see those other guys. Uh and even in normal skids, you're not really fighting with this one so consistently. Like I think most of the time you would rather take the mouser and have an upgraded like sorry like the mouser and have like a guaranteed shot at two damage because that's kind of like the important part of combat.
So I'm going to put it in fine. And I think the reason for that is because good narrowly used is where I would like to keep this but there is no good narrowly used. So I think that makes it slide down into fine here. Lockpicks. Three costs, one experience, uses three supplies. If lockpicks has no supplies, discard it. As an action, exhaust lockpicks. Investigate. Add your foot value to your skill value for this investigation. If you do not succeed by at least two, remove one supply from lockpicks. Uh lockpicks, however, is a staple. It could be strong universally used at this point in the game's lifespan. Right. Um, my gut says staple, I mean, it's one of these two. It's probably strong universally used. I think realistically is a better place for it. I feel like a staple. So, like unlike guardians and seekers, I feel like a staple in the in the rogue class needs to be used by fighters and clovers. Does that I think that makes sense and I think that's fair, right, chat?
I think that that is kind of a better place for the staple where um like a card that exists that takes up the accessory slot that may or may not be in core 2026 I think is a good example of um a a staple rogue class card right so I'm going to put this one in strong universally used this if you did not play from the beginning of Arkham Horror the card game this was a gamecher in terms of what rogues were able to do and how they were able to impact the It being reprinted in the revised core was huge for the Rogue class because it allowed you to actually like start getting stuff done. I'm pretty sure Skids was able to investigate at seven with it, which is actually a usable number. So, you're able to do a flex skid outside of the box, which was a lot better than whatever Skids was in the first uh OG like old old core. So, great card. Um I'm going to miss it.
Switchblade, one cost, fast fight. If you succeed by two or more, this attack deals plus one damage. Takes up the hand slot, too. It's a weapon. Uh, this card's really bad. Uh, it's it has all the problems of the Daringer. It sacrifices it in terms of um, you know, it's fast, it's one cost, so it's like takes out very little to get there. Um,
it's not good. It's not good. Even if you're playing Tony Morgan and you want the upgraded switchblade, it's going to be a priority upgrade. So, you're going to like run for it pretty quick, right? Um, it's not reliable. like with skids you're fighting at three and you're trying to like at a certain point and I think it was because of the machete the game came about damage needs to be two for it to be worth it right um and this card was one damage and I think that they wanted one damage to be Okay, they wanted two damage to be a reward, but unfortunately machete right in the core box taught the players that one that that two damage was the norm and like everything kind of cascaded around that from the design afterwards because it kind of became more interesting for them to be able to make monsters and enemies that were three health and then being able to kill in two actions felt nicer than like three actions. And I think that the they wanted this unreliability, but I think unfortunately just the core set already changed that from the get-go. So, switchblade, it's stinky.
Catburgurglar. I think this is one of the a very strong card that is very rarely played. I'm going to put him in good because he's not universally used. He's not even narrowly used. I think he's just a good card. Four cost one experience. You get plus one plus one foot as an action. Exhaust them, disengage from each enemy, engage with you, and move to a connecting location. This action does not provoke attacks of opportunity. That's a very powerful ability on an ally card. Um, so I think what the big thing that really made Catburglar kind of just like not exist was that for the longest time, um, foot didn't really matter, right? like treacheries didn't enhance as much as brain because we went from Dunish legacy into path carcosa and then when we went into the forgotten age when foot started to matter we got Lola Santiago who is one of the best allies in the game right so catbug never really had a time to show off and shine and really like show what he was capable of right I think that's made it so that people kind of often overlook Look, Cap Burglar, but anytime Cap Burglar hits the table, it's always impressive. So, I think he's a good card.
Leo Duca, six cost. You may take an additional action during your turn. This guy's probably the staple, right? If there was a staple in the core set, it would be level zero Leo Duca.
Well, I'm not really um like super excited. I'm not really like super excited to play Leo Duca um because I think that you ultimately can outv value the game with other allies. I think it's mark on the card pool is is very noticeable and I think he is still very good and very playable today. I feel like at this point now he's better played outside of the rogue class, right? like if you're playing him as a rogue splash or like I recently played him in parallel Jim Culver um like the actions and classes that don't get actions so easily I think Leo Duca is more impactful and I think that might be why I scaled down on him a little bit because like I think other people just like do it better than him at this point. I think he is still just like still very playable. And when economy got better, this guy became like very much easier to put in and and like pay for without having to do the thing which I've seen happen so many times where you pay six resources, gain like gain an action on your gain a resource on your first turn, play him, take two actions, and then lose him.
Um, so yeah, I think he's still very good. I had a good impact from this the start of this and uh I think he's still played in a full collection, so he deserves a stable spot. But I think um overall um I think other allies uh out beat him in the long run, but I still think he is a very powerful guy. So he's he's definitely a staple. Definitely a very good very good ally. Uh weird question. You think Cap Burglar would seem more playated is a unique ally with a name. 100% more personality makes the characters feel um like you want to play them more and uh by nature I think that there is a a subconscious feeling where if an ally does not have a unique name they are um expendable.
So, it's one of those things where you don't imagine cat burglar sticking around. Um, like the same way like you do with BOP. Like a B cop eventually is going to kill himself down, right? I think it's a mental thing for sure. But it's funny. It's funny. I never thought about that, but I think you're 100% on that one. Yeah. Leoduca definitely the staple. His upgraded version I think is strong and universally used. I think in the early part of Arkham um is something that you would want to um prioritize upgrading because being able to play him off your mulligan was really like was really good. But I think that now is the as I mentioned that experience sorry as uh economy got better experience matters more because there's more experience cards as well.
So I think he's less of a priority. If someone got into the final scenario with Leo Duca zero over Leo Duca one, I'd be like, I get it. Nothing wrong with that. Burglary. Let me just scroll back down to the bottom here. It's a space waster. Uh, one cost action. Exhausted. Investigate. If you succeed in discovering clues, gain three resources.
Um, so it's kind of really funny, right? Um, because this card actually reads pretty good. Like it reads pretty like it's like this is a this is a dependable form of economy, right? Like when you just read this card, you look at this and you're like, "Yeah, um, this actually is okay." But it's never really seen play outside of, as Vogloss is saying, like Rex Murphy, right? Because he could still get the clue with it. So, it's basically just a basic investigate action that he gets three money on as well.
[snorts]
Because Dexter is like Rex's ability is like an additional clue, right? Like you don't it's not an additional clue. You discover a clue, right? Cuz that's how that works, right? But this card is just like not the way. There was just something about it. And I think again it calls falls down to the fact that their first two investigators I think dropped the Rogues off on a horrible spot because they had threes in their do something stats and like those numbers were good um those numbers were good in um like theory but they never really followed through with the design. I've seen it to great effect in Lucius with the four different action cards. Okay.
Um I will also say is like because I this happened in one of the comments on the previous video when I put a card in fine or space waster and there were some comments who were like but I've I've seen it or I've used it here. Just because it's in the heading of space waster doesn't mean the card is unplayable. Uh, I have played every Arkham card and while some cards are deemed unplayable, it doesn't mean that they are truly unplayable, but they are given the blanket of unplayable because compared to other things, they are unplayable. There are a few cards that I do legitimately believe are unplayable, but I don't believe burglary is one of them, but there is no amount of money that someone can pay me to call burglary a fine card. By the way, that's an absolute lie. I would gladly take like even a $100 to say burglary is fine.
Yeah, it's like because I play like a burglary Bob Jenkins deck. That was very fun. Um but it's one of those things. So just just people know um that like I'm not saying these cards are unplayable, but in the blanket of terms compared to the stuff around [snorts] it, it kind of is. Hard knocks. I think that this card was also a space waster. I think it was like one of those things where it was playable at the start, but it very quickly fell off. This is crazy. Um, I don't want to chat. Do I need to talk about these talents again or can I just move on? That was something that I really liked about being so far away from the core set is that these talents, so I didn't have to think about them anymore, but now I have to be like, "So, this is bad because your money is better spent on cars that impact the game as opposed to helping you just like pass a test, right?" So, I think I'm going to just say that and say that this card is a space waster. I think it was fine when it was just this and you needed something, especially with like Jenny Barnes, but I think pretty quickly level zero hard knocks space waster pickpocketing.
I think you're 100% right on that dice gods. I think they're they they're good to start right now. the new talents. Um, these ones for people like silver tongue, but I think that they're going to fall off on your collection pretty quick as well. All right, pickpocketing. Uh, two cost activate an enemy exhaust pickpocketing draw a card. I think pickpocketing is a good card. I think pickpocketing uh two is a phenomenal card, but this is just card draw for an action that rogues want to take. Uh, I think it pretty quickly became some value when like I mean skids would play this in the core set, right? Um, Finn started to really love this card because ability is now also red draw card. I think that um, pickpocketing is pretty good.
Backstab I think is another good card. I I might be on the fringe with my thoughts on this card. Um, so I I'll kind of talk about it. Three cost fight. This attack uses foot instead of fist. This attack deals plus two damage. Like this is a very uh big amount of damage to drop on an enemy in one action, right? And it's it's with the skill that the rogues are are good with, right? But I've never liked backstab. And that might be because of my play style and how I aim to solve my problems in a game of Arkham, right? Like that could be could be how I'm approaching the logic for that, right? Like it's just like a vibe based thing.
But I think as a whole um is it's because it's Yeah. Whole helicopter. That's that's that's a big part of it. It's cost three and like you don't really get a boost out of it, right? When I think it actually has a very similar sort of space to this decisive strike that we're going to talk about in the in the future. Um, but I I don't think it's a bad card. I just personally don't think it's a strong card. Um, I've been impressed when people have used it, but they have to put a lot of resources into it, and that's kind of like where I find like the good card. Like, it requires like other things to like really make it pay off. I think it's a well-designed card and well balanced card, but I think as a whole, for me personally, just a good card. Definitely playable. I've seen people play it a lot. I've played it a few times. Um, yeah, that's all I got to say.
Elusive. This is an interesting card and I don't really know how to talk about this card. So, this card got tabooed. And we're going to kind of talk about the I have the original version here, but we're going to kind of also talk about like the taboo version because the taboo was just like connecting location, which was a lot better for a level zero card.
I think this whole card's probably good, right? taking the taboo into account with this for people watching at home cuz I think that I mean that's the way that I primarily play and I think it's the way that the majority of the Arkham community primarily plays and yeah even when it's tabooed I think it is still good tech right um I'm here for it I don't really have much to say as well like it's not an exciting card like that's the thing right like if you look at put a thumb over lock pickicks and like even the upgraded daringer, right? Um these are cards that didn't really do anything like backstab does like that's the only card that actually like does something here in the good category, right? And I think this kind of really sums up to why Rogue had some issues is that their cards didn't really do anything. So, now that they're going to start getting cards that do something, maybe they're looking better off, right?
Hot streak, three cost, four experience, gain 10 resources. So, this might be controversial. What I'm about to do, I think that this card is fine. I think that this card fits the definition of fine where when you have a small collection and this is your best economy, you're going to take it, right? But why would I want to do that when unless I'm a big money deck, I can just like stay with Fouian bargain, right? Why not just play fouian bargain? Why not just play watch this, right? Why not just play pickpocketing two? Why not just play hot streak two, right? Um it's one of those things where I think that it's just um outclassed by everything around it. For a long time, you played this card out of necessity, not because you wanted to, because it represented in theory five actions for Skidzo Tool, right?
But I think in actuality, as the card pool got bigger and economy eventually got better, no one's really chomping at the bit to play Hot Streak 4. Even hot streak like two is like still I'm only playing that in big money decks. So, even like for the best case scenario, that's going to live in like the strong narrowly used. So, yeah, I'm going to drop this one here down into the fine category. And with all that said, I actually don't think it's a problem that Hot Street got power crept. I think economy should be good because the game is a bit more interesting when your economy is good. I think at a certain point, economy became too good. So, I'm hoping they can kind of pull it back a little bit, but I do think that um hot streak ultimately got outclassed as the game got bigger.
Sneak attack deal two damage to an exhaust enemy at your location. I think it's fine. I I played it a lot back in the day, but I don't really touch it as much anymore. Um, I I I I still I play the upgraded version sometimes, but I'm less inclined to play the sneak attack. I'm only playing sneak attack in like two player decks when I need like a a panic button in my lower level decks to just start killing some things. Um, I think it's a fine card, but I think you upgrade out of it as the game goes. I think at a certain point I probably would have card called this card good, right? But I think at this point now, not so much. Just as like the card pool got bigger. Like I said, I think the upgraded version is fine cuz that's just like deal two damage to an enemy, not engage with you. You can just like move into location and go like, "Hi."
Um, yeah. So, I'm going to just put it there. Great icons though. Great icons. H. Sure. This is sure gamble. Uh, two cost three experience. Perfect chuck card. Am I learning a new word? What the hell is a chuck card? A card you commit. [snorts] Uh, two cost three experience. Fast play after you reveal a chaos token with a negative modifier. Switch that token's minus to a plus. Oh, Chuck Fergus. That's so funny. Oh my god. That No, that's on me, chat. That one's on me. No, that that No, that is honestly that is really funny.
You guys got me with that one. And you weren't even trying to get me, which is makes it which makes it even funnier. Honestly, I'd love to see Chuck Fergus promoted to an investigator. That's a great idea. [snorts] Uh, sure gamble. I think it's a good card.
Yeah, I'll put it there. I don't think it's strong or universally used. I think it's just good. Um, it's a bit expensive experience-wise, but I brought it I brought it to a recent campaign and I was like, "Yeah, this still shows up." Brin bought brought it to a recent campaign and I was like, "Oh, yeah. This is impressive." Um, but yeah. Are we doing every rogue card? No, we're doing all the core set rogue. We're comparing the old core to the new core and kind of making predictions about the new core. Well, looking back at the old core cards to see where they kind of fell into the legacy of things. Opportunist is bad. Space waster. Goodbye. No one likes you except for Winred. Actually, technically I'm playing you tomorrow, but don't worry about it.
Uh, we're going to still This card's bad, though. Bad card. Uh, succeed by three or more, return it to your hand. Uh, I I think the theory of this card is good. I think it definitely should have been two or more from the start. I think if we had this card released today with the exact same intention behind it, it would be the two or more version at level zero. And I don't think it would have been too strong. Um, yeah, I think that this is um [snorts] bad card. So, as we can see, the rogue class has a lot that's living at the bottom, and it has, I think, are the most space wasters of every one of our things. So, yeah, Guardian Revised had three. I can show this again. Guardian Revised had three. Seeker revised had three. Survivor revised had three. So, this had two more. Survivor did have a lot in the fine category, but it was one of those things where like the survivor investigators were powerful, so the cards didn't matter as much. And like the rogue ones, they weren't that powerful, so the cards mattered even more, right?
And damn, the next 53 months of the Golden Table. Rogue did get cooked, but let's see how they're going to be going forward. So, one thing to keep in mind before we get too deep into this is that this video is entirely predictive. Um, like this tier list here, I don't know where things are going to be. I'm basing entirely just off hunches and the Arkham card game knowledge I have. I am happy to be wrong, but my hope is that I can look at these in a few years and see how things went. So, as I mentioned earlier, do I think that [clears throat] the Rogue class has improved? And I think they have in the sense that I think they're going to have less space wasters, but I think as a whole, I wish there was more for the rogue class in the core. So, I'm very curious to see the investigator starter decks because I think that's where the true beauty and power might come from.
So, let's start with the M1903 Hammerless. This is a three-cost asset. Takes up the hand slot. Uses four ammo. Spend one ammo as an action to fight with your foot. If the target enemy is exhausted, this attack deals plus one damage. [snorts] So, what do how do we really feel about this weapon? Like if this card came out in the core set, how would we feel about this weapon if this card came out with Skidzo Tool? Because that's going to kind of be where I want to start.
[snorts] It is good enough to do the thing. Yeah, it is good enough to do the thing.
[snorts]
I need to check something.
Sorry, I'm deep in the tank. I'm gonna put it in. Fine.
Where would I put the 25 automatic? I'd put the 25 automatic in. Fine. The level zero, it's a priority upgrade to me to make the other version if I'm going to be running it, right? I'm not really looking at playing 25 automatic zero. Um, I think that this card is playable, but I think that it's gonna be clunkier than it reads on the tin in practice. I think it's going to be one of those things where it sounds really nice and it looks really nice and then suddenly you draw a 4foot enemy and you're like, [ __ ] You know, that's kind of like the thing where like I think it's like I mean Trish can use it pretty good and like that's nice for Trish.
Let me just let me just say this right now and this is my problem with the rogue core that I personally have as a player. They should have included an upgraded version of this instead of sticky fingers. This sticky fingers in my opinion is just it's not good enough. It's not good enough to be a core set a core set slot. You know, I think that the level zero rogue stuff is for the most part pretty good, but I think the upgraded rogue cards have really kind of like like faltered, which is why I'm very excited to see the player cards in the Andre Patel deck. Um, yeah, and like Elamine, that's a great point, right? having to spend your foot icons on both the evade and the attack is a bit tough because maybe you have a two health a two evade enemy, but what if he has four attack or what if it's a two attack enemy, but he has four evade, right? Like that's um that's like the real sticky part of this. And that's why like my gut is telling me I think this card is playable, but I think you're going to be prioritizing like if a better gun comes out in the Andre Patel deck or the first cycle of player cards we get. M1903 Hammerless is going to hold space until that comes there. I think the card is playable. Like I'm going to I'm going to enjoy playing in Winford Habamuk, right? But I do think that it is as a whole I think this card is going to be less impactful than it seems on the tin. And that's what my heart of heart tells me and that's why
I'm following. And honestly, I convinced myself during this. I convinced myself during this thief's kid. Yo, that's a good ass card. I don't think it's strong or universally used, but I do think that this is a good card. Three cost uses six supplies. Takes up a hand slot as an action. Spend one supply. Investigate with your book or foot. And before anyone asks, you could do that with the original version as well. If you succeed, gain one resource. Uh, I think that this is a very healthy card for the rogue class and I think that this shows the real nice um flexibility that Rogue should have and I think that it they're showing this as well with the hammerless and also decisive strike where Rogue can kind of use what's best for them in the moment.
And I think that this is is is really nice. I think it's a it's a fine economy card to kind of like pay itself back and get a little bit more if things go really well. Um I think that it's going to be really good with pressed digitation as we get to that. Um Trish she can use whichever version is this. She can use um I mean there's not too many things she can use here, right?
I mean I don't know. Maybe something with out of sight, right? But I think like the like she can use deduction for one. I mean she can switch from manual decks to perception she has going that for her, right? Um I think that this is um a really nice piece to rogue for rogues to have in their in their in their in their pool in their pie. It's here and it's not going anywhere. Please don't print level three. Do not print lucky cigarette case number level three. Please do not do that. Please do not do not do that. Please do not do that. Level zero lucky cigarette case I think is a perfect card. Um two cost takes up an accessory slot as a reaction after you succeed a skill test by two or more exhaust lucky cigarette case draw one card. Um it's a staple. It is, I think, the the the perfect rogue staple, right?
I I can't think of like a more like staple rogue card um than Lucky Cigarette Case Zero. Uh and I'm happy it's here. I know there's some people who have said that this makes the accessory slot more competitive. There's a great way to compete with Lucky Cigarette Case Zero, and that's just to make cards that are like good enough to be played instead of Lucky Cigarette Case Zero, right? Um, I do like the change where Lucky Cigarette Case is the draw card and Sticky Fingers is the resource, right? Um, because I think that's healthier as a whole. I have some issues with sticky fingers that we're going to get to once we get to it. Um, but that is just where I am with this.
But I think Lucky Cigarette Case is nice to still be here. I will say though, um, I personally think at least with the card, how the card pool is in Legacy now, Lucky Cigarette Case is less of a staple than it was at the start, but I think it still isn't easily easily included in the staple tier. That's kind of a fun looking tier list.
[sighs]
Olivier Bishop four cost two- one soak takes up the ally slot. You get plus one foot as a lightning bolt during your turn. Exhaust Olivier Bishop move to connecting location. Where is he? This guy's a staple. This guy's going to be played until the end of time. Uh, great card, great ability. Um, I do like the movement being in rogue class. It definitely feels like I mean like seekers still have movement in their class, but the rogue ones feel like they should be the ones who have the best movement. Like Pathfinder should have been a rogue card from the start. I think it actually probably would have set up the game to be healthier if it was a rogue card from the start. I do think it was a design failure of um having Pathfinder be in the seeker class. It definitely should have been a rogue from the start. Um the plus one foot on a level zero rogue ally is something that people have wanted for a long time and I think having it in the core set and as um Beard has pointed out there is uh a plus one stat for all of the classes and then survivors get their health and sanity plus one kind of. So I think that that's like a very nice thing to have. Um, overall this card's going to do a huge impact in every format and I'll play him in a clover or a fighter because he's just that damn good.
Silver tongue. Oh, the talents. I'm so excited to talk about this. Two cost asset. Lightning bolt. Spend one resource. You get plus one book for the skill test. Plus two instead if it's a parlay or an evasion. And you get plus one foot or plus two for an evasion or parlay. So the evasion one mode is pretty nice for this, especially when you get the money back with sticky fingers. Uh, this one's probably fine, right?
These are the things that like the talents I think are the ones that I'm most curious about how they're going to be. I think like the originals, they're going to kind of be removed from your collection as you get more and more alternative options. That's kind of like my hunch for how these are going to go. I could be wrong with that, right? Like I could be wrong. I haven't actually tried them out. Maybe they play better and maybe like just like having one resource to get plus two for an evasion, like get a manual deck that doesn't draw is really good. Like I could definitely see that being a thing. So I'm going to I'm going to put him in fine right now, but there's like a little pin in this one to see how is it going to go in in the long run. Right.
This how you get your four of eight on the foroot enemy so you can hammerless them. It's I mean it's true. It is true in theory, right? Like I know there's a kappa there, but this is technically a true true statement. Sticky fingers. I think this card is Let's read it. One cost asset. Limit one per investigator. Have successfully evade an enemy. Exhaust sticky fingers. Gain one resource. So pickpocketing is is in the good tier back here, right? Pickpocketing is in the good tier. Pickpocketing is better than sticky fingers.
Yeah, I'm going to go out on a I'm going to go out on a limb here. I'm going to say something that's in my heart and I need to say it. I think as a whole the rogue cards aren't a massive improvement over the original core. But what makes all these cards look and feel better is that there is a competent investigator for the rogue class in the box.
[snorts]
I don't think Sticky Fingers is that good. I can't put sticky fingers and pickpocketing on the same tier. I just can't.
I think Sticky Fingers is just fine. I think it's a fine card. You're going to want to upgrade out of it into not Sticky Fingers 2. I'll tell you that much. [snorts]
Yeah, I would play it in current with someone like Trish. Yeah. Like Yeah. Like I think you would. Um but like that's the thing. Like that's where the fine is, right? But you'll eventually be like I need to this needs to be something better, you know? Like I mean like I think it's fine and that's also just like some drip economy, but as soon as you get any better economy like why would I want to do this, right? Because like I the draw is the the good part of these cards is pickpocketing is like is the draw, right? The upgraded pickpocket is good because you get an upkeep phase, right? Like that's why it's good. And I feel like the upgraded version of sticky fingers like maybe cost three and gave you an upgrade. Also, we're just going to stop at Sticky Fingers 2 here. I think this one is an actual legitimate space waster. As I mentioned earlier, I wish this card was not here. I wish Sticky Fingers 2 just was not here.
There's not enough of an improvement in my opinion for this card to be [clears throat] included, right? I would rather it like have more to it. Like it just being fast is just like not enough, you know? Like it does have the two icons which is relevant because you can only have one of these in play, right? But like
I wish it was just something else. I wish it was just like something else or like the card was better. This one was very weird when I saw it because I was just like I don't I don't know. Like when it got spoiled I was just like It doesn't really like do anything like that's worth the upgrade. You kind of just like upgrade it because [snorts] it's there and you're like your upgrade pool is so small, right? I do think yeah, this should have been an upgraded hammerless that gave you plus two foot, right? Uh I think that sticky fingers and that's why I think it it I feel like it really wastes space.
Or even if it was like if it followed the thing where it's like after you successfully invade an enemy, exhaust sticky fingers, gain one resource, two resources instead if you succeed by three or more. LIKE WHY COULDN'T THAT HAVE BEEN on there, right? Like that that could have been on there, right? Like that I think would have made this more of an of an enticing card. Like they have the staple for the rogue thing. Just put that on there because that's what the pickpocketing two had, right? Gain two resources instead if you succeed by three or more, you know. Do you think another day is another dollar is a space waster, too? I think another day, another dollar is a playable card, but I do think that in the vibes it wastes space. Yes. Once Travis said that he wishes these um the permanence were in the investigator starter decks instead of the core set, I was like, "You mad man, you're 100% right with that." Like that is the truth.
Okay. Uh that's not on sticky fingers. Let's go to another day, another dollar. Yo, I think this is a good card. Um but let me just talk about it. As I said, I think that this should have been in the starter decks, not the core set. Um, core sets, they're a whole different beast where even though the original core set was designed alongside Dunich, and it's very likely um that this comes with like designed in kind of tandem and like in partnership with the investigator starter decks. they still need to be standalone. Um, so I wish that there was like some switches to kind of make that work better. Um, to go along with that. Um, I do think another day of the dollar is a good way to spend your experience, especially if you care about money. Um, people talk about a lack of uh uh economy cards in this card pool and I think that as a whole um it's it is kind of that way. But I think like another day, another dollar is the solution they're attempting to present with that where like you start with seven or nine. Um but I do think there's going to be probably more economy cards to come to kind of round it out. Um, I think that just like I think the bal they they they made some very purposeful decisions for how they balance the cards and what cards they chose here. And I think as a whole for every other class
except for maybe seeker, I think they were successful. Um, but I think in the rogue class it feels a little bit I don't know. It just something feels off about it and like my my spidey sense is tingling and I'm just like there's something here I don't like and I think it is sticky fingers and to a lesser extent out of sight and also another another day another dollar breaking and entering. Yo, this card is strong and universally used baby. Two cost event investigate book. Add your foot to your book for this investigation. If you see by two or more, you may automatically evade an enemy at this uh location. This action does not perfect opportunity.
After you successfully evade, not even evade. They could have just made that after you evade an enemy to work with breaking and entering. And then we would have been talking. Uh so uh let's let's pivot away. Um, let's pivot away from the sticky fingers thing because I think the cards that they chose to reprint in the core set were absolutely phenomenal choices. I think thieves get breaking entering and lucky cigarette case are perfect representations of the rogue class and what they were um uh and what they were and how they achieved good boosts of power over the game. So I think that's really good. Um this actually was card that I'm probably the happiest was reprinted. I think that this is a phenomenal card breaking and entering. The reason it's not going in staple is because of the thing I mentioned in the last one where I feel like the seeker and sorry the clue getting rogue and the fighting rogue should use it and I think that's true for these two cards but not as much breaking and entering decisive strike two cost two experience fight with your fist you get plus two fist to deal plus one damage with this attack if this attack defeats an enemy gain five resources So, this is another weird one that I think also adds to some of the confusion in the core set for the rogue class
where this feels like it doesn't necessarily have a home, but I feel like this card is going to um um that this card is going to grow really well. I think this card is actually a very powerful card in the right hands. I just think right now if we look entirely at chapter two, we don't really have the right hands, right? But like Tony Morgan can go nuts with this card, you know? He fights a guy, kills him, walks away up four resources, right? So, one of those things that um I always like to talk about and try to push on players more is the idea of active economy. The strongest cards are the cards that reward you for doing what you are already doing. And Decisive Strike is one of those cards. So, I'm flagging it right now that this card, I'm going to blow your minds, is good.
It's not strong, universally used. It's not a staple. It's definitely better than fine. This card actually reminds me a lot of Backstab. Um, but I do think that this card is very powerful. Any splash rogue is going to play the hell out of it. Um, I'm going to go nuts with this card with Leo Anderson. Like he he's salivating at that economy while also killing an enemy. Um, if you zoom in the face of the guy in the yard, that is the face Justin makes when it gets his economy while progressing the game state. You mean this guy up here, right? The guy in the in the top. Because the one in the front is me being like, "Oh, I took a basic resource action." Uh, for Marian Tvarez. Yep. Marian Tvarez would like this card. Yep. That's a good That's a good shout. Um, yeah, I'm the guy with the pipe. No, for sure.
100%. Yeah. Uh, good card. Um, I think that it's I do think it adds to this kind of like weird conundrum with the rogue core set where it feels less engaging uh because there's no real home for it, but it's going to be a card that I think grows with the card pool, which to me are really nice cards to have in the long term, but maybe not so much in the short term. [snorts] Guy in the front is a typical YouTube commenter. Surely no comment, but you brought peace to this 36-year-old man. Pay the town red. Zero cost event parlay. Search nine cards the encounter deck for a non- elite enemy. Draw it and gain resources equal that enemy's printed health.
Shuffle the encounter deck. Okay, so this card has some upsides compared to kicking the hornets's nest and some downside to kicking the hornets's nest. Downside is it's a parlay. So that's not that's an upside, but not really. Uh the downside is that it uh the enemy is spawns somewhere. So you can potentially get free resources from this if you know a scenario really well. The downside is you don't get a clue, right? Like that's like um am I mixing up downsides and upsides again? Let's just talk about the card. Go back to my first thing about the spawn. Who cares what that is? This card doesn't get a clue. Um this card also is a little bit swingy where you go through the deck and you find like a two health enemy and you're like, "Good, I drew an enemy for two resources." People play kick in the hornets's nest mostly for the clue and the resources are like a bonus. This card, you're playing for the resources, but you don't really get that bonus. Uh, I view this card as future parlay support. I think this card is not an economy card. I think this card is for those decks that want to find enemies because they are a parlay deck. I think with this and silver tongue there is the implication that parlay is going to become more of a thing going forward and it's just going to be something that the rogues and seekers and I think to a lesser extent mystics are going to do in that order of priority. Primary rogue, secondary
seeker, tertiary mystic. That's my prediction and I'm making it here. But for the time being, uh I have a hard time already playing uh kicking the hornets nest. I actually think the card is pretty bad. Uh, in except for some investigators. So, I'm going to put this card in a space waster. In my opinion right now, that's where I think paint the town red is going to live. Two out of 10. The town behind that guy is white and beige. Hey, you're right. It is white and beige. What the hell, guy?
Okay. Press the digitation one cost event fast play on your turn. Play an item asset from your hand reducing its cost by two. When your turn ends, return an item as you control to your hand. Uh this thing and that's funny beard. Uh this thing is uh like slight of hand with some upsides, some downsides. um where uh you can return an item to your hand. So, you can return any item to your hand. So, you can like refill a thieves kit to put something else into play. It doesn't need to be the item you return. Uh difference is also that you don't get a full free reduction, so you do have to pay a little bit for things that cost more than two. Um but overall, I think this is going to be a strong and universally used card. I don't think it's going to be a staple, but I'll be honest, I could see myself being wrong about that. I could definitely see Press to Digitation becoming a staple card.
I'm also very curious if this card is going to be tabooed because there was a lot of um there was a lot of weird stuff that came out with Slight of Hand. Um where I'm curious to see if the similar problems arise or if it hurts designing as much as the first one did cuz like they just play the Necronomicon or if the new designers are just going to be like who cares? Let them let them have fun, you know. Um, yeah. And Dexter can play two items with this fast, which is pretty good. Then return your Doom item back to your hand at the end of your turn. Feels pretty good. Feels pretty good. Yeah, great card though. I think it's going to be uh very very impactful on the card pool going forward.
Out of sight. It's a skill max one committed per skill test. If this test successful by two or more, the performing investigator may disengage from each enemy and move to a revealed connecting location. Uh I think that um like survival instinct because this is practically survival instinct. Um uh I think that this is a good card. It's not really like exciting or fun and you might upgrade out of it, but you also might keep it the entire time, right? Like you could see with their design ethos with Trish's like Finn Edwards ability is that the intention was that each evade you're like just like like just ringing value out of the game, right? like it's not like obvious free value apart from the free evade, but it's like the intention of like what can I [ __ ] squeeze out of this in terms of value? And I think like out of sight is an example of that.
Um, so it's one of those things where like it it might drop down to a fine. Like I can definitely see that being a thing, but I'm curious in the long term. I mean, like, cuz the two or more is a little bit like sticky. I'm not too sure. I'm not too sure. This one's hard to say. Like, it could be fine as well, but I think Survival Instinct is a good enough card that people generally don't play. Um, but they could. Like, it's one of those things that just because people don't like evasion style gameplay, but when they run into evasion style gameplay, they look for cards like Survival Instinct. So, that's why I'm thinking like the same thing for Out of Sight, the upgraded version. If this test is successful by one or more, the performing investigator may disengage from each enemy and move to revealed connected location up to two connections away. I think a big thing for us to talk about is the fact that it's a revealed location. That really does limit um how cards work. This is something that actually happened with a card that Beard and I designed where all the play testing notes we got from it were like, I wanted to play this card, but it was so awkward to only move to connecting revealed locations, right? And I think the similar thing is going to happen here with out of sight where it's just going to be like slightly too awkward to play with.
[snorts] Guys, I kind of want to put this card in Space Waster. Is that controversial? [snorts] H. It's probably fine. It's probably fine. Like I see why you play this card. It's a good upgrade if you have nothing else to upgrade. You know, I'm going to put it up into fine. I don't think it's a space waster. I don't think it's on the level of these things. I could see myself upgrading into this, right? If there was a category for overcosted, and I think fine kind of lives there. And yeah, like three agility is Yeah, it covers most of the bag, you know.
Interesting. So, what do we got here? Two staples, two straw. So, we have 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 eight above the line and six below the line. Guardian only had three below the line. Seeker had four. Survivor had two. So, this is what I mean. Like, I feel like this the rogue pool isn't particularly great. However, I will say to give some credit to these cards, rogue by its very nature and design are a combo class. So maybe this is going to be something that when we see the cards come together, we're going to be like, "Aha."
You know, um I think there is something that can be discovered here that isn't obvious until you guys start to get the cards into practice. But I think what ultimately weighs the card pool down for me is the weird choices on upgrades that I think could have been better if they were other cards. I understand that like upgraded cards are there to kind of give like a direction for players to upgrade their cards into, right? But I think that as a whole, uh, newer cards, like new cards are more exciting for new players because they can be like, "Ooh, what could this be?" you know, but I don't think there's going to be any player who is like, I can't wait to upgrade my sticky fingers into a fast card because that's just like not really that engaging, you know.
Um, as a whole though, I think that what's important is that the topline power is very good, right? Um, the topline power is very good and the strong universally used is very good. Um, and I think that that's going to be a real sticking point. But I also, as I said earlier, my theory now that it's kind of just like come over me is that rogues feel better will feel better because their starting deck investigate, sorry, their starting uh box investigator is much better than Skidzo Tool. She can just play magnifying glass and uh magnifying glass in her hands and then like a lucky cigarette case around her neck and then like sticky fingers to get free resources, right? Like [clears throat] Yeah, it's one of those things where I think it's just uh just a little bit a little bit weird.
How much better do you think Skids would be if this was old Skids with this card pool? I think it'd be a lot better. like just thieves kit, Lawrence, sorry, Olivier Bishop, um the hammerless, right? Like these are all massive improvements. Breaking an entering he can still [ __ ] around with, right? I think just already Olivier Bishop is already a huge boon to him, right? So, I think that this is going to be a weird card pool. And I'm very curious to see um the starter decks as we go through this. And maybe I'll do a similar thing where it's not a core comparison, but maybe just like talking about my predictions for the cards from these starter decks. If you want to see that, you can let me know on Twitch or if you're watching live right now or on YouTube if you're watching the the the VOD when it comes out. But in the meantime, thank you so much for watching. My voice is starting to go away. So, honestly, I'm kind of happy the video is done. Uh, we only have the mystic one left to do. And the mystic one is looking pretty sweet, if I'm not going to lie. Thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one. And as always, piggies.