Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brave & Bold: Bag Building Combat Game Review: Gag Building

Transcript 15:35

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Bassel and today we're taking a look at Brave and Bold bag building combat game. Now this is the combat vault. Um you can also buy a two-player version of the game. that has Supergirl versus Lobo. And I expect they'll be making many, many other DC characters where you'll be taking Batman against Superman or whatever you want. And I was very interested in this game. Very excited because it was looks a lot like Dice Throne, which is one of my favorite games nowadays, and bag building like Quax and Quillingberg and things like that. I love that that combo. Super interesting, and I like the DC universe. So, I was very excited about this. Let's take a look at it and we'll be back.

Here are all the different people who are in the game. The bottom uh eight of them are in the big box that I showed you. Then Lobo and Supergirl. They do fit in this box sort of. Now, the way this game works is to play the game, you need some extra tokens that are going to go in this black bag. And so, [snorts] how you store that is going to be a little tricky where that black bag goes. And in fact, everyone comes with these tokens. So I have a whole bag here of extra tokens, which are kind of just wasted because you only need one set from two different people. So I have one, two, three, four extra sets. And if you buy the big box, you have three extra sets. But when you get some, let's take Lobo here for example. It shows you a picture in the box. You open the box.

Inside is the basically a player for the game itself. uh a component list for that character and then how their special abilities work for that character as well as a picture. And then you have the tokens in here and a bag for that character along with some event cards. And then you're going to be having this board open which will be how you play. Your box is magnetically connected to the board. So it opens up and you're going to have all this information in front of you. Now, on this sheet here, it tells you your starting tokens that you put in your bag. And as you draw things, you'll put them here. When you discard stuff, you put it there. These are extra tiles that you have the opportunity to get over the course of the game. You'll also take, like I said, those extra tiles, mix them with your opponent, and that you'll put them out here. You'll draw from that deck of tokens, six of them that players can kind of purchase in between rounds.

You also will come with a bunch of tokens that match your character. You have these special abilities. There's a lot to keep track of. You'll take your special cards, mix them with your opponent's special cards to form a deck, and each round of the game, you'll be drawing a card from this deck. So, it says if you draw at least seven tokens this turn, during rebalancing, you may reduce the number of these crisis tokens in your bag by one to a minimum of three. And we'll talk about what that means in a bit. So, then players are going to be taking turns. So, the first thing that you will do on your turn is there's the watchtowwer phase. You figure out who goes first. The lower health. Each player is going to start with 60 health in a standard game. Lower health goes first. It might switch back and forth. You reveal that card and then you'll do a recovery ability. A recovery ability is listed on your thing. You're going to this, for example, flash recovers two hit points. Then you draw three from its bag. For each of those symbols you draw, you do plus two. And for each of these symbols, you do this, this, and this, and this, and so on and so forth. So, there's a few things that you will do during that recovery phase.

But then the combat phase comes, and everyone's going to simultaneously do that, where you're going to be drawing tokens from your bag, and you can put them in your current draw or you can place them out here on the different abilities you have, trying to activate those special abilities. Um, what you're you got to be careful for though during this phase is drawing crisis tokens. So, when you draw a crisis token, you'll put it here. When you draw your third crisis token, then you're done for that round. So, what that happens, it means that you have a crisis. You will then uh you're not going to get to do your combat or your powerup. You're going to calculate your total resource pull, all your resources that you've pulled because not everything has to go in one of these special abilities. some things like resources. When you draw resources from the bag, you're going to be able I'm sorry, these are resources. You're going to be able to use those to buy more chips. So, you're going to calculate them and that's going to be equal to one damage for each combat token. So, you do a little bit of damage to your opponent when this happens. Everyone else though is going to get to basically activate their abilities, calculate their total damage pool. So, as you activate these abilities, when you have the tokens on them, they will give you damage tokens that you do to your opponent. Plus, you might get extra things like for example, if Flash has the slipstream, he'll also get this special ability token, which he can use to take the Justice League during the powerup phase. During his turn, you can purchase two copies of the same token instead of purchasing unique tokens. And that's the other thing.

You're going to be able to buy more tokens to put. Also, depending on how much power you have and how much things you draw, you'll get some bonuses that are listed down here in the bottom of the board, and you have little tokens to put on these to give you that extra stuff. So, this is going to take some time for everyone to do. They're going to be calculating your total resources. They're going to calculate their total damage pool. You'll do that much damage um and see how much damage happens to your opponent by calculating it all together. Remember that single single tiles can be used for some of these things. It's possible for you to get your big finishing move down here and then you'll do your power up phase. Both players will do that where they will resupply where they can use resource to buy up to three unique tokens and you just have to basically look here or it's on your card. This is how much tokens cost. You can buy stuff from your own supply, more of the crest, your specials, utilities, a reverse, and then the hall of justice which are the tokens that are between players. Those can be bought and this tells you how much the they cost here. And there's also a critical mass which allows you to do a lot of damage to your opponent if that token even shows up. But then we have the rebalance phase. And I want to talk about this because in the review I'm going to tell you how much I hate this phase, but you're going to count how many tokens you have in your bag total.

And that's how many crisis tokens, the things that you bust on. So at the beginning of the game you have less than 17. So you only have three. But once you go over 17, you need to count your tokens of return and throw that many crisises in. If you have 40 tokens in your bag, which it seems unlikely, you'll have eight of those crisis tokens. And then you'll take everything, throw it back in your bag, and start another round. Now, what I've just given you is a very, very, very highlevel overview, but there's a reason for that. Let's go to the review.

One of the things I hate at conventions is when people come up to me and say, "Tom, what's the hidden gem?" As if I know. It's usually not hidden. But at Gen Con this year, this was the one I told people. I'm like, "I saw this game. It looks really cool." They showed it to me. They talked about how it played. It's very exciting. I'm so sorry everybody to point you towards this. I really don't like this game. This was a huge disappointment for me. Now, quality-wise, the game is very good. There are some issues I have yet. Despite that, remember I showed you that bag of tokens said that was the extra tokens. Nope. I was incorrect on that. Those were extra extra tokens that you don't need at all. That on each sheet they gave you some extra tokens, which is fine. I wish they put those extra tokens in one section because you have to count them out. Some of them have an extra token, some don't. No, there's a ton of I think waste in this. It's the fact that you get all these extra tokens in each set of this that you buy and you mix two sets of these together and it just feels wasteful after a while. Also, it's kind of a pain to store it. Do you store it in one of these boxes and the other one? It doesn't really fit in this box.

Other component issues I have, I again, I like the tokens. They even tell you, hey, coin capsules and and card sleeves work well, but I don't love that the rule book is not particularly clear at all. This should be a really easy game to teach people. I don't love that. And there are symbols and everything everywhere. And you're constantly like, "How does this work? What does this one do? What does this go? Wait, how does that go?" It's just it's just a pain in the neck. And I I Let's talk about gameplay. I like bag building games. I like the idea of pulling from a bag and don't push your luck, you could bust. But in this game, it's once you pull two of those crisis tokens, hey, maybe you should stop. It just it pushing your luck. What What's the advantage to pushing your luck? You might get a couple more good tokens. I don't want to take that chance. And you know how disillusioning it is in your first turn to just pull pull those two as your first two tokens or in two of the first three. At that point, you might as well push through. You'll get a little bit of damage. You'll do a little bit to your opponent, but they might whail on you on turn one. and it just feels awfully lucky. And the push you us aspect doesn't seem interesting at all.

Combine that with that, oh my word, one of the worst rules in any game. I I read it. I was like, this can't be true. This idea of every phase counting up all your tokens and seeing how many of those crisis tokens to throw in. Now, you don't have to do that in the first couple rounds because you have less than the 17 chips. But the fact that you have to do that every turn because you're losing and gaining chips and you have to recalibrate, that's insanity. If they really wanted that in this game, then there should have been a marker that you can mark how many chips are in your bag built into this. It's just it's phenomenally when when I teach it to people, they're kind of like they look at me like, "You're joking, right?" I'm like, "I am not joking. That is a rule in this game.

But beyond that, where's the game? I pull these tokens. I'm like, I guess I'll try to complete this one, huh? I guess I'll try to complete this one. This constant looking up symbols. What does that one do again? And and I know and the responsibility, once you play the game a ton, you'll know it. I want to be able to play it right away. At the beginning of this game, I I said this game looked a lot like dice. Do you know how easy dice is to teach compared to this? Because you have a board, you have like three special things maybe. And there's more complex ones later on, but for most of them, there's three special things. When you roll, it tells you exactly on it what damage you do. And even dice thrones, do I dearly love it does a few things I don't love where they talk about there's a little stack and you can do a card before and after.

And I find that a little confusing and I kind of I can teach people without teaching those nitty-gritty things. This one people are looking and going, "What does this token do again?" Well, that token is money. Oh, okay. And this token, that token doesn't do anything for you, but it's part of a special ability. You can use it or not. And that's even before we teach the special abilities, but nothing about it. First of all, it doesn't feel like the superheroes at all. Sort of. I don't I I don't get it at all. Um uh Supergirl has multiple sons that affect her. we but you you play these tokens out one at a time and maybe it'll trigger ability and then you sit there and do math for a while and you're like, "Okay, this this and this and this." Uh who buys a token first? You're buying a token from this middle pile of generic tokens. It just I was really excited about this.

I was like, "Oh, wow. This game's going to be so interesting because I have my own bag and I can pay two and buy a throw another punch in a bag." Yeah, another punch. and and and there's a bit of that, but I have to look at this chart and see how much all the different things cost and they all cost different amounts or I can buy from the middle which cost different amounts. But then it's just boring pulling from a bag. Where's the strategy? Where's the choices I have? My choice is to stop. And I get that that is the same choice in many bag building games. Quack of you pull and you decide when to stop or not. But that game is dirt simple. This game is not. This is a complex fighting back and forth that doesn't have the game to meet that complexity. The complexity level to how much strategy and tactics are in a game is wildly off the charts.

I'm giving it a five out of 10. And you might say, Tom, that seems pretty high for how much you're beating on it. Well, there's a lot of good things about the game. The production, other than, you know, some of the things I mentioned, the production is off the charts. And I have talked to a lot of people who seem to have a good time with this. And if you go online, you're going to see a lot of very positive comments about it. I might be the outlier here, but I just found this to be so slow, so plotting it. It and and so rules heavy. The rules are clearly written like, "All right, we're ready for the tournaments. I don't want to play in the tournaments. I just want to play the game. Maybe I can get to the tournaments later, but at the be it's a four out of 10. I'm sorry. I I can't give it a five. It's a four out of 10. The art is fantastic.

It's a DC one versus the other, but why all this effort and it feels like it is this soulless bag building thing. I really wanted to like this game. Oh, well, maybe the next one. One versus one games are a a a genre that I really like and I've mentioned a lot of things like dice drone and and I got to be honest, you might say, well, dice run, you shouldn't be comparing to that much. This game clearly was inspired by dice if nothing else for some of the ways that some of the things are worded and shown and in between. But there's a lot of things I just don't care about. I don't care about that deck of cards in the middle. Oo, I might pull your event or I might pull mine. I like the concept of filling up abilities and doing them.

A good way to do that, go look at the Invincible game that was released from Direwolf. And that is a game where you have different abilities and you pull cubes and those cubes are color. I know exactly where to put it. I know what I'm doing. In that game, there's all kinds of cool special powers and all kinds of neat things that can happen and I can teach that and play and it's exciting and fun and not this. Ah, nah. Sorry, brave and bold. Can't really recommend it, but hey, you might have a different opinion to me. Let us know in the comments. Maybe you have a lot more fun with the game than I do. Anyway, until next time, I'm Tom Bassel, and you've been watching the Dice Tower.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games. We do top tens. We play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved