Skip to main content
Loading video...

Summoner Wars Starter Set: Discussion

Transcript 26:15

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we're doing a no run through review for the newest expansion to summon their wars the tundra orcs versus the phoenix elves which is apparently a starter set uh it comes with tokens a i mean a paper paper mat um but apparently yeah you can get the uh the starter set instead of buying the whole box so that's kind of cool uh of course i have the starting set uh so these were just two extra um extra factions uh so josh and i played uh these two yeah these two um against each other we haven't tried them against anyone else um but coming straight from the box and if i'm not mistaken i had friends tell me about the first edition of summoner wars and about the phoenix elves and how they were broken in that edition i don't know if they're necessarily broken in here but specifically with these two fighting the tender orcs suck ass and the phoenix are vastly superior in every game we played the phoenix elves and by swapping because it wasn't just player skill or anything by swapping um i would like to preface i'm only good at magic the gathering these are the the phoenix elves are just superior and even then like if you take the phoenix elves out

of the equation and you compare the tender orcs to other factions like from the base game yeah the [ __ ] the orcs suck like yeah they are not fun to play in any way well so one of the two biggest grievances is uh his ability to boost is only if he moves right and hers is if she attacks but her second ability literally is right afterwards or at the end of the attack phase right i mean technically you can spend his yeah if he just moves he can help people re-roll but her being able to summon people back because the game is built around utilizing your summoner effectively it's one of the strengths of the game you run out with your summoner and use them as an effective like a fighter like regular units you're most likely going to lose um because the how quickly you can just summon units to swarm them uh so you almost always want to keep them in the back um and there's some you know summoners that are more effective getting them involved a little bit more than others uh specifically i do think these two these two are good at coming out to help fight but being able to protect your summoner with cannon father units is crucial and her being able to be like oh i attacked oh now i'm also going to pop someone back to me and corner up you know with with gates and then just oh okay now they're here yeah i'm gonna pull my ember mage which has

guard yeah and it takes one damage if it's attacked yeah only once yeah so you have the first time you have to swarm a two health you know creature uh and so you because you can only attack with three units you've effectively just that one unit being like oh okay i'm gonna turtle with her and bring in ember mage and there's a [ __ ] ton of them in the deck that it's like there's three or four there's at least three there's i think there's four and it's like okay well that's incredibly annoying there are four so grognac's ability of letting units roll like we're just re-roll by spending a boost um i don't think it's good enough i don't think it's good enough i mean he can stack boosts every time you can too right uh and then it's like okay yay they get to re-roll and even then it's like it's not even like that good because yeah you have you have their shamans who are four health and three actually don't think his stacks um yeah it's only if he is oh that's right that's right is infinite yeah so he gets he gets a one-time re-roll and even then he's penalized again by having uh like frost shamans who yeah they're one cost magic four health three attack that's pretty good but if they don't roll a surge then it's like okay they do nothing so he's basically trying to keep his shamans to do something

now granted just like slap him on the back right hey happy [ __ ] stop yeah hit him uh now once again his strength is that he has 14 health and he has got a huge health meter but the health doesn't matter in this game because you almost always hit yeah you may not hit for max damage but you're almost always gonna hit so being able to like 14 health it yeah i think two attacks it's just like okay i think in the like all the games we played we whiffed both of us whiffed once yeah and it was both at range yeah i think and don't get me wrong i i very much prefer that in a game like this because there's nothing worse than rolling like trying to strategically move and missing all the time oh yeah that would be infuriating exactly so whiffing every now and then like very rarely it's just like you're not upset about it it's like oh okay god damn dice yeah and because i'm trying yeah so what what the tundra orcs are built around is swarms they don't need high magic to be able to bring in a bunch of units i think the highest costing thing in there was maybe six uh i mean but they have mercenaries uh yeah yeah splinter or uh the the rat on queso yeah con queso uh yeah after you've seen the moves roll two dice add damage to each adjacent i mean but they're mercenaries so sell swords yeah highest bitter the

other one is literally like hey you can spin magic and summon me yeah well that's some of you they take control of it um which i mean can be effective because it means if i had this person out i mean it's one cost champion unit five health three attack and it's like okay well i put her in a smart position then you can either burn your magic to just take control of her or just allow me to but that could easily backfire because it's like i'm gonna back up and then you're like oh yeah i think i'll take the magic and now i'll have her attack and kill your unit uh he does have other like champions like shank uh when this even attacks add one damage to the target for each surge rolled instead but that's he rolls eight dice which is insane um like literally all dice so in this case it would be one damage one damage because he only hits on surges and stuff melee attacks i see yeah it's not in addition so he rolls a lot but one two two damage and he has 11 health i just don't like anything it doesn't feel balanced whatsoever i mean the freeze freeze spell the event or the freeze should be that should there should be like four of these in this [ __ ] thing freeze should because if you're if you're supposed to um swarm them with weak units you oh there's two of them in here uh like if you're gonna try and move like you're you're summoning her back it's

like oh actually but then she can't be attacked yeah uh so really what you do with that is you keep her in there and then you swarm her with your units and wait till their next turn i see the theming they were trying to do because like i have a an ability or an event called burn two damage to a unit within x amount of spaces away from my summoner whereas you have freeze the difference is mine is just damage direct damage freeze makes it to where you can't the unit can't move attack or be attacked oh sorry it's not you can't even be there somewhere uh and it's like well if they're frozen that's when you want to attack them right they can't attack back it shouldn't it definitely should have an errata where it's like i'm going to attack this unit all i want yeah yeah i'm going to try and shatter it yeah uh this reminds me you were talking about like the burn and the freeze kind of thing it reminds me of like death battles like on youtube whenever they just come up with a theme and find two fighters but you obviously know one of them is way more powerful one is like dumb it's just like oh man let's do uh let's do like fire you know benders let's do zuko versus the guy from my hero and it's like well zuko can only do fire but the other guy can do fire and ice oh i wonder who's gonna win that where it's very obvious that there's a very there's a powerful definite gap in power somewhere yeah it's just for this for the tundra orcs

they're they're i feel like they're too restricted because they're not the only and that's they're not unique and then they summon a bunch of people no because every day well yeah almost every deck does it but i mean goblins do the goblins do it the uh the rat um i think his name is rat skellig i think is his a rhett talus he's like he's a necromancer he does it um so these are just like a mild sub theming to each of them it's like ah i can bring my stuff back from the discard pile yeah i mean smasher is pretty good because he costs three six health four and but once again he takes extra damage he takes extra damage and then like you have cards like this that take ah smasher [ __ ] x amount of dice oh it's always one damage yeah so the tender orcs suck the phoenix elves are really good oh yeah like i don't know if they're busted as compared to the because i didn't play the first edition of this yeah no i i i don't remember either i was just told specifically because a friend of mine hated the fee he loved first edition hated the phoenix elves because i don't remember why he said they were they were broke they were probably something similar to this very i can't imagine that they would change too much you're right asymmetrical nature of another build so in this particular instance the phoenix elves are also quick at getting

units out um very quick damage like your ember archers just like move and then just ping with someone for one damage i was i'm not gonna lie i was really surprised i was like he didn't play as many units as i did whenever we when you played the elves and i played the orcs no i actually didn't yeah you did not play i played way more units than you did i burnt them i got more champions out yeah um which is i mean that's something with summoner wars the more i play it the more the and i and i like it but it can be frustrating if you are how your gameplay goes is going to be luck depending on what you draw uh so like the first game we played with them we had no extra gates no and then whenever we whenever we swapped and played again it was just like boom boom like we literally both are first turns we had three gates on the board yeah and uh and then yeah i brought out champions i brought a few champions out here but uh it's like oh man i got this chat saved up i got this champion out oh burn okay two damage and then i'll just block everything with the ember mage uh it felt with the tundra orcs against the elves it felt like it made the moving and the attacking like very restrictive very pointless on your end right because i'm just like okay well i can't i can't do anything because you can summon and block your summoner uh or i can do the same thing and

i just i i like the phoenix elves i think they're really good but because they're they're a burn deck like magic they're very quick damage uh but in a game like this where i know one major change they made to some of their wars was less health uh because they wanted the game to feel quicker so units die all the time yeah so having a quick burn deck is very powerful because you gain magic every single time um you kill your cards kill an enemy unit so it's like oh yay like i summoned all this stuff i mean whenever you summoned a bunch of units like i'm like oh okay he's dead he's dead he's dead okay that's three magic thanks it just it felt incredibly unbalanced specifically from this starter set which is incredibly frustrating because if people don't want to buy the base game they want to be like oh i'll try to start their set i feel like they're going to be very upset they're like wow these elves are great these orcs suck yeah and these are the only two decks i have so then you're one either feel you feel compelled to be like well i have to buy a whole game now just to see if how they compete against other things right or you uh lose a customer because they're like this game [ __ ] sucks because half of it doesn't work right yeah and i mean and the orcs are also not the only faction to be dealing with like ice and stuff there's literally another ice like the girl at the top

um of the of the box i believe she's iced no she's humans it's cisco this one yeah they they look actually identical like she's got braids yeah yeah the the face the face itself looks like i think it's the exact same person it's probably uh maybe they're twins or something just artists in the lore i don't know but yeah so she also does ice things now but she does like ice walls uh but i i i mean because there's constant the the events in the can i see the phoenix the phoenix deck please there's constant events in here that i just thought were way better divine retribution oh okay yep if you attack my summoner or anything units that your unit takes a damage divine retribution i already just said that even their champion vanessa is really good nine health and if you attack her if it's if she's still alive pings you for a damage yeah and with some of your units only having two health yeah that's devastating yeah especially because if you like your units at least for the tundra orcs if they want to be like rampaging and like uh you know uh uh chaotic you shouldn't like some of them that are like the charging ones should be like blood rush they take eight damage but their health is two it's two so you already have they're free but if you're drawing cards and you're not drawing all of them at once to then boom and then have them rush forward then you're very limited

say on my first turn in our first game i quite literally had seven units on the board you only had four uh three three yeah you didn't even summon anything on your first turn yeah because i started using my summoner like right away and then the royal guards are really good like they attack i mean they roll one die but you're most likely going to hit and it's like oh okay i hit you for one final shove you and you another deal another damage which then kills every single unit the tender orcs have pretty much amber beasts if they start their move adjacent to anyone then they deal with damage then they get to move yeah then and then hopefully you know live to hit everyone around uh they can be summoned by any other friendly ember unit yeah and one of the i believe that there's a champion in there ember drake so you could just play now next to the dragon um yeah and this unit the fire drake can be summoned uh adjacent to your summoner this unit may attack through units when it does a surge adds one damage to each unit between this unit and its target so it could just melt an entire and it has ten health eight it costs eight to summon and it does four rules four dies uh but still those you may summon ember units adjacent to this unit so that's like a second summoner they're just so yeah they're just so quick like imagine if you got queen the queen out and put a gate on the opponent's side summoned her adjacent to that gate and then you just

start summoning emerald units whole army on your side of the field yeah what are the orcs got oh i can i can move freeze yeah boost boost my god my boy over here he ain't hitting [ __ ] ride the frost shaman and then i'll re-roll everything and he misses a second time and it's like god yeah i mean some of their events are really good uh i mean primal furious but i mean grognak should have like 20 health yeah 14 is a little light when you've got specifically against them 14 is most likely decent against every other like i would i would imagine like i said we haven't played these against we played them specifically to focus on the new event the new smasher is good i mean i'll take a three six health person because you're not always gonna roll surges so they can he can stick around for a while um that's all i got man these these these works suck but yeah i was trying to look through for some of their events brutal force i mean like if you can somehow flank like their units like let's say flank the summoner with regular common ones which most likely won't happen because most people don't bring their summoner out yeah uh but if you could do that that's the only thing i can think of is if like let's say you flanked the queen and you just dealt piddly damage but each time you attack her she gets forced and you can force her out like and then it's like oh hey now you're with now you're next to grognak and then he hits

you for four uh it's uh i mean but that's that's not going to happen no there's just no way because then they're going to be dead before they can the fact that these phoenix elves have resilience and the damage output that they do makes them a very high caliber faction yeah um so i can honestly see these going toe-to-toe with almost all of these probably and probably beating several of them fairly easy yeah because i've played everyone i've not played the water chick but i've played yeah i've played or scene played everyone else um and they're all good like all six of those i feel are balanced uh but these two i just do not see balanced against each other yeah so i mean really what it comes down to is don't buy this if you don't own the base game yeah is this i don't know what this costs i think thirty dollars this is not a starter setting yeah just like just scratch that out this is a supplement yeah it's an expansion to that uh because then you get more factions which is always good i know the first edition have a bunch uh it hasn't changed my opinion of some of yours i this is uh also a skirmish game oh i guess there is a second one that i really like uh i don't mind it like summoner wars is

really fun yeah uh just because even though you pre-built it maybe i know they're adding i don't know if they've added it yet but they did plan on adding deck customization it's not just pre-built these are pre-built phoenix elves are really good pre-built um but maybe there's maybe you can combine cards to make the tender orcs good but as the as it is as it sits you are buying the starter set specifically just to have more of the game yeah in our opinion uh yeah so uh on a scale of one to ten we'll we'll rank both of them separately um because i can't really rank the starter set as a as a whole um so it's just easier to rank the individual factions okay so the master set versus the starters no no the the two the two yeah the phoenix elves and the tender orcs we'll rate them separately yeah okay um the tundra i mean the phoenix cells i'm gonna give a nine oh yeah like they're super good [ __ ] stacked it's but it's frustrating to fight against them because it's like it was always something it's just like oh man i might be able to nope okay uh and then i mean i even got rid of your main gate just trying to freaking get like access yeah just trying to clear out your gates just to just to get them out of the way um maybe that's just what they do maybe you just send them forward just to constantly destroy their gates so then they can't summon anywhere but then once again the counteract to that is the

phoenix elves have some have units that summon directly someone directly next to them so it's like okay great they're walking gates yeah she's a mobile gate and then you have four gates in your deck and i got shamans who can't hit unless they roll a [ __ ] i mean once again i mean it did happen but with that role that would be an amazing you know our arranged role except in this case i didn't roll a surge so they miss uh yeah so the phoenix you said a nine mm-hmm yeah i agree with you there it's not perfect but it's like they're [ __ ] stacked they're really good yeah uh the thunder orcs i'm gonna give them a four i think they're below average even if like i mean yeah i can see potentially some combos going off but you have to search and they're not fun i didn't have fun playing them uh i actually really agree with that i was thinking of four also uh just below just right below average um it's cool having a summoner that has a [ __ ] ton of health but his ability is kind of ass yeah because re-rolling sounds good initially but you're almost like you're guaranteed to do damage and there was an instance where i had i used his re-roll to try and one shot your uh royal guard and it worked and i was like yay but since he can't stack them to just constantly re-roll it down the fact that she can stack her boots and he can't is that alone's a

heavy heavy unbalance yeah like i get it he's got more health he's got i mean mobile troops to be fair and this is actually a really annoying way to play this game and it's happened i've actually played the game like it uh because he has 14 health all you do is you just summon the piddly units to go forward and you time out the the game because if there's no units left alive and you cannot attack your summoner takes damage so really all you do with him is since he has 14 health he'll be able to outlast so if we just killed everyone's units and you and you know he had to run away and then she had to chase after him then and then he just summoned something for free just to guard like she would it's like okay now we just time it out to i'll have five extra health if we if none of us got hit and we just took the attack damage you in nine rounds you would be dead and i'd still have five health yep and that's just a shitty way to just stall out a game i like and i would i would hate if so if i knew someone was doing that like with the orcs i'd be like you win and then i would get out yeah there's very very few games where you ever like want it to go to time yeah like hardly ever uh you i mean you would love for it to go to time if it was close but it's right it's not close yeah like if you're playing a really close game and then time happens to run out and then they're like okay and you're like oh [ __ ] i had 22 health and you have 23. that'd be frustrating but at least you were still

fighting back and forth but literally just using him to run around and then just kind of like oh time to summon you know a shaman you know just real quick have him come out and then because he'd have a re-roll and she and just to keep like your summoner at bay just to keep him from running around he's like oh you couldn't attack me like you taking damage that would be and it has come down to a game like that and it's very frustrating uh it was luckily we have not it wasn't frustrating it was boring yeah like because like that's kind of we both had like i like i had like very little health so it came down to the summoners of a grudge match but it got very boring so but yeah um what is that that'd be a 9 13 divided by two so i mean i would i guess make the starter set the 6.5 if you averaged it out like that that's slightly above average yeah total because the elves are so good are so good yeah and i and i was like whenever we were playing i was like i feel like that was the faction that that i heard was broken uh i'm like well they probably fixed it at least not against these two all right so that's our thoughts on the tender orcs and the phoenix elves everyone let us know what you think of them in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful every time update is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the

channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved