Skip to main content
Loading video...

Railway Porters Review: Rolling Luggage

Transcript 25:15

Hey there everybody, I'm Mike Delisio.

I'm Zee Garcia.

And today we're going to be talking about railway porters coming from Sashi and Sashi, a Japanese publisher. He's done a number of games that we've both uh reviewed and uh uh come to be a pretty big fan of his stuff, but he doesn't work with dice all that often.

He's done it a couple of times, but you're right. This one is very much a dice forward game. Um a little push your luck, a little dice placement, uh little interaction between the players.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah, well, let's head down to the table. I'll give you kind of an overview of how it works. I do want to state up front that I'm going to be talking about uh the rules as written in the rulebook, but I'm also going to be covering what are called expert rules that were released a bit later, uh but only downloadable on the web right now. So, I am going to talk about both of those. Let's head down and we'll be right back. All right, here we see railway porters. Each player is going to have a set of three double-sided boards that are lettered from A to F as you can see here. All right. They're also going to have six of their own individual luggage dice. One of the players will become the head porter, and that can be chosen randomly, and they'll take this uh token here, and they're also going to be in control of these two larger dispatch dice, which you will see. The head porter is going to change at every station. The last thing you need to do uh to get ready to to the game is they suggest for your first few games, you start with the A board as the first station you're going to play in that game. You're going to be playing through five of the six stations. So, you have these tiles that represent all of the other stations. What you do is you just shuffle those up and then you remove one at random without looking at which one you removed and you place the other ones face down.

Meaning that of these six boards, you'll be playing through five of them, but you don't know which one you will not be playing. Each station that you visit is going to be comprised of several rounds and each round is broken up into five steps. So, let's just talk about those. Um, whoever is the head porter, the first step is going to be to roll these dispatch dice. So, they would take these two dice, they would roll them, and they'd place them on this board. Now, if there was ever a time where you showed the same face on both dice, you need to reroll one of them until you have two different dice face showing. So, here we've got a yellow die with two hands showing and a purple die with one hand showing. The next step is that all the players will simultaneously roll their luggage dice. All right? So, you'll roll your dice like so. Let me make sure all of those are on camera. The third step is that all players will simultaneously place out their luggage dice onto their own board. So, when you're doing that, you have to be looking at the dispatch dice that were rolled. Okay? So, in this case, the two colors that are uh available to place are yellow luggage dice or purple luggage dice. The other thing you have to keep in mind are the number of hands that are on there. So, if you choose the yellow dispatch dice, uh you have to place up to two yellow dice if you have them. Well, in this case, I do have two yellow dice. So, if I wanted to

play yellow, I would have to place both of these onto my board in the yellow slots. If I only had one yellow die, I would place that one. Right now, the purple, looks like I don't have access to it here because there are no rolled purples. However, there is a black die, which is essentially a wild die. And so, if I wanted to, I could instead of placing the two yellows, I could place this black die as a purple. Now, each board is going to have a different rules of placement. In the A board, it's telling you that um all the dice have to be placed from left to right. That's what these little double arrows show you here, okay? And all the boards are going to be handled differently. I'm not going to go into a lot of detail about how the different boards work, but just know that they all have different ways of being placed. So, for example, this C board doesn't have those double arrows. So, when you place dice, they can be placed anywhere. They don't have to be from left to right here, okay?

But, in this case, they would. So, if I chose yellow, I would be placing those right there. If I chose purple, I would be placing this one right there. Now, let's say for a different example, I had something like this. If I chose to do to do yellow, I could not choose to just place this one yellow. I would have to treat that as if it were a yellow and place it there, okay? Again, if I were choosing to place it as a purple, I can still keep this and put it here. Let's say that instead, I had a situation like this, okay? [snorts] Where none of the dice I have are valid. I have no yellow dice, I have no purple dice, and I have no black dice. In that case, that's considered a failure. I would have to choose one of these dice, it doesn't matter which, and I'd have to put it in the failure area of the bottom on the bottom of my board. There are two failure spots. The second time you fail, if you do, you have to place it there and then you are out for the rest of that station and you're going to get some penalties, which I'll talk about in a moment.

After everyone has um placed their dice or potentially failed, then the head porter is going to conduct a roll call, which is the fourth step. And that means that they in clockwise order, they're going to ask all the other players if they either want to continue to the next round or not continue. If players choose not to continue, what they're going to do is they're going to immediately go to scoring. They would score their board and then they would take the appropriate uh scoring tokens right there. Otherwise, if people are going to continue, then they're just going to go through this process again where the head porter is going to re-roll these two dice. Everyone's going to re-roll their um the the passenger dice they have and they're going to place it out. So, uh in this case, I have no purples, but there's a black hand showing, so I could either put out one blue or one green.

One because there's one hand, so I can still do that here. Okay? If when you choose to not continue, you have dice that are left over, so let's say that this player was down to two luggage dice and they chose to not continue, what they're going to do is they're going to have a handover, which means that they're going to choose one of the dice and they're going to place them in the depot area of the player to their clockwise uh from them. And then, if they have another dice, they would place in the depot area of the player next clockwise as well. No player uh will be given more than one by the same player. The rounds are going to continue to go in this fashion doing those steps I showed you until all players have chosen to not continue. That means that at that point, everyone has conducted scoring and then the fifth step would be to prepare for the next round. When that happens all the dice get cleared. If there were any dice that were handed over to other players, they would come back so that everyone would have their six luggage dice again and then you'd flip over the next tile, find out what your next board is, in this case it would be E, and you would move on to that board and you continue to do so until five boards have been played.

When you go to another station, the headquarter moves on to another player. In the last round of the game, all of the scoring is going to be doubled and so that's one thing that you keep in mind is that you get a chance to double up whatever the last scoring board is. After all five boards have gone been done and you've done the scoring with double scoring the last round, whoever has the most points is going to be the winner of Railway Porters. Now, these are the basic rules as they are printed in the rulebook, but I think it's important to note that the designer, Sashi, has created expert rules that have been updated or excuse me, have been uploaded to BoardGameGeek and they change a couple of things. I do want to talk about them here because this is an official rules addendum that is available and so I think it's important to include it here. The main change with the expert rules is that now you're going to have a new board. This one is just printed and it's going to change also how the head porter moves. In the original rules, the head porter only moves when you change stations. Here the head porter is going to move clockwise every time the the dice are rolled and placed. So that's one big change and that's denoted here is that it changes after every die roll. It also is going to be changing how the scoring works. So unlike in the original game, you're not going to be

scoring these uh completion bonuses uh depending upon how many dice you have left over. Instead, you're going to be getting bonuses based upon when you go out, when you choose to not continue. The first player to choose to not continue is going to get a bonus of 20 points. The subsequent players, so in a four-player game, players two and three to go out will get 10 points. And whoever the last player to go out is will get no points. So, in a two-player game, the first one to go out gets 20, the the last the second player would get none, but in three or four-player games, you have some people in the middle there. What it is also saying is that the last player to go out, when they do decide to not continue or are forced to not continue, any dice they have left over are worth minus 10 points each. So, it uh is a risk to stay in longer because you can score more if you stay in longer potentially, but you're also taking a bigger risk. The other big change is um overtime mode, as they as they mention it right here. After the first player goes out, any subsequent round is considered to be in overtime mode. And what that means is that if you fail to place a luggage die, it immediately has to go into the second slot of your board, even if you didn't have a die here, and you will be going home that at the end of that round. If you do fail

while in overtime mode, you still can potentially get a bonus here uh if you are eligible for one, but you're going to get all of your points halved. So, some similarities to this original mode, but you're definitely taking more of a risk by staying in longer. And uh so, that significantly changes the game in the fact that the head porter changes every roll is significant because the order at which you go out means so much more and so having that shifting makes more sense in this mode of the game. So, those are the expert rules. They are available on BGG right now and it doesn't really change any of the components other than you can print out this secondary board here. All right, well, that's going to do it for the overview. Let's head back up and let you know what we think.

Okay, so there you go. And like I said, it was a pretty wide wide level overview. I didn't go into how each of the individual board score, but the central core of the game is going to work the same. The scoring is really what's going to be different on those different boards. So, I think you have a pretty good idea just based off of that. We can talk about the production first, I think. The artwork in Sashi and Sashi games has been divisive, I think it's fair to say. I adore it. I think it's very charming, but I have heard people that don't particularly love this look across his games.

Yeah, it's always the same style, right? Same artist, so it has this very whimsical feel to the the the whole thing and I think his theme choices go really well with the look of the games.

I agree.

The games tend to be whimsical. This tend to be sort of gentle themes for lack of a better term. Things like getting in an elevator, going on a trip, welcoming people over for dinner, dancing. I mean, like really, you know, this is about, you know, putting away luggage, right? The themes tend to be very digestible, very easy to understand. They're meant to be sort of universal is the idea. Um And the game's target, generally speaking, are very much targeted at families, at I think he said, you know, playing with grandmas and kids, something like that, right?

So, uh I think the the look of the the the the feel of these games goes right in line with that. I think it's a good match, you know, they're well done that way. Um and the production, I think, is very good. Um the dice are nice, they're well put together. I like this box size, everything fits in there well.

Good quality cardboard. Yeah, it's a good production, for sure.

Yeah, and I think to keep this box size, uh the actual player boards themselves are not hard cardboard, but they're perfectly [clears throat] fine for the purposes of this game. I don't think you're going to have any issues with that. So, I agree, it's a very nice production. Um now, gameplay-wise, this is one where um the first several times I played it, I played with the rules as written in the box, which is a very family-weight type of of a rule set, where, you know, you're you're rolling a couple of dice that are going to determine how everyone is placing dice. It's not a complex rule set. The only things that are maybe a little bit kind of um off the beaten path, I guess, would be the idea of every time everyone's rolling dice, you have this roll call. Are you going to stay in, or are you going to stop and score? And if you have dice left over, you might be passing those on. There's a little couple of quirky things that I think take it out of the you know, filler type of a of a of a game

gameplay.

Yeah, I think so, too. Uh quirky is a good way to put it. There's a couple of ideas here that are a little off the beaten path. Um And they take a little getting used to. Uh they are worthwhile having, I think, for the sake of interaction, things like that. But, there are a couple of things that are kind of quirky. The the perfect example of all of these kinds of choices is the fact that every score in the game is multiplied by 10 needlessly. There are like the least to anything is worth it's is 10 points. But, there are no five-point pieces. Like, there is no such thing. So, it has that sort of Yu-Gi-Oh! idea of this monster hits for, you know, 720. It's like, well, it could have just been 72.

Yeah.

And the scores at the end of the game reflect that. So, it'll be like 520. I have 610. Well, that could have just been, you know, 61 52. I don't like that. I think it's sort of a weird artificial a ballooning up for no good reason. Uh but, it it show it goes to show you those little kind of quirky moments have seeped into this game or maybe just part of the DNA of the game, and that's that's okay. It's neither here nor there.

Yeah. Uh I think where the game kind of uh shines is in those different station boards. Because the core loop of the game is the same. It's a very simple dice game. You're placing them hopefully. Maybe you have a failure and that, you know, it can can have some penalty involved. But, you are having you're placing dice with restrictions based upon color and based upon the number of dice that you're putting out, and then you're throwing in the wild cards of those black dice, which may force you to to place more dice than you might have wanted to otherwise. But, the different scoring boards, I think, keep it fresh. I have some that I like more than others. Sure. But, even the most kind of vanilla basic A board is perfectly fine. I think if that were the only board in the game, then no. Um

I could see that being like a little, you know, you get you're you'd get bored of that much more quickly. Yes. But, I do like the idea of the it some nice play room for design when the dice are placed, you know, the the purple for example. You can only put them out one at a time. So then the designer is able to go to say, "Okay, well, they they get richer quicker."

Yeah.

Because you're you're you're having a harder time sort of deploying them. Whereas like yellow, you throw out three yellows all at once, you know. Um And that's interesting. There's a there's a nice um There's a nice give and take there. There's some neat ideas. There are also some ideas that feel like very much that were left on the cutting room floor. The idea of running out of dice first does not incentivize anything in this game, at least in the rules included in the box.

Yeah.

Which Michael will talk about the advanced rules in a second here. Um So running out quickly is not necessarily, you know, something that's advantageous for you. So doing it isn't really good. Um Dropping out sometimes with a single die left doesn't feel advantageous. You can just sort of like even if it's your first bust doesn't really penalize you too much. There are some ideas that feel in some ways on the one hand kind of game-y concepts. Like, "All right, calm down. You're playing with people that aren't thinking about this." On the other hand, not a whole lot more to implement and might have added a little pizzazz, a little bit of like a ooh, a little more tension. Um So there is that. But I do enjoy the cadence of this game and the feel of the game. I like playing it.

Yeah. And I think that's a perfect segue to talk about the {quote} "expert" rules. And uh because I think you're you you touched upon an important point, which is that you know, push your luck is an element of this game.

Yeah.

But under the basic rules, maybe not as high a level as it feels like it should be. It doesn't feel as impactful, especially when you're down to one last die, and the penalty is like, "Well, I mean, I'm risking 10 points here. I might as well." You know what I mean? Where um what the expert rules, I talked about them in the overview, but that really changes that completely. It It very much changes the importance of turn order,

Yeah.

you know, there really turn order doesn't mean a whole lot. It It does in the basic rules in the sense that you may get past dice, and that'll impact whether you stay or or go out. But, it's much more impactful in the expert rules. And also, when you go out becomes a much more impactful decision because, you know, you're into that overtime mode. As soon as somebody drops out, everyone now, you bust one time and you're done, and your score is halved. Um so so I I feel like the game is much better with the expert rules. You want to teach people that haven't played a lot, you know, that that that aren't, you know, regular gamers, sure, you can play, and they're not going to really care, probably, about the push your luck being not as impactful. But, for people that play a lot of push your luck games, like I know you and I both have, we wanted a little more teeth, and the expert rules, I feel, does provide that.

I agree. Um there's some graphical issues you're going to have to deal with if you do choose to print that out and play with it, but it's an option. It's out there. It's online. It's not in the game box, right? You're not getting that. You have to go seek that out. But, it's uh it's official. It's been put out by the designer, and it is nice. It's a great way to play the game. I do wish there was an interim position that had been provided, whereas maybe even just the overtime idea of as soon as anyone's out, you now will just bust straight up if you miss. So, you have to decide if you want to be in or out. And honestly, I might implement that myself into the game because I think it's a good idea. The overtime idea is good. Everything else is nice, but then it clashes. I cannot you know, the iconography clashes with what's printed there. Um it's nice that it's been provided. I appreciate that.

Yeah. Yeah, specifically the iconography on the failure spots don't apply when you're playing with the expert rules. And so that can be confusing to players is like what do these mean? Well, they don't mean anything the way we're playing it. Yeah, so that that is an issue and and it's important to point out. Uh did you want to go into final thoughts?

Yeah, I'm ready. Um I like this game. I think you know, Sashi and Sashi makes a lot of interesting games. Uh there's been ups and downs. There are some that I've really really liked. Some that are you know, keepers forever for me and some that I thought were pleasantries, but not something that had a lot of staying power in my opinion. I actually think this is one of the better ones in a while. It is uh it feels distinct from a lot of other recent ones that have been generally card games. Um I like the the the cadence. I like the way this game makes me feel while I'm playing. That idea of rolling a couple of dice, okay, I see what I need. I chuck my own thing. I might have a a choice or two, but they're they're simple things. This game kind of buzzes along at a nice even clip. There's no high highs and low lows. There's sort of a pleasant game to play. And yes, the more I played it, the more those little kind of issues have have bloomed for me.

But I think it's they're the kind of issues that when I take this game off the shelf and show it to someone that is not worried about who is Sashi and what games have they done? Is this the latest game you got from Essen? The people that are not asking these questions, I think they're going to have a good old time with this game. I think it's going to be incredibly pleasant, fun, just a a good time. Um I'm giving this one a seven out of 10. Um I like it. Yes, I would love to see those expert rules officially implemented, something printed officially. Maybe a second edition of this could do something like that, find a nice in between. As it is right now, I definitely recommend it. I think you're going to have a good time with it.

I'm a little bit higher, I'm at an eight. I I really tend to like his design philosophy, right? And and this is just right along those lines. And you articulated it fantastically, kind of the idea of what type of experience he's trying to provide, who he's going for, who he's targeting as far as people that play his games. And this is these games are like a warm blanket to me. You know what I mean? And this is I I agree with you, one of the better ones. And I I like when he plays around with dice. Um It it's not He usually is more of a card

Right.

uh type of a designer. And and I like what he's doing here with the dice. And so, an eight out of 10, I agree with you. There are some some things that I wish had been cleaned up a little bit. Uh they've already announced new boards, so that's exciting. And I do feel like if you are playing with people that have played a lot of push your luck games, you probably want to throw in the expert rules. Yes, it it means that you have to go on to BGG or on to his website and print off the rules. It's one page. Um but I think for a widespread audience, I agree with you. I think most people are going to just have a pleasant experience playing it. And it's a a lovely looking game as well. All right. Well, that's going to do it for us. I'm Mike Delisio.

I'm Zee Garcia.

And may all your luggage be correctly delivered to you. Cuz look.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things we review, games, we do top tens, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved