Emerge – Nothing a Little House Rule Can't Fix
Transcript
hi my name is Ben this is board game dad and today we're talking about the two to four player game by pandasaurus games emerge but in this review I'm going to be talking about the game with a house Rule and you may be thinking that that's not what a board game Reviewer is supposed to do I'm supposed to review the game according to the rules as are written in the rule book and that's a fair point in fact maybe even Panda Source games Who provided this review copy won't like it either but this is the company that published Machi Coro and Machi Coro 2 so something tells me that they may be fans of game revision and in any case I am going to argue that the house rule is essential for this game so here we have a merge it's all set up but the way I have my camera framed you can't see the entire uh game board that's because it is enormous it's over 3 ft long so let me show you what is off the screen so there's nothing here except land and that is where the supply of birds is supposed to be located and there's also a round tracker it starts the game by moving to space one and every round new discovery tokens get flipped over the only other change I've made to this setup is that in a normal
game players begin with their starting Island over here in the corners but in order to display everything within the frame I've put the starting islands in the middle uh there is no significance to where the islands are the only significance is when these tokens come up so what would normally happen is these tokens would be down here the islands would would be over there instead and then the tokens that were here would be revealed once the ship gets to that location but we're not even going to play an entire game so I will put those tokens there and it won't have any effect on teaching these rules so emerge is a competitive game with the objective of scoring victory points and there are two ways to score victory points the first way is to achieve objectives during the game and these objectives are competitive with more victory points for the first person to accomplish it and fewer as subsequent players obtain those objectives so we have up to 20 points possible over there and then the main scoring method is going to be by building these islands now thematically the game is about Discovery so it's not building Islands it's discovering Islands but the way you represent Discovery is by adding tiles to the board and they emerge they erupt from these
volcanoes in the ocean so as you discover them they get taller and taller and taller giving you these layered uh pieces and then as those islands grow they're going to be getting life forms on them so plants and crabs and turtles Etc at the end of the game you are going to score points equaling the product of all the life forms so in this case I have three multiplied by the height of the island so 3 * 3 this island would be 9 points the first thing that's going to happen is the round marker is going to advance that's going to reveal more Discovery tokens these Discovery tokens can be picked up when an island is placed there and if the round marker passes a die those dice get distributed to the players so for the purple player the yellow player and the red player so you'll start with six Dice and you'll have up to 10 during the course of the entire game now the next thing players are going to do is they're going to upgrade or modify their player boards so modification involves taking one of these tiles and placing it somewhere else on the board now it's advised in the rule book to take either a plant or an island and place that on top of the seal you'll see why in a minute I'm just
going to go ahead and place that there and then all players simultaneously roll their dice so I'm rolling seven Dice and all of these are going to go into their spaces now when all players have done that in turn order beginning with the start player they're going to perform an action as determined by the role of their dice so one action I can do is to add trees to My Island if I pull this up closer we can see that the first tree is wor is going to cost one Dy and the second tree is going to cost two Dy the third tree for three D now because I have that placed here I actually have a total of five dice that can be spent on trees for a turtle I would need three Dice and I only have one here and for an New Island I would need at least two dice but I only have one here which is why we use these modifier tiles so you can see that it says I can add one or two to a die so on my turn what I could do is I could either plant trees I can't add any turtles because I can't afford it and there are actually a few more requirements for Turtles which we'll talk about in a minute um and I can't do an island or so it would seem but if I use this tile I can add
two to my three and that becomes a five which places that here now I can perform the action of building an island so I will take those off my player board and I would choose any location on the board now the location doesn't matter for scoring but it does matter for getting these Discovery tokens so for example I might want to use this ability or this ability or if neither of those appeals to Me Maybe I just want to uh take one randomly so I could choose maybe I'll choose this location and now I've earned the ability to place one crab for one die so I'll keep that over by my player board and every other player would take one turn performing one action using their dice it would come back to me and I could build a tree so I'd spend one die to place the first tree on this island now both of my Islands have one tree so when it comes my turn again it's going to cost me two dice for the second Tree on this one and two dice for the second Tree on this one now I don't have to use all my dice let's suppose for the sake of example that instead of uh rolling ones I had rolled uh two
threes okay I don't have enough to place a turtle not only that but another requirement is that you can't have any turtles if you don't have any crabs and you can't have any crabs if you don't have any trees so there's actually a a food chain or a hierarchy in these discoveries here uh you can get a crab next then you get a turtle then you get a seal so in the first round of play there is no way to get a seal because you need to have a turtle and you can't have a turtle without a crab that's why I use the first turn to cover the seal the only one that doesn't require uh having something lower on that food chain is the birds birds can go anywhere whether or not there's a tree whether not there's an animal uh and there's two ways to get a bird the first is to spend two dice so if I had two sixes I could spend two dice to just take a bird from the mainland way over here and when the bird comes over it lands on my Island and birds carry seeds with them so a plant would come with that bird and regardless of how many trees are on my Island it's always going to bring a tree and in fact you can have up to four trees on an island and adding a bird is the only way to get that fourth tree because you can see here
that using dice I'm only allowed to go up to three tree uh three trees so I could either bring a bird from the mainland or if the bird was on another player's Island I could spend three dice to transfer that bird over to my own Island and that would also grow a tree so this is one way of stealing victory points from your opponents and does not require any other life to be on the island when you do it anyway to go back to my previous example and we'll put the bird back if I have two threes here it's not enough to place a Turtle but what I could do is I could just keep those dice right here and I could wait for the next round or what I could do is I could use one of my tokens at any time during my turn so this token lets me Place one crab for one die I would discard this take a d of any number off and add a crab to an island okay or the last thing I could do is I could discard any two dice regardless of the number they don't have to be matching even if this was three and a five I could take two off and I could buy a token from the market okay the One requirement of buying
tokens from this Market is that once you begin buying tokens you can no longer perform any actions up here so I would always save that for last so now all players have done this they've all taken their turn when we're all done oh the market gets refreshed we do this again so round counter moves up everybody modifies again so for modification I'll add that you can always discard a modification if you wish to on your turn that's free but there are two acceptable moves either you can move modifications around they all get refreshed in a new round so maybe I'd move that to cover the bird or something or I can add I can either move around or add I cannot do both this continues for8 rounds with players getting more Dice and more modifiers now those are the official rules and that's how I played the game when it was first introduced to me at Essen Spiel however when I Tau the game to my family I immediately introduced a new rule and I want you to understand why so the thing with this game is assum as soon as your dice are rolled your plan for the round sort of unfolds automatically and very little of what other opponents are doing is going to influence it there are only three ways in which opponent's actions
can influence what you do there is the placing or stealing of birds the achieving of objectives and The Taking of uh Discovery tokens from the market but all of the actions concerning trees crabs uh turtles seals and even growing your Islands doesn't have any influence on other players at all so waiting for your turn in order to do those things is not very engaging so what I've done is I've broken that Discovery phase into two parts the first part are the first five actions all of those actions that don't influence other players we perform all of those actions simultaneously then once everyone's done with those first five actions the second part is the placing of birds that has to happen in turn order because who you're stealing the bird from is influenced by turn order so we do that and during that same phase people can buy the the discovery tokens from the market those are the only things that are done with uh turn order into consideration now with this house rule there is still one contradiction or two contradictions remaining the first is if you're placing Islands simultaneously there is competition for the discovery tokens that are available on the board so one way to resolve this is to just leave the discovery tokens
face down for the entire game however if having the discovery tokens face up is something that you want what you can do instead is you can place a player piece on the token you're interested in and if multiple people choose the same token you can just resolve that in turn order there's also the matter of achieving objectives what we've done there is if multiple players achieve the same objective in the same round we just let them Place both of their player markers on the same number of victory points I highly prefer this house Rule and in fact I haven't played the game with my family without out this house Rule and I don't want to because as the game goes on you're just getting more and more dice so your turns are just getting longer it's much better in my opinion to just condense that by letting many of those actions be perform simultaneously so that's the house rule take it or leave it now let's talk about this game in terms of its theme mechanics components strategy and complexity as far as theme is concerned while I appreciate all of the figures that are used to represent these discoveries uh the rules are more motivated by the scoring mechanic I mean them aut atically there's no reason why you can only have one crab or one turtle or one seal and there's also no reason why a turtle can't be on an island without a crab being present it doesn't make thematic sense it's just there for the mechanics of scoring so this is not a very thematic game uh it's a very
attractive game and I'll talk about components in a minute here but for theme I'd say this game is no more than a three whereas for the mechanics there's a few things I'm looking for there one is to what degree is the game motivated by the mechanics and this is definitely a game where if you like dice actions if you like games like Machi Coro you're going to like this game for its mechanics regardless of the theme there's that and then there's also how engaging is it so for me the game becomes substantially less engaging when you're taking turns and I would give the game a six for mechanics but when it's done simultaneously there's actually sort of it's a lot of fun to to manipulate Cate your player board and then play the dice and make an optimal plan with the limited amount of luck mitigation that you have I would say for mechanics the game is about an eight four components there's two things I'm looking for when I rate components one is how the game looks and the other is how the components function so you can just tell from watching the game is very very pretty and I love the wooden components I love the color the problems that I have with the components though are all about how they function my first issue is how big this game board is there's no reason for it to be that large it actually interferes with gameplay when the only thing that it's doing That's essential for gameplay is counting the the round the round counter
that's all you need the the relative space between the islands doesn't matter it doesn't matter if you're adjacent to somebody else or not you could just have your four Islands in front of you without a board at all it actually interferes with visibility you've got the the market of tokens that you have to it's way over there and then the pieces are way over there you it would just it would it just isn't conducive to how this game is designed if there were objectives that were related to adjacency then sure a a board would be justified it's there to look nice and that if it if all it does is look nice that's not s satisfying to me I'm also disappointed there's no player eight at all there's nothing on your board that says that a tree is required for a crab and a crab is required for a turtle you just have to know that there's nothing on your board that says that a discovery token costs you two dice you just have to know that um there's nothing that tells you what to do during you know each phase of the round in terms of the steps that you take or the order that things are performed there's nothing that tells you that you can't buy Discovery tokens until after all of your Discovery actions are done you just have to know that all of these things it's not a complicated game but also it wouldn't be complicated to just put a player Aid on the player's board and I don't I don't know why it was left out unless they just didn't want to clutter it because they they wanted the game maybe to just look just just just to stand out for its
components in terms of its beauty it's beautiful but that has to be in addition to being functional in my book so I would give the game for components rating a four other people wouldn't other people probably give it you know an eight because it's it's very attractive function first in my book that's that's what I look for um for strategy you know you look at this game you think especially in the first round there's no decisions to make the dice tell me what to do but that's not the case especially as the game goes on and you get more and more of those modifier types there is plenty of decision making now this is not you know some heavy strategy game it's still a strategically simple but there's more than it seems at first sight for strategy I'd give this game about a three and for complexity you know I wish there was a player guide there are some rules that really need that but it's still not a lot of rules for complexity I'd probably give this game A two my final thoughts on emerge the thing is we really like this game we like it a lot and we like it more every time we play it every time we play it we add the house rule so can I recommend this game absolutely but I also think that emerge 2 is right around the corner or there will be some expansion that that addresses some of these complaints that I have the complaints are there but it doesn't mean that I'm not loving this
game um I also would recommend this if you've enjoyed Machi Coro but the thing is Machi Coro the dice are telling you or determining way more of what you can do in your turn and emerge has a great deal of added flexibility with those modifiers so act in my opinion I like this game more than Machi Koro I think it's an improvement um and you've heard everything I have to say about what could be different but that doesn't take away from the overall experience for us because it is so easy to adapt thank you for watching this video uh if you have enjoyed this Channel and if you would like to participate in discussions with me about the games that I'm coming out with the lists that I'm going to be publishing soon this week the patron members have been discussing the top 10 family games of 2023 so if you'd like early access to what I'm about to release and if you'd like to be conversing with with us there on the Discord Channel details about becoming a patron member are in the description and if that's not your cup of tea if if uh supporting as a patron isn't something you're interested in there's also the perfect board game.com which you can always check out it has all of the family recommendations on there videos and much more that's my personal website um that is just very rich resource in
many many features on there if you'd like if you haven't taken a look at it please do other than that thank you again and I look forward to seeing you next time bye-bye