The Isle of Cats Duel - Board Game Review - A Tail Of Two Cats
Transcript
hi everyone I'm l k this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games but usually more the ranting part well it's another one guys yep because every freaking franchise needs to get in on the DU front whether it's seven wonders k Tokyo to kaido you name it there is a dual version for just about everything these days so at first yes I did kind of roll my eyes thinking well the aisle of cats now has a du version but then I kind of thought to myself well hang on a minute the big clunky big like massive a of cat as I said can get a little bit on the clunky side I don't want to play it with a lot of players it takes way too long it's not a short game by any means it takes a while to do all the different rounds and do the Drafting and do the scoring and the public lessons and stuff and it's like oh yeah and then that flip and right came out I forget I forget the exact name but um you know I gave it a pretty decent rating it allowed me to play the AL of cat solo with a pretty decent solo mode or maybe with two to three players in a roll and right fashion well flip and right I guess I don't think there was a dice in it so the idea maybe that this one is for two players only might work who knows worth a try so you know will this actually replace the other two that I have just mentioned or is this going to be another forgettable entry in the door like the Dual Universe I don't know it might as well be its own Universe by now but we're going to have to wait and see I think not baby puppy so if you played di of cats you already know the gist there's a bunch of cute little kitties on an island and you're trying to save them you get them on your boat and it's a polyomino Tetris Style game where
you're putting all these different shaped pieces on here as efficiently as you can although being efficient isn't necessarily the aim of the game here the way it works is that it takes place over four rounds each one playing pretty much exactly the same you first set up the central board with a cat tile on every Green space but then also with some lesson cards so some of these might be Instant Power Cards on the card spaces so you're effectively going to have about 10 cats and about five cards out this osac cat you know the legendary cat per se will start at one corner and then essentially all these spaces have got Footprints between them and on your turn you can move this cat up to two spaces and you're allowed to take one of the items here from either where you started where you've passed through and where you finished so effectively typically you can pick from three different things if you take a card it might be a special instant ability it might be collec tiles but most of the time it will be a lesson card which scores you points at the end of the game so seven points if you've got the largest family of cats for example and there's a bunch of unique ones in this deck but alternatively you'll go onto a cat tile which much like the original game you've got a board with several rooms rack tokens rack spaces a minus one point and the idea is is that you will place your cats however you like on your board so first one's got to go pretty much anywhere as long as it doesn't hang off the edge and then subsequent cats must tach at least another tile that you've done so you have to S build out from where you started but what you're essentially
trying to do with the cats is you're trying to cover up the rat spaces cuz they're minus points you want to try and complete as many of the rooms as possible because that's minus points if you don't do it but the primary thing that you are trying to do is create families of cats so basically a family of cats is three or more cats of the same color touching each other by an edge somewhere doesn't matter how you do it and there's five different colors in the game so there's a lot of different you know colors that You' got to try and get on your boat but you obviously can't get huge families of every single color you got to pick and choose your battles and of course the lesson cards might gear you into certain things like for example nine points you have exactly five purple cats on your boat okay well I'll get a family of five purple and then I'll leave it at that and I'll think about other colors the round carries on until players either consecutively pass twice or everything's taken off the board in order to pass you basically move your cat and don't do a selection for that round sometimes you don't want the tile sometimes the cards have no interest to you or sometimes you just can't physically reach the space you do have fish tokens which give you optional actions like say move the cat further take two tiles teleport the cat to somewhere else you know but essentially it's all about mitigating the movement and the spacing on that board rinse and repeat for four rounds and then then you total up on your score pad for points for various size families all the lesson cards minus points for the rooms and rats and then see who's got the most of course yep not a lot of rules there and honestly if you've played aisle of cats most of this is pretty familiar getting the cats on your board building the families being
efficient covering the rats using the lesson cards all of that treasure tokens fish tokens the works pretty much 99% identical to normal Arab cats the main difference is how you select the tiles and cards in the first place and also the fact that fish tokens in the original game had like a a special use whereas here they're basically used to do optional actions which is mostly to take treasure or move around this board but the selection mechanic is pretty much where this game differs because all of this on your board is essentially identical it's all about the selection idea so normally in the big game you drafted the cards uh first so you drafted cards some of them helped you take more cats off a selection of t in the middle of the table some got you more lesson cards you know some were used for specific abilities and such but here you primarily have lesson cards that score you points at the end of the game there's a few that get you treasures and the odds few instant ones that get you extra fish but that's about it for the most part they are blue lesson cards and all unique the C tiles exactly the same artwork as before the same style of polyomino as before it's just the fact you've now got this little cat moving across the board and selecting your tiles so with everything being quite similar to the big game do you actually need the big game anymore I got to admit I'm actually thinking you might not because really the only thing that you miss from this version of the game compared to the big one is really
mainly three things firstly you can only play this with two players so there's no solo mode and you can't play this with three four five okay fine but then I never really wanted to play all of cats with more than four and even four was a bit of a push they you also lose the drafting phase so you don't draft cards or anything you're moving this piece around the board and collecting stuff I can take or leave losing the drafting phase honestly because not having the drafting phase means you don't have those extra cards which were like you know ripped up baskets that you had to do and foots for init feet you know boots for initiative and stuff like that you don't have to worry about here it's just alternating turns and finally the last thing that takes away is the public lessons which I didn't really care about anyway you didn't have that many public lessons out in the big game and they were just fiddly to deal with people missed out what they did it was like ah whatever it was a half decent idea but whatever if I lose them I'm not really going to care but other than that everything you do on this board is the same if you enjoyed all the tetris putting together of the tiles trying to keep the family of cats together trying to satisfy the lesson cards or whatever all of what was in the big game is here in a much more condensed package the rule book really easy there is no ambiguity here it's got the color guide it's got the you know the different like it's even got lore for the cats I don't think you quite need that but it's got scoring examples it's got you know pictorial examples it tells you what each section of the boat is how they set up it's not a big rule book at all I mean we literally from the first bit just said I got to play this game we got out of the box I read through the rule
book once over we knew all the rules never had to look up another rule again it was that easy but you know everything else is printed on your board you've got the the scoring system on your board for the families and the minus tokens it tells you all the actions you can do with the fish all your board is easy enough to look at and the cards are simple enough that you don't need any kind of FAQ to really explain them it's just super simple super easy Al of cats was never that heavy a game it was pretty easy to get but this one is just even lighter and even you know even less complex the selection board mechanic d it's sort of in two minds on the one hand it's very simple on another hand it's you know you do have site of what tiles are available what cards are available so basic on what you can see at the start of a round you know what sort of things you can aim for and chop and change tactics on your own board but I do missed the drafting phase to an extent but I never really found it difficult to get from A to B on this map you know you can spend fish actions you know one fish to move an extra space with this thing you know two fish will teleport it to another space well you've got footprints that go between the spaces and there's so many of these Footprints between the spaces that it's pretty easy to get to where you want to go without even having to spend any fish let alone having to spend that much fish now you don't get that much fish during a game in fact you pretty much only earn it from occasional rare cats that give you a fish or from the instant cards which typically say gain a fish Max free for doing some particular thing but
other than that yeah fish aren't that plentiful but as long as you're not spending the fish to constantly get treasure tiles all the time which is two fish per two you know you could spend three fish to get two things in a turn I mean that's pretty cool but I don't know this didn't feel quite tight enough you know the cat is there and yes you might be restricted oh I got to spend a fish to go over here but I couldn't really block the opponent from getting what they want all you can kind of do is gear them in a Direction so that they'll take a cat that they particularly want so that you can get a lesson card that you particularly want but at no point do I go right I'm going to go over here and I've denied you a purple cat ha not unless I actually take it myself maybe I don't want to take it you know that's the thing so this whole moving around kind of just feels a little bit unnecessary not to say that it's terrible but you are basically more playing the cards and the tiles that are on the board and thinking about whether the opponent is likely to take certain ones over others then you are really caring about the Restriction of movement on the board because really it doesn't feel like much of a restriction but it plays in a very quick time 30 minutes on the box and that's pretty accurate 45 absolute tops for your learning running game if you're taking your time you know but 45 minutes should be the absolute Max this takes you can get through four rounds in about 30 to 40 minutes with ease because the round don't take too long you've got essentially 10 cats and five cards on this board between the two of you so you're probably going to take about seven or eight things each depending on whether you end the round early or not and once you put it on your board you're
done move on to the next player turns a pretty quick turns are pretty Swift yeah there's not much else to say this is a of cats with two players what board do you really need to know you don't draft the cards anymore you don't have the whole basket boots thing and it's not a flip and riser there's no like dice or you know flipping up cards or anything like that and you don't have public lessons that's basically the only difference other than that I get the same level of enjoyment of placing everything on my boat than I did in the big version so do I need the big version I don't think I do honestly I honestly think that this if you're happy with only playing this with two players there is no reason to own the big version grab this instantly why why grab the big version of two players it's just not worth it but then if I want to play a of cats multiplayer I'd rather play the flip and right one that came out because I think that one's better it's quicker it's less clunky than the big version of a of cats so between that and this two-player version I honestly don't think you need the big a of cats anymore I think it's now pretty much redundant it's a huge box tons of stuff in it the expansions added way more cards and was physically necessary and the game takes quite a while to finish and is terrible with like five or six players really do not play a lot of cats with a massive group just take the flip and right version and grab this one for two players simple that's all I do I just wish that maybe this whole movement mechanic around the board was a bit tighter that's kind of the main weakness of this game this doesn't feel
restrictive enough to enable you to block out other players from doing stuff so the cats duel gets a fine seven out of 10 from me it's decent it's good I give it a seal of endorsement and I think it's probably the one to go for if you want to play this with only two players it's quick simple and has that same Tetris feel but if you want to play it multiplayer then maybe you'll have to go for the big version but then honestly I think the flipping right version is a better game than the big version so just grab that one and then at least you can play it solo so you know the world your Royster you've got free effectively to pick from it's up to you what you want I'm just telling you that this is a pretty solid in the whole jeel universe it's one of the better jeel versions I've seen you know I mean it's not going to measure up to the levels of Seven Wonders duel or anything like that but yeah this is definitely a pretty decent one so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please consider subscribing to the channel your viewership and engagement helps to keep this channel going and for the you patrons out there your funding to the channel helps keep this afloat so if you haven't subscribed to the patreon please consider doing so by all means let me know your thoughts which of the three do you prefer the a of cats duel the a of clats flip and right or the big a of cats give me your reasons why is there any one of these three you particularly dislike and why I'd like to know your thoughts and comparisons until next time remember regardless as if you are willing to abandon this cute little kitty cat on an island all by itself you monster it's still only a game so bye for now