Honesty, Hype, Positivity and Bias (Topical Ramblings)
Transcript
hello everyone this is Cinema and this is Johannes and you are watching board gaming rambling and welcome back to topical ramblings where we talk about different topics that we want to ramble on about this is basically a continuation of our last video we did on paid content and previous today we're going to talk about other things that are being in the content creation hobby lurking around and some people might find this video unnecessary but we we just want to talk about it because we find it interesting and would like to share our thoughts on it which is basically why we make all videos that we make is to share what we think about stuff mostly board games and board game related thanks today yes you were taking over and I was trying to not do it so we continue um I just think that openness and transparency in these topics are important to see if our channel is the correct one for you so remember that everything we say in this video is a lie yeah no no way it's it's not that's that's the other thing so today that was a very good transition to talk about what we're talking about today today we're talking about honesty yes we're talking about why many reviews are positive yeah we're talking about hype and we're talking a bit about bias a lot of topics into one videos we're going to try to keep it under half an hour and see how it goes so some topics we might talk like deeper about some might be like just some comments here and there if you have any questions how to how we
do stuff just let us know in the comments and we will answer let's start talking about honesty lately there has been kind of people murmuring that oh reviewers and content creators are not honest they're both and they don't say their meaning and stuff like that as in the last video we cannot talk for anyone better self because we don't know what's going on into the side the brain of anyone else um so let's start by talking a bit about why people think that yes and the reasons for not being honest yes that people come up with is that you get free games so then you want to continue to get free games yeah you want to maintain a positive relationship with the Publishers which equals free games yes and that is basically kind of the main reason I'm I'm seeing and of course paid stuff as well but that is a completely different category of things because it makes no sense to make a negative video that you got paid for and we talk more about that in the other video let's talk about the and we're gonna really not we're gonna talk more about like the free game stuff in the bias section of the video um but for me like the big thing and there I haven't asked to quote it's not going to say who said it but it was a really really nice things that in a discussion about this and that is there's no like
hidden agenda there's no uh conspiracy theory trying to trick people into buying bad games no in in which case we're not a part of it no we haven't heard it we haven't got included in that money making we haven't got that memo of people because that makes no sense no like there's so many games coming out each year and and so many of them are horrible and most of them you're not gonna see people talk about and and and there's really like I cannot fathom like the the thing that people people think that you are lying to make people buy a game so let's talk just briefly about like it's not a biased stuff let's talk about like the continuing to get free games because of course getting a free game is a perk whatever I'm gonna say like whatever because I said in the last video and I I stand by that that that's not like the I don't mind paying for a game doesn't bother me at all but the free game is obviously approved what I had to say is that any good company is not going to stop sending you again they think you will like if you didn't like their last game because of course if somebody has a party game for eight to ten people about drinking alcohol and being rude they might not send it to us don't do it because we need to probably have a bias against that if I'm not gonna like that game yeah but it doesn't really make sense like let's say a company I'm not gonna name any companies
but let's say company a send us a game that they think will like and most of the time we probably would like that game but then we ended up giving it for example a five or a six then the next time they make a game which is fits perfectly for us it doesn't really make sense for them to not send it to us if they enjoy what we do like it's all about all of that stuff it's more important and I think honestly very many companies really um appreciates yes honesty yes because they also see the value in that if we are highlighting some negatives for us other people might find that information really useful and that might be a positive to them maybe not like bad components and stuff but I don't know I hate these guys I love that but like in general a lot of information out there is really good for your company and also the fact that like few games we play are bad yes we are specifically trying to play good games yes because there's so many games and we kind of play them all we're going to talk more about that pretty soon just one thing that's kind of like a pet peeve of me is that every time we make a review and other people make negative reviews and not gonna name any like names you always get these comments like thank you for the honesty thank you for being brave and honest and stuff like that and we never got that on a positive review no because positive reviews aren't it looks cool I don't know I kind of get
it because it's it's it takes more of you to say a bad thing about the game than a positive okay yeah about a game I feel like it costs more of me to say negative stuff than to say positive stuff and it is like that for humans all across the line in real life we find it much more easier to agree with someone than just take a stand and disagree so I feel like it's it's a valid point to say thank you for highlighting this negative things but I am I hope that the people making those comments doesn't think that we are lying when we are making positive reviews no because I hope so that's not the case positive review it's because we like the game yes not because we're lying so basically like the conclusion of this we're gonna go to the next topic because of honesty it's basically you need to find people that you enjoy and find people that align with your tastes yes and we try to to make a Balance review and I think you should search for reviewers that make a Balance review just not like all positive not all negative to see like yeah both sides yeah but manually yes we do I'm like when I'm writing notes for it I'm like okay what is it negative to say here like there's some maybe there'll be like a small thing but it's not really a point to have a lot of negative points just to happen yeah which yeah you don't need that and and and and so many reviews end up maybe feeling even more positive because of that but it's really
like I don't like try to find something just to find a negative thing it's not that all reviews need to have that negative it might just be like hopefully the reviews we make gives you a feeling of if this might be for you or not and that is basically the only thing we try to do the review it's not like if I give it a game an eight you need to buy it no because that's not how it works yes let's briefly talk a bit about why many reviews are positive yes and it's a little
have it all in one video it's nice anyways uh we do this as a hobby and most reviewers do so we want to spend our time playing good games we don't want to play Bad Games because this is our hobby so we want to have a good time yeah so like many games that like if we play a truly horrible game we probably might not review it and because different reasons like one reason is the the times that we do the times that we for example within two one Legend we made a very negative review of that and and I think like the reason the times that we do make this kind of more negative reviews is for games that you have heard about it's for hot games it's things that because we enjoy people watching our videos so it makes no sense if we play a small little game that nobody has heard about that was horrible it makes no sense to make a view of that and put it out on 50 people are going to watch it because that's what's gonna happen because you never heard about the game and you're like oh it's a negative review why do I need to this game is bad why do I need to watch this review while playing these or doing like these reviews for smaller games that we really enjoyed those make sense yes um also because when we review games we spend more time playing them so if we don't have fun with a little bad game I don't want to play it anymore yes because I don't like it but say we play a really nice small game that we are excited about we want to play that more
and we are also excited to share with you that hey this is something that you should check out yeah so that's kind of like a small reason why probably if you go on look through all our reviews many more of them have like a positive like a feeling about them because we want to play fun games and all this is a hobby in that kind of same thing let's talk about hype yeah because things are getting hyped and let's talk let's not talk too much like about Kickstarter hype because that's like another kind of thing with the pre-launch hype and all of that and let's talk a bit about like we probably end up being in like if a lot of people like a game and a lot of reviewers talk a lot about the game probably people are going to be hyped up about it because people care about the meanings of others and and so many people saying like this is kind of my my in to this topic is that for example we played Federation give it a 10 out of 10 and be like oh we love this game and then we might not play it for five years yes and but it still again I really still standing by what I said and people are like oh but you play that a year ago and loved it and now you never play it again and now you never talk about it and stuff like that these are comments that are coming in this kind of oh but you did you hyped it up and then it died and as I said before we do not play board games like normal people no and I would guess that most reviewers do not no we we play games specifically for reviews
or the wish of making content and then we move on because there is new games we have to keep track on what is coming out to be relevant for people yeah and it's kind of like as I said we we play something new we get like wow this is the most amazing thing ever played four times put it on a shelf and then be like oh never gonna play that again so you cannot really reuse reviews yeah and I would say most reviews I think so to know if a game is going to be fun after you played 10 15 20 times because we cannot play a game 10 15 20 times before we review it review it and we don't have time to play it in in um like continue playing it even though we really liked it yes I think like Cult of the new yeah that is a thing yeah and I feel like keyboard colors like a great kind of CounterPoint to that and I see like many many people are more and more enjoying like finding the great games for 10 15 years ago but new games are still coming out and I love Keeper Girl for that because we get a balance yes both it or play life but also in our in the channel but I love a new game yes you have always been searching for new stuff and I felt like even before we started a channel even before we started reviews you were always chasing the next new game and you've always been like that I feel like yeah I always like to
exploring before we started reviewing stuff I didn't really care about when the game came out it was more like oh yes this new game Raul talked about it this new game Tom talked about this new game on bdg or this thing oh top 10 of these kind of games yeah and always like exploring and that is kind of but now the way we explore is kind of playing the new thing yes and and also because we the more we play the more of the great games from the last 10 15 years we have already played so I always like I'm not like chasing a new high that's not kind of what we do but it's basically a great excuse for me to need to play all these new games because we have the the channel so that we can it makes sense to play the new games and and right now we have quite a few new games and I have to choose like which of these do we want to review which of these do we just want to play for fun and which of these are going to probably be on the shop for another year before we get to play them but what I'm trying to say basically this is about hype and I absolutely get hyped for games yes and when I do and I try to like when I get hyper game after I played it I will talk about it and I will be hyped about it and I will say like I will try to say that if you like the same kind of stuff that we do if you have watched more than five six seven 10 15 20 100 videos of ours you probably know what kind of games we like that's not the same as saying you will love this game but it's saying that if you enjoy kind of the same kind of games we do it as a high chance that you will enjoy this game and
and it's kind of we yeah I don't know do you yeah but yeah we we get excited and we want to share it with people so yeah um because it's a hobby basically yeah and hi let's talk about a little bit about hype because hype is kind of said to be a a negative thing hype hi hype hype hi Hi and then people get super hyped up and it's hard then man let's say I'm super duper excited to play this game and it's harder to meet those uh expectations expectations yes so I never liked the first time I played a game I was super hyped about it can go either way and but I'm always trying and this is like one of the most hard things for me to do you are really not almost never that hyped about again no because you are doing all the research so I when I game hits our table I I don't know the rules you have rhythm and you teach it to me and I have very few expectations going into it but I will say that I get hyped for for example I've heard different mechanisms that really click with me or I know that oh this is from a designer that I've enjoyed working before then I get really hyped and that might be a bias actually if the same game was produced like not from the tallest Serena would I enjoy it that much or do I enjoy it just because it's without but he's doing amazing stuff but that is also interesting though yeah but that's for example like Federation we
just heard the game was good yeah nothing more really I didn't know anything about it and it's nearly a perfect game that and I don't care who made it I don't know the designers I think like it's the first design they did and so I think that like also to your question I think like it's yeah we play paid full price for that game also just well so it was damaged so I got a discount but I think that that's kind of like a designer bias yeah we're going to talk about bias right now let's do it let's talk about bias bias is a base it's a hardware can you describe what is bias what is bias what is bias maybe you don't hurt me it's a factor that is there that will influence your opinion or your decision about a thing it can be a positive bias or a negative bias do you know like the dictionary definition of class no why why do you die no no it's just wondering if you knew but yeah basically as you said line there is something in the way of you being completely object objective about something yeah and I feel like as a human being in general we have biases every single day towards everything in our life and it's it's hard to go in a world with all these um things around us not being colored by them and change our view based on what is around us if you're not living under
a rock you have bias in your life but let's talk about boring game related bias yes let's do it first off we're going to talk about a few different ones let's first talk about the bias against or four as I said like mechanisms or Publishers or designers for example I am not a huge fan of co-op games so every time I sit down to play a co-op game I'm a bit negative about it and I know that and I think it's important to know your biases that you can kind of try to look past them but it's harder for a if I sit down Playbook replacement game it's gonna it's starting like I'm still starting at a positive sign yes and so when I play a Corp game I'm like oh this is a Corp game probably gonna be super boring and then if it's not boring I would be like wow it's even better and probably I get even more excited about it but the fact that I don't like them usually is a bias yeah it is and that also is important for you to know when you're watching our Channel and we try to say it also in reviews let's say we are reviewing a co-op game you then will say I'm not usually into code games and you have to know that to know if the reviews will have what kind of meaning it will have for you personally I don't think that that's an important thing that is kind of like the the Small Things the thing that you learn when you you watch us and then we have kind of like the two other big biases yes which is the first one is realize real relationship relationship bias and the other one is kind of we I have called it
when I written down free game bias yes let's start talking about relationship bias yes I feel like this is the biggest one for many reviews and I think also us and I I I think it's very hard to be completely free of it when you're uh in a such a small industry yeah all that it's so small they are but basically that that means that can can we be friends uh with Publishers and designers and still review their games uh Fair completely unbiased I I think Fair we can yes but I'm biased we cannot no and I think it's important like we it's kind of like it's kind of for me it's kind of it goes over a line and then you feel like I need to say it for example every time you review something from our porter games yes I have to tell you that we know these people we are friends with these people but if you go and check the reviews we made for reporter games you're gonna see that we have treated them almost the same as situation everything else and it's kind of like I'm I'm doing my completely best yes to treat it exactly the same as a game from somebody I never knew a publisher I never spoke to but the only thing we can do is basically let you know it's there and I can be aware of it and I can try my best like I think Alex from Morgan Cole again is I think he did a recent one but like his first read about bias he was like have I given a game like a a
3.5 which would have been a tree and I think he said like yes I I have probably done that but I don't it's hard to pinpoint it it's hard to be like oh it's because of that or it's because of that um but for example let's take um revive the most here which I gave a 10 of 10 and you gave a 9 out of 10.99 I think uh and I I am 99 sure I would have given that no mother who made the game because when I sit on a play the game I don't really think about knowing the designer no I'm not saying thinking oh Christian did this or or I live kind of did this thing I don't think about that when I play the game when I play the game like okay this is a great game and then I'm like oh it's cool I know these people because they made this great game yeah so it's kind of I'm doing my absolute best to differentiate do I agree I am sorry yeah no um I think that you just have to decide if if you think that we are the a channel that you can trust but I think as you said we are not perfect but we are trying to be we are striving to be the most objective and unbiased as we can but with relationship bias in such a small industry that is hard to be completely unbiased but we are trying okay so let's talk about free game bias yes this is one that if you have like decided your case on it you're probably never going to go the other way but it's
when it's hard I think it's very hard because it's kind of um I was I was uh taking um aeon trespass I was lifting that big box up the stairs so we could play it and I was thinking I was never saying okay would I feel differently about picking this game up playing this game if I paid zero dollars or if I paid 250 dollars and okay this is I think this is a very hard one because let's put it the oh like it's kind of like many people also say that when you pay 200 for something you have a stronger bias towards liking it yes and that is kind of like it's so hot it's so funny because I feel like people are going both ways on this because everyone when somebody gold puts a Kickstarter game and it's rising on on Board Game Geek people like oh it's all the uh Fanboys on Kickstarter who rate it high because they paid a lot of money for it and had to like it but then they also don't like us playing the game and not paying for it and talking about it so it's kind of it's kind of like a a a both sides of the coin is biased in Wing yes and I think that it's hard to decide which one is more biased because I think it goes either way but it's been a lot of research on this field but if you pay something for it you will have a higher chance of finding it appealing than if
you get something for free that is really interesting and 10 years ago in 11 years ago I ran a stand-up club and we there was a lot of talk in the stand-up Community then in Norway about there was like one place in a city that did free stand-up and people like smaller spaces as well but it's like a big space that is free standard free entry and people are like that is stupid because when you pay that let's say you pay five dollars or ten dollars to get in you are much more likely to laugh because you have invested something in it and you need it to be worth that investment if I invest nothing in it and I go in and I sit down and be like oh this is not funny I'm not gonna not gonna laugh about that of course it's different when you get the product for free yeah maybe I don't know I haven't read up on this but I think that it goes either way sometimes you can be biased because you got a game for free or sometimes you can be biased because you paid a lot of money for it might be influential I must say that I have no control of what you have paid for and not because I don't I don't have contact with the Publishers that's kind of good I seldom no which games we have gotten for free and which one we have paid for we try to disclose that in the beginning of reviews but I have basically made up my mind before we start filming
i i i this is one it's it's one of you just have to take my word on I know it's kind of a bias and we talked about the honesty part of it I don't it's not a wee we talk negative about games we got for free we don't think about Davido playing sweet but on Kickstarter I mean talk negative about games that we bought in retail but I am I do my absolute best I don't I'm gonna say this now and you might believe me or not but I don't care where the game came from it's a game and sometimes we get to play games that we never would have bought because we get it for free that is kind of like my that's not the perk for me I wouldn't have bought this game now I got it and I really liked it or I would I bought this game no I got it it was fine we played it we might talk about it or not and and I I don't I don't I'm pretty sure that like 95 about that bias I don't really care no because I am just happy having the game playing the game and if I like it I like it if I don't like it I don't like it it's let's say let's say like like Alex said like might it be a 6.5 instead of a six if we got it for free you know we know the designer or we have a good relationship maybe I don't know I don't know but I'm I might have done that I might have skewed it like a half a point or a point but that's not really the point of this it's it's basically what's in there like the review score at the end that's not the
end all done all that's just like the point like if it's a big difference between a two and an eight but like a 7.5 and 8 that's kind of like a thing that happens in my brain it's kind of like a small thing like that uh so just we try just tell you if we have a personal relationship with the people who made the game or if you got it for free yes and when you know that and you know what we said here I hope that is enough to basically know how to take the things we're saying yes does that make sense yeah absolutely I want to quote um Flight of the conquers here on the last video um a case is not a contract but it's very nice and it's the same with um review copies yeah it's not a contract but it's very nice and that is the end of this video If you enjoyed us rambling about this topic or you enjoying other videos that we do and you haven't yet given us a victory point then you can do so because it's very very easy for you and it's a big deal for us how do you do that let us know you give us victory points when you click that subscribe button down there so make sure to click it and click the Bell button get notifications every time we post a new video and that is the end of this video right here I'm Johannes and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and bye bye