Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 122: Sebastian Bae on Littoral Commander

Transcript 59:45

thank you it's at break time I'm pleased to announce that the Beyond Solitaire podcast remains proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to amazing things first their latest game 500 year old vampire is on backer kit through August 16th and you should go and check it out Link in the show notes second it's time for another year of courses for clgs's certificate in applied game design Damon Stone's class core Loop finding amplifying and refining the fun starts on August 28th and you should absolutely go and register for it as usual I also want to plug my own patreon which can be found at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire if you enjoy my work your support would mean a lot to me my patreon money is what lets me be on site for con coverage it lets me pick up copies of unusual games to play for the channel and it also helps me upgrade the equipment I use to film and edit videos with that said let's get on with the show hey Gamers this little series for Beyond Solitaire and I am here today with a very special guest Sebastian Bay how you doing Sebastian it's great to be here thanks thanks Liz so Sebastian is a repeat guest for those of you who don't know he is a professional War gamer and were you working as Sebastian I work at the center for Naval analysis excellent and you were a teacher I know that you taught in multiple locations but tell me where you're teaching now so I teach at Georgetown now in the center for security studies which is a graduate program that looks at your National Security and defense issues

fantastic so those of you who want if you're still going to school and looking at Master's programs I'm just saying there's an obvious obvious destination for you um but uh the last time that you're on the show uh we actually talked a lot about your war game class and how you teach people to design games and what's awesome is that since then you've had multiple games kind of Hit the market like I just saw a tweet about malign today which maybe we could talk about briefly but your main one at the moment is littoral Commander so talk to us about the signs that you've been doing where they are and then we can talk about where literal Commander is going yeah so I'll save the troll Commander for last um because that's really a great topic to transition to but currently we're looking at two main projects that are about to hit the streets uh one is with catastrophe games is actually a set of two games um that I need to talk more about which is a two series of small mini games that were micro games like postcard games that were sort of fleshed out a little bit further uh looking at the Korean peninsula in a modern context one is looking at loose nukes uh which is uh essentially you play as China and the us and you're competing to essentially secure the nukes before the dprk regime like you know fires off the nukes in a sort of Civil War context so it's a little fun right you know different angle right instead of like your normal kinetic conflict looking at the peninsula um you're trying to secure all the nukes and there's a weird

collaboration yeah competition dynamic between the China uh China player and the ROK us Alliance player so that's always interesting um the other game was at currently called kto crisis which is looking at a very simple very simple abstracted fast playing version of like a broad conflict on the peninsula you're you play either as the dprk uh North Korea or the ROK U.S Alliance and you're trying to essentially win the war uh you know I mean on the premise that the North Koreans have come across the DMZ and attacked right it's a very simple game is designed to really introduce people to various concepts of game design but also be fast playing and the reason these are paired is that you can't really separate those two issues of the nuclear aspect and also and the conventional fight and when does the Continental fight go nuclear right is one of the things I wanted to look at in in the game um and you'll find out through various play tests that like it goes nuclear whenever the dprk player feels desperate right they're willing to go and end the world right if they're they're like hey if we don't have a place in the world the world doesn't have a place right uh for us right sort of thing um so it's a really interesting Dynamic I wanted to look at about uh how this conventional fight can expand really quickly uh unexpectedly at times so that's one catastrophe games uh that should be coming out in the next year or so we're working on maps and you know doing some uh extensive play testing with it right now we're doing some tweaks but the core rule said is pretty

much set um the next other project that is TBD and Publishers we have some talks with some people um that we're still pursuing some um various options but that is malign which is co-designed by Emily yoller who's over at Rand we did this as a personal project outside of work so outside of CNN outside of rant and this looks at influence campaigns and you play in a fictional World um looking uh playing fictional countries and you're trying to build influence campaigns to sort of spread influence malign or resiliency like good and bad influence um through like this sort of like pandemic Cube mechanic but it's interesting because it sort of Blends narrative elements and Concepts like you know like you do a DND you're like hey you played this mechanic but you fill in the story like what does these cards mean like you know you may use a Malai or like you may use social divisions um you know conspiracy theories and Bots right as your card and that has a certain value and your role for those values but you as a player have to fill in what the story is right what is the conspiracy theory that you're like propagating and let's say Liz's country and so forth right um and that sort of fills in that Collective storytelling which is actually I thought would be a really uh hit or miss mechanic but is the mechanic that most people have loved the most right uh which you know reflects why you're in RPGs are so popular because that Collective storytelling is really um immersive and like it gives a lot of

agency for the player so we're really excited to find a publisher that we're um keen on and we're exploring some options so Emily and I are collaborating on that portion but that has been in collaboration with the hybrid a hybrid threat center of excellence and Helsinki uh and we designed that for their educational purposes and lastly the total Commander via the Deets Foundation um that sent out its first printing and we're all sold out uh we're very excited there's some exciting news on the horizon with uh hex war and Co code Wizards doing um professional military education digital version for Marine Corps University and their Cloud wargaming Server we're also looking at uh literal Commander baltics which is expansion looking at the Marine Expeditionary Unit in Europe um and potentially Army multi-domain task force as well along with the Russian adversary and then we're working on the second printing right now so hopefully all those fires and my long weekends on converting caffeine into game design work will be all worth it oh wait is that all I have to do is just drink more caffeine that your your people always ask me what my job is and I was like my job description is pretty much turning caffeine into some sort of game design either for work work at the center for Naval analysis or uh for myself hearing me on the side on the weekend so they just convert various forms of caffeine into uh game design uh and I've been told that switching between coffee energy drinks and like tea does not mean that I'm drinking I'm

being healthier as I switch modes of caffeine it's just like you know you're just doubling down you know like like a healthy serving of each of those things are not meant to be like cumulative right like three cups of coffee 200 drinks and like three cups of tea is like it's not like technically if you only have three cups of tea you're okay but like when you add it on they're like I'm like I'm like I do like a bit of a rules lawyer I'm like that's not what it said on the label I mean you're like a one-man resource management

so talk to us about literal Commander what is it and what inspired you to make it so in many regards the total Commander is like a really strange game on the commercial Market um when I first approached them uh Jim and other Publishers about the game I was very adamant about I want it to retain its original Vision which was I want it to be a professional military educational game that is publicly accessible right but it's core audience and its core vision is to be sort of a intellectual sandbox looking at the future conflict and to help people really think through the challenges of future warfare at the Tactical level right and I was like that is the key goal like my key audience is to help my community that I work with on a day-to-day basis which is the defense Community um and specifically the Marine Corps Navy and a lot of Publishers like what are you talking about educational games like we do games for entertainment for new I mean for fun but I'm like yes I want that too but I the primary objective for the game is to teach people to allow people to learn from each other and think about uh hard challenges in the future and some Publishers were keen on it so we're not um and there's a various process but eventually end up with Deeds Foundation which is a non-profit educational game publisher which aligned with the vision of the game and but fundamentally the game is where you play either as the U.S Navy and Marine Corps or as a as the PRC the People's Republic of China's um Marine Corps or navy

the PLA and the pl uh plann and p-o-n-mc uh because acronyms are fun right um and then you play out on four different Maps it's a really tactical game so if you are familiar with like old school Avalon Hill SPI games you'll when you see the game itself on the on a table you'll see hex encounters um I mean you'll see combat values you you'll be familiar with the bucket of dice mechanic that is like you scored a hit of combat value and so forth um but there are other elements I imported from other games that I love it's a car driven game um as well where you have lots of joint capabilities from cyber information operations and so forth represented by cards along with air operations and engineers and all that fun stuff um and it's really modular and sort of scalable in many regards um so you know that's pretty much the game but the game was originally designed back in 2020 looking at uh what we call now expeditionary Advanced space operations or eabo or stand in force the Sif for the Marine Corps as the Marine Corps is really going through this transformative change and if you're not familiar with it because you're not a defense nerd like myself uh the Marine Corps is really reshaping how it's thinking about uh what it does and what it provides for The Joint Force and um the United States military in general so it's really focused on like how do we sense and avoid sensing by the enemy but also how do we strike Naval targets and how do we uh contribute to the naval and

sort of broader joint campaign as a long-range uh Force but also forcing contact which is during the traditional like infantry stuff so it's going through that sort of um pivot right which was an interesting moment and I want the game to be a Sandbox where people can be like hey what does this really mean what are do all these Technologies means from everything for hypersonics to cyber warfare to I mean all this stuff like what does this mean and I want the game to allow people to explore that those options So speaking of it sounds like you've started answering the question but I wanted to ask what exactly is it that you can learn from littoral Commander because it's an educational game like what is the learning objective oh yeah so how do you get there yeah so the principal learning objective in the game is uh what in military parlance we call the sensor to Shooter chain right it is the simplest way to think about it is like how do I see something that I want to Target or reveal of the enemy that they're trying to hide or you know I mean uh avoid being sensed to how do I inflict uh some kind of effect on it right often we talk about the sensor to Shooter chain in um missiles right like I see you with a drone I Target you with a uh I track you with a drone and then I drop a missile on you via like a high Mars right or a bomber or a fighter jet whatever that may be right that's a very simple sensor shooter change and Military problems we also call it the F2 t2ea process or the fine fixed track Target engage and assess process right

it's really like a nitty-gritty near a step-by-step process of how do we find uh enemy targets you know keep track of them to engage and then also assess what we did to them right if you hit them with a missile and you fart or you want to see like how well have I hit with the missile and so forth the literal Commander simplifies this process right uh using a lot of different research um predominantly Wayne fuses Fleet tactics which is looking at Naval Warfare and Salvo equations but really looks at how do I find the enemy when they don't want to be found and how do I hide myself when they're trying to actively seek me while also inflicting some kind of effect right whether that's a missile a cyber effect some kind of you know I mean other special forces effect right and that's really the core mechanic and engine of the game and from there the other learning mechanic is how do Technologies like you know future Technologies incorporate and integrate with our current concepts of conflict at the Tactical level right like does urine unmanned ground Vehicles right like you're in Killer Robots in normal parlance right like does that change how Warfare is fought or does it just make it more lethal right uh if you're looking at Ukraine how to do drones right and their prevalence on the battlefield change the F2 t2ea process can you sense better can you sense more right how do you avoid being sensed when there is a little quadcopter all around right if you're on Twitter you always see those videos from the conflict right um so the idea is like how does this really work out so the idea is like how does our current concept of a Warfare and

conflict interact with new technologies that are coming up online but also things that are theoretical like hypersonics uh like Weaponry a lot of tactical cyber stuff that we haven't really seen quite yet in the open space how do these things work with uh this sort of sensor to Shooter chain but more more importantly is like your typical stuff that you learn from more games is like hey what happens when my plan goes out the window because Liz has thought of a better plan uh how do I collaborate with my teammates because the game is designed to be collaborative you're playing teams often two versus two or three versus three is my favorite because you have a lot of the most tension in those kind of games right uh where me and Liz maybe like on the same page but Dave Thompson he may be doing his own thing right um we're like Dave come back here right like you're in stay with the team here all right are we flashing back to land in Freedom again yes yes exactly right so it's it's sort of like that where there's a Cooperative element on the team and the idea is like hey we may have different compositions of forces and different incentives right of what we're able to do and how do we work as a team to a common goal right um and the idea is like yeah it's supposed to really truly be a Sandbox like hey what does it mean to have these capabilities on this map right in Luzon in the northern Philippines versus having a similar set of capabilities or different ones that you may need in the streets of Malacca in Singapore where it's really dense lots of commercial shipping right it's a different terrain uh a different scenario or the recus in Japan right

versus let's say Taiwan right it is to be like there is no set answer with the capital a right is the fact that there are different answers and different ways to win right and one of the things I've Loved about watching other people play is seeing them think of different approaches that I would not have seen and which I find interesting because I designed the bloody game and I'm just like why are you doing that and then right um and they will always think of something very interesting uh to be like oh and sometimes they don't even have to have more military experience right sometimes just like you have a fresh lens and you're like this sounds like a cool idea right and they do it and it works on that was a cool idea or sometimes I'm like that was a terrible idea and it was a terrible idea yeah I mean so they but the idea is like you allow these people to explore these uh Notions uh themselves which is always interesting oh that is really interesting so it sounds like this game is a mixture of teaching real Concepts about you know weapons and Military processes but there's also a lot of theoretical stuff in there so how did you choose the right blend of what's real and what's theoretical and then also you know I guess what consequences does it have for your game as a learning tool versus as something that is like kind of in the realm of of more fantasy yeah no you're right um I joke that there are capabilities in the game that are like unicorns they don't exist they only exist in like some kind of like news article that the Navy

said that it's gonna get or whatever and the idea is like I want the people to start thinking about how these capabilities really work uh before we really have to worry about them right um for example uh a couple months ago the ukrainians use like this like kayak looking thing right that is unmanned to essentially attack uh Naval surface combatants Navy warships right uh it was all over the news and so forth right but this was a concept that has been around for a while and that people have been noodling around and it is something that you can do in the game it's called Naval swarms it's represented by a card right it's like what do you do right when your ship is not designed to defend against these kind of attacks right um so sort of think of how the Kamikaze really changed uh how Naval Warfare happened in the later stages of the second world war right where it introduced a new dimension to Naval Warfare that did not anticipate they essentially turned themselves into Precision Munitions right our deadly effect um the idea was like and the same thing about these unmanned systems what does that mean when you have these unmanned drones all around so but you know it may not exactly work the way or we say it does in the game the the combat values may not be accurate because we have to make certain assumptions when we're doing research about these things that that semis exists or uh only exist on paper uh some of the Cyber things we had to make a lot of assumptions about about uh how cyber warfare will work work at the Tactical level um so you know I always tell people I'm like hey if you do not agree with the

numbers in the game you have bought it already so like get a Sharpie and change them right like you're not going to hurt my feelings right like right um and I always tell people I'm like hey make your own cards use Post-its remember whatever a lot of the Marine Corps units that we work with like they have specific training needs um or training focuses or like um I tell the story a lot when I talk about literal Commander where uh Marine Corps Engineering Battalion um complained to me like directly they're like hey like we do more stuff than like get rid of like IEDs right because that is shaped that is reflective of my own experience in Iraq and uh right so they're like we do other things we like repair airfields we do kind of Mobility we do like barricades and affordifications all this other stuff I was like yeah I never saw you do any of that in Iraq so like cool let's like let's make cards for these right uh and they we would email back and forth and make card mechanics and I sent them a PDF but that that's how they did it originally they just did a bunch of Post-its and stuff but like the idea is like if you have a cool idea if you see something in the news that is interesting like make it into a card if you know how to the game system works and just like use it right like you know I have no issue with that so how do you design scenarios for the game um is each scenario meant to teach something different um where are they set and to what degree are they based on real current conflicts or historical ones and then to what degree did you make them up using information about reality

yeah so great question so the game first has four primary Maps uh Taiwan uh which covers the Taiwan Straits um the upper recuse which is for those who are not familiar familiar are part of the island chain archipelago that is from the southern bit of uh Japan all the way down short towards um Taiwan and we called it upper recuse right which is uh Okinawa right where uh third Marine Expeditionary Force right is station so that's the second map The Straits of Malacca which is near Singapore and Malaysia and like along the primary streets in the world for commercial shipping and the last one is what we is known as Luzon which is the northern region sort of if you see the Philippines it is that top portion of the island that is actually south of the Southern bit of Taiwan right so that covers the Luzon Straits uh and near the babanu islands so those are the four primary Maps so for the scenarios we made at least one for each of the maps uh in terms of the scenarios of why we chose the scenarios we did was one we either riffed off other people's analysis and your articles and writings like um there was a I think it was Reuters and I apologize if it's wrong but I think Reuters did a really interesting Taiwan scenario like what could happen in Taiwan scenario right uh over the different disputed islands in the Taiwan Straits so we ripped off some of those right we ripped off of some uh like I

mean future fiction stuff right but we also looked at it uh primarily through the lens of what is the Tactical problem that is interesting on this map right um that we can look at right so okay for Luzon pass right it is looking at a scenario where you are the Marine Corps and uh and you're trying to stop a Chinese Navy uh surface Action Group a bunch of ships from breaking out of what the military calls the first Island train or the thick right which is from Japan through the Philippines and Taiwan right all the way down um so he's like how do we contain them within uh the first island chain and that is the first primary you know uh problem set that they have to follow solve while the Chinese side has to look at like Hey how do we get past this you know I mean Marine Corps element that's trying to pick at us right to stop us it's like goalkeeper versus you know scoring our goal uh Dynamic where range and sensing is really important right um and then you have other nearing scenarios where it's more like Hey we're in a small space like the streets of Malacca it's a nice fight right and it's gonna be bloody it's going to be quick it's gonna be hard-hitting uh and very and very fast right so the idea is like how do how do we approach each of these tactical problems differently um and how what is the right mix of cards what is the right mix of risk and tactics that you want to approach um it's really been really fun uh designing the scenarios um the scenario we only have a handful of scenarios mainly because I wanted other people to

design their own scenarios and hopefully people will submit scenarios as the uh the game is used more and they work through the scenarios themselves that we've created and I'm hoping to add them back into the game sort of like rifting off how like uh scenario editors work for digital games right like for like um command or Arma and all those things right I want it to be a collaborative uh process with the wider literal Commander community that's awesome so speaking of The Wider literal Commander Community um it sounds like a lot of military teaching spaces have been looking at your game and playing it so tell us you know where has your game gone uh who is it teaching right now and what have you learned about the results of people using your game so far oh man it's been really surreal to see um people use the game both for hobby enjoyment but also for professional military education um the primary example is Marine Corps University down at Quantico in Virginia they have really embraced the game with other educational games so I would say I want to say like the troll Commander is not the only game that they're using they're using owos which is a government design game and other commercial games as well but uh literal Commander which looks at the future looking at the Marine Corps it has really aligned well with what they're teaching so Marine Corps Universe has used it uh for various reasons along with the crew lock Center down at Quantico but more importantly which I'm very

excited about and this is my own bias is as a former enlisted Marine the College of enlisted military education called Simi which is also a Quantico but has campuses all around the country over uh Marine Corps bases it is where unlisted uh leaders go like non-commissioned officers so like your sergeants your staff sergeants your Gunnies your uh your master sergeant so forth they all go to the school at various points in their career for career school which is for um staff sergeants um and advanced school which is I think for Gunnies uh Gunnies and so forth like but the idea is like they're using the game as like their Capstone is like hey we have taught about these Concepts that the Marine Corps is doing let's now play Let's play against each other let's hear and do this iteratively um like I was at a event where I was like demoing the game and the Marine walks up to me and they're like hey I know this game I played it in you don't even see me like and they knew about the game they had they were picking my brain about like what cards that they use and why they uh you know why they won or why they lost it was fascinating another great example is um damn neck which is the Intel school um they have really embraced the game and I've also adapted the game to their own purposes but they were telling me how like 400 enlisted Marines go through their program their Schoolhouse annually and if all 400 uh move in the last year or two have played the total Commander or it's a prototype version right wow and um a great story is a colleague of mine who is in a reserve Intel Battalion he

was running literal Commander right uh he was part of the play testing pool and so forth um and he was running it and one of his Young Marines uh who just came from damn neck right um fresh from the schoolhouse he was like Hey I know this game and he's like how the hell do you know this game right because it was relatively early when it was like shipping to people right he was like oh like I play it at the schoolhouse right um and he's like they played this at the schoolhouse so it was really interesting that this young Marine who just came from Intel School came to this unit they were playing the game that he was familiar with right and that he he led the session right and he's like all right you take over you like you know go ahead and show us show us how it's done um and they were talking about learning how Dave ran uh after action reports are essentially like uh your post game like your discussions like why did you do this why did Liz do this all right I mean what would you have done differently what did you think about this blah blah how does this relate to our work in our day-to-day right and then I have um I won't say who but like there are other countries who have uh you know allies and partners who have used it like uh the bundesphere which is the German uh schoolhouse is they have embraced it and used versions of it they have actually created their own spin-off version um which is called expeditionary Brigade operations ebo right which is like a a spin-off based on their German units which I'm really excited about I'm like yes please do more of this right so like in the professional military education enrollment has been embraced a lot of buying me by allies and partners by our own military by other services like an

army colleague of mine was telling me he was playing with a bunch of his buddies at his base um and the things that make me the happiest honestly is when like a random marine or a random Airman or a random sailor would be like oh find me on Twitter I know like DM me and they're like hey like like you don't know me but I'm at this unit we're playing with your game last night with my buddies drinking beer or whatever and we are having a good time here are some photos I'm like yes please like this is awesome thank you like this is all like because that's where I wanted I wanted a game that was beyond the school housing it's great that it is in like the school and the curriculum and all that that's obviously super amazing but what I want is like the game to go all the way down to this like 19 year old marine or sailor or or Soldier or Airmen and have them play it and think engage with games engage with decision making right because how do you exercise that intellectual muscle to be a technical leader right was the purpose of this game and then but also to engage in conversations of like I'm like oh yeah like this is what a B2 bomber does right like I'm in the Navy and I don't really think about bombers right um or I'm in the Marine Corps I've never thought about ships for the last like 10 20 years right so like this is what they do right so it's really interesting it's great and I love getting like inter-service teams together and they get to play I also love putting civilians in the mix because they'll also add a new dimension and new thinking right um so like I had with my students where I had a lot of Military Officers or former vets playing the game but I mixed

in some of my civilian students and at first they're like oh like the military like there's this Dynamic oh the military guys know better right but then as they're playing you know I mean one of my students she was like uh she worked on a think tank in DC and she was like a missile uh air defense like specialist that's where her research is so so she was like teaching these guys like oh yeah this is how missile defense works this is how missiles work this is what the difference between a supersonic and subsonic weapon is and I was like she was taking them to school right which is like awesome right like that is the conversations that you want sometimes that learning is tangential right it happens in the process of just playing right it is the conversations and discussions that happen in this uh in the space of the game oh it's really cool truly um so speaking of the community players and civilian players uh this game has also been doing pretty well in the hobby space so is that something that you expected and what kind of responses have you gotten from you know people who aren't even in the military so far picking up your game and giving it a shot um it's been really amazing so although I told Publishers that it wasn't not my primary audience right uh which was maybe not wise as a designer pitching a game to a commercial publisher uh at the same time um I wanted to be honest about why was why I was publishing this game right it was for my field and my community but it has been really well received by The

Hobby wargaming Community uh I would say is not giving root or any I mean even vocal run for their money in any regard right but for the hobby Gamers who have embraced it has been really well received and it's been awesome to see people posted on Twitter and Macedon and like you're mean all these other places of sharing their experiences and like uh I will admit like every morning I wake up go to the BGG pace for literal commander and answer questions or see if there's like complaints and stuff um and most of the times has been really like good like you're often like nuanced questions of like I'm like man you you're already asking these hard questions that like this means you played it a couple times my friend this is not a beginner question right um so that has been really encouraging seeing people post photos and uh to talk about uh what their uh group is discussing right uh and developing their own scenario so that's been really exciting and surprising at times right because I was like hey I don't know if an educational game will be commercially viable slash popular I just don't know right and I didn't um because I would say there's not many games like this right especially in the war gaming space that's explicitly says Hey like we will at times Buck the traditional normative things that happen um in war games that make it easy and balance like for example I will be the first one to say when we're talking about scenarios some of the scenarios are not fair right they're just not fair right to one player or not right so like uh which is like heresy in like games right in many regards because like you never truly has a like a hobby game

right want to sit down and be like I know Liz is going to win because I think the game is broken right because the scenario is broken right but in the real world when you're really solving tactical problems sometimes you have to walk into a broken broken scenario and you're just like hey all the odds are against you it is nine to one that you win this scenario good luck right and you you just have to figure out a way to get that 10 Victory chance right um and I was okay with that and that was something that Jim and I had conversations with and he was very supportive I was like I'm okay with adding skewed scenarios where one side is disadvantage sometimes severely um because as long as it reflects a true tactical problem that you have to solve right and I'm also like if you don't like that scenario don't play it right but I do want those who are wanting to play the challenges on hard mode this is the scenario for you right um and so there's that element to it and and I was surprised at how people have embraced it pretty pretty well right um but other things that like I would say is that that go back and forth that there's a tension between the entertainment make it easy to play and versus like at times it acts like a test right it's like hey you know what I mean tell us the answer right like this is the problem give us the answer right uh it's open-ended and people sometimes don't like that right uh a perfect example is that people always ask for a list or like a uh like a suggested cards for each of

the scenarios right right and I get why they do it and I even during the design process thought about doing it right being like each of the scenarios you get to pick cards like you think of like a resource allocation mechanic right each card costs different points and you buy a bunch and there's a hundred and twelve cards pert on the side right so a lot of cards right uh so a lot of people are like hey give us suggested loadouts right like suggested cards that I want to play in scenario one scenario two and scenario three um and I've always pushed back on it right um and I'm like no right uh and they're like why not it'll make it easier we can like get up to speed about it faster but I'm like yes but it is different when a designer just like a teacher tells you like these are suggested things you should do they're not really suggestions anymore right there there's a pirate because I am the designer it will be seen as these are the right answers right um and also limits your Paradigm and it eliminates um a creativity that I wanted you to approach the scenario with right as a as a Sandbox right so I have constantly resist the pressure to give suggestions for cards and be like just play the game it's okay if you lose it's okay if you get your teeth kicked in just do it again right um and we can talk about it right uh and and yeah and I don't know if I will change my mind in the future but this is where the Line in the Sand I have drawn so far uh about like hey just and I just had a recent conversation on

BGG on the forums of like this one person was like yeah I was like Pro suggestions like three weeks ago and now I am not right I'm like I've converted right that where yes like these conversations of why you choose these cards is really important and like sometimes it takes an hour and that's fine I'm like like again like I'm not here to make you an entertainment game that plays under two hours I care I care if you Lord I don't care if it takes three hours or eight hours right or 18 hours right um if it takes you that long it takes you that long right now as a teacher I feel that very much yes so it's like when like oh like you know I mean like Liz like please give me like your suggested ways I would do this I'm like but is it a suggestion if I tell you right as your teacher right sort of thing um and that's something I've pushed back on uh and there's a little core attention there but we'll see if I change I doubt it because I I really enjoy seeing people do things like and use it differently and there's a creativity that I really don't want to squelch yeah you know I actually I kind of hope you don't change I support you in this just because something that games do that other things don't do is that because there's not necessarily a right answer and like you know even with roguelike games right sometimes the function of a game is for you to get your teeth kicked in and you learn from it um there's so few I think opportunities in this life where you can safely fail and then just brush off and try again and I you know and I struggle with this

like I'm a very competitive and perfectionistic person um I think that games do me a lot of good because I have to mess up in order to get good and it forces that I mean it's a character building thing too even if it's just a game like the fact that people are asking you right means that they're sitting around worrying if they're doing the right thing and I think getting through that is actually important if you're if you would be great you have to learn how to just jump off the cliff and hope for the best yeah sometimes you just gotta so how chromey is your game so you mentioned that um you know you're talking about how uh you know you had to balance between what would be fun and accessible and then what would be accurate um you know to what level of granularity did you take it um what do you mean by like chromie you know we're talking about teaching people to use different types of weapons and different types of Technology how specific does that knowledge have to be for somebody to approach this game because I don't know anything about any of this if I picked up literal commander and I didn't know any of this information um what would happen to me oh yeah so I would say it's a design that you don't have to have any knowledge on it it's actually why I chose the car driven mechanic for a lot of the things right like for example like I don't know if you know what a B2 bomber is right uh and that's okay right um and you don't need to know what uh unmanned near me underwater vehicle is right and that's okay because the the

game will have you like the this is the beauty of Cards Right is like has a picture of what I'm talking about so like visually you're like oh like that's a B2 right or a B1 right um and that's a green uuv or whatever right um and then it will have the game mechanic right which will often be like if shoots missiles or like it reduces some kind of tactical cyber effect or like does this affect right and then we'll have like a little bit of flavor attacks of like this is what it is in real life right like this is what it does to sort of give you a little bit of subtext and but you do not need to know anything about any of these capabilities right um to play the game right um and and that's how I wanted it and I also wanted to act like flash cards right um especially with like Chinese capabilities that people are like oh like what is their version of it you know of a bomber right um the h6k the badger right I want them to be able to like look at them be like uh over time be like hey Liz can you get that your main uh pla rocket Force card right blah blah blah because then now that just from using the cards looking at it um they are like studying right in their own ways they see the picture they identify what it is they'll be able to recognize it in a news article or Twitter feed and like yeah like that's near me why whyj 18 Chinese missile launcher right like bam I got it right like uh and that's a part and people are like I don't want to like sit here and look through the cards like for an hour

I'm like that's exactly what I want you to do right I want you to do that like like flash cards like you're studying for like an exam right like you're in Med schools right I'm like and and people are like can you send me a manifest or I don't have to like look through the cards for an hour I'm like bro like that is the reason I have you do that like um so um so there's like these tensions right of like what the learning mechanic is and what the ease of play is at times right but you don't need to know any of those things are you like if you understand the rules as a gamer you're good and then you're like oh so like in the real world when you hear like a B1 uh uh bomber right you're like I know it drops of missiles that kill ships cool right like or you can kill like land targets awesome right so like you know it will help you have a better as a as a someone who's new to let's say War gaming or these technical capabilities will give you more context right and often one of the things I liked about it is like uh let's say in other traditional war games where you have like air rules and these counters and NATO symbols and stuff right um and you're like I don't know what does any of this looks like in real life and you can still play the game right let's say like next war or Indian Ocean or whatever right but like I wanted you to be like oh that's a funky looking plane right uh and it looks like you know I mean uh like a weird like T right which is like the B1 the answer right um and so forth like what does that look like and what does it do and so forth right um and and that's what I wanted the game

and the cards to be like to be like flashcards that's really interesting and so what kind of stuff is going into the Baltic expansion and so why why did you choose that area as the next expansion and then you know what what's going in there that kind of represents stuff you've learned from from round one with this game um oh man the Baltic it is giving me so many great like opportunities but also at times I'm just like oh God I wish I give my time myself more time to just like relax between games um so I would say I'm really excited about the Baltic version because it is uh I would say evolution of the core rule set right um like all good franchise series trying to do um it is looking at different units which is the Marine Expeditionary Unit so if you're like what does that mean Sebastian it means about Marines on boats right on ships right uh it is what you traditionally think of Marine Corps like your infantry units I mean and other like artillery units on ships to do amphibious what we call rating or uh amphibious Landings right or amphibious um and so forth right so there's that right and we're also looking at the future capability called The Marine uh the multi uh multi-domain task force or the mdtf for the Army right which is like a long-range fires hypersonics you know long-range cruise missiles all that stuff all the fancy whiz-bang things for the future um in the in the European theater the

reason we chose the baltics over other other elements of the theater uh in Europe over like the say the Mediterranean or let's say the high North Arctic which is what's interesting to me at first um or like the battle of the Atlantic sort of thing was had the most diversity of scenarios um it is really hard for blue um right and there's a lot of research already on it right so uh in the nearing anywhere from 2014-15 to present day that uh before Crimea there was a lot of stress and worry in the defense Community about the baltics right and this still is what happens if the Russians just bum rise to the Border um and the idea was like hey this is relevant to people this is a problem that people care about um and there's lots of interesting tactical problems right uh the Baltic is like the Baltic Sea is really shallow relative to other C's right it's a hard area to operate it is really difficult geographically like if you're not familiar with Russian terrain there's this little part of uh of Russia called kalinograd that sits on the Baltic Sea and it is a pain in the ass because it can has a chock full of muscles right so the idea is like huh how do we do that right how do you deal with that right when you're operating in a really confined shallow sea right surrounded by people who don't like each other right um and during the Ascension of um Sweden uh into NATO and so forth right and maybe Finland in the future and Norway and urine so there's a lot of

interesting elements to uh the scenario which I was really keen on and we all and the fact that the baltics like uh Estonia Latvia and Lithuania are large um spaces although very complicated spaces right like it is um like a lot of it like it looks flat on a map and you're like hold on these are a lot of farces swamps and bridges that are really difficult to operate in so we're hoping to do more of to flush out all the ground mechanics a little bit more but also retain some of the amphibious littoral elements of the series right of how do we do this right and how do different formations Beyond um the indo-pacific version which focuses on the Marine the Tor regiment uh we'll look at so you know we have different cards different counters um different scenarios um and a little bit of expansions of rules hopefully for those who are new or coming from the original box set we are uh we're gonna like highlight the new rules so you're like you don't have to reread everything be like these are the things we change like so if you you need to skip things like this is okay right um there are also like little things that I forgot about and I wish I did that I want like I have made notes for like for example like uh I have a table of context uh content in literal Commander right like oh of course like 5.1 and this is what you'll find at 5.1 and 5.2 right but I don't have page numbers which was like a rookie mistake right uh so I was like damn I should have had page numbers to these table of contexts right right

um and like No And like and editors looked at it like other designers looked at it no one said anything and I was like God damn it guys um so maybe I'll have to have it send it to you next time like Liz look at this thing um for baltics uh so there's like little Common Sense things and little typos that I found that drive me insane um and so forth but um in terms of the game cool uh core rule set that we're really working on this new mechanic of like uh how do Marines fit on trips and how do these amphibious operations work right um and we're really fleshing that out that's awesome so given that your game has seemed to get some widespread play in the school houses as it were in in educational settings um in military educational settings what do you think that that says if anything about I guess kind of the continued push for using War Games to educate in leadership spaces for political and military issues like does this indicate that we are moving forward well in that area like I know there's always like a little bit of pushback um you know where what is the current state of gaming education oh man um I guess you caught me on an optimistic day uh that I would say it is doing better right a lot better actually in in

some regards um it is like the Marine Corps and the Army are pushing uh heavily into wargaming again right um as Educational Tools and also analytical tools um and for those who don't know the difference the quick you know I mean Spark's notes version is analytical games are uh about using games to collect data or produce new knowledge or new insights right new data right um educational games is about the transfer or discovery of knowledge and it is not binary is it can be like a Venn diagram right so you can have games that are both educational and produce new knowledge but broadly speaking for those who are very not familiar those are the very simple ways to think about it um and educational gaming is increasingly being used at the Marine Corps University air War college and air University army war College uh the naval war college and even in the units and even service members are increasingly making their own games for their services right on the Air Force a lieutenant colonel Pierce he created a game called Kingfish Ace about air operations in the future um Tim Barrick who what is uh is a retired Colonel and he led the war game division in the Marine Corps and now is the educational War gaming director at Marine Corps University he created ows or the operational war game system which has like it is like a massive game on like operational War like his uh European expansion right if you think my box is heavy right his box has 2 000 calendars

right like Hefty little thing like you could beat a small bear with it um um and then there are other games that um that are working across with our allies and partners right so there's a lot of positive things going forward um but the pessimists or the concerned citizen in me is worry that will this be the flash right in the pan or will this be sustained um effort that can be built on in in coming years right uh you're a teacher Liz you know like sometimes like something works great for a year or two or three years right and then it dies right because someone moves someone retires or someone gets promoted and they get they're not the ones putting it together and that's one of my major concerns about the educational gaming space right now yeah I would say I find it very encouraging that you're hearing from people that you've never met or things are getting played in settings that you haven't heard about because that's always promising I would say in these situations but yeah I you know even with Latin programs that I've been part of in the past you know the teacher sets a lot of the culture that program and if they leave the program could die or it could completely change when the next teacher comes in yeah exactly yeah so that is sort of my concern right about this recent boom um my hope is that it we are able to keep it going but you never know these things right um and we try to do our best uh but you know I mean there's only so much you can't do you can do with the limited time that you

have as an individual and as a group as a community but also about funding right like I mean like in in some regards like all the best intentions all the good efforts all the long hours that you can put in as an individual like sometimes you just need funding to move the needle um and that's true for anything yeah well I'm gonna be helpful this is like a promising Way Forward because I you know as a as an educator myself I really believe in gaming in the classroom and having that as a major part of my pedagogy I think I'm not the only one um for right now I see I'm having a growth mindset as it were but um you know I guess we'll just kind of keep checking in over the years and see how it goes uh but for now what are you playing that is making you happy what are you doing for fun right now oh um let's see why am I playing for fun let me look at my table oh yeah so War Whispers is like my new obsession uh recently um I'm also playing actually going back to divided Europe Dave Thompson design um which is interesting uh because I'm you know Milan has been thinking about influence mechanics and Emily and I are working on are trying to think of our new next project together um after malign and um you know we're trying to find inspiration in places so War Whispers if you're not familiar it's an interesting like concept of where you don't play as

a nation state but as like a secret society trying to tip the balances of War um that where you're like you're like uh you're you're playing the shadow agents right so I really like that concept and that sort of like I mean uh narrative uh and the game design is pretty simple straightforward which is really nice but it's like it's complex because of the human behavior you're like can I trust Liz do I know what Liz is gonna do right that that adds the depth to the gameplay um divided Europe is really interesting because it spins off of other influence games um and sort of competition games like um Twilight Struggle which I say it's a war game we'll just leave it at that and so forth right so those are on my table right now I'm also experimenting with till five which is a like a augmented reality uh toolkit that you know I'm doing for work of like how do we incorporate like you know in TTS modules and like manual games into AR and is it worth it how do we contribute uh to our game designs are there interesting things that we can use it for design that we can't do it ready right like doesn't open new doors right um in one way or another whether that's by dissemination or just by like mechanics right like um like uh there's a game called air scammoosh which is a Tactical Air war game and it has a like an app Feature to it and like I like that right I like I think there's interesting ways you can like try to limit the bookkeeping

portion of games right especially war games where you're like tracking Supply and stuff like with apps right but like hey I'm gonna do this and this and then and the app just like calculates it for you right or at least like the busy work right um because that's like for example like I love playing Scythe online like on Steam uh because it just calculates all the victory points for me like I don't have to like do the math right um right so I'm like yeah it is four times this and four times like three times this right bam and this is the winner right um stuff like that right like that doesn't affect your decision space right like I mean like right uh at that point you ever you made all your decisions now it's just like a tedious map problem right um and so forth right um and also can you add more rigor or or math into the game as a you know I mean as an analyst myself I'm like how do we add more interesting depth to the game without making it like of like a homework or assignment for our players or so those are things I look at so uh as you probably know like my pleasure and my work are like circles not Venn diagrams I'm not gonna fault you for that because that would be very hypocritical of me yeah um but if people have questions for you or want to see what you're up to where can be found online oh man that's such a loaded question these days um all right so I'm on Twitter uh use my name Sebastian uh s-e-b-a-s-t-i-a-n-b-a-e um so it's just my name uh it's one of

the benefits of having a very unique name uh so I'm on Twitter I'm also on what is it the new one threads right uh I think it's the same exact username um and then I'm also on Macedon and what's the other one shoot blue sky blue sky right uh uh I think exactly I think I'm on the same username for all these because I'm I'm not a creative person uh for usernames at least right it's not about creativity it's about brand consistency yes exactly that's what I'm going to use brand consistency which is my name birth right like brand consistency since birth right cradle to grave uh brand consistency is what I'm going to go with that's like in my new like tagline Liz um which is funny because I was thinking of like a bunch of like weird funky names um uh for our new project that uh that Emily and I are working on or semi brainstorming I don't know if you've ever seen um Mythic quests on Apple TV no so if you have time look at it it's about it's like the office meets a game Studio like a video game studio right so um great uh has a guy from Always Sunny in Philadelphia right I forget his name shoot uh he owns the soccer team with um Reynolds uh Ryan Reynolds okay I'm forgetting his name but he's the main character he's like the lead creative designer and

um poppy Lee is like the programmer uh and they have like an interesting dynamic as like co-workers and like uh creative Partners right uh and I like your Emily and I just go back and forth like sending GIFs from that show because I'm I forced her to watch it uh I mean I was like hey watch this and I was like I see both the worst and best qualities of uh uh uh iron who is the main character in myself and I'm like I don't know if I like this or not all right because he's like a crazy jerk at times I'm just like oh no because I would just say things I'm like in a creative process for me and I'm just like uh like in the first episode they'll be like blood tighter I think it was like blood Ocean or whatever and he's like I don't know what that means but we're gonna make it happen and like everyone else is like what the hell right and like and I'm like oh man I've definitely sent Emily a email or like a random thought I had while walking in Winston and I was like Emily what do you think about blood ocean right and she's like what does that mean what's that and I was like I don't know yet but I like it and she's like okay right so um so watch it and it will come back to me and we'll have another conversation just about um Mythic Quest because it is about video games what's interesting about the creative process about uh the different tensions in The Gaming Community industry about modernization uh monetization and player experience creative direction or even the creative process right of like what am I willing to do and so forth right

um um yeah so that's interesting let me know what you think about it I will all right so that's my homework for this episode yeah I can be found anywhere online as Beyond Solitaire because I also believe in brand consistency although not since birth only since about 2016. cradle to grave over here but Sebastian thanks as usual for coming on I absolutely love hanging on the show and I know that it will happen again at some point in the future the next time you do something awesome that I just have to have you on for yeah absolutely and one of these days we'll design a game together Liz I'm in I enjoy co-designing projects like that's clearly something that does it for me so definitely all right thanks again all right those of you out there please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved