Skip to main content
Loading video...

Pi Mal Pflaumen / Plums Review

Transcript 15:14

welcome to John gits games today I'll be reviewing P Al flowman this odd little card game plays three to five players and has you trying to build sets of gorgeously Illustrated fruit using some mechanisms from trick taking games as well as pool drafting Games first I will go through the rules and then I'll jump in in my review a full game of Pou flowman lasts three rounds and each round has its own individual deck of cards at the beginning of the game you will deal out the entirety of the round one deck to each of the players once that round is finished we would move on to the second round deck each card has a strength value in the top left corner in a three-player game you will play with cards from rank 1 to 18 in the four-player game you go 1 to 24 and in the five player game you bring in the 25 card the round begins with a star player playing one card from their hand for instance they could take this 15 here and put it face up in the middle of the table then in clockwise Order each other player will play a single card into the center of the table once all players have played a single card it's time to evaluate their strengths the player who played the highest value card will take the one and then the second highest value will go to the two and so on around the table the player who played the weakest card will get this card here which shows a bonus of a plum which means the person who plays the lowest card gets a plum at the end of the round and now we begin with a player who took the one card and they take one of the cards from the center of the table and they put it into their face up supply for instance they might take this card here and put it face up in front of them and then you move on to the second player who might take this one the third player might grab this one and once again the fourth player they have no uh decisions to make they just get to take this card but it also comes along with a

plum because that's what the rank four card shows and once everybody has taken their cards we look to the person who took the rank one from the previous hand and they begin the next round there are five different types of cards in the game the First shows no special bonuses and has nothing in the middle or on the top so once this card is taken nothing special happens and the next four have an action that activates when you take that card from the middle of the table and add it into your Tableau the first of these is this card here with the three piie cards so once this card is taken and put into your area area you get to draw three pie cards off the top of the deck they are all the same and they say plus 3.14 in their top Corner what you do with these on future rounds is you can add these to the single card you place in the middle of the table as a trick and that will add 3.14 to that card for each of these pie cards you add to it but you can add multiple cards if you like next up there is the Steel action this allows the player who takes this card to grab a single fruit card from in front of one other player as long as they don't currently have the dog sitting in front of them so if a player for me took this card they could also take this Cherry card here for instance and put it into their Tableau next up we have the dog card and simply put when you take this card and put it into your area you get access to the dog from wherever it was so the person who had it now loses it and it comes in front of you and you have the option of using this side or this side they're the same but different kinds of puppies and lastly there are these Victory Point cards which have a fruit mixing set on them this says a AA that means you just need to have three fruit that are the same so when I take this and I look at my area I actually have two other pairs in my area that means I have three pairs

you can actually use the card that has the victory points on it in this case I would discard both of these cards and I would flip this over and it would be worth eight points to me at the end of the game and there are several different fruit mixes that you're going for for instance this is three fruit that are all different and this is just a pair of fruit it is worth noting that you don't need to use the card that has the victory points on it for instance I could grab this and then cash in this pair of figs here to flip this card over for five points and lastly if you take a car that has a set that you don't currently have you can leave it in front of you in your Tableau and on future turns as soon as you make that happen you can activate it and flip the card over for its points you can do as many of these on a turn as you like it's worth noting that these Plum cards that you get for playing the lowest card function just like any other fruit they have no special purpose they're just another fruit that you can add into your fruit mixes you'll keep playing in this manner until everybody's played all of their round one cards at that point you will Shuffle up the round two deck and deal out to all the players and you will keep playing as normal once you go through the entire round two deck you finally end with the round three deck and after you've played every card from this deck the game will be over at the end of the game each player is going to add up all the points in their score pile the person who has the most points wins so now I'll start the review for p out flamman and I will begin with a couple of positive points the first of these relates to the interesting combination of the three Central mechanics of the game first of all you have trick tiing which in general means you take one card out of your hand you play it down once all players have played a card you see who did best in your typical trick-taking game the person who wins the trick is the only person who gets stuff but in this game

everybody is always going to get something the strength of the card you put down is going to dictate how good of a thing you're going to get or how many options you have on the table when you go ahead and do that which is a very cool uh mix of this trick- taking playing of cards and this pool drafting style of taking cards up from the table it's also interesting in that you don't always want to win the trick the worst thing to do is to come in second to last because when you come in last you don't have any choice as to what you get but you always get that Plum so the person going last is the person who's going to get two fruits compared to everybody else's one well unless somebody does a steel action of course so I really like that sometimes you're gunning to go high and sometimes you're gunning to specifically go low and you're most upset when you are the second to last person and then you also throw on top of that the reason you're doing all these things which is set collection trying to make different sets and it's not just trying to make um all of one kind of fruit or all of different kinds of fruit you have full houses you have um consecutive pairs you have several different things that you are gun for and so what that means is when you in a position where you're the second to last player to grab a card from the middle you often times have a decision between a card you don't care about and another card you don't care about but you look in front of you and you say well will I make a pair with either of those uh maybe I want to do that because I know that there are full houses in the deck or just pair of cards are easier to grab or maybe I specifically take the card that doesn't make me a pair because it seems like you get a lot more points for doing the um the sets of different colored uh fruits so there are a lot of

different things going on and I just really like how each of these three mechanisms weaves in together to breathe a bit of fresh air into all three of them and positive number two relates to those piie cards which allow you to modify the card that you play into the trick you get to add 3.14 to the value which is a little odd in general I mean you're adding Pi why couldn't be something else and mechanically it makes sense that 0.14 means that you will never have uh ties which is a very important thing and thematically I guess it kind of works into the scientific uh theme that the game is kind of going for with the illustrations on the cards trying to look like they're in some sort of Journal but when you come back to the mechanics I also like that these cards allow you to get around a bit of the luck of the draw like if you feel like you did not get enough High cards well you can potentially win some pie cards and you can modify you can throw a couple of those on and definitely win a trick or maybe you throw a strong card down but you know like maybe you put the 22 down but you know the 23 and the 24 are still out so you throw a pie card down to ensure that you're the person who gets to win it now the other thing about the pie cards is that they only add they never subtract and I do feel like I kind of wish they could go both ways because sometimes you really do want to tank when you put a car down you want to be the lowest person and that can be kind of difficult sometimes based on the the hand that you're drawing uh but I will get into that specifically later I just like the pie card in general it looks weird an odd on the table and it adds some interesting mechanics uh into the way you play the game so now let's move on to my neutral points and the first of these relates to

the stealing action in general I'm not a fan of stealing in games in general where you just take something from somebody and put it in front of yourself and now it's yours but in P flowman it does kind of serve a purpose it adds a tension to the game where that card that you draft from the middle and put into your Tableau it's not secure you uh especially if you're grabbing those Victory Point cards and you can't quite cash them out yet there is a tension of Will I be able to get the set and complete this card and flip it over before somebody takes it from you and you might be even more incentivized to try and grab the dog and put it in front of you to protect it so I like that aspect of it I also like that there are not that many steals throughout the entire game there's three in each deck so there's going to be nine total steals in a game and it's likely that nobody will end up stealing from you at all or maybe just once or twice and it seems like oftentimes when you get stolen from it doesn't actually hurt you that much uh people are stealing to grab the thing that they need more than grab a thing from you to prevent you from doing a thing that you need to do because the game is not very long and so people are very self minded like it's all about what can I do to bring myself up and less what can I do to bring that other person down also because it could be a little hard to tell who's winning like just because you have a bunch of cards doesn't mean that you are um that they have high Victory Point values on them uh the last game I played actually half of my victory points came from a single card so uh to sum it up the the stealing seems somewhat necessary but it's definitely a direct interaction between the players that some people might not like neutral number two relates to the role of luck in the game this is a card game where you're going to be dealing

out all the cards to everybody and the first thing you're going to do when you pull up your hand is decide is this a good hand or is this a bad hand uh now a good hand in my opinion is one with some high numbers and some really low numbers because sometimes you want to tank the bid and you want to have the lowest card so that you can grab a plum so you get two fruit you might not really care in that specific instance what other kind of fruit you're going to get but sometimes you really do need to play high to have control to grab that one card that you really need the game does try to mitigate luck by adding in those pie cards which I talked about earlier and I do like that they added those into the game but they only help you win tricks they don't help you lose tricks uh they don't they never subtract and that is somewhat important thing in the game I the last game I played I never pulled a single plum because like the lowest card I ever got was an eight and I just never had a good chance to tank a trick with it because I wasn't the last player or maybe I played the eight and then the last person played a seven or something like that so so you need to know that there is luck in the game and I think everybody's going to expect a certain amount of luck in a card game but this is a card game with only three hands and then the game is over which is a relatively low number of hands for a card game and you can get unlucky three times in a row that's not um that unlikely a thing and you also need to know that if you pull up an unlucky hand odds are somewhat good that somebody else pulled a lucky hand like theyve got they have a much better hand than you and you might say that it's kind of interesting trying to squeeze Effectiveness out of a mediocre hand that is there's some fun there but the flip side is somebody else might play worse than you in that one given round but still do better than you as far as getting fruit and getting victory points so luck is here it's definitely a factor

but I don't think it's worse than anybody would expect from a card game and neutral number three relates to the card art in the game I think it is a stunningly Illustrated game I love every card in the game I love how they have cross-sections from all the fruits and you can see all the different stuff inside but the reason this is not a positive point is because these cards are also somewhat busy like it looks great in your hand but when you look across the table and try to see what your opponents have they maybe have stacked the cards on top of each other to save some table space and you're trying to look at that tiny little icon in the top left of the cards and while the icons are differentiated from each other relatively well there are a lot of different fruits and it could be a little difficult to figure out exactly what your opponents have at any given point but in general I just I just love the art I'm really glad they went with such a stunning vibrant theme to the game I just wish the icons were a little bit easier to tell from across the table and now let's go into my one negative for the game which is kind of hard to articulate and if I'm being honest it might not even be real this is just a vibe that I've gotten after playing the game a few times where it seems like the person who plays the best is not always the person who play who who wins and that is a bit of a bummer I think a lot of that has to do with the card draw luck I mentioned earlier but I think the biggest aspect to it is just the number of hands in the game you only play three hands and then the game is over and I feel like if it was a six-and game you would have a much higher likelihood of the person who played best being the person who wins now I'm not saying I think the game should be six hands long I think it would probably start to feel like it was maybe overstaying its welcome in this given um circumstance so it's tough to say like when you end a

game and you feel like the person who won maybe shouldn't have won that's definitely a bad thing but on the other hand maybe I'm just crazy and this is just a silly vibe that I've had and that's not as much of a thing as um I really think it is but I want to throw it out there it's a Vibe I've had and you can take from that what you will all right so now let's discuss the replayability of POF flowman and I don't actually have that much to say I think it's uh pretty typical for a card game you're going to see every card each game and each time you play it it will be pretty much the same game with maybe slight differences and in one game you might be stealing a little bit more and another game you might be taking bigger uh risks based off of the cards that you get I mean the game is all about playing the hand of cards that you receive and I don't think anything in particular drives the replayability up or down in this case and now let discuss the different player counts for POF lman it plays three to five players and I've played each of those player counts and I think that the four-player game is best uh the three-player game works but it felt a little weak and the stealing was a much uh bigger thing it's the same number of steals in a three-player game as a five player game and you actually have less cards uh in a three-player game you take out the 19 through the 24 when you're playing in that set so with less people and the same amount of stealing it's going to be you're going to get hit more often which is not great uh in the four-player game you play with 24 cards and it seems to work very well the game hums along and good Pace somebody has a dog but there you pretty much always have good choices from which to steal from your opponents and it just feels right the five player game worked pretty well it maybe went a little bit

longer just because people are thinking and you're going around the table and there's just a lot of cards down and it is nice having all those cards in the center of the table more options to grab especially if you win a trick um I don't think I would say no to playing a five-player game I think I probably would say no to playing a three-player game but four is The Sweet Spot in conclusion I've had a pretty good time playing P flan I was originally interested in it because it's got this gorgeous artwork it's got a goofy name and it's got these these pie cards where you add 3.14 like that's just a fascinating weird thing and that's kind of the game in a nutshell it's a gorgeous fascinating odd game and that LE makes for a fun time I've had a good time playing it but not a great time I've never like had that moment where you sit back and like whoa this is really good I've never been blown away by the game at all but I've consistently had an enjoyable time and I've been consistently fascinated with the decisions that you make and also just with seeing how the different mechanisms click together as you're playing it I've enjoyed introducing it to players and seeing them kind of figure out how odd and fascinating the game actually is and at the end of the day I would recommend it to pretty much anybody who enjoys um simple card games especially simple card games that are deceptively complex underneath but I don't expect you to be particularly Blown Away by it it's it's a fun time but not an amazing time if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com jongetsgames thanks for

watching

Progress saved