Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dwarves of Aquilon Review: You Got GA'AT

Transcript 19:21

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel.

I'm Zee Garcia.

I'm Mike Delisio.

Today we're taking a look at a game called Dwarves of Aqualon. Um this is a new game and it's called Nidavellir sequel set in the Dwarves universe. This is definitely a new version if you played the game Nidavellir. This is a new version, same designer.

Mhm.

Uh with different scoring. Uh before we start Nidavellir is a game I love. I give it a 9.5 maybe. It is in my top games of all time. I think it's fantastic. And so we are selling this game at Gen Con 2026. We're the quote unquote US distributor. It actually says that on the box.

Okay.

Not a lot and I don't know what will happen after that. So we're going to make a very small amount of money off the game.

Yes.

So keep that in mind as you watch this, but I wouldn't have done it if I didn't love the game. But that's just take that as you will. Maybe I'm just saying this bad game is good to make money. I'm not. I love Nidavellir and this is more Nidavellir.

Well, you've loved Nidavellir many years before you ever were distributing a few copies of this game, right? To be fair.

So but maybe it's different. Maybe we don't like it. We'll talk about it. I'm going to show you how it plays and we'll be right back. In Dwarves of Aqualon, players are going to be assembling an army of dwarves. We're going to be scoring them bravery points and whoever has most bravery points at the end of the game is the winner. In this game each player is going to start with their own board. They're going to get five coins. 0 2 3 4 and 5 that they'll have in front of them. They'll also have a random gem which will be used to break ties. Now over the course of the game, the game can take place over certain number of rounds, half of them from deck one, the other half from deck two. And in each round you're going to put four dwarves or not dwarves equal to the number of players. So, then the four-player game it would be four under each of these three taverns.

Each player then is going to bid on which tavern they want, you know, they're most interested in. So, they're secretly going to put three coins face down on these spots. The other two remaining coins, they will place underneath their board like this. So, you always have five coins placing them out. Then in the first tavern, everyone will turn over their coin. Whoever plays the highest coin here will get to take one of the dwarves first, second highest, and so on picking whatever dwarf they want. If there's a tie, the higher gem will break the tie, and then you'll switch gems. In multiplayers, let's say three people are tied, then the highest and lowest would switch and the other person meet them. So, you'll always eventually win a tie. The dwarves that you'll take, you'll put next to your board in five columns keeping track of them.

If after you reveal one there's a zero, very rarely will you win anything. You'll you'll always get a dwarf, but you probably won't go first. However, when you play the zero, you are going to reveal the bottom two tiles, add them together, discard the higher one, and draw a coin equal to the sum of them. So, 2 + 3 is 5. If I had two and five down here, I would get a seven. The game comes with a coin display that has spots for all sorts of coins. If I need to take a five and there is no five here, then I would take a six instead. So, this is a way that you can increase your coins. You can even go all the way get up to the 25, which would mean you're automatically going to win whatever thing that you're fighting over. Let's talk about the different dwarves here that when you get them. The gray ones, you simply going to score points. You'll see how many gray ranks you have. Each bar is called a rank. And you're going to get points equal to however far down you go. So, you can see if you get 15, you're going to get 195 whopping points.

These cards here, you will simply add the bravery points. So, 4 + 4 + 4, and then you'll take the number of unique runes you have. If you have a duplicate rune, that won't score. So, if I have these four cards, for example, I get 16 points here, and then I have three unique runes, and I would square them for nine more points. These cards here are going to simply give you points equal to the number of ranks that you have. So, let's say I have these four cards, 2 4 6 8, times the number of occult symbols you have. So, I have four here. You only see three, but you have one printed on your board. So, this would be 8 * 4 for 32 points. These cards are going to give you a lot of points, 10 11 12 or 13, which is fantastic. But, if you ever take a card, and you already have a card of that number, then you are going to take an anarchy token and cover it up. There are some special abilities that allow you to remove anarchy tokens, but otherwise, you won't get any points for that.

The blue cards are going to give you bravery points, but also the coin that you used to win them with, you will discard and take the next highest number, or if there is no next highest number, the highest number after that. So, maybe I turn my two in for a six, if there is no three, four, or five coins available. The game also rewards you when you get one of every color. So, if I play a card here, now I have one rank of each of the five different types of dwarves, then I am going to be able to go through all the different warriors here, and I'm going to pick one of them to add. I might pick one, for example, this one has two of these occult symbols, which is going to make those even stronger, or maybe I'll pick this character here, which comes with two unique runes to add. Some of them get added to the dwarves lines that they have down there. Others are going to give you points maybe at the end of the game. For example, this one just gives you 15 points, doesn't go in any of these spots, but does provide you with an extra wild guy who can go in any one of these spots. So, there's a whole lot of these different warriors. And in fact, there's a special kind of warrior called mercenary.

A mercenary can only when you play somebody, so let's say for example, I have no one here right now. And I play this person down. I've now completed a row. I may take a mercenary if by putting this mercenary down, I then complete another row, which is worth 24 points. And then I get to take another mercenary. If that completes another row of one of each type, then I would play another one. Although in this case, that won't happen. I get to play two, but that's still 47 points for the end of the game. Between the the first half of the game and the second half of the game, you are going to compare all the ranks that players have of the different cards. Whoever has the most blue ranks will get a reward. Whoever has the most red ranks, etc. And if there's a tie, then nobody gets it. There are five reward cards for each of the types, which might give you a random rune, might give you the ability to take off one of those anarchy tokens, etc. Also, this card is going to go out here. Each player, when as they're taking cards dwarves, they will have different hops on them. And whoever has the most of these will get this card. At the end of the game, each of those is going to be worth one point.

But if I have this card, they will be worth an additional point. So, you're going to be playing through all the rounds. After the last cards have been dealt from the second deck and everyone has taken them, you'll score your points and whoever has the most points is the winner of the game.

All right. Dwarves of Aqualin is a much it's I don't want to get too caught in the nitty-gritty stuff, but we do need to talk about it first of all because it is very much the same game in many ways other than the scoring and then the special warriors and things that you get the mercenaries. They are all all of that is different actually. It's all different. But it's different in a way that if if you played Nidavellir before, I could teach you this just by showing you scoring.

Yes.

Explaining the new guys which honestly takes 90% of teaching the game anyway.

Sure. Sure.

but that's all you would need to know. Um and other than that it's pretty much the same thing. So we'll talk about this and come back to if you own Nidavellir should you get this or not. So um the base game of this though if you've never played Nidavellir and you've and you were interested in this the five coin system is one of my favorite systems ever in any board game and I've been I'm still kind of surprised no one has tried to copy it.

Yeah, I can't think of an analog game that does that. It's it it is super smart. The idea of being able to upgrade your coins is very very smart. I mean there are hints of like the raw bidding system in that. [clears throat] You trade

I'm surprised you didn't do that.

Uh that idea of like well I have my my shifting power but in this one you're always going up. You're not you're not sometimes trading in something for a weaker purchasing ability later on. There is that forward propulsion is always part of the game. Pretty much. I mean you don't have to put out the zero token that lets you upgrade a thing. But then you're falling behind in some aspect of the game. On the other hand that is very much part of this game. You're falling behind in some aspect of this game every round cuz you can't do it all.

Right.

Right? You want better coins. Great. Then you're losing out on some card you were hoping to get and you're not going to get and so on and so on all the way down. So that's part of it.

Correct me if I'm wrong but this does do something different than Nidavellir also Did Nidavellir have the mid game those cards?

Yes. Okay. Why I don't remember

I don't know. It's easy a couple things it does differently than Nidavellir though. Uh

And had cards that you could take that just added three to a coin and did not give you a dwarf.

Right.

They got rid of that and now they have dwarves that add plus one. I think that's a vast improvement

Mhm.

because it does almost the same thing

Yeah.

but still gives you something that scores for your army.

And that feels good. And it feels good to always be getting a little something.

Yeah.

And I think everything in this game most everything in this game is fairly easy to explain.

Yeah.

Yes. Yes.

With the caveat, I think the mercenaries are pain in the neck to explain.

Yes.

They are just because everything else as you said is so intuitive. That just is the one thing you're like, okay, wait, wait. That That works fundamentally different than every other kind of leader that you're going to be getting. It's something you have to build towards. It's something you have to be I think you can potentially just like, oh, this is great. It worked out. But you're probably going to be having to actively work to make it happen I think in most cases. And so, yeah, that's a little bit uh clunkier probably than it than it needs to be. But it is neat if you can pull it off. It does feel like this big and the point uh that you would get for the points you get for it make it feel like it's worth it.

Well, speaking of clunky, I thought that the this game was very much improved as far as the the sort of clunky scoring and and general differentiating, you know, qualities between the groups of characters you're collecting. That was my one big hang-up with Nidavellir. And I thought Nidavellir was fine. I would rate it 6.5, 7 on a good day. That's kind of where I'm at on Nidavellir. Um cuz I thought the coin system was always brilliant. So fun that forward propulsion really feels good. And then you would take that system and what what the thing it was driving, right? The engine was great, but the car was you're collecting these guys, they score 1, 3, 8. And these guys are scoring 2, 12, 21. I'm like, who cares? It's Yes, these are better, these are worse, but that's boring. And those guys were sort of didn't mean anything. You know, in this one there's a little something more interesting about the groups. These guys are merchants, I guess. They make my coins better. These dudes are cultists.

They They multiply this times the strength of your cult, okay? There's the gray guys. They just have that sort of like thing they score down the line the more you have, but there were multiples of those in the original game.

two.

Yeah.

Yeah, and it just felt like we couldn't come up with one more interesting thing to put in here. You know what I mean? That was one

We came up with five, actually.

Yeah. But that's That's what I think is better about this edition. The The groupings feel more distinct and interesting to me.

100% agree. That to me is what takes this above. You know, I like Nidavellir. To me, this is a better game than Nidavellir because it keeps the best part of the game, which is that coin system, and now adds more interesting, varied, diverse scoring.

Yeah.

I also like the the mead, the wheat hops

malt

malt tokens, sorry. The malt tokens

It looks like wheat, but

the malt tokens, because it also differentiates, "Hey, I want this card or this one." And there's a slight bit of interaction because those cards where they cancel out if you take two of the same number.

That's neat.

It well, yeah, but you could You're sitting there sometimes sweating cuz I don't want another 11 because it just becomes a big zero. Unless you take the insurance Some cards will let you get rid of those tokens.

It makes some cards actively bad for you. Whereas, I don't think there was anything like that in the original game. Every card gave you something. It would just be like, "Well, that one's two. That one's 12 points. I don't want the two points."

Right.

Now it's like, literally, this will just be a big old goose egg unless I get something else that turns that off, and then the the valuation of those cards you can earn uh is so different per player.

Yeah.

Like some cards are just fantastic for me. That guy has two gray stripes. That jumps me from, you know, 24 to 70 points or something crazy. But you might not be going into that, so who cares? You know, you don't want that guy. And so I I really like that. It obscures the scoring. You know, you have that feeling of I'm never quite sure who's winning. I think I'm doing pretty well, but I can't tell. And I like that. I don't want a game where I can tell I'm getting, you know, suckered, yeah. Um But then it makes all those characters easy to figure out, which I did think they were very, you know, straightforward and very different per player. Some things I just don't care for and some things I absolutely want and need in my engine. Like that, too.

Yeah, and those interactive ones specifically that will zero each other out. It adds another little wrinkle to when you are choosing uh what coins to place at the different taverns because it could be like, "You know what? You know what? I don't really care about any of those cards. I'll take whatever's left over. I'll put a two on there." Well, now if one of the cards could cancel me out, suddenly I do care. And I don't I it's just like I I don't want to be last. And so that's a neat little thing, too.

Yes.

Uh we did play a version of this live on our show. If you want to watch that, uh a couple uh things with buyer's guide. So, if you already own Nidavellir and you like it and you play it a few times a year, I don't think you need this unless you want to get rid of Nidavellir because they're very, very similar in many ways. And I I'd be hesitant to say you should own both. If you love Nidavellir like I do, I think you'll love the new things this adds and so that you might consider it. And if you don't own it either, then get this over Nidavellir. It's better scoring and they focused the the leader everything seems more balanced. I sat there. The game plays a little quicker because the warriors that you get the extra ones in columns, usually you go, "That's the one I want." You don't have to sit there and think about what they all do. You're like, "That's one."

It's a little more gamery. Um but overall, I think it's it's the better of the two. Um and if If those they make some poker chip versions of the coins the set I you can that would also be compatible with this.

Yeah.

Again, I don't know that you need both for most people. So keep that in mind unless again you're going to get rid of Nanty Narking um unless you like love it like I do. So it's not necessary for everybody but I love it.

Yeah. I I like it way better than I liked Nanty Narking. Like I said, it's been a while since I played Nanty Narking but I found half of the game

Mhm.

kind of boring.

Yeah.

And so like I said, it was like a seven. This is an eight for me. I think this is a whole point maybe a point and a half if we're thinking it was a 6.5 before. This is better. The characters are just more interesting and also less clunky special characters before. Some of those people you would take that were a little clunky like I know there was one that was like oh you guys have to put out your coins and then I put out my coins. Like I don't want to deal with this stuff. That's going to slow down the game. It just seems like whatever. Um this is more engaging. I like it better. There is it's they it's called a Nanty Narking sequel. It's somewhere between that and like a 2.0. It's not really a sequel.

A lot of people compare Dune Imperium to Dune uh

Uprising. Yeah.

Uprising or Ticket to Ride Ticket to Ride Europe. It's very much like that.

Yeah. Right. Right. But I agree with you 100%. If you don't have the original one this is clearly improved 2.0 version of that game just get this one.

Yeah.

It's an eight for me.

And I'm at an 8.5. Uh I do like it uh a bit better than Nanty Narking. I think I had Nanty Narking at an eight. This this takes it into the excellent category. I think really honestly the only thing that keeps it from even higher cuz I really love that core system so much in the scoring is definitely improved is that it's a relatively short game and it is one of those games where you'll be spending a fair amount of time for end game scoring. Um and and you know that was

It takes a little bit of time to count up your scores at the end of the game. And that's just something that, you know, if that was a little bit more streamlined, maybe I would go with a nine, but an 8.5, I really, really like the game. I think it's terrific. I'm with you though, it's you don't need both. Maybe if you played Nidavellir and you want to try the new stuff, give Nidavellir to somebody you know that wants a great game, and then you can both be playing a great game.

True. Yeah.

All right, it's a 9.5 for me, bordering on a 10. I Again, I just really like this game. It's Nidavellir was a game I pulled out at every convention and taught people because it really scales well. Two is okay, but three to five is fantastic. And um five is a is a number I often have at conventions and it's played so quickly. I like that. It is like an hour. And it's also a game that I have great success with. I explain the five coin things, everyone goes, "Ooh." It's just fun. And if someone gets that 25 coin, they're so proud. Getting a whole lot of one dwarf feels great. Getting the leaders, you're like, "Oh, I'm getting something really cool." And so then that balanced out I with a lot of gamers I played with, they've said they like the scoring better. Um yeah, so that I like it a lot. So, Dwarves of Aqualine, if you're going to Gen Con, stop by our booth, 249.

Um we'll have it for sale, not a ton of copies. And then after that, who knows? Check back with us in three or four weeks and we'll figure that out. But, great game. Check us out on The Dice Tower. I don't know why I said that. Um until next time, I'm Tom Vasel.

I'm Zee Garcia.

I'm Mike Delisio.

Check us out

on The Dice Tower. Hey, we're here at The Dice Tower.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved