Campaign Trail: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for campaign Trail uh and whatever green party it exists they felt bad for the party that they're like well we'll include you because you're not actually included in the actual debate you know anything else um so yeah I mean this was kind of a game that I I think I think I backed this around also the time I played chosen um and because I had the expansion and of course I'll probably actually we might compare these to compare this to shawson because both political games and internet control and Airway control so which is not a whole lot of but overall this one's not bad nope uh at least in my opinion I don't think it's great by any means like I I couldn't see myself wanting to sit down and play this all the time right um but in terms of just kind of a I mean there's not a whole lot of simple area control games right most of them are just doused in rules or like heavy conflict right and this one I felt the conflict was warranted like anytime someone was taken a spot or you know playing a card that like negatively impacted someone right it was like well that kind of makes sense for the theme uh but there's a few issues I kind of have with it but I think I kind of went and they didn't bug me as much probably
because I went into this not really caring like I wasn't gonna take this game too seriously because I feel like if you were if someone was going to play this game seriously it would it would be like the cheese dude right Derek anymore like he really went off the handle when you made fun of Missouri like he just went off so I felt the same way I went into this game not really caring that much for what it was which I'm happy because for area control game the cards have a lot of agency but because the cars are so Random their agency doesn't always feel like it matters yeah not really uh Zach what do you think um I don't I'm kind of on the same page as you I thought it was okay compared to shawson uh shawson oh you have played chawson okay I wasn't sure obviously I knew who we had so cool I um I think shawson's area control is much better yeah it's much more interesting I think the cards and shawson have a length of time before they become an uninteresting yeah I think they after about five games especially with the same deck you're true they eliminated that and it would just be this game but better yeah um kind of uh I like you're talking about the the debate like the discussion cards like whatever I like them in theory but yeah the first two times you play that deck and then it's just out the window yeah it's almost like a few decks though there are the only ones that are kind of of any pertinent is the obviously the US one because it's where
we're based but they have the Sci-Fi and then yeah um I think oh they did go okay and then I know there's an expansion for shawson coming out uh yeah with so so for let's talk about this real quick before I do I do want to make the comparison to shawson 100 here's my issue with this I'm gonna compare to shawson immediately because because Charleston is arbitrary like it's not an actual country it's more ambiguous the area control feels a little bit better whereas this one wanted to be more realistic right so it's like obviously the Midwest is going to be more Republican held than you have the green party sporadically around in the same way libertarian is all the ghost and that's perfectly fine there's something wrong with that but this game I feel like just gets immediately dated or it's immediately like well I'm gonna control these states right and that's that it's so hard to swing it obviously we haven't seen Missouri swing left in 20 years so I think that's actually probably the thing that bothered me the most is so California Texas New York we're almost in none of these cards yeah and so it's almost like well of course those States can't swing so you can never campaign there there's nothing you can do to go do the whole point is for me to redefine the math right right and it's like it's not that yeah oh my God you're right yeah because was there any any campaign California
uh I know you I I know he there was an advertising one no did I have one you well I drew it but it was supposed to be yours I think I've had one I had one campaigning for Texas the entire game yeah I mean I had a car that let me put three just on there but it didn't matter where it was I could just put three there um but incredibly Limited in campaigning in certain States yeah I mean really what it comes down to is you take those states by debate right um which I like I think that that's I think the debate mechanic is it's great easily the most thematic one but also not because you're not you're not actually debating you're not talking about them this game doesn't warrant discussion and it shouldn't because this is too close to home where shawson is also too close to home with the cards but the gameplay is not but you could go an entire round without getting like the gender discussion or other topic right right you could just lock out on your cards yeah which there is a big luck element to this game um it's still fun like it's it's short enough that it's not it's not a huge sweat yeah the random nature of it but it does it feels weird for this faction not to have I know that they probably got more placement on the map as a compensation for not having high Burgers tie Breakers but yeah you're at you're almost left out because of that little thought process of strategy you just you just don't even think about it yeah like you have to think about other people taking it but green is not even which
thematically makes sense but it's also kind of an interesting which may be even more interesting because you broke ties always to your favor yeah you had no tie Breakers anywhere and so again like we were talking about the advertising as well we just didn't do a lot of it because you broke ties every single time and it wasn't hard for me to stop ties against you right and talking about a thematic game a couple games use this mechanic where you have like a middle person who wants to put a wedge in between the two parties that would be much more interesting yeah like if you could bet like I'm gonna do this and this and this throughout the game at the beginning of the game and you did it and then that's how you won the game yeah that would be interesting or two people could win the game party could also win because they did something true yeah it's kind it was kind of like Ahoy where a boy had had the two polarizing factions and then the merchant was kind of like the mediator between between the two yeah yeah this doesn't have that and it's like look I get they why they wanted to add green party because it does exist but when you're trying to go so realistic right it's like this should be just a two-player game how shitty that is like how there's only two parties but it's like that's kind of how it is and libertarian kind of gets in there but here's my other problem with the the factions but not factions the parties um you like you play a like a idea like right just because I'm yellow and I'm libertarian none of my cars nothing denotes that I'm
libertarian except the states that I happen to right have swing in my favor right so I feel like I don't know like I I almost want this game to have a little discussion because what this could be really good for is educational purposes like a US geography or U.S history class or a government where it's like okay hey we're gonna play a game and then this is just around I mean it might be a little too much for that but you can bring up these breaking news cards you can talk about why certain states are the way they are right I think you are in the minority of most Gamers I think most Gamers would violently want to avoid discussions of politics whatever side you're at um yeah I think there's a lot of people who probably wouldn't back this game because of that just based on it's about politics that's true same thing with shots and shawson was a big thing which there's not anything too terribly controversial in that when people actually play it they're like oh okay yeah I don't know there's some explicit cards in like the that that there is but if you're doing a fascist thing and you're like that's a fascist thing oh yeah we all agree that's a fascist thing so like you know and if you have a problem with it you go Roman or you go cyber it doesn't matter then yeah and also you're probably not playing shots in with people that you don't already know yeah right I'm not going to Gen Con and randomly playing shots and be like oh man hell yeah school shootings you know like I would like and someone's like I think they're great I'd be like okay security like this guy's clearly a psychopath yeah yeah but with the shops
and thing it is interesting because like I'll play it and I'll get the colors I want it's I'm never doing it because I agree with the card or not just because I know that card should probably be red and I already have two Reds and I need a third red yeah and so I'm going to say yes to this it means nothing you're supposed to role play the role you're doing um and then you may have played the game with Josh Josh is just like I hate this like the entire time I'm like it made it made that funny but I can see looking through a window that it would be unappealing right so making this as plain toast as possible then one side makes it boring because I'd love to have like a character of Al Gore and like you get like areas in each like tree area and stuff yeah that would be funny to talk about but it also it pulls you closer to real exactly right and you can definitely tell that some of the characters that they have is you know Donald Trump Hillary Clinton right you can you that they that's like oh hey the rich guy well clearly who else would that be yeah um but I actually think that they did that in a very tasteful manner like yeah regardless of your opinion on who what what whatever politician none of them were like uh oh man I got Bill Clinton okay I have no advantages and and I have seven disadvantages okay like they didn't do that to just make it shitty right I think overall the balance the balances of the characters now granted there's a ton yeah in the game
and we haven't seen them all I thought they were pretty good like I don't think that it was like wow really okay like my disadvantage is so much worse than all of yours right I've never felt like anyone was overly powerful right underly powerful yeah it also didn't feel particularly aggressive for area control which I like yeah no I [ __ ] hate that and in area control games and the first thing that happened is you you did that thing with my money which [ __ ] me on the last turn but I was gonna get [ __ ] anyway so it didn't really matter right but I would say one of the things I think why I didn't feel like it was super aggressive is you didn't really have agency to go to an area that you wanted to it was always on the cards you had yeah you could move to the location and you had to the campaign but you had to be lucky enough to get I can't like the only reason you move there is because you already had a campaign and you knew what you were going to plan to do right and it just so happens that my very last turn it's like oh lucky me I moved there and I have no control over here and I have the money because you guys gave it all to me so I was super pissed off because I finally got on the car to take Texas the campaign car with the only taxes I ever had the term before I am uh jumped all the way back to my home state and that's why I was asking how many cards are there oh yeah I was like I'll just put six on Texas and take Texas right now yeah yeah because you put three down I was like oh he might try and he might try and grab it which would be huge right yeah it's just I think there's enough like this deck is huge yes um and there's probably enough in here that the randomness probably
evens out yeah or the fact that you have five cards like I was never really throughout the entire game I was never like truly wanting right like it was like okay these are all pretty good most the time it was over States I had yeah and that was kind of annoying but it's like okay well they have a politics I mean I have so many politics cards that just got me stuff yeah it's like I had to give away I mean I had to give away this one that's for the complete middle I had to give away you know these ones for the ones I didn't have control over when you play this with a vice president like two versus two do they get their own hand of the cards everybody yeah everyone gets their own handy you can share between each other you could meet um and you have to meet in the same spot but then you can share cards that's interesting all right yeah and then I think there's a there's some different setup um for that but but yeah like it's generally you you both are campaigning together and not the worst idea for a team game no and here's the other positive I'll say of this game it works really well at three yeah like area control games usually is one person just getting [ __ ] on and I would say up until the very literally the very end of the game it was like neck and neck yeah like and I was sitting here and you're like and you were probably out of it at that point um but it was kind of like well that could have been like oh I'm gonna take Florida and Texas right and then I'm out of it and then he actually swings forward so I never felt like in a three-player game someone usually is just getting [ __ ] the entire time right
and I usually find that annoying but it wasn't that bad here nope it wasn't that bad granted none of the choices are really all that interesting right uh there wasn't any cool like moves that I was like oh man even the debate section was just kind of like I'm gonna move this twice and one up okay I'm gonna undo that right all right and concerning like at that point I had two cards the other card I couldn't even play like it was just one choice yeah and I'm like oh okay so that's super awesome and it doesn't benefit either one of us it doesn't yeah move anything it's the debate while it's interesting for the upheaval so again because of the cards you hand are kind of random and you're cycling so fast it's like well I can't plan for it like I'm not playing yeah four turns ahead never yeah never once did I hold on to cards specifically for the debate it was kind of debate time oh like it was kind of like if I was if this this guy's a genius he's like the debate's tomorrow right oh [ __ ] I'm trying to get his notes together uh right drugs are bad the like dopamine well the dopamine hit of you going into that and just getting to put like 25 things on the board is fun yes and like the strategy of like making sure that I I now realize that you want to be last and whenever you're going into a debate which I Was preparing for in this last round that I realized there was no there's no debate not Cooper which I like I like how there's not a third debate right I do too
um but yeah I like it in theory it just it could have more to it yeah the and this is actually the I think this the deluxe yeah with the wooden pieces I you know visually I like the way whenever you just quick glance at it you can just see the majority like if they if you were to take a snapshot and just highlight it it's like okay this stays you know for green party and then it goes like here's yellow like you would see with the demographic right vote in practice though it's muddy yeah like so many times was it like okay I need to place one voter out okay well I don't have anyone so anything it's a lot of upkeep and also there were multiple times because like the end of turn cards that I had where it's like okay into the game I'm gonna take these I didn't want to give away what I was gonna get but I could I had no idea what those electoral votes were right so I didn't want to sit here and be like okay so what is what is I did figure that out is in your book oh my God you're right it is I forgot oh because I had the same situation at one point um oh is when I was looking at Florida and Georgia because I had the car I was debating do I go and try to take those from you guys and so I came in here looking at what the boats were for them it's like oh that's a good chunk right there yeah yeah yeah okay yep that's a good point so I will say that is probably the number one great thing is you need this and everyone gets one it's amazing um it literally tells you every you know every token what is for every state that's associated with that token so you
can to a certain extent plan and you can see the boats over here so like California's 55 Arizona is 11. and you can quickly kind of go over here because that's what I did it's like oh Florida's 29 because you guys were covering up over there I did not want giveaways like I put tons of votes down there and also tells you for each policy because you see my faith it's like oh international relations and National Security oh if I went out on National Security that's 98 votes my way and that's oh it's all those States I can take them from set I don't know if I can take California Zach's out of the game cool but it's so hard right and like I was like okay I want to take California and then I want to move to uh Alaska and Hawaii and take but never even got a car to go for those things yeah I'm like so for area control games like well then what what's that value for right it would be nice if like whenever you campaign you could also do the state you're in right like as well as those others because it doesn't make any sense for you to be like I'm gonna campaign in this region but you also have to be there it's like I mean I get it they give you a wide variety so you don't have to like hoof it right you don't have to spend six turns moving and the advertising is good because you know basically that's how you're getting the broad range across the map right um so to me I do like those two are different um but realistically for the advertising other than the fact that you can't just just pump in one spot
best bang for the buck is probably advertising pretty consistent probably yeah if you don't have someone who can break ties and even then it's like the tiebreaker is really nice but if you noticed I only put enough yeah to to break the time hope you guys didn't take it back because I I was so I was always low on registered voters which again I like the fact that it's like oh I only have one I'm just gonna play this card for seven oh yeah I'm just gonna quickly go anytime I did that is because I had a plan that's like I started counting up how many states there were oh there's seven states and I got four yeah I need more yeah and it's just so quick you don't have to do any some cumbersome [ __ ] thing to get more it's just quickly get them yes uh but yeah I mean a lot of my free time the reason I played as many as I did is because I was banking on the tiebreaker right but and then once it got towards the end that was the only time I preemptively was like okay just in case someone sneaks in maybe they won't have enough to break the tie yeah so overall like not a horrible game no uh I still would rather play shawson um kashasan to me is a solid area control game uh on top of discussion right like um like every time I've played it normally I'm also I'm not playing with people who have disparity viewpoints just because that doesn't sound fun but it's like oh that's interesting you know I'm gonna pick that and then it
might cause some discussion right I like that every game that you play always ends in a why is that that you can always choose the wrong I've seen it in every single game oh yeah yeah somebody picks the wrong option and it's like that doesn't make any [ __ ] sense right um You see I've never I've never had that problem like and because like I'll play with people you know somebody will walk by it's like how do you just have red and blues like well you just guessed the right answer yeah I've never played that game in the sense of like trying to guess what the options are they say you're supposed to be able to get context clues to get the the tokens you want I'm just like well I'm playing a super passive person so that's what I'm gonna go with yeah and to see what they get um yeah I don't really have like much else to to talk about on this game nope uh I do like the I actually the breaking news I didn't think was actually all that bad no that actually did add some flavor and theme to it and I felt that they were pretty like oh some of them were like oh everyone has to do this right or you know they look so devastating yeah there wasn't like one person that was like that only affects me like why uh because those type of top deck events are really annoying and then others were just more hey if you do this now you get a benefit for it right um yeah uh on a scale of one to ten what would you guys give campaign Trail start with the sack I'll do seven seven
yeah six point five yeah I'm actually I'm kind of right there I think I'm gonna give it a 6.5 as well um it's I think also because I was thinking six I think six and a half I'll give it a benefit for also not being all that long right and the reason why I was gonna say that is because when when we went through August it was like oh my God that's a huge deck but then after the debates it ramped up because you had to drop to your hand limit and I'd already shortened the September deck and then October and we started playing more cars that because we started getting engines and people were drawing more carts per exactly so yeah it wasn't so then it's like it was kind of like okay well August is you starting your campaign to prep and then after the first debate then it's like okay now I'm gonna try and swing some of these right so it actually worked out pretty pretty well yeah all right well that's our thoughts on campaign Trail let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like I'm gonna share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like put not other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you