"Strong-Man" Government, Weak Military (w/ Akar Bharadvaj) | Board & Book #6
Transcript
Hey gamers, this is Liz Davis from Beyond Solitire and I'm here for another episode of Board and Book and this time my guest is Car Barvage. He is the designer of Chalice of Poison, uh, which we'll be talking about today. How you doing, Aar?
I'm great. How are you, Liz?
I'm doing awesome. I'm super happy to have you on. It's always a delight to chat with you. Um, for people who don't know, uh, what is just the basic rundown on Chalice of Poison? So, Childs of Poison is about the Iran Iraq war that occurred historically between 1980 and 1988. Um, it uh was a war between it was the largest uh conventional war of the late 20th century and yet it's uh kind of undertalked about and certainly undergamed. Uh so I did a lot of research in it and I thought it would be an interesting topic for the game. One of the reasons it's been undergamed is that the war itself was kind of a stalemate and a slog for a very long time. both countries kind of uh hit their limit pretty fast and then just kind of wore away at each other. So that's a little frustrating as a military game, but uh I thought of another method of kind of gaming it out that focuses more on the political challenges within that conflict. And I think uh all the kind of frustrations become a feature, not a bug when you consider it that way.
Oh, that's really interesting. So, how did you I mean, if it's sort of undergamed and underdone, how did you stumble on the topic or was it something that's long been an interest for you?
Uh, so Middle Eastern history uh of the 20th century is been a interest of mine for a while. It's that was kind of the core of my undergraduate degree. Uh, specifically, I returned to it uh in to this topic uh in 2022. It was during the Russian invasion of Ukraine and I started reading about uh that conflict and try trying to read some about theory about why uh Russia which if you looked on paper should have absolutely destroyed Ukraine very fast in that war wound up getting kind of uh dug down and took a long time. And so uh a work colleague and I uh were kind of talking about comparing those two historical examples. the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the Iraqi invasion of Iran and trying to understand what features of uh authoritarian rule uh lead to uh militaries that seem very powerful on paper but not in reality and ironically more prevalent in so-called strongman regimes than it does in other kinds of authoritarian regimes. So a country like uh Ba'ist Iraq run by Saddam Hussein kind of as a personalist regime had a lot of uh problems inherent to it that led to uh not doing very well in combat and I think uh Putin's Russia has had a lot of similar things.
Got it. Um stupid question. This is the war that is a major plot point in the Procepilus graphic novels. Correct.
Yes. I believe mostly in Procepilus 2.
Yeah. uh which uh yeah sadly we lost Marjan Centropy recently uh but those books are excellent. Um highly recommend them to anybody. I should have included that in my book list. That's
well what was funny is that that was the only reason I really I was like I know what this is because I've read about it and um so comics do educate everyone. Uh but uh so for me that's really the only thing I have to contribute to this conversation in terms of any historical context or expertise at all. So that's why you're here. Uh so you did put together some media to um to to help us as we want to explore the background of child poison. So what is your first recommendation?
So my first recommendation uh is this book. It's called the dictator's army by Dr. Caitlyn Telmage. I believe she's at MIT currently. Um, and this book is great. It's all about uh kind of the paradox that I just mentioned about why strongman regimes tend to be bad at uh fighting adversaries in military conflict. Uh so her she puts together a very clear framework based on a lot of research into different different conflicts and uh specifically the book focuses on two case studies. One is of the Iran Iraq war and the other one is North versus South Vietnam. uh potential spoilers for future games that I want to make using the same the same system. Um but her basically argument is that uh authoritarian regimes often base uh use their militaries primarily to prevent coups rather than actually be effective enough to fight adversaries. And every factor that makes a military coup proof also lowers its military effectiveness.
So she identifies uh four different factors which are literally baked into my game as different actions. Uh it's promotion patterns. Uh authoritarian regimes tend to promote for feelalty and syphy rather than competence. uh training uh regimes. Authoritarian countries tend not to train, especially since a lot of training requires live fire exercises and Saddam Hussein didn't want large militaries with arms uh driving around Iraq and near Baghdad. He wanted to avoid that. So people didn't learn. Uh he also didn't let people um study uh a lot of their planes were Soviet made and he didn't want people going to the Soviet Union because he was worried that they would come back with communist ideas and uh not be as loyal to him.
Um there's also command arrangements. Uh so authoritarian regimes uh including Iran and Iraq have tend to have centralized or unclear command and control. So, uh, if I'm a troop on the ground, uh, I would have to contact headquarters or the capital before I can make decisions rather than improvising around the uncertainty that appears. That leads to very slow reaction to combat situations. Uh, these these governments al also often separate their military forces. So, that prevents the ability to have combined arms. If your air force and your navy and your ground troops are not talking to each other, they can't work together. Uh but if they are talking to each other then they're potentially a threat to your regime. Uh lastly is information sharing. Yes, exactly.
Um lastly was uh information. So uh a lot of these regimes uh instill a fear to tell the truth uh because uh they they want an officer that tells the truth uh puts his own head at risk. So uh and this historically was the case where a lot of officers would tell uh their leadership that uh you know things were not going great and they would get demoted or even worse uh because of it. And so they it wound up being this kind of saccharine view that the top level leadership would have of how strong they were and uh they would learn the hard way that they were not as strong as they thought. Uh this also prevented uh a lot of forces from learning lessons. So um basically in in Iran of this time there was this idea that the revolutionary spirit made people natural fighters and so a lot of uh a lot of the early successes were attributed to that uh fact and so they basically they thought they were invulnerable and they weren't and they learned that the hard way.
I um I know this is about the Middle East in the 1980s, but uh this sounds kind of familiar.
Yes. Uh so a lot of the a lot of the arguments I make in this game uh became more relevant uh around the world after uh I started designing this. Um so yes, it's it's rather unfortunate, you know, this and there's there's kind of interesting kind of gender studies dynamic to this as well. Like we call them strong man regimes. There's uh there's an element of hyper masculinity and this the sort of fetishization of military power uh and anger against sort of um diversity of thought that actually leads to effective outcomes and uh you know I know you've been working on a game about Gettysburg and uh you've seen various uh school teachers who utterly routed Lee's army and
Oh yes
yes for the win
exactly creativity ity that liberal arts teaches that you know um lifting weights does not
Yes. You mean doing like a little half pull-up is not does not a man make?
No.
But this is actually really interesting. Like it makes me think about I mean some makes me think of the Roman Empire too, right? where you have like pritorian guards and
you know deepening paranoia forces you to kind of split up or set at odds leaders who could be working together for you.
Um yeah I never thought about it that way. So when it comes to game mechanisms how did you like express this in the game? So within the game, kind of the main currency of the game is uh political power which are represented by cubes. And basically [clears throat] the different actions you take in the game all require expending the political power cubes or uh kind of pushing them to downwards towards your officer core. Uh and so if that's your currency to make every change that makes your military more effective. But if your regime pool ever runs out of political power cubes, then that's it. That's the end of the game. your regime has collapsed and you might be close to winning the war, but all of a sudden your officers are having ideas. Why should they listen to you? Uh your dissident groups are uh declaring independence and you everything kind of uh falls apart.
So, it's a it's kind of an interesting uh play dynamic that I think is fairly unique. And I've noticed with play testers, a lot of them, their first game goes pretty fast because I think if you give a if you give a gamer 10 action points, they're going to spend all 10 action points. And if I say, "No, don't do that. That is a bad idea."
Uh then, you know, they'll it takes a little while to kind of fight that instinct. Uh but then, uh usually that first game happens pretty quickly and then immediately they're like, "Oh, let's set up, let's play again." They got good clicks. So that's kind of the core of the game. There's also a a series of uh actions and officers that you basically have to play with. Uh your officers learn things from battles. Uh but the key is that not every lesson they learn is a good lesson. So you'll find a lot of officers who will win a battle and then become arrogant and that will make them uh worse as a commander. And typically speaking in the game uh losing battles teaches you more than winning them does. Um, but of course winning battles has its own advantage on the battlefield. So about half the game is uh the actual conflict. The other half is more internal dynamics and military effectiveness, but it's um uh it's a lot less fiddly than that might sound
interesting. So basically sometimes you have to lose and get punched in the face a little bit in order to know better.
Yes. You're you're winning the war, not the battle. That's really interesting.
Okay. So, all right. We talked about some of like the core tensions of this game and how they're coming out. What is your next book or media recommendation?
So, next book is this uh big old chunker. Uh it's the Iraq War by Pierre Razu. This book is hands down the most thorough analysis of the conflict that I've seen. Uh and it's pretty new. I want to say it's a couple years old uh at this point. So because this conflict is so recent, there's uh a lot more information coming out about it all the time and a lot of countries offer access to their archives that didn't before. And so uh Pier Razu uh has gotten access to a lot of information that historically people have not and um I think certainly among American scholars uh have not gotten access to a lot of Iranian information sources that I believe he's French and he's been able to uh reach out to a lot of people. So it's been pretty great to get that level of information. Uh the other cool thing about Pier Razu is he's actually a board game designer as well. So, he's uh made a couple games. Uh one uh is called uh Bloody Waves, I believe, and it's about sorry, Bloody Dawn, and it's about the Iran Iraq war as well. Uh and he has another one called Fitna, which is uh I believe it takes place in the 2010s, and it's more about kind of global war on terror, uh ISIS era, uh conflict across the Middle East.
So, uh, super exciting person to to follow, uh, if you're making a game about the history of the modern Middle East.
Have you all interacted about your respective work?
Uh, no. I I need to reach out to him. I've talked to, uh, Kaitlin Talmage, who wrote the first book, but I haven't reached out to Pierre yet, but I'll
you write this guy.
Yes, I should. Um,
I'll put together a panel.
There you go. No, that'd be great at some point. And his games have a very different focus from mine. So, I think it's um I think there's a lot of uh interesting conversations we could have. I unfortunately have not played either of these games and I really want to, but I'm not sure that uh I have the group for it currently.
No. Well, I mean, SD has coming up, so
it's true. I should uh I should pick up copies and bring them.
Fantastic. So, we've got a kind of like theoretical underpinninging book.
We have a really good overall historical coverage book.
Uh, and then what's next?
So, after that, I kind of focused on the two countries more specifically. So, I have this book here called The Iran Iraq War by Williamson Murray and Kevin Woods. Kevin Woods is a former colleague of mine. He was the one I was talking about earlier who uh we were talking about writing a a paper co-writing a paper about uh Putin and Saddam and comparing the two. So uh this book is very interesting. Basically it uses uh documents that were captured by the US military after 2003 uh from Iraq and they found massive troves of documents that uh they archived and uh for a while the archive was open to scholars of the National Defense University but then it got closed due to government budget cuts. So then it uh it's since changed its uh housing a few times. It went to the Wilson Center and now it's at the Hoover Institution at Stanford uh and it's finally open again. So it's basically open if you are a researcher you can access it and uh kind of learn a lot. So this book is excellent. It provides an inside view into what's typically an opaque regime and you really get a good idea of Saddam Hussein as a person. uh you think about his aspirations, his worldview and his decision-making process. Uh, and it's super interesting stuff because, you know, it's it's kind of tricky to put yourself in that worldview being, you know, I live in a very different world that than Saddam Hussein did. And I think it's pretty easy to, you know, make assumptions and be like, "Oh, he's just a crazy person." But it's like, okay, so let's understand that a little deeper like what what made him tick?
What were kind of the objectives that he had in mind? And um, we we'll talk a little bit more in in a few minutes about kind of how how great he thought he was and what sort of aspirations he had. But it was it was helpful not just to design a game based on my worldview, but about the world view of the people that a game model.
So, um I I'm just making assumptions, but the names of the authors of these books so far sound like pretty western.
Yes. So like
um I guess like what how do like people who would remember the word people who were there or people whose culture it directly impacted like how do they seem to feel about child of poison about the sources that you're using? like how do you like how do you decide how do you get at like more firsthand accounts or more um I guess accounts that are are more local to the conflict.
Um so because my game kind of takes place at the strategic and political level. So uh there's a lot of kind of firsthand accounts from the officers who uh fought in the conflict. uh in terms of kind of the the popular view of the conflict among the the civilians who lived it and suffered horribly. Um I think uh you know there's a lot written there I think and it's fascinating and very harrowing a lot of the times but it's um I think it's important to read for uh to understand the conflict more but in terms of the the model of the game it's uh unfortunately a little out of scope but uh that said I did get a lot of firsthand accounts uh that's actually is a good segue to my next source which is uh called Saddam's generals perspectives on the Iran Iraq war uh and this was based on a project uh called the 1946 project. Um 1946 the US Army interviewed a lot of former uh German officers to kind of understand decision-m within uh the German military during World War II.
And they decided to do something similar in Iraq uh after the 2003 invasion. And so that is a lot of firsthand accounts from the uh military commanders uh both talking about how uh kind of their personal perspectives on the war, what it was like to fight in it, uh what it was like to lead folks who fought in it, uh what got people promoted, what didn't, and so forth. So that's been very interesting. Uh that was a good source, especially from a more personal firand view of it. Um I would preface it by saying that there's a lot of bias and subjectivity in these interviews. uh both it's it's people's opinions and it's people's opinions who agreed to be interviewed by the US military after an invasion. So very specific sliver of uh of what people went through but it's still kind of useful for analysis.
Nice. That makes less sense. Um so uh I always say three pieces of media but I also love it when people cheat. So, do you have anything else before me before we go to the SL before we go to the slideshow?
Uh, I will I'll I'll uh do lightning round of two more things. So, I talked talked about kind of the Iraq sources. Uh, this is a great source uh about the Iranian military and uh how it navigated the uh Iranian revolution in 1979 and then the following purges and then conflict erupting uh immediately afterwards. So, I'd recommend this book as well. And then uh kind of a good uh primer on the situation that just came out in his book Black Wave. Uh this is excellent. I'd recommend this to anybody. It's not super um it's not super like historically deep. It's and it's very uh exciting to read and uh fascinating, but basically it views the entire history of the Middle East since 1979 kind of as a proxy conflict between Saudi Arabia and Iran. Uh super interesting stuff. not uh uh the Iran Iraq war plays a role in it, but it's not kind of the focus of it. So, this was better for thinking about broader cultural context, but I definitely recommend this one uh if you don't read anything else and have a have a very tangential interest in this topic.
Oh, cool. Okay, nice. Um, so this is actually a very nice range of books. I like the the popular to more thorough scholarly coverage. This is really good. But I want to look at some pictures. Picture time, everyone. Um, so
you put together a really cool slideshow of propaganda from this period,
and I I just want to know what all of it is.
So, I was very I was very inspired by uh Tori's uh book board and book series where she talked a lot about the murals of suffraism and I thought it would be interesting to kind of talk about this as well. So, uh, it's kind of looking at Iraqi and Iranian propaganda from the time and thinking about what it says about those two, uh, governments in the 80s. So, if you look at Iraqi propaganda, it tends to be very personalist. It puts Saddam Hussein in the middle of everything. You can see this here. Uh, he is couched as the protector of Iraq. Uh, and all the other people in this picture are very tiny and he is massive and right in the middle. and he is protecting the country from uh uh this uh this giant threat here. So uh the Ba'ist party in uh was nominally a panarab nationalist party but by the 1980s Arab nationalism was kind of waning in popularity. So Saddam needed a new source of power and uh he he built it based around his own personality. So he became the center of a lot of this uh and Iraq having uh you can go to the next slide please. So Iraq of course has a very long thousands and thousands of years old history and Saddam Hussein being uh considering himself an Iraqi nationalist looked to history to justify his rule. So he was uh obsessed with comparing himself to two figures. One was uh Saladin uh from the middle ages and the other one was the ancient Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar II. Uh both of these folks were famous for uh
capturing Jerusalem and uh as as somebody who was very anti-Israeli, I think Saddam Hussein connected himself to these folks a lot.
Yeah. Also, is that kind of Hammurabi in the middle of the one on the top left?
Uh yes, I think it is. I I did not notice that.
I am I very certain that's what that is.
It looks like it. Uh interesting. Um so yes I mean he loved Nebuchadnezzar but uh there's a lot of reference to other Mesopotamian kings of this time and the next slide actually shows that but uh that kind of the height of this comparison between Saddam Hussein and Nebuchadnezzar I was uh a big push that he made in the 80s to renovate the ancient city of Babylon. uh you wouldn't think this would be something that would be high priority while while this country was partially under occupation of foreign forces but uh and this country was horribly in debt but it was important from kind of a propaganda perspective uh to bring together uh the spirit of nationalism. So you can see on the bottom left that is from the 1987 Babylon uh fair or convention. I don't know what it's called, but it shows Saddam Hussein and the book in desert the second together on an ancient looking coin.
That is really an ancient looking coin. Like the profiles, the Oh, that's hilarious, you know. But hey, you know, ballrooms, Babylon, what's the difference?
Exactly.
Um anyway, uh so then we can look at the next slide. Uh
there we go.
Whoa. Sometimes the ties between the Iran Iraq war and HMS Mesopotamia were a little more explicit than others. In this case, this is
very subtle. This one,
very subtle. This is a direct take. You can see there's a a dead lion on the front. This is a direct take on uh another work of Asher Bonnipal, the Assyrian king, uh who I guess there was a a famous picture of him hunting lions. And this was uh
his way of saying, you know, I'm hunting lions as well in my own way. Uh but yes, very subtle like you said.
Yes. Uh
have you seen the lion hunt um carvings from um they're in the British Museum now, but there are some really incredible like ancient images of animal hunts that this is this is wild to see with some helicopters and planes. So, like I spent I don't know if we ever talked about this, but my um Okay, fortunately, they've renamed it because the name was not good, but uh my first like real kind of like summer job was at the the Oriental Institute. Oh god. At the University of Chicago. It's now called Isaac Institute for the Study of Ancient Cultures. I think that's much better. Um,
but I spent like hours in my undergrad years like looking at like the mess exhibit in that museum. And so, you know, who knew that my college gig would make this look much more familiar to me than I would have expected?
You should be talking about this propaganda you know you know more about than I do.
Super interesting. I I don't know that much about ancient civilizations admittedly. I just uh I looked into it a bit for to compare these two. But uh yeah, super interesting stuff.
Yeah. The thing is though, I don't think that this evidences any serious knowledge of ancient civilizations either other than that it's like a cultural image that people understand like like the Roman togate George Washington sculpture.
Exactly.
That is in the United Romany stuff. It just makes us feel good. So like this is their Romans.
Exactly. Uh it's just usually I've never seen any sort of neocclassical stuff with tanks and planes in it. Uh though that might be coming soon.
Um
you know, let's now that we've said it like oh god what horrors have we spoken into existence together.
Um so well we can contrast uh the this Iraqi propaganda with some Iranian stuff. So if you go to the next slide please.
Oo. So Iranian propaganda is very different at this time. Uh it a lot of it focuses more on national unity. So Iran was just coming out of its 1979 revolution and uh basically the government recognized that the war was an opportunity to consolidate power uh over what was an unstable situation and there was a big kind of boom in patriotism after Iraq invaded Iran. So they didn't want to let this opportunity slide. So most of their propaganda was based on national unity and based on the idea that you know together we can win. So this was a lot more similar to a lot of western propaganda you see during World War II. Um the one on the left you can see uh up top. So he is in the picture but he's not the focus of the picture.
He's kind of in the background looking on in support. But what do you see in front? you see a lot of Iranian soldiers that are all of different ethnicities all fighting together and so this is kind of the the sign of this is our country getting together and fighting together uh under the opaces of uh the Islamic Republic of Iran. So kind of taking this nationalism and using it to drum up support for the regime.
Yeah,
the one on the right is super interesting. If you think about it in the context of coming out a year after the revolution, uh you see something that's very uh a symbol that's very focused on popular revolution, the fist in the air and uh it's squeezing some planes and uh the planes show a Soviet and American flag. And uh there's a a massive crowd in the bottom of protesters and the idea is like the same power that took down the sha uh can take on the entire world. we can take on the Iraqis as well as uh the two superpowers that sold the Iraqis weapons. There's a lot of poignant symbology there that involves the entire country, not just uh its leader. Uh so we go to the next slide.
So a lot of the Iranian propaganda showed all the different elements of society, right? It's kind of um I think it was inspired by a lot of like futurist. Um, yeah, Iran had a very kind of thriving modern art scene that uh I think the a lot of people left after the revolution, but there were still a lot of great artists that were there that could make this sort of work. Um, so these two pictures, they show the different elements of society fighting together. Uh, in both of them, you see soldiers, but you also see clerics, the elderly, the youth, you see women. Uh, and they're all facing the fight together. Uh, you'll notice the women are in the back. Uh so they're not facing the fight uh kind of uh at equal levels, but they're still part of the fight.
Um you see kind of the symbols. So you see, you know, soldiers holding a rifle. Uh there's people holding a Quran. The the woman on the left is holding a baby. And it's like the different the different like kind of tools that Iran was going to use to win this war. Um super interesting to think kind of as a society about what uh war means for people. Wow.
So then we can go to the
Let's have a look.
Next slide, please.
So this is kind of a grim one, but uh a lot of Iranian propaganda was focused on martyrdom. Uh so I'm not going to go into Shia theology but essentially during this time uh there was a big push among the theologians in Iran to uh support martyrdom as a concept basically tying uh historical uh sacrifices uh including the 7th century battle of Carbella as kind of justification for modern-day martyrdom for a greater cause. And so the Iranians figured out a way to kind of use their uh their sorrow and their loss as a way to drum up support for their side. So whereas the Iraqi propaganda had to be triumphant all the time, uh Hussein would like needed needed that feeling like he was winning, uh a lot of the Iranian stuff was more meant to uh to tap into uh more subtle emotions like this is remember your loss. Uh the one on the left if you I don't know if you can see it in the size but it's um it's a funeral where a bunch of people are holding a coffin that contains hearts and uh all of them have a hole in their chest and it's got this is the loss and then the one on the right is um directly tying uh the martyrdom of Iranian soldier to uh the seventh martyrdom of Hussein Iban Ali 30 and Shiism.
Wow. Yeah, these are really
um so I think
brutal
they're pretty they're yeah they're pretty they're pretty rough. Um and so kind of to switch to something slightly lighter if you go to the next slide please. So uh so I mean cartoons were also important. We were talking about comics earlier. Um, but uh the you know the one on the left is uh an Iraqi child fighting an off an Iranian cleric uh with a pencil. Um and it's basically I believe that says we draw for victory uh in Arabic there. Uh and this is you know this is propaganda trying to involve this is one of those Iraqi propaganda points that does involve kind of the greater society. Uh, and on the one one on the right is also pretty grim, but it's at least cartoony, so hopefully it's a little lighter than the previous one, but it's an Iranian soldier stabbing Saddam Hussein with a bayonet.
So,
but how are exactly? Uh, I think he's running trying to cross the the river to go back to Iraq. But, uh, yeah, it's from a a humor magazine called Salt Shaker, which I was trying to understand what that was in reference to, and I was notful. Uh,
oh, that's really interesting. I was going to ask who's the target audience for this. So, Salt Shaker sounds like adults would read that, but this one looks like the one on the left looks like it's
I believe The one on the left is from a children's coloring book. Uh the one on the right I believe is uh I think it's targeted as adults, but I was trying to figure that out and I couldn't tell. Um I I looked up this magazine and the only reference I could find was this cartoon.
So, oh yeah, I was saying like at the one on the left, I think there was there was a lot of pages from this uh coloring book that were of of various qualities in terms of how they were colored that I could find. And this one was one of the better ones.
Oh my god. I'm also fascinated by the Salt Shaker magazine like that the logo of that guy um riding backwards in that donkey. I think um so there's there's kind of there's a um like in folk in Middle Eastern folktales there's a character named Nasaredin Hoja which uh kind of he was kind of like a a smart alec character who um uh he's one of these like wise figures who there's a lot of funny stories to show how like wise and tricky he was. I believe that comes from a story of his. I might be completely mistaken. please racist if I am, but I think I believe that's the case.
Oh, that's really interesting. So, um, you mentioned like finding kind of different, uh, iterations of the coloring book, like it being colored in different ways. I guess like this kind of raises a question of we don't really think about archaeologies being of recent things,
but how good is our source preservation? Like, you know, you mentioned like archives being open, stuff like that, but in terms of like pop culture, newspapers, magazines, like how good are our are sources from this time period and from this place?
Uh, it's pretty challenging, I think. Um, you know, and as as somebody I I studied Arabic for a bit, but I I'm not fluent uh anymore and uh if I ever was, and uh I don't know Persian. So I think kind of language is a limiter there in terms of remembering this. I uh I also don't know how much of this has been digitized. Uh certainly government documents have but in terms of like popular culture like this I'm not entirely sure and even kind of propaganda was not as easy to find as I would have imagined. Uh the other kind of interesting thing that I found was uh kind of doing research into both countries is seeing the difference between the two because so much of uh the Iraqi stuff because their government uh fell after the USled invasion of 2003. There's a lot of their archives that are open uh and researchable.
Whereas on the Iranian side, a lot of the folks, a lot of the military officers in my game, a lot of them are still in power. Um there was I saw recently there was one who did to uh a very senior position in the military. I saw him on the front page of the New York Times. I was like, "Oh, I know that guy." And then I reached into my prototype and I found the card that had his name on it. Um
Whoa.
There was another one who uh there was another one who uh was assassinated by an Israeli strike uh earlier this year. I was like, "Oh, wow." Uh and it felt very real. Um, and so it's interesting to think about, you know, this wasn't very long ago and a lot of these people are still here who they still have very similar jobs that as what they had did before. Uh, but you know, I mean, I was alive for half of this conflict and uh, it wasn't that long ago. So, it's interesting what gets digitized, what gets remembered. Uh, I don't know that Western sources are going to have full access to the Iranian archives anytime soon in the way that they did with the Iraqi archives. Yeah.
Um, so I think that's kind of the risk of making a game about a more modern conflict and you kind of have to work around that and caveat everything appropriately. This is not a perfect worldview. This is based on a lot of biases, but all all historical game models are.
Yeah. I mean, fair enough. So, having looked through all of this awesome stuff that you've pulled together for us, um, what do you want people to come away with the most after playing Child of Poison?
Um, if nothing else, in kind of a weird way, it is uh an ode to kind of creativity and diversity of thought. um it's that that you can kind of fetishize violence and uh and power and that's not the best way to look at it. And if you're more kind of open to changes uh to your system and to learning uh how to improve yourself, I think there's a lot to learn there. And uh in a lot of ways hardness is brittle. And I think that lesson is maybe more relevant now than when I started uh started designing this game. But I I think and just to think about if you are a historical gamer or war gamer to think about that the fact that war is not just uh an act and of itself. It has objectives. It has kind of uh political goals. And I think we forget that in historical gaming a lot.
So I I wanted to put that kind of more in the center. And I think that's that's worth thinking about.
Fantastic. And if people want to play Chalice of Poison um or get a copy, what is the best way to do that?
Um so on the GMT website, uh so Chalice of Poison is currently on their pre-order uh system called the P500 uh where you you can pre-order your game and then uh once it hits over 500 then they'll uh start scheduling it for produ. It has just hit 500, so uh hopefully it should be coming out in the next year or so. Uh but yes, please pre-order it. The more pre-orders we get, uh the faster the game will come out. If this sounds interesting to you, um you can also follow on boardamegeeek. I usually post links that come out about it on inside GMT.com. Uh I've posted a series of articles that are about my design process and uh going a little more detail about uh what goes into this game. So, uh, those are three great sources you can learn more. And, uh, we're also looking for play testers. Um, if you are interested in play testing, uh, I I need to figure out a way to get, uh, Discord, uh, link out, but, uh, you feel free to join that.
I'll put it in the show notes if you want.
Oh, yes, please.
Perfect. Uh, so, Aart, thank you so much for coming on and talking to us a bit about your game. I honestly this just makes you want to know a lot more about this topic. I'm really really excited for Chaz of Poison. Uh and if you're out there watching, I think you should be too.
Awesome. Thanks for having me, Liz. This is a lot of fun and I I love this series. I think it's great what you're doing with uh kind of thinking more academically about games and their sources.
Yeah, I've been I I just feel like I learn something every time. So, thanks for that everybody out there. I hope you learned something, too. So please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions and most of all happy gaming.