Skip to main content
Loading video...

Amun Re Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:51

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at almond Ray this is an older Rhino canitzia auction game that's just been reprinted by Alley Cat games this one takes 60 to 90 minutes to play and accommodates two to five players now before I get into my thoughts on arm and Ray I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so Ammon Ray is gonna look like this when it's set up and the main board here is made up of all these different locations where we will be bidding for to try and control and they'll come with their different benefits at the top of the board here you have this little currency track which shows how much goods are going to cost you later in the game you have an initiative track you have the score track around the outside of the board and you have this Ammon Ray track which can affect other moving Parts in the game such as your payouts from your farmers as well as points if you end up controlling these temples other components include the location cards which have been drawn on the board already so each each round essentially you are going to be drawing the same amount of cards equal to the number of players so for example here I've set up for a fire player game therefore there are going to be five locations available to be bid for this round you have this deck of cards here which are going to give you some game breaking Powers you've got the farmers and each player is going to have their three little scribes here which are

essentially just their bidding markers you have these bricks the pyramids and these double pyramids now essentially three bricks will turn into a pyramid and two pyramids will turn into a double pyramid so it's just a way of tracking your presence on the map and these are going to be one of the main ways of getting points you could have some currency cards that look like this each player is going to start with 20 uh in total of those you have these scheme cards which are going to be objectives that you're going for so you can see here when it comes to a scoring phase I want to have control of at least nine farmers and if I do I'm gonna get three points for doing that and each player is also going to start with these two and precise cards this architect card and this thief card which I'll talk about the relevance of later and of course you have the remaining currency cards for the bank so the game is broken down into six rounds and each of those six rounds has four phases and after the first three rounds there'll be a scoring with What's called the Old Kingdom and then the final three rounds will be the New Kingdom now let's start with the basic rules and then we'll uh we'll talk about how the special cards can break some of those rules the first thing you're going to do as I mentioned earlier is going to draw a number of cards equal to the number of players and put it on the relevant spaces um on the maps you can see how I put this Thebes card on the Thebes location and then in player order the players are going to be placing their scribes bidding for these different locations so without thinking too much

um let's just place my marker here let's say I'm willing to bid three for this one then I'll go to the next player and perhaps they want to bid for this one and try to get a cheap deal on it like say by only bidding one uh then the next player might say you know what that's a cheap price I'll go for three uh on that one the next player will say you know I'm gonna try and be cheeky and get this one for zero and then maybe the final player will say um I'm gonna try to do the same thing and get one over here for zero as well now if you if it gets back to you and you have been outbid like for example if it gets back to the uh the blue player here and they've been outbid by this orange player then they have to move their scribe onto another location um and be winning essentially so they could either try and outbid another player or they again they can try go somewhere else but let's just say they went here like so to try and get this one for cheap if you are still in the um in the lead when it gets back to you then you are going to remain in place and pass and essentially you're going to keep on going until everybody has the lead on one of those cards let's just say this one ended up going here in the end so once everybody has won a location outright you're going to pay that amount of money to the bank and then some of these locations will have rewards on them in these Yellow Boxes like this one would allow me to draw two cards from the stack here some of them will give you brick which will let you put bricks straight on uh to the map some of them will give you other things such as

instant money like this and so on you can also see that each location has a certain number of cards on them and this is relevant for the next phase of the game which is the market phase where you can choose to buy Cards Farmers or bricks or any combination of those and if you spend the corresponding amount of money then you can take that amount of cards get Farmers or bricks I could spend say six money and get three cars then they could spend say two money and get sorry three money and get two farmers and then maybe I want to spend you know 21 money and get six bricks and for example however however those cards are relevant because you can only ever buy an amount of cards equal to your highest um or your strongest location in the card so let's just say I did end up controlling these two locations I would be able to buy three cards in the market phase and I don't add them up together so it's only your strongest one that counts now if you buy cards of course you would add them to your hand if you buy the farmers then they would go instantly onto empty Farm slots that you have so let's just say that the you know the yellow player end up buying some Farmers they put them straight on the relevant spots that they control now if you don't have any space to put them then you cannot buy any and the same applies to the bricks where again you spend your money you'd put the bricks or the stone on the relevant spots where you want to put them obviously locations you control like so and of course if you buy if you end up having three on there that would

instantly convert into a pyramid so once each player has completed their Market phase and bought everything they want to then you're going to go into the offering phase where each player is going to simultaneously choose a number or an amount of these money cards bearing in mind you could always get change and secretly bid them at the same time of the other players and reveal them at the same time now once all that's been calculated as in the total value so say I bid three and everybody else bid two that's going to be um 11 in total you're going to have a look at this chart here and move it to the relevant spot so that put me on the two spot here because again that's between three and twelve now whoever's bid the most money is going to get three gifts out of these here so you can get any combination of these three so I could get maybe three stones I can get two stones in the farmer and the second player would get two gifts and I think everybody else who's at least donated one um one at least one coin to that offering is going to get one gift now the only Special Rule that I'm going to talk about now is in the cards you can choose to play one of these Thief cards which will allow you to take three money from the bank but it will reduce that total coin value by three to keep it on the lower end of the spectrum the amount of offerings made during the offering phase is also important when it comes to turn order because whoever has contributed the most coins will be the new first player I'm in descending order and if there's ever a tie then your

initiative pieces will stay in the same order and once the offering phase is complete you've got to go into the Final Phase which is the Harvest phase where you are going to collect an amount of money depending on a number of different things so if you control any Farmers like the yellow player has here he's got two you're going to have a look at the number of the track here so it's on spot two therefore each farmer is going to pay out two money so in this example the yellow player will get four additional income because they've got two farmers two times two equals four now some locations also give you pure money like for example here is some berenike gives you eight um income but it doesn't give you any other options and some of them with these camels on will give you income but only if the Ammon Ray track is on the first two slots and that is essentially how a round of the game plays now after the first and second round you're just gonna simply um re-rack a new set of five cards you know for a five player game but after the third round there will be a scoring where you'll score points based on all of the pyramids you control so you're gonna get a point for each pyramid you have of course these double ones are going to count for two points you're also going to score points based on the sets that you have so if you have a pyramid in each of your locations then you'll score an additional three points uh the temples will cash out points based on the position on the Ammon Ray track so this if I control this um Dam

and her location that's two temples there it'll be two times two for another at Four Points there will also be points based on who's got the majority on the either the left hand side or the right hand side of the Nile Abby Five Point up for each of those and you'll also cash in any amount of different scheme cards that you have as long as you complete that criteria so you can see here if I did control 9 farmer then I'd get an additional three points now another really important thing to say is that after a scoring phase a halfway point in the game almost everything is going to get taken off the board as in all your farmers are going to go and you're going to lose control of the regions however and this is probably the biggest Twist on the game all of the pyramids are going to remain in place as well as the stones of course and now what that means naturally is that these locations are going to be much more lucrative um during the second half of the game because there's already an infrastructure there and some points to be had by hijacking that land with the pyramids already built and again for the second half the phase is going to play in the exact same way you're going to have another scoring phase based on what I've already explained and also there's going to be some bonus points based on who has the most remaining money left in their hand so now you know the core rules of the game let's take a look at some of these special cards so there are some more scheme cards shuffled in to that deck and these again score in tons of different ways such as having all of

your pieces either on the left hand side or the you know the east or the West Side um of the Nile if you control all adjacent connected regions you get an additional three points um you know if you build all your pieces right next to the Nile or away from the Nile there's some more points to be had there and of course there are all these special cards so we've already talked about the thief but there's also this one here which simply gives you more income during the Harvest phase you've got this one here which basically allows you to re-bid on the same spot that you did last time so if you remember if you're outbid you have to bid on another card but this one allows you to break that rules if you've got your eyes fixed on something um you can commit to this one and stay on that same um on that same location it's on here increases the outcome of each of your farmers and this one here allows you to manipulate that almond Ray track up to three spots either you know more or less this one here allows you to put a farmer on a location even if there is not a farmer slot invoke involved there as you can see here I can actually put a farmer in Baron UK even though there's not a farm um and the final one here allows you to block the next bidding space in front of you so let's just say you know in a in a future round let's say edufu came up for auction um again if I say bid here I could cash in that card and prevent anybody from bidding 10 they're gonna have to bid at least 15.

okay so let's share some thoughts on almond Ray now if you watch my content regularly you might know that I am quite a big Fanboy of Reiner konitzia especially his auction games and this one has some pretty cool things going on that separated from the other auction games of his that I've already played and we'll talk a bit uh more about that later now one of my favorite things about this is the actual idea that when you bid on something or when you're outbid you cannot just re-bid on that same spot you have to go somewhere else now what that means is you have to wait your bids a bit more carefully because you can be completely thrown under the bus and have to kind of go around the fences before you get back to the car that you want to and by then the price is really ramped up so waiting it just right so that you know nobody's gonna outbid you but at the same time not you know not out pricing yourself or over costing yourself um on that particular location and you do have to weigh up a number of different things when you are you know evaluating the value um of these locations because of course you need those slots to put farmers in to make sure you've got more income in the future getting a little kick with bricks is nice because it gives you a little leg up on your opponents you're drawing cards is nice making sure that you have um High cars locations so that you can always have that flexibility to buy loads of cards um in the market phase having income here like you know just pure money being given to you in the

Harvest phase so again tons of things you need to consider but at the same time you are not only considering the rewards you'd get from the locations itself not in the instant one also the ones in the Harvest phase but you're also juggling or spinning those plates of trying to achieve as many of these scheme cards as possible and sometimes you can manage loads of those at once like some might say well I want to build all of mine to the you know east of the river but at the same time I want to have them adjacent and I want them to be right next to the river as well that could be three scheme cards there completed at once if you manage to win all of them but of course that might come with some punishments because you might not find a location with temples on for example so it really is a delicate um assessment of trying to place the right bids I know when to commit and know when to give up on different locations so there is a lot of moving Parts when it comes to you know deciding what you're going to go for and I didn't even mention that scoring phase when you're going to score for the majority of pyramids to the you know to the west or to the east um of the Nile but another one of my favorite things about this game and something I don't think I've ever seen before is that you do essentially do a code reset halfway through the game and get basically give up all the locations that you've already won but the pyramids and the bricks stay in place naturally increasing the value of those different locations so you might have an infrastructure already there and start bidding for things knowing that you've got some sets already pre-built and you know when it comes to the scoring phase you've got a

loads of points there without doing any work but of course it's going to come quite a hefty cost and people are going to be competing um for you so I do love that idea of you know pretty much cold resetting but there being something or some Foundation there from the earlier half of the game the turn order for this game is actually very important maybe more so that first appears because having first bid on the location that you want is so important because as I said people will be very careful about what they're spending I don't want to spend a penny more than they need to because they want every single coin for that market phase um and of course you know tie breaking is going to go in your favor if you are highest initiative initiative order which always ties back to how much you're offering during the offering phase now generally speaking I think you want to run up the prices here because um your farm is going to pay out more money but you know just because they're going to pay out for more for you it doesn't necessarily mean it's going to pay out more for other people because you might have way more farmers and therefore you're going to get way more money so sometimes if somebody's not really invested in Farms or not had a chance to win the Farms place the farmers down they might want to try and steal and keep that almond Ray track down because they don't want you getting a whole bunch of cash that can be used to outbid them in the future and of course that even ties to the temples as well you know you might have a ton of farmers and want to run at that price but you don't want it to be the high points when it comes to um the scoring phase because people who are controlling temples are going to get some points so

again lots of little things to decide here and of course even sometimes you might want to keep that almond Ray track down because you might control regions with the camels on so as you can tell I have quite a few positive things to say about this game but I do have some issues with it and they mostly stem from the luck of the draw when it comes to these favor cards now I generally like what they do I think they're fairly interesting you know being able to put farmers down when you haven't got the space for them I'm getting just a quick cash injection all these things are very helpful but some of them are a lot more circumstantial than others sometimes you're going to get just completely luck out and get a great card and sometimes you're not and that is Amplified when it comes to the scheme cards um yes you can always cash them in to get a piece of gold but that's not a great payout um sometimes these going to work for you sometimes they are not sometimes they're going to be straight up impossible to achieve and that is Amplified when it comes to lower Play account games because I think if you play with fewer than five players then some of the spots on the board are actually blocked off and when you especially play at three players quite a few spots are blocked off making getting those adjacencies very difficult to achieve and sometimes not impossible because we've played a game of this where like this spot was blocked off and then this spot was blocked off and it becomes very difficult to chain things together and there just isn't those openings to get everything you want done now instant as

a part of the game but when somebody draws three cars and they get three fantastic Powers they're gonna get a great benefit from it and you are going to get three pretty pants uh skiing cards it doesn't feel terribly satisfying and I also think that during the market phase all the different kind of benefits you can get here are just too cheap it seems like you can get a location um with the farmer spaces on them and you're very affordably being able to completely populate it with your Farmers which will pay off by the end of the phase anyway because you'll just get all that money back so it just felt like you could kind of spam all these things down yes it does really amplify when it gets to the higher end here because it does go up by you know two then three then four then five then six and seven but generally speaking you know spending three or spending six and getting three benefits of each type is pretty affordable and you'd be a fool not to keep doing that as you'd expect with an auction game the interaction is strong it was always nice to get into a nice competitive bid and I do like those opportunities that that can come up if you know if two people are wrestling over a particular location you can kind of zigzag off and divert off to another card and get an absolute bargain by paying sometimes even nothing um to get it so there's some cool interaction there I think the game generally does scale well apart from that issue when it comes to the blocking and some of those scheme cards and I don't think the game outstays it's welcome either you know you can probably play this in around 75 minutes maybe 90 minutes at that five player count the

production for this version of the game is very nice you know the board art looks fantastic this is Vince to do trade artwork um it does have these nice chunky kind of resin pieces and for the Almond Ray track and for all the pyramids and Bricks looks really nice when it's on the table uh all the little wooden meeples that the scribes look great as well there's a very nice polish production and good card quality now the only issue I have I suppose is that the money in the game is cards now I understand that you do need High denominations and quite a lot of money but I don't really see why they couldn't have just used coins um and made it a bit nicer that way I just personal preference I don't really like using cars um as currency okay so let's share some final thoughts on almond Ray now I do like this game a lot I think it has some cool things going on here you know that bidding mechanism the idea that things stay on the board um I quite like the offering part of the game and there's yeah a lot to like here now the problem is and I say this with any auction game that I play I have so much competition in my collection for auction games and even ones by the same designer so I played most um of the I suppose more notorious or most popular Rhino connected games such as ra which happens to be one of my favorite games of all time um High Society Medici and some others as well now I think I like all of them more than I like this one and that is not even Throwing Shade

um on this game because this game is good at what it does but there are some little things I find unsettling such as the luck um of the card draws I understand that is more personal preference and that's going to be fine with most people but I could do without it um if I'm honest so I really can't ever really see myself pulling this one off my shelf above those other titles especially where this one is really going to flourish and shine when it comes to four or five players because there's going to be more Open Spaces um on the map so I think this might just be a victim of being too much competition I might let you know at least for me and I don't think I'm going to keep hold of this one for that reason when I can get probably a more enjoyable and a richer game in slightly shorter time when it comes to something like raw or of course I want a more Breezy fast card game I could play something like High Society so yeah I think this was just going to struggle to find its niche in my own collection but despite having a lot of upside to it I think the new production here by Alley Cat games is a very nice to look at and I'm sure it's going to do um quite well but I don't think it's going to find its place in my collection and unfortunately despite me loving that idea of things staying on the board I'd love to see that mechanism used again in a future game because it's a really cool thing to you know wrap your head around and try to understand how to weight your bids not only the first time when it's empty but in the future when it already has all those points inbuilt to those locations but yeah not quite enough to salvage this one for me and you know I'm

speaking like this as a negative review it's absolutely not and you know this is still a high standard of a game and I'm sure you're going to enjoy it just like I did but it's just not going to quite make the cuts

Progress saved