Whistle Stop Overview and Review
Transcript
I've always had a soft spot for railroad games because when I was growing up my father was a Model Railroader and I learned a lot from him I even got into modeling for war games because of it well at Gen Con this year a railroad board game came out from Scott Caputo and I've decided that I'm going to do a review of this railroad game and it is called whistle in whistle stop the players are attempting to move their trains west pick up Goods at stations drop them off at cities for points and ultimately arrive at the West Coast for one last big delivery each player has a number of engines that start on the east most stations on their turn they may spend up to four coal or whistle tokens to move their engines each coal tokens spent allows one train to move north south or west ending at the next stop no matter how many tiles it takes to get there once there they collect the resource that stop provides if your engine moves on to an empty space before reaching a stop you play a tile from your hand and move to the next stop on that new tile if you spend a whistle token your engine can move to full stops and it can even move backwards to the east when an engine stops at a city you spend the goods depicted at the top score the points and take a share of stock shown in that city if you can't make a delivery when you arrive you lose victory points there are a number of special stops that you can make as well
some examples are the general store allows you to take any resource of your choosing the coal mine allows you to get extra cold and move your engines the gold mine gives you a single nugget that has varying points on the reverse side and the stock market when you stop at the stock market you score points for each stockpile that you've collected to this point once reaching the west coast this engine is going to make its one final big point score and then you put it on the resource track and collect your rewards optionally on your turn you can also spend a series of resources to purchase an upgrade from the display or from another player these upgrades can give you special abilities that will help you be more efficient and either after a number of rounds have passed or everyone gets their engines all the way to the west coast's which won't happen you do some final scoring including majorities of the shares you've collected and the player with the most points is the greatest railroad mogul in the entire Whistlestop universe Whistlestop is a charmingly simplistic game on its surface but there's there's a lot of depth to the game if you really dig in deep starting off it's very similar to games like a cable car or like sir or it's a tiling game and you're building routes and you're moving along those routes and it's actually a very beautiful game when the game is complete and the board is done and all the tiles are out it kind of looks like a mess there's a there's tracks going in all directions and
things like that but it makes complete sense while you're building it and it's such arming looking game from a component standpoint I only have one negative and to start off I'm color blind and the components in this game don't take any account for color blindness at all I can't see my pieces most of the time I have to look really close and then sometimes I have to ask which ones are my pieces I have to memorize where they all are after a while you get used to it but it doesn't affect my overall thoughts of the game at all it's just something I like to bring up because it's something that I deal with and I've learned over my 40 years of in life how to deal with those types of things so not a big deal but publishers and designers should probably pay attention to that sort of thing otherwise everything is beautiful look the components are just great and I and I like the way everything's laid out and it's the artwork is great as far as the game goes I mentioned that it is simplistic on its surface it is such an easy game to play essentially you get four actions that you can take to move your trains and pick up and deliver and score points and your turns over you can buy an upgrade - very easy stuff but there's the sheer number of options that you have in this game are so vast because each one of those trains if you're playing and a lower player account game you have five trains on the board up to sometimes you'll have four and three but if you have five trains on the board each one of those trains have a destination that they can go to
sometimes two and three destinations that they can go to and then with the whistles you almost double that at that point of places that you can go with these things so there's almost an infinite combination of paths you can take to score points and the the most exciting thing about this game is the discovery of that one great combo and it seems to happen every turn for me you know I go into a turn and I'm thinking well this is just gonna be a building turn I'm gonna get a bunch of resources and I'll have a good turn next time or the time after that and then as I'm looking at the board I'm like wow it'd be really cool if I could go there Wow I can go there and if I do that I can do this and if I do that I can do that in that and then I score like twice and I get twice the number of points that I expected I was even gonna get out of the turn because I just kind of studied those options a little bit and obviously I didn't study all the options because there's so many of them but you find this one classic play and you get it and then the next turn it's almost like you can do it again like in a different way that's what's so satisfying about this game there's so many cool little things you can do to score those points now I mentioned that you pick up deliver score points there's something that happens before that it is getting coal you get two coal per turn because you can essentially spend for coal or whistles whichever you spend so that's means for actions you don't always get four actions because you might not have enough coal so you got to be building a little engine to bring in coal so that you could be maximizing your turns if you don't maximize your turns you're
kind of squandering time in this game the people that do the best for the guys that do the best at keeping coal coming in maybe you have a workhorse train that just keeps going to the coal mines and bringing in coal so that you can perform better actions with the other guys I really like this I like the fact that if you're just frivolously playing you could get to the end and everything would be fine you score a bunch of points but if you really focus on the coal and you focus on the combos of the game you could really score big there's a lot of strong things you can do positioning of your trains one thing I didn't mention in the overview is if you have a train at the destination that your one train wants to go to it skips over it for free and if you have a bunch of them it skipped over all of them so you can get one train all the way across the board if you have a wagon train of engines there and setting up those big plays can get you tons of points and get you across the board much faster there's a lot of tactics and strategy that goes into this game it's really well done as far as the things that I don't dig and this is just me and I can't say that it's a negative really but to me it feels weird the fact that you can go back to the same location as many times as you want you can't go east unless you spend a whistle but you can go north and south so essentially you could set up a train outside of a city that's a high point scoring city and just kind of keep going into that city over and over and over racking up points just with that one engine as long as you're feeding it with resources and honestly it felt like I
was cheating when I did that it's not cheating it's part of the rules it's fine it's it's a valid strategy to set up a little point scoring engine like that but usually when I set up an engine I'm like proud of the engine when I set up this little point score engine wasn't proud of it I kind of felt like I was exploiting something I don't know I just didn't feel right it felt clunky it felt wrong somehow when I was playing it but it's part of it it's part of the strategy if you can set up there's really good like just point engines that keep turning off to turn pumping up points you can do it ultimately I think the game is great I think it's really fun to do despite that little bit of weirdness and the colorbond thing whatever it's a really solid game it's a it's a lot of fun to figure out the puzzle to figure out the combos to outdo your other players it's all about out thinking your other players in this game because they have all the same stuff as you have they picked their starting location just like you do it's really neat in the stock market the stock market is such a cool concept here because it's call most like a throwaway thing you you deliver to a city you get a stock for free you just get it because you delivered there and then later you can cash those in for big points and at the end you get majorities for those so you can target certain ones to get the majorities for them it almost feels like if you don't go to the stock market at some point in the game you're squandering all of those free stock tokens that you got you get lots of points for doing that you don't expend any resources to get them well
you spend resources to go to the city but you score points for it anyway so you're paying for the points not for the stock and the stock comes anyway really neat it's a really neat concept there's a lot it's not difficult to play at all but it has those cool things in it the upgrade tiles I think are very cool as well and it's really neat that you can buy them from the other players like if you see somebody really utilizing an upgrade like crazy you can steal that away from them make sure they stop doing it now you could start doing it of course they can buy it back but you're spending a lot of resources to do that I really like that little element of it as far as like components in that go it's very strange that there are three locations to put upgrades but you can buy as many as you want there's no limit to the number of upgrades you have but your player board suggests you can only have three I don't know why weird but anyway really neat concept there - like I said before simple game but so much depth and the choices that you can make in this game I really like whistle-stop and highly recommend if you like railroad games it ain't like any other railroad games not like Steam or age of steam or 18 XX of course not it's a different style of game but has that Railroad theme and feels like you're doing railroad stuff fun game whistle stop well alright thank you very much for joining me today for my review of whistle stop if you love board games card games miniatures games role-playing games check out our audio podcast the secret cabal gaming podcast
you can find it at the secret cabal comm or on iTunes and until next time have a good one