The Hungry Gamer Reviews Shackleton Base Expansion
Transcript
Ooh, that looks tasty. Welcome folks. Today the Hungry Gamer is back with another game review. Today we're talking about Shackleton Base Below, Within, Above. This is the first expansion to Shackleton Base and designed by Fabio Lopiano and Nestor Mangone with art by David Sitbon and published by Pandasaurus. And thank you to Pandasaurus for sending me this copy so I can make this video. Now for those of you that maybe don't follow my channel regularly, you will know that the core Shackleton Base was my honorable mention game of the year this year. It was my heavy game of the year, I should say, last year. What this is is this is the first expansion which adds three new factions that you can play and it also adds these tokens right here. So I'll talk about these tokens first.
Actually, before I talk about anything I'll say, if you are not interested in what the new things do in this game and just want to jump into my final thoughts, then you want to go to the time stamp on the screen right now. For those of us still here, let's talk about how these new bits work. So first there are these tokens here that say 10 or 25. And when you cross those point thresholds, then these are bonuses that you will be able to get. It's just resources or points at the 10 and when you get to the 25, you get bonuses when you take various actions, be it around the crater, the lunar gateway, building funding a project or building. So you get new things that you're able to do and use. Now beyond that, the three factions are the lunar city where you are getting new citizens on the moon.
There is the Zenith Works where you are actually building things higher on the moon, kind of building skyscrapers. And then there is the Under Moon where you are tunneling into the moon. So we'll start with Lunar City and that looks like this right here and this happens to be the comb the board at the culmination of a game I just played, but as you can see, there are four areas where you have these purple citizens. And and one of the things that you're going to be able to do is with your corporate action here, that will allow you to claim one of these guys and put them somewhere into your base. Then there's also this corporate action right here which allows you to take one out of your base and then put it somewhere around the crater. Now you're going to take a hit to reputation for doing that, but it will also allow you to pick one of the areas and get the resource, be it money, a corporate icon or a mining material. And then at the end of the game, you're going to get one point for every one of your for every citizen in your base. Next we have the Zenith Works. And this is the one where you are building up. And the corporate action on this one, or the corporate icon I should say, is simply you're going to get blueprints. And I'll tell you how you use blueprints right now.
So what you can't quite see is right here, you'll see that I actually have stacked up on top of my big one. I have my big one, then I have a three, then a two, then a one all stacked up and this black one here as well. And all of these are going to get built on top of existing buildings and the base always has to be bigger than whatever comes next. These black ones here, those you're going to get through different cards. So I happen to have this card last game which gave me a corporate action where I could build this on top and you get bonus materials and also there's bonus materials given if you wind up mining that area. The other thing you can do is you can use those blueprints. And for every hub of a building, you spend one blueprint and you can build up. So in other words, when I was right here, I spent three blueprints and was able to build this up on top. Now what that does is it's going to get you points at the end of each round based on how high you've built up and it's also a cheaper way to build things in some ways because you're using the blueprints to build, you're not paying the different resources. But it also does not count for strength of the hex. You still only get as many domination points as the base. So in this case, I would have one, two, three, four, five, six, no matter how many of these I have here as if we're trying to figure out who might get a worker from the row. And finally we have the Under Moon. Now the Under Moon has two parts that go with it. First you have this
mining board here and you have your little tunneler and as you take the corporate icon actions, you'll be moving down through these spaces. As you go down through, you get to these spots here and when you hit them, you've put a fracture in the moon. And then you take it off of your board and you put it out somewhere on a different spot. So the yellow one, I would put it right there if I happen to control that area and I would get the resource, but now until that gets repaired, no one else can have it. Then there's the red one, they kind of go in the on the line in between two territories, that means you can't get any money. And then there are blue ones like this, that mean you cannot take that corporate icon action. And then in order to get rid of that, as you're placing a worker to you'll to activate the crater and you go across. So right now I could not gain money here, but instead I could use this, activate it, I would get two reputation and I would take this and that's one of the goals you're going to be trying to chase down for points during the game.
The other thing about this is you have a corporate action over here that's going to allow you to take these tiles and place them into your tunnel system. And what they're going to do is they're going to give you income every turn if you've placed a worker next to them. The other thing that you can do with your corporate action is you can flip these over and when you flip them over, they're going to be worth six points at the end of the game if you have an astronaut next to it. And then at the end of each round, depending on how far down you've tunneled, you're going to lose your reputation. And broadly speaking, that's how these new expansions work. So with that said, what do I like about this expansion? The first thing is I love that it fits in the core box. I love that. I know a lot of people like to keep all the boxes. I do not. It's all right here in the one box. It all fits, no problem. Love that. Next thing I want to say is talking about the actual game play itself. The first thing is I really like the addition of those rewards you get when you hit the different milestones in points. The 10 and then the 25.
It's great and the reason I like it so much is it really encourages you to score some points as you go. It's very easy in Shackleton Base I find to have almost no points at the end of the game then suddenly you're shooting up and getting points. I really, really like that. I love that those are there and I hope they introduce more options for those as the game continues to grow. Next thing I'm going to say is I like that the three new factions all are one, very thematic and when I say they're thematic, I mean that in the sense that the things that you are doing fit the theme of what they're supposed to be. It just it works. Eurogames are famously not thematic. I feel like these three do a really good job of hitting that theme.
But at the same time, they play completely differently. Just like all the original factions do, now I think you're up to 11 factions and they have different complexities and they all are completely different and I find that one, very impressive and two, lots of fun because that increases the replay and discovery of this game even more. Even though I'm on record of saying I think replay is a little bit of an overrated metric, this is a Eurogame that you can just play over and over and over again and have a completely different experience and all three of these factions are really unique. And I also like how they can synergize with some of the others. That is really, really fascinating to me. Particularly the Under Moon and Lunar City. The Lunar City's letting you get more workers and you need workers for the Under Moon and I just love the way that that works.
It's very, very clever. And so what you're hearing is I think this is a very good expansion. I want to talk briefly about the way I rank these three new factions. My favorite is the Lunar City and that's probably because I tend to favor ones that feel a little simpler, but I particularly like this one because one, it's doing stuff with your reputation. In general, it feels like your reputation just kind of goes up and you rarely use it. And in this one, not only is the Lunar City when you put these workers out, these citizens out on the crater, takes away your rep, but also it's, as I mentioned earlier, giving you new workers. It's giving you new ways to get more workers around the crater which gives you more opportunities to get the workers into your base and it's more ways just to make to make money or get the corporate actions, the corporate icons I should say, all of that I really like. Also I should point out that the new country that you can be, being India, that utilizes reputation a lot as well. You can use reputation to take extra corporate actions, you can use reputation to bypass the power or credit cost so when you're funding projects. But again, dealing with reputation. And I really like that. And with the Lunar City, I like how easy it is to do the things. It is very easy. You want a guy in your base?
Activate the corporate icon. You need a little more money? Do a corporate action. Send the [snorts] guy out there, get some points, take a hit on your rep. Really clever. My second favorite is the Under Moon. I love the little tunneling. I love the idea that you're tunneling down, and as you tunnel deeper and deeper, you get these fractures that you're going to have to repair. But when you get the fracture, you get a bonus. So you want to get these fractures. And then when you fix the fracture, you get a bonus, which is the reputation, which is really important because you're going to lose reputation every round depending on how far down you've gone in the moon. And again, this one is just quick and simple and fun, but I really like it because of the new passive income that you can get. If you get a cavern opened up, and then you take a corporate action, you put a thing in there, you can get a worker next to it, and you're getting passive income, and then you can turn that into mega points at the end of the game. Really, really like that.
Then third on the list is the Zenith corporation to me. And that's only because I had the hardest time understanding how it worked. Once I got it, I really got it. But really what makes that the most interesting to me is it's giving you a way to push out your buildings on the cheap. Get those blueprints, and suddenly you're sending them buildings out. Now you have to overbuild. But there is its own value in that overbuild as well. So very, very clever. I like the way all three of them they do different things to get points. I didn't talk about their projects. The projects are in line with everything that you have from all the other projects in the core game with the exception of Zenith, how Zenith has those projects that specifically will build a specific neutral building out onto the game board.
But all very, very clever. So with that being said, what are my quibbles with the expansion? First thing is, and again, it's not necessarily bad, but just in case it wasn't clear, this is a more of the same expansion. This isn't drastically changing the game with the exception of the factions all kind of change the game. This is a more of the same. This is akin to getting new characters in your dungeon crawl, or a couple new decks for your deck building, or a couple new decks for your living card game, or something like that. And so you take that for what you will. The next thing I'll say is I think the solo is maybe a little bit more complicated when you add in some of these new factions. And the solo I always found to be very good, but very hard. It's hard to make sure you're doing all the right things that you need to do, and this doesn't make it easier. If anything, it makes it a little bit harder to do that.
Next thing I'll say is this does amplify, I think the biggest challenge that Shackleton Base has, is that you're doing a lot of reteaching every time you play. Unless you play with the exact same factions over and over again, well now you're adding more to the mix, and so there's more of the okay, how does this faction work? How does this faction work? Well, how does this faction interact with this faction? Can I take a citizen, the purple meeple, and can I put it at this place over here? All of those things, it does amplify that a little bit. And the only other two things that I will say, I said with the original game and probably my quibbles there, I think really this game is best at three plus. Though I do enjoy the solo, I think it's best at three plus. I don't I think it's at its worst when you're playing two player. And this is one of those games that it's just hard to do things. You will often do things, and suddenly you're like, "Oh, I'm one credit short. Oh, someone took the last solar panel." And so this doesn't do anything to alleviate any of those things. But there you have it, folks. That is the new expansion for Shackleton Base. I'm very high on it. I was already very high on the game. I am now higher on the game.
And this one is one that is immediately in the mix for me for best expansion of the year. Really, really good. We'll see how it holds up through the entire year, but I'm very high on it. I think if you are someone that really enjoys Shackleton Base, and you are getting it to the table, then this is a must-buy expansion. If you are somebody that's only playing Shackleton Base maybe once a year, or once every three or four months, well you might be able to wait on it because you probably haven't experienced everything there is to experience with the original factions. But if you have played through those factions, and you know how all those work, must, must, must pick this one up. These new factions I think are great. I'm not sure where I would rank them in the entire pantheon of factions, but they're up there. I I think probably the Lunar City would be in my top three or four of all the factions in this game.
But there you have it, folks. That is the new Shackleton Base expansion. As always, if you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.