Bloc by Bloc | Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson for Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing block by block Uprising this is the third edition of a Cooperative Uprising game designed by TL Simons and this version is co-designed by Greg Lauren Albright this is a review copy so take that into account as you watch so this is a two-player setup of block by Block it's a Cooperative game so this is also the setup that you'd use when you're playing it solo you could play with up to four players but really it's easier just to manage two factions so what we've got here is we have a city and the city has several districts that are occupied by police and then we also have starting occupations in districts that match our faction type so there are four factions in the game I randomly Drew prisoners and neighbors for this but you could also have students and workers and basically the idea is that all these different groups are unhappy with the way the city has been run and the names of their locations really say something about that so you have a garment Sweatshop you have an underfunded high school we have the projects or a polluted slum the prisoners are stuck in things like the super max prison or the immigration Detention Center so even the names of the things in the city imply quite a bit of Injustice and that is what we are supposed to be having an uprising against in the city basically where this game works is that you have a total of 10 turns to try to win and you win by having each faction
Place their completion token on a condition that's up here so let me show you what those look like throughout the game we're going to be revealing these condition cards and these are all potential ways to win the game so we have liberated Telecom Network Hub we need to build an occupation in this liberated District so what that would mean is that we need to find the Telecom hub which is right here we need to liberate it which means we need to get the police out and we also need to flip the tile over so all these tiles flip to more colorful sides and there are some special things underneath them as well and you need to build an occupation there and so whichever player manages to do that first is going to be the one who gets to put their token here for completion and then the other player or in my case since I would be playing solo the other faction is also gonna need to complete a condition that comes off of the conditioned deck and then once we've both done that then we win and we have this timer this time limit in which to do so so how we're going to do that we're going to do that by basically proceeding through the game and taking our actions as well as we possibly can so the game is divided into night time and daytime segments at night we're gonna start with police Ops where we draw a police Ops card and resolve it uh we start with just one card while the police morale is at the timid level but there will be cards that make their morale go up until they're deadly there are also things you can do in the game to bring police morale down and decrease the number of cards they're drawing if you need to but usually the police are going to move or more police are going to come out basically things are going to happen in the police Ops deck that you don't like and that are frightening
to you so in this one the groups of police squads would Advance into adjacent prisoners districts those the orange ones and as you can see that's pretty easy for them to do these are not adjacent but this one certainly is once the police have had a chance to do their Ops then it's the player turn so each player is now going to take their turn so the first thing you're going to do is roll your dice let's say it's Orange's turn so you'd roll all of your dice this is what we've ended up with and you place in one new Block in your starting District so you expand a little bit and you get some action dice then you use these dice to take actions there are some basic actions that let you do things like just move so you can essentially move anywhere where there are Road Connections or using metro stops if the Metro is open so right now we see that it is you can also use dice to build barricades so if we'd started adjacent to some police we would start with barricades on this map setup there's a randomized map setup each time but at any time you can build up to three barricades between tiles then there are some Advanced actions and those actions are based on the total of your dice so basically you need to hit certain totals you can combine Dice and treat them as one single die to hit the totals you need or if you roll High then you can just spend one dime so basically this is your die pool and you need to hit certain numbers but if you've rolled High you might have more options so if you're not currently in a clash with the police your Advanced actions include looting building occupations and then swapping occupations so basically you need to get yourself more little bases around town and the
ones that you build after this starting one are going to have special abilities that are helpful to you the other thing that you can do is a set of attack actions so if you were in a clash which means that you're sharing your tile with police uh depending on who is there then you can either defeat one single Squad which would mean one Cube you can kick two cubes out to an adjacent space so if we are here we could kick the cubes out in a direction of our choice and then your third option is to attack police beings they are very difficult to defeat you basically have to manage multiple attacks against them before they have a chance to reconstitute themselves so you can disable them but if you want them gone you've really got to put your back into it then there's going to be a retaliation step where these cards are revealed and we find out some more about what the police are going to do so this is where the fans are repaired and where police attack so this game is obviously meant to mimic popular uprisings against oppressive governments according to an interview I did a while ago with Greg Laurie Albright and some of the material about this game this is meant to evoke multiple different uprisings across the world including things like the Arab Spring although to me this feels very very much like a way of playing out protests in the United States possibly because of the art style and because of my own experience as somebody who watches the news in the US so one thing that's quite interesting about this particular game as well is looting so all these shopping centers can be looted but you can choose the way you want to do it so basically if you want a loot
card which is pretty handy right away when you loot you have to put down a fire token and you basically burn the place that you looted you have a different choice however which is to put graffiti there and if you let a bunch of graffiti pile up in places where you have some influence then that can actually pay larger benefits later but it doesn't necessarily get you the resources you need right now so looting represents sort of a moral and a resource management Choice within the game the other thing is quite interesting thematically about the game is the need for solidarity really your faction cannot do anything alone it absolutely needs other factions to help out and if you do not help each other then you're not going to get where you need to go but the other thing is even to get winning conditions out you have to be willing to send people to meetings and that means that you have to take some of your cubes temporarily off a map in order to go to these meetings and reveal these conditions so you'll have to work together in order to reveal the conditions that are going to allow you all to win as a team so basically what this boils down to is it is an uprising themed somewhat more Juiced up version of pandemic where the police are causing problems everywhere y'all are doing your best to solidify your little strongholds to liberate areas and you ultimately want to Prevail in Block City before the countdown winds down so that's an overview of block by block let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts I can totally see why a lot of people really love block by block uh including
people like my friend Jason Perez and Dan Thoreau whose reviews I really enjoy however I thought that it was just okay and the reason that I thought that is because I feel that the theme is very ambitious and I'm not sure that the gameplay lives up to that ambition so I think we should talk first about the theming I personally think that you can make board games about just about anything and it's the treatment of the subject that makes the game truly interesting so I want to see how it's coming out the mechanisms I want to see how it's coming out the design and the art and I want to see you know which Historical Notes it's hitting so for me it's a lot less about what the game is about than about how it does it and in many ways I do think the game does a good job of representing an uprising that is Justified against police it's really really clear that the people in this town are oppressed uh it's clear they're trying to band together to overcome bad things like polluted slums or sweatshops or really things that nobody should be subjected to in a good Society and I also like the way the game forces some solidarity that you have to send multiple cubes to meetings in order to uncover Victory conditions that you have to work together in order to overthrow the police however I think that the way the theme is implemented specifically that it steps away from specific historical events and instead wants to evoke them in this fake variable City with these kind of almost cute cartoon blocks I personally felt that that took something away like I can see how you might prefer it because it's more theoretical so you can think maybe without risk right or with less risk
about what it would be like to do an uprising you know what conditions would cause one but for me the Detachment from reality uh actually took away from it and the reason I feel that way is that I think that there are a lot of moral ambiguities to some of the things you're asked to do in the game so one of the issues we could talk about is attitudes towards police I think we're all somewhere on a spectrum right now but the one aspect of the game that I really want to talk about to illustrate this is looting so in the game you're given a choice about how to loot you can either burn down a shop and get a bit of it now or you can tag it with graffiti and then maybe benefit from it later and so you know there's kind of oh am I building up the community or am I tearing it down you know sort of tension however I don't really think that that expresses looting well enough because I don't think it's personal enough I've been if you're gonna walk into you know your neighbor's corner store in the community that you say you care about and take their stuff and maybe light it on fire that maybe you need to Grapple with some consequences of that um you know when I interviewed Greg Lauren Albright he talked about looting you know being treated as an academic subject and recommended a book I'll go look it up hopefully and like put it in the show notes there are people who talk about looting as like a part of these uprisings in a way that's not 100 like looting bad and negative I still feel 100 bad and negative about it and I really wish that you had to look somebody in the eye when you burn down their shop and I sort of feel like this idea that the other people in your community are okay with you taking their stuff and messing with their small
businesses potentially um it's interesting but we should have to Grapple with it more and there are other aspects of the game again that I think are kind of almost sanded Away by the cuteness of the blocks by the abstractness of the colors like even though the police are white cubes like oh how symbolic um I still think that there's enough depersonalization going on here that it doesn't quite Express the nastiness of going through something like this and that sanitization displeases me um I also think that you know yes there's a semi co-op mode for the game but I still don't think that it introduces enough suspicion and enough kind of toughness of messing up a social movement for everybody else to get yours um that would happen in an actual history Oracle version of this game of an uprising and so I think the game has a lot of aspirations that are cool and I think that it it does Place some of them out like the game actually gives you sort of interesting ideas about how uprisings play out and the way that people can band together to make them work and you know the relationship between meetings and trying to do good things in the community some of the Liberation cards are super interesting but I also think I would have preferred something that was more gritty and realistic to talk about this issue because I think that it's almost like the uprising is a little too nice and too heroic to be real in this version of the game I also do want to talk about gameplay for the most part gameplay is not bad like the rule book is super clear I really appreciated that um gameplay is simple you could really teach this game to anybody uh it's like
you know it's maybe about as difficult as pandemic maybe a bit longer than pandemic to play and um you know the variability of the city there's a lot of really neat stuff that's going on mechanically in the game I think it's really nicely put together the product is really nice that said I think there's a lot lacking in the AI and that is a problem in my opinion for a Cooperative game so you know the police are your enemy in this game and they attack different spaces they move to different places they have different focuses depending on which cards you draw and I felt like the AI was too clunky and too unintentional uh to really appreciate this game so your games are gonna swing a lot so I'm not gonna be easy because it's like why are the police focusing on this totally unrelated thing to what we're doing right now oh well I guess I better liberate some tiles and make my Uprising strong while I can and then other times it's like the police are just Relentless hit hit but you know it's not on purpose because it's an AI deck uh and so I felt that the games Ai and its engine don't work well enough um to have a fully satisfying experience and especially not a consistently satisfying experience which I was disappointed in uh that said you know I really like the way that the dice are used in the game I like the way that the people can play their own actions out so as a human player I really liked what I was able to do and I liked my decision space but the AI response wasn't robust enough for my taste I guess that leads to a conclusion of I think the block by block is an interesting game it's definitely not an all-time favorite for
me um it plays well enough to appreciate a few times it's not going to stay permanently in my collection so I'm really glad that I experienced this game and then I got to have a look at the thoughts behind it uh but I really would prefer something that's more gritty and real if I'm going to game an uprising which sounds weird because you know we talk about war games being about difficult topics well I would like to embrace the difficulty and to Grapple a little bit more but that said this is a game that I overall appreciate I think it's worth playing if you come across it it's just maybe not hitting on all cylinders for me so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment and most of all happy gaming um