Beyond Solitaire Podcast 110: Jason Perez on Playing Oppression
Transcript
thank you add break time the Beyond Solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and they've got something big going on this spring they will launch their Kickstarter campaign for 500 year old vampire a Cooperative RPG by Jason Cox that is fun with friends but also written to National educational standards I've personally played it and had a blast so check it out I also want to put in a quick plug for my own patreon at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire after this year I would like to devote my entire summer to doing games work instead of teaching summer school and your support would help make that possible for me for now though let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and for yet another return because we had to have him on season six I got Jason Perez of shelf stories how you doing Jason if you're watching the zoom call we're holding up the six everybody six seasons six seasons of Jason and Beyond Solitaire yo my people's what's up what's up Liz
which was like as we recorded this three months ago and it's too long man we gotta uh we gotta record game reviews let's do some game reviews like this all this like hooty 20 intellectual stuff is fine but like let's have fun you know me and my Naval gazing tendencies so we did get together for a very nerdy task which is that Jason and I both read a recently released book called playing oppression uh and this is by Mary Flanagan of Dartmouth and how do I say his name appropriately I'm gonna go with Mikhail Jacobson yes we're American and we're just gonna ruin everything um but he's at MIT I am showing it here there we go Raquel Jacobson I'm showing you on the camera right now uh a uh yeah both um the Arista board games this is not their first work uh this I think there's the first part together but this is they definitely uh highly highly decorated published people and Mary has at least been on your show yeah the other one has no so these are uh basically these are board game academics who have written a book called playing oppression and it's about a lot of themes that if you have been in a hobby long enough and enjoying conversations about colonialism and games long enough you know you've actually touched on a lot of the things in this book so we're going to talk about it and kind of talk about what new things it brings to the table um you know whether you help you decide whether you want to read it kind of pull out what was interesting in it this is a review people we are going to get into the guts of this thing we've both read it we both uh you know kind of processed it uh and we're gonna give our honest
thoughts you know disclosure these it's a small circle you know and I just did a um chat with Merrick Flanagan we did a colonialism and board games chat kind of based on her book and she's coming back on the show in a couple of months do something else so it's like we have these relationships uh so disclosure you know where we have these uh relationships but we're gonna do the best we can to provide an honest perspective yes and that said I do want to say I am very happy to see academics interacting with Hoppy board gamers more that has some that is something that I personally believe should have happened much earlier and I'm very glad that it's happening now because I mean I'm post hack right so I've lived my life like with academic training but not in Academia at this point and I I see some of the most Lively discussions and these topics happening on Twitter yeah in a forum somewhere on somebody's blog like and so you know it makes me really happy to see like my Worlds Collide because I think they should actually I think we've got things to say to each other that matter right and so this book is a contribution to that discourse uh and we're gonna assess the you know what the contribution makes uh as I was saying Elizabeth before I think of it I think of this book in three different levels uh on the one hand uh they are tracing so the subtitle is the legacy of conquest and Empire and colonialist board games uh focus on the idea of Legacy like this goes back so they go back to the beginning of board games they talk about the earliest board games like set and chess and they go through
uh games that were made in the uh the medieval period and the Renaissance period like they're not it's not like comprehensive I mean it's not like a huge Tome but you know they give you a paragraph or two and they give lovely pictures of you know the Mansion of happiness and Snakes and Ladders or the original iterations of it so there's a a level at which it's just this is like a history of board games from you know whatever um colonialist perspective it is so they're picking they're not it's not every board game uh but it is you know that's there's that level in which you're gonna enjoy this book and then they are going because they're Scholars they bring in uh some scholarship and we'll talk about that uh uh after that and then the final level is they say at the very first chapter that they don't just want this to be an academic tone that they want to achieve some kind of change they want to forward the conversation they want to chart ways in which uh we can get new games and kind of deconstructs from the Colonials Paradigm so one two three we're gonna try to do uh the best we can to hit all those points uh so let's start uh history your history buff Liz uh did you have a little bit of fun kind of seeing the historical Trace that this game that this book engages yeah so this book is basically split into two halves for those of you haven't read it there's kind of like the history background half and then let's talk about modern board games in this context yeah so there's a lot of historical contextualization here and I thought it was pretty good um it really hits on some of the kind of important aspects of how colonialism has affected gaming for from early days so for example Snakes and Ladders originally had some quite spiritual
elements but it got sort of reprocessed by British commercial interests and this Indian game it was basis Indian subcontinent game right so not the American Indians amerindians but like actual Europe Indian subcontinent uh and it had its uh there was a conscious sense that like they were educating like these were Educational Tools and so the original sense was like okay uh we are going to educated Hindu virtues and you know and it's going to have that kind of um tilt to it and then British come in they appropriate they do the things that we've talked about many many times uh and they reproduced uh the game which eventually we have come to call Snakes and Ladders and it create and it was kind of recast which cultures do uh to a more Christian virtue centered lens so like you go up you know the stakes represent vices and uh you know so you know the ladders are representing you know okay your Ladder Up in virtue away from the snakes right or you end up with something that's having much of a value set at all it gets presented as purely for entertainment and then sold back to people in India so it's like oh let's just sell back these people's own game but like stripped of its cultural meaning great Commerce uh and so so overall I thought the the analysis of British colonial gaming and mechanisms was really interesting however there was also one big Omission that I want to bring in so oh so we're already starting okay it's actually a person who got it omitted uh so the if you search for British
colonialism board games in like Google books or anything the very first hit is Megan norch's gaming Empire and I actually had her on episode 35 of this podcast and so I looked for her in the bibliography and she was not there and so if you want to get a really interesting read on um games puzzles Etc and its impact on British children that's actually I think the best place to go um so Mega nor just gave me Empire album Kid in the show notes sure but uh this book covers a lot of the same ground and so um I really enjoyed the discussion of not only you know looking how you know colonial empires like co-ops people's culture and then sell it back in kind of deteriorated ways but also um but that's a little strong right I mean it reincultuated ways like reflecting the cultural values of European culture capitalist culture all that kind of thing yes although you know I'm history and but
um the other thing that I thought was really good is they had a good discussion of how British games meant for British children uh and this is again you know I would actually think that norwich's work is a fantastic place to go on this uh but it talks about how the mechanisms and the themes basically teach British children to become a little imperialists so things like travel narratives and depicting people in other countries as just sort of like these amusing things that you can go see as part of the grand tour of the world from your British perspective um you know those sorts of things popping in from an early age do impact the way that you see the world and how you see the world is existing for you and so it was just a really fascinating um way of kind of putting together a lot of what I think that we like to say about historical tourism and games now uh it kind of Harkens back to discussions at you and I've had about modern games um but you know it really brought home the point that I think that you and I are always trying to make which is it there's no such thing as just a game like all games are cultural artifacts all games say something about how we see the world what we think is normal what kinds of mechanisms we naturally would be inclined to use to interact with the world around us and so this book makes a really nice case for um how British colonial era games actually brought children into that same culture and made it normal to just kind of plunder other countries and just use them for trade and see people in other
places as exotic and you know that starts in the drawing room at home when you're seven right so that gets us to the second part so first of all history of games it's fun you'll see game boards you'll see you know uh the the evolution it's not just Britain they talk about French games and there was one instance of like you know Mexican games and that kind of thing and well so I'll get to that in a second so fun history you know kind of survey uh where we've where we've been and where we're now um now we're getting into the kind of central scholarly thesis of the game of the of this book so it as Liz said this game utterly rejects the notion of it's just a game right uh and that's kind of part of the deal right that's part of the cultural conversation like you know you've been in these conversations Liz what what do you say what comment comes those it's just a game we're thinking too much of it you're putting it in there right you're putting it in there it's like we're we're doing our own thing and we're putting it in there so we I mean we don't want to rehash that conversation I mean it's one of those things where it's like that's a food fight you know you either you either kind of Believe it or you don't we're trying to make the best case that we can this book kind of helps with that that's one of the real virtues of this uh that the games aren't just games that games reflect culture and games recreate culture yes that is a beautiful way to put that so in a sense the game the game is uh again any any piece of media not just games any piece of media right a movie a book that a game talked about a one called there was like a novel it's
like the novel is only possible within like you know Bourgeois European Society it's like okay all right thinking about that but like to kind of situating these hinge points of culture and saying okay this piece of culture came from has and has all these cultural things within it and it recreates so like in a game sense you're doing the thing you're being the colonizer you're being the king you're being the this that and the third thing and you kind of add to the larger culture and and there's an educational piece to it and so I think this is where the book makes the strongest case is that it does a lot over the course of the chapters to show how game makers in the past have taken on explicitly educational role in Game yes and so the whole thing of you know uh British colonial games taught kids how to be good little imperialists uh and so I you know I don't know if that was fleshed out that's kind of the thing that with the Megan Orchard point but that's not totally resonating what's what's happening here um there's another part we're talking about uh in terms of France and like the people in the French Revolution one of the things they did in order to kind of make France France didn't exist as a the apology a democracy like that had to be created you don't just overthrow a king and all of a sudden we got a new country everybody's so easy that's worked every time that but that's how they that's how they make it seem in like the history books right so it's like yeah 1789 a French Revolution now it's a new country
heck no like like this has to be done and practiced and instantiated and and you know taught and games were one way in which France was made the idea of France the idea of Mexico like they talked about a little bit about uh how games proliferated in that particular case when Mexico is in uh engaging revolutions those games made that country and it was done the people the game makers knew what they were doing and it's like here you go and they didn't say be a good colonizer it's not that's not like on the top of the box here's your here's how I teach colonization it gives it a kind of nice veneer and it just so happens that that's what you're doing I think one thing that this book really brings to the surface in a way that I think is always worth talking about especially for all of us as players right is that creating a culture makes its work right it's work whether you realize you're doing that work or not I think is debatable but I mean even if you go to a game convention and you play five different games right there's certain expectations for how you're going to engage with that game for how you're going to be taught that game for the sorts of things you might see in that game all of that is culture creation at work yes and so you know what other messages are coming with it I don't know that's why you have to try to take a step back from yourself and see it and it's so much easier to see like I love talking about games in history because when you have that distance it's so much easier to see what's happening like we can't see ourselves clearly but we can look back
at another period in time and see some of the same issues that we have playing out with a little bit more distance right and you know we're never going to know the full like truth of any historical period right but giving us the distance makes it so much easier to kind of look at what we have now and think through like hmm like what what did I see in this other period that I don't necessarily see in myself but might be there So speaking to the it's just a game crowd because that's kind of the shot against the bow right like in terms of whatever changes is making it's like trying to educate people uh you know a way to criticize that Paradigm and try to adopt this more kind of holistic paradigm I I pose it that it is on the it's just the game perspective to answer the question where does culture come from okay it doesn't come from games it doesn't come from movies you're not influenced by it people make their own decisions oh where does it come from and so like you have to answer that question so I was like we're answering the question we're like okay why do we uh you know have these games why do we constantly get these colonialist games why do we constantly get uh or games that you know exoticize right uh the outsides we could talk about like where do these things come from and so we're answering it you may not buy it it's like okay fine but then let's hear your perspective on okay where do these ideas come from does it descend from the sky was these or um I think there's an idea that like okay culture is kind of always this way you know a European culture always has done this and it's kind of like a Titan
memorial thing which five minutes of reflection or maybe not five minutes that's being dismissive uh but just a considered reflection of that uh thesis kind of I think falls apart because things don't come from anywhere like we do it humans do it and not just like powerful people or you know certain artists or whatever it is like great men we all do it and we all do it either we're making the games or we're playing the games or we're brought or we're doing what you and I doing or broadcasting about the games so we're all involved in this culture process and games just so happen to be one from among many many different fields so so uh just the idea that like I think maybe a culture person kind of imagining that back and forth uh they might say well it's a game right other things do it movies and books and other but games are just games and we're trying to say yeah I mean as far as I'm concerned games are art games are media and just as you can have kind of like a like a trashy no my air quotes like grocery store checkout aisle book you know and you can also have like pruce or something you know I feel like gaming is the same like you have the the games that are ostensibly just for fun but do communicate things about our culture whether we realize it or not and then you have things that are kind of heavy meditated statements about culture but they're both culture and they're both creating gaming culture right yeah you know we're all part of this process and so accepting your role means that you
can do something about it as opposed to just kind of thoughtlessly flow along with it so okay so the the book is trying to make this point um it is trying to do so doing in the scholarly way it is Liz is smiling if you're not seeing the zoom call uh it is quoting the the very familiar Theory if you are you know if you've been to grad school in the last however many years in any liberal arts program so I haven't been in a little while it's been I think I graduated with my undergrad degree in 2001. uh and I haven't like been steeped in like the latest cultural Theory since then so but I remember like uh you know Franz Fanon and Edward Saeed and there's a couple other names that I recall uh but things have developed then you you know uh Liz you had noticed some of the other names that have popped up yes so this uh book makes a lot of references too and it's been a while you know I've been out of grad school for 10 years now but I still recognize the names I was proud of myself I it stuck but um you know there is an entire branch of theoretical work that focuses on what's called post-colonialism and so postcolonialism is basically the study of how former colonies respond to the impacts socially intellectually and materially of having been colonized and one phrase that comes up a few times in this book or a term is the sub-altern so the sub-altern I don't even know what that is yeah so basically it describes like lower social classes and social
groups that have been displaced to the margins by an invasive colonial power so in an imperial situation um somebody who's subaltern would be a native person who has had their agency reduced if that makes sense yeah and so you know Natives and reservations and this place you know you were Elite in the Old South but now you're kind of lower class in the other in the new place yeah yes and so there's like there's like a oh God what's the article it's called something like can the sub-alter and speak and basically there's a whole bunch of kind of philosophy I would call Theory modern philosophy right happening about these topics and oppressed peoples and like asking to what extent has their actual voice and ability to assess themselves and their culture been alighted by the fact that they have been colonized and so when you talk about post-colonial stuff you're talking about can the subaltern Regine agency how do they now view themselves how how do we break away from that sort of colonial period and do our own thing um there's like a whole lot of you know basically studies the continued dominance of the West and the West way of defining things knowledge culture um you know but in a world where we might like to kind of walk back from that uh does do you feel in your opinion because I mean this is a review we're trying to we're speaking to different audiences we have audiences that are well read they have 17 grad degrees and you know they'll eat this stuff up we
also have Gamers that just want a game and a lot of you know gaming is college educated but they're not necessarily educated in post school no Theory or whatever do you did you feel this book was accessible to both audiences do you feel it was pitched to either one of those audiences or something else is going on what do you think oh okay this is interesting because I feel like this book kind of hit it was almost like an awkward middle it's like it kind it depends on what knowledge base you're coming in with if you were an academic and you know nothing about board games I think that this book would do a lot for you because it would give you a sense of the modern landscape but in academic terms to help you understand okay maybe this is important I should take it seriously so I would say that that is the most potent possible audience for this book people who understand the theoretical underpinnings who understand like the little linguistic and argumentative tracks that this book takes because it felt like going back 10 years when I read this book about this term paper I understand exactly how this argument is going to proceed I understand exactly how they're going to make it like it almost felt like doing a dance where I actually already knew the steps and I didn't realize that I did until I started dancing um near a different hall now like you're doing it open Hall which is the gaming Hall yeah yeah it was very weird um not in a bad way just just really trippy because it was like my worlds were colliding in a funky way but I think that if you're an academic and you want to understand how we could talk about gaming in an academic way this book is Rock Solid right I think if you are someone who has no idea about the academic side of things I don't think
that should stop you from reading it I think that you'll get enough out of it but you should be aware that they're gonna be times when you're like what what are they talking about yeah I totally missed that yeah yeah and so like that can be a little bit awkward uh but I don't think that that should stop you because frankly the way that I made it in Academia is just by continually reading things I didn't fully understand and so I've seen it enough times that I had context for it you got to start somewhere and so I actually think playing oppression is a relatively decent place to start um just make sure that you're looking at the so the other trick right to reading academic books is that you make notes of names you don't know you look at the bibliography and you decide if you actually care enough to track it down you know because one in in Academia because the the inter references the intertextual nature of it is that you can't just read one book and like feel totally grounded you have to read Around and then as things start going in circles you realize you've created like an intellectual net where you can catch everything um so you know I would actually say that go for it it's not going to hurt you um and the other thing that was weird is that I I felt like for me as somebody who's kind of been in both sides like thinking about board games at a fairly High critical level and having been in Academia right the book felt so familiar that it was almost more of a repackaging of things that have already happened for an academic audience sure than a totally new Venture is how I would I would say so like I would say that somebody like Dan throw would probably read this and be like yeah or like somebody like Cole Worley probably read this and I was like oh
yeah okay but let's see something like Joe thank you for saying it in a shorter way that's under 200 Pages kind of thing yes yeah this is short it's a good intro to the situation so like I wouldn't read this expecting like a complete everything's flipped on its head and my life has forever changed but I would read this and look for okay this is a really good overview of like the situation as it stands now both in terms of historically why this is important and also in terms of games mentioned like what are some of the little landmarks in our modern gaming culture um that you need to hit and know about so this brought up Puerto Rico this brought up uh archipelago um you know a bunch of like the sort of classic little you know modern hobby games that people have expressed discomfort about over the years but they're all kind of brought into one place as examples in this book so if you want like the full overview um instead of having to read 5 million different Board Game Geek conversations and arguments on Reddit at tweets this is where you go right um okay so I'm glad you mentioned that like this game is I mean or this book I keep on saying this game because you're still usually yeah uh so this book is I think it's coming from an academic tradition and and some ways speaking to an academic tradition and kind of like inviting people along into an academic conversation doing things to kind of make it uh more accessible so it's not like a weighty academic home at all I commend it for being you know quite
readable and I think you know people who don't have that academic background we'll get something out of it they won't get everything but they'll get something um I think one of the weaknesses of the book and this is kind of getting into that kind of last level of okay this book is academic and in a way it kind of preaches to the choir a little bit in order to get changed you have to kind of Branch out and and speak to different audiences and kind of convince them and so one thing where I wish the book could have done a little bit more was hunt bigger fish so it has a point to make about colonization in particular and it has a way it thinks about colonization in particular I'll get to that a second um actually I'll get to it right now because talking about it it um so the the key chapter for me well or the key Um passion for me was on page 13 with a defined colonialism so what is this thing that we're talking about this colonialist thing and they are looking at it from like a very kind of observable Empire perspective like okay that as soon as they say what are we doing what is this the colonialism thing well the Persians did it and the Romans did it and you know on and on and the Europeans did it and the Americans in some way are still doing it because we're Puerto Rico and Grandma kind of stuff it is the active Act of one country going to another place and taking their stuff and like you know being the boss of whatever land it is from an absolute perspective that involves violence it involves oppression but like for the most part uh it that is what colonialism is according to what this book says and it is taking a very
much Lefty effective because it doesn't it doesn't talk too much about like the great things that have been accomplished we've built roads and we you know brought medicines and all kind of stuff it is talking about quote the irrevocable violence to families individuals livelihoods uh spiritual Community bonds environmental damage obstruction of habitats it's not a Happy view of colonialism or at least in terms of like the over and act of colonialism so what this book did was focus on those games that explicitly take on colonialism so like you know you mentioned archipelago it talks about Navigator uh it talks about you know some of these other games and it's like okay within that like bubble yeah sure let's do it but should we care about that bubble you know it's if you're making the case that like games are have this larger influence then you kind of have to talk about the games that have influence like what is everybody playing there was a couple of pages on Katan that could have been bigger because katana's usually in for one show uh aspect and it was a quoted um an article but my good friend Greg Lauren Albright who wrote about Katan quoted it but kind of like moved on it's like no we have to be here uh and I mentioned this um in when I was chatting with Mary uh you know take it to ride has had dimensions of because it's evokes like the real world old west and the real world old west is very much a field of colonialism and they're not directly dealing with it but there's kind of stuff under the surface that if you aware of the history of the old west kind of tease that out why do I mention
tickets arrived because it's one of the biggest games and a so many games in terms of influence those are the games that are teaching other games how to be and what's popular and what's fun and that kind of thing so I it wasn't bad like they talked about you know certain games they mentioned the playback okay some games that are spiritershire they're influential that kind of thing but I feel like because of the way to define colonialism in that very no Empire taking over other Empire and like the overtax of violence it talked about certain things and kind of didn't missed some other dimensions if that makes sense yeah and Okay so a couple things to say about this see what was interesting right is they tried to bring up a couple of games that are about Colonial themes but are pushing against the grain of how those things are presented I actually thought they did both of those games kind of dirty so like I thought that Pax Premiere was like unfairly dismissed very quickly and just a paragraph in this in this book because it was like oh well you know it still uses Colonial structures to you know talk about to you know as a gaming mechanism and so like whatever is basically how I felt about that I was like wait a minute like paxmere is an extremely well thought out and intelligent statement about colonism it's really an academic work of its own and just having it just kind of watching it get tossed like that was like ouch um and then I also thought that you know there are certainly legitimate criticisms to how the Dahan comes through in spirit Island but again it was like it just felt like a little tap dismiss move on and I don't
know it just I I wanted a little more um but I actually think that this is where and I mentioned that academics you know and and hobby Gamers should talk more is what I actually would have liked to see is kind of an expansion on what you've been saying about things like historical tourism because the entire British history segment of this book was kind of an argument for the legitimacy of claims that you've made about that and that we've talked about in the past where you know you are subconsciously being taught certain things about how you fit into the world through the games that you play and so I thought it was very interesting that the modern games they chose to talk about were more explicitly Colonial when I think that you actually could have gone at a different or a further Direction by trying to apply the sort of subconscious aspects of what's happening for kids in the games of the past and looking at how what kind of parallels we have for that now and that's where I think something like Ticket to Ride is important right because it's not just Ticket to Ride is really popular that's not the sole reason why you'd consider it it's that ticket to ride it lies really key parts of history in order to be pleasant right right exactly uh yeah and he mentioned uh the author of the um uh Michaela I I pray apologize I production we haven't met in person um they mentioned about there was a Finnish version of Ticket to Ride Like the most popular game I think it was called the African star uh and that one
was pretty obvious you know because it's the African style they're taking the gym and they they're leaving Africa with it so it's kind of an obvious thing it's like okay um that allowed them to talk about it and I was like yes that yeah this is the most popular game in Finland let's talk about it right because because we're not talking necessarily about like the topic we're talking about influence this is a game about influence and so they did it it's there it's there to be teased about but if we're talking like you know how does this why should people care about this I think you know teasing out the idea that games are influenced by influence culture that should have been kind of the active or to me uh of the book again it almost gets there it's not like it doesn't uh but there are points where I think it could have made the point A Little Bit Stronger quote issues
personally wouldn't have chosen for my perspective and like you know I mean it's they're the authors of the book so okay um so I I hammer this because of what they said in terms of what the goal of this book is they want to make things better they don't just want to present their if the goal was humble like because I want to you know like I want to do an academic work I wouldn't I wouldn't say it I wouldn't bang on about this uh but the if the goal is to you know really uh you know move the ball forward uh get the Publishers noticed because that's who eventually is going to make the changes like the Publishers deciding you know uh would a publisher pick this up uh would a group of Gamers a group of influential Gamers what a an influencer who has a huge following would they pick this up and like oh wow we got to change our minds uh uh I'm a little iffy on that so going back to the idea of the way to define colonialism so in terms of like focusing on the overt acts and the actual you know like going over and colonizing planting your flag of genocide even natives you have a large segment of the gaming pop list that is willing to kind of in their minds make that trade-off they say oh yeah they were bad yeah the colonialists were bad and the Nazis were bad and these people were bad but we're good now so reminding me that they were bad doesn't do anything for me all you're trying to do is make me feel guilty and you know it's so like I read that section that particular section because like this is where we're defining what we're talking about in the book and it's like okay these were this will happen in the past it's happening now these people are bad it lets it it's written in a way
that lets people off the hook and that lets them say okay these are the bad people I'm not the bad person so that just doesn't apply to me and so oh I I did something no I can see the no I see your point I think it's a good point yeah and so like still and believe me and this is born out of like years of culture criticism at this point like the Liz and I've been in this game for a little while now with multiple videos and hearing that pushback of like it's so like you can make the you know all those points and it's a huge structure but it's so easily dismissable if if it's just at the level of like okay these people did bad things okay so how do you fix that you fix that by really widening the scope and bringing in the full sense of what colonialism is and how it impacts it is not just a bunch of powerful people did a bunch of bad things it is an entire cultural system it is a system of Education it is a system of uh it's basically like a story generator like I mean the colonists did what they did because they thought they were good yeah I'm the hero you know and this game this book plays with that but it doesn't to me it doesn't really hit that point out I'm like okay no I'm we're doing a good thing we're bringing the you know uh the civilizations of the natives and all that kind of thing uh so when you're in a game it's not that you're playing a a colonialist you're encouraged to think that I'm a hero the colonialist is the hero I kind of wanted more analysis of
like that aspect of gains as like I am the hero now and teaching that the colonialist the Nazi or whoever you're talking about the warlord the the magnate the robber baron is the hero and how much that has a wide cultural thing and when I think as a person as an everyday person that these people are the heroes then that influences the larger culture to make I I'm I'm getting this together so I'm hoping no I like the way you're piecing together it makes a lot of sense and the other thing it kind of made me think of that I had meant to mention like I didn't take notes but this is like a mental note that I'd had so the other thing I noticed that was very interesting about this particular book like as an academic work is so you know my PhD is an ancient Christianity and so I read a lot of things just that you know people argue about okay so is it okay to call a heretic a heretic just because ancient Orthodox Christians did and how do we change our identities and you know what point of view are we you know are we looking at things from but nobody ever like looks at religious violence from this period it is like those people were bad this was oppressive and bad but I noticed that there were statements throughout this book that were things like oh you know if you thought the cover was bad the contents are worse and I was very fascinated by that not because I disagree on an emotional level right but because it represents kind of a different turn in academic discourse normally at least in my experience in books like this the value judgments get held and you try to hold back and just
like have this kind of even though everybody's always biased and everybody always has a direction they're going there's a certain pretense that you're just merely examining something under the light and that didn't happen in this book and that's not bad it's not good it just is but I think it's very interesting that we were willing to have some value judgments in here but not go as far as you want it to go it makes this book easy to dismiss if you don't agree with it so it makes this like the okay someone's reading who doesn't have the perspective they're reading the book and saying okay they're calling a presser is bad they're using value judgment language this is their perspective that's not mine I don't have to think like them and you kind of say okay what that's what happened to the value judgments okay that's what you think that's what I think we're gonna go on out about today it's not how you get changed that's what you if that's a goal the goal is to get changed and to convince mine persuade people at ultimate goal that's how you get changes persuasion uh so I don't agree with like the former way of doing it like let's just present the whole bunch of academic Theory uh either I think there's a middle way of like okay let me uh present different facts I'm still going to talk out of the facts but I need to present different facts right and present things differently and you know get into what how the other person sees things see what their facts are see what facts they're seeing and then try to deconstruct some of that stuff that way or or help them see what they're not seeing which would help them make some links so I spoke about the Hero part of the story I think that was
something that could have been emphasized a little bit more the other part and this is a huge part and I find that it was in there in spots but like not not where it needed to be which is front and center what is colonialism colonialism at the end of the day is policies and law so when a colonialist goes to a place they don't just like win a bunch of wars and that's it they set up the laws they they restructure Society they Institute power structures in The Institute ways of enforcing those power structures so I I I'm going to make a whole video about this um because I think this is a really important point that very few people understand because from a place of privilege it's hard to see violence is violence violence is not oppression violence is the individual acts and people Gamers can kind of do whatever they want within their heads it's fun to be violent in games okay finds oppression is a whole nother level right of colonization and colonism what is oppression oppression is the constant pushing down of peoples through enforcement mechanisms through law through cultural norms it happens on the every single day it is the difference between a romp you know a kill all the Orcs And a game like papers please where it's like I'm doing the violence but I'm doing it by just demanding someone have their papers and if they don't have their papers then they're out they're excluded right you know and at this in a way colonialism
is about following the rules and that that parallel should be with games all the time when what happened why are you getting excluded because you don't follow the rules colonialism is another group gets to make make new rules yeah well I think that's what makes expressing thoughts about colonialism through games extra interesting because in order to play a game you are you are implicitly agreeing to follow the rules of the game and so if the game is structured like you know once you decide you're going to play colonialism you're going to play by Colonial rules yes and that's you know emotionally historically true but it also makes you wonder like okay what are we doing in our games that we are asking players to implicitly accept as the norms because that's where it's hiding the workers can't win at a game it's against the rules guess what the workers can't win in colonialism it's against the rules and so in a game there's no pushback there's no agency we talked about or like many many popular kind of and I I focus a lot about worker but you can kind of do it other places I'll focus on workers so in the game it's literally against the rules for the workers to win because the workers aren't even people right they're just like little like resources right so it's against the rules in a colonialist perspective the workers are the same you know if you're an indigenous population you are your worker you're there to generate value and if you try to be other than that well that's breaking the rules and that this is not a game that gets enforced and that's how you bring people back within the bounds of the game I also think that these sorts of conversations are special especially
topical now and like I'm just gonna go here because it's my podcast I can do it um you know I'm a teacher I'm one state north of Florida right now if you think that it's ridiculous and just silly to be banning books and making it a class 3 felony for a teacher to lend a book to assume that a parent disapproves of to try to limit what books kids can bring to school themselves because maybe they'll expose someone else to something else these are setting the rules that lead to Future problems right if you even if you think the rules are stupid and say well I'm just going to break them it's actually not that easy this is now putting people's jobs on the line and resetting the rules in a way that's going to limit what people are allowed to say and think for who knows how long for as long as this persists with unknown consequences and so you know all these like little like oh it's just it's just a silly legal thing you can twist around it you can get out of it you can no you can't not after a while or the fact that you're twisting on in the first place you've already distorted what you're teaching yes so like if I'm you know and the big thing in Florida is you know not the modern black perspective of like black lives matter and you know CRT all kind of stuff so I can teach these other things and kind of get excuses that they're not CRT and I can sneak it quote unquote sneak it in that way well by the sneaking I've changed the end yeah and now I'm teaching a different ID and so therefore because of the rules of whatever is happening I have to do a different thing so so what okay so getting Zoom back on the lens how do
games recreate culture well games um they teach us how to follow rules like I've done this as many times like okay games are good for teaching kids how to take turns how to you know wait their turn how to be a how to be a good Loser yeah and so there's so many things how to milk rules to get what you want like and what's possible you know like you know like telling people okay what you know how to push you know against the boundaries of the rules and that kind of stuff so when a game so there's not just like okay I am a sexually colonized I'm learning about colonization these Heroes that's one part of it but just the idea of like okay what's possible you know I I get into so many conversations about worker-centered board games and people are like oh that's boring that'll never happen well I thought that games were filled where you do whatever you want right also most of us are workers are you saying that we're all boring oh that would there's not it's not possible for us to kind of overthrow our bosses or like live jewelry live joycly and you know did all game Teach that no did the preponderance of games that Center the powerful people and the rich and all that kind of stuff did that teach us that then I'm willing to say yes that didn't come from nowhere I put it on the per the it's just the game person to tell me where that came from because I think it came from games media movie and all kind of stuff yeah so this inability to imagine that we can have games that are other than comes directly from the ways in which we are taught to follow the rules of certain games just as in a colonial
perspective so I can say like you know in a way that the colonial the colonial mindset really what it comes down to is follow the rules and their absentee rules or somebody else's rules and they will be enforced violently if you don't follow the rules so getting and I've never really read that that's kind of a thing that I'm um developing and and it prompted it was actually probably from this book so I got to give the book credit for prompting you know thinking on my part oh this this definition isn't what I would do what would I do that kind of like came up with this so I'm not saying well think like I think I guess what I'm saying is if you want to influence people if you want to really cut in get change in the hobby we need to think a little bit more broadly than just saying colonize is a bad don't do that yeah and I think as you were talking I was just kind of trying to narrow this down for myself into something pity you know you know how I am um but it just made me think like you know if you can't get out of your own perspective it's not because your perspective is obviously right right it's because you might be stuck in it if you truly can't see what somebody else is seeing that is a sign of intellectual stagnation not intellectual like you're locked in because you're right yeah and they say that like they actually say like we are two European or American European uh White academics and we have our perspective we're gonna have blind spots so like it's not like these aren't attacked these aren't like no this is terrible like they own the fact that you know they just have a perspective and
I'm imagining by admitting that that they're open to thinking differently so this is you know kind of invitation to be like okay here's some a way to think differently about it which might get us as closer to go all of us yes to get you know changing the hobby as a postdoc person right like I understand all contributions to academic literature as you're never you never think you have the final word I guarantee you nobody ever unless they're just nuts thinks that when they when they publish an academic book the point of an academic book is to contribute to an ongoing Conversation Over centuries and so this is a great contribution to that conversation because look at how much we've been able to talk about it that book gave us some intellectual anchoring spaces and made some statements for us to kind of bounce off of think about push ourselves with if that is the essence of a good academic book and that's why even though I don't agree with everything in here or think that you know of course it's not what I would have done but like of course not but the fact that it managed to push us this with this much gas right tells me that it's a book that's worth being part of the conversation and that's worth engaging with and that did its job I think you said it great where it's like that I think the the best audience for this is the academic who isn't a gamer but uh who isn't a gamer who wants to kind of apply these tools to games I think that's like the really well said uh this isn't the audience that is listening to this podcast necessarily because they're game Centric will that audience get something out of this yeah I mean I think that you'll get the history the survey of games which is really fun in and of itself you'll get nice pictures you'll get um a as Liz said some foothold into the
conversation so even though I found the conversation kind of limited itself in the way it defined colonialism it still represents a where we are where a lot of us are and gives us a launching point for more so yeah could we get we could definitely recommend the book on those levels yeah I mean this book I think represents an important moment in game discourse because it is nice to see academics writing a book that is an academic book but also engages our community and it's very Flanigan's Community too you know she's a gamer and an academic and make sure yeah we don't know it because her games aren't in like Target and get you know that million copy print runs but yeah no they uh she's part of a um outfit I think is like what it's called but they make plenty of games like social games and educational games one thing we should mention is that last chapter uh you had glanced at it because you mentioned you know Spirit Island in a couple other games but they do talk about a whole bunch of games and they mentioned the zenobi awards and they mentioned um Stonewall Uprising and they mentioned kind of a lot of the other games are kind of bubbling up uh did you feel um how did you react to that last chapter kind of going through where games could go um I just wanted more but I think that that's the nature of like they they they put their investment in making sure that the grounding was there and so now it's up to their next book or somebody's next book to kind of take up pick up the ball and keep running um but it also made me happy to see I guess the acknowledgment of all the work
that we like the Gaming Community right are doing um and it you know I'm really excited by Stonewall Uprising I'm really excited about a lot of the games that are coming I think that I think that we're entering a really good age for historical games trying to push in different directions and that they are aware of it too and that they're hitting the right pulse point that you know this is this is where we're going to move forward if you want change this is where it will be you know and yeah I mean it goes back to kind of my influence Point like okay these are very small games so it's like to kind of you got to be really careful when saying okay this is the possible future of the hobby because I mean the past future the hobby is like kickstarters and million dollar things and everything and I wish uh kind of being a little bit more honest about the fact that okay it painted a sunny picture of what's on the horizon but I think it could have done more to be like okay um this is actually what's happening in terms of like the influential games we're still getting chainmail bikinis on Kickstarter we're still getting uh you know the archaeo society which this book was been finished in 2021 2023 we got the re theme of ethnos hypnosis is a game that kind of has some uh it has its fans from a couple of years ago it's getting a reprint with a um Indiana Jones researcher theme going around the world scanning artifacts type thing there's a giant monkey statue on the face and it's like oh my God here we go again uh so we're still getting that and I think the book could have been a little bit more like okay no um this is this is where this is the hopeful part this is where we are and
the reason I say that is I want to help like the next Generations understand that we got to put our bootstraps on like yeah you have to be in this for the long haul it isn't just a question of oh let's you know make other games and game game and what kind of like uh you know flower that way there's a that's a part of it but we're still in the poo when it comes to cultural Appropriations and stereotyping all that kind of stuff and we gotta we've gotta strap in so there's a little bit of again going off of the idea how can this book help yeah you know some ideas of like okay this is how the book could have helped and this is how maybe Future Works built on this could help yeah I mean I absolutely see your point I think what's happening there too though is that you know I as a postdoc person who likes to talk about historical games like I'm really drawn to those more Niche games because I love talking about them because they give me something to grip onto when I'm talking right if that makes sense they're like they're actually saying something they give me a statement to interact with I think so with the Zenobia Awards so you're you're right in there but the area where you're working is harder because it's easier to dismiss what you're saying about what you see it's less concrete you know and you can just be like oh it's just a theme you know it's you work in the in the territory where you know Taylor Just is making a statement about you know queer history it's it you can interact with it because he said something it's harder to interact with something that is saying something but pretends that it's not and that's where the real Insidious things happen and it's also
where it's much harder to get a grip it's much more like protein um and it's much easier for somebody to rhetorically slide away from you when you're trying to make a point about it so yeah are you I'm so glad you said that in a way I guess I'm saying please help me can someone help me please I get a lot of comments and this is a me thing I I know but I think we're reacting kind of from our own perspectives like I get us so many comments of people who are helpful and they're on the right tip but they they'll DM me it's like okay I don't want to do what you do like I don't want to kind of go into the maw of the Beast and deal with these you know different these you know kind of moderate perspectives and I can't do what you do and I'm thinking like I can't do it either I mean I'm doing it but it's exhausting I had to take a three month break because I got so burned out and I think the idea that like because I have a I have a philosophy of how to get change and I think there's a lot of people online said that want to get changed it is hard yes especially because it wasn't just like you know let me kind of educate people in my liberal perspective and people will hold on to it's so easy for them to dismiss it if it stays at that level you can't let people off the hook like that if you really want to get changed yeah and I mean I already admit like I'm a relatively culturally comfortable white lady like you know it's easy for me to not to to say oh I'm not gonna let that get to me that's not a huge deal but in aggregate it is and you know I have to do the work of kind of stepping back and be like oh wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait party Foul right right yeah
um and yeah I mean it's a project that we're all engaged in like like we said earlier right every single person who plays games and Designs games and talks about games we're all contributing to gaming culture and we get to make our choices about the contribution that we want to make every single person from the person who's like just really mad on Facebook uh to the person who sends a nasty screen email to the person who makes a fake account on Twitter and also all the people who are out here you know trying to make critical content about games and who are trying to design thoughtful games you know every single one of us wherever we are is contributing to this culture and so we all get to decide what kind of culture we want to have and who we want to be in this in this world of ours all right I'm good uh I think again but no seriously stepping back you know I recommend this book for all the reasons that we said it it at the end of the day it does continue a conversation it does and I mean if you if at the end if you can come up with your criticisms okay um and we do but if again if a book contributes to a conversation and so going back to like okay what would Dan Thoreau think what would the co early thing they'd be like it continues the conversation boom done go ahead yeah that's that I would guess that as well I mean you talked about this I'm assuming but um but yeah I I do recommend that you read it if you're interested in these topics it's a nice grounding um and then I recommend that you keep going because reading one book Is Never Enough you got to read absolutely start here keep going um anything anything else to say before before we sign off statistics we're looking forward to
season seven at some point nine and ten hopefully not going anywhere absolutely not and then uh you are still on the One Stop Co-op shop and are you uh updating socialize right now um I I think when it came uh so people know at this point Puerto Rico the 1897 is released I won't say a lot about it because there's a whole other conversation uh in terms of printing errors and uh or production issues that I just don't have anything to do with uh so I just don't feel it's my place to kind of participate in that conversation in terms of the thematic statement that it made I think people are getting it uh and my hope is that the product can kind of overcome some of those uh production issues we can get back to kind of talking about that uh Puerto Rico on a on that thematic level uh so I kind of ended shelf stories I'm like okay this is what I'm talking about people this is shelf stories and if you don't think that shelf stories then go back and figure out what I am really about I am not about games for a quote-unquote tiny minority I'm not about taking Peak games away that's the things we get accused of no I'm I'm four games for everybody and this is my thesis statement and if you don't understand that then well we need to talk about what is happening and not just what you think is happening right so that's where I kind of ended my active run-up shelf stories and if other stuff comes up then you know I'll throw up the flag and uh you know kind of run it back I'm also I think we mentioned this before we're still designing our people's history United States so there's not a card game a pure card game uh who knows what it'll be it might just be a mini Fest six months
but I visited Greg uh we had a whole weekend design Jam we got a lot done so we're it's happening so we're feeling good about it beautiful uh and I'll put your Twitter handle in the show notes and every out there hopefully you know by now I can be found anywhere online that's beyond Solitaire so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming hey everybody foreign