Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:27

this video is brought to you by the 3-minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon warning this video contains an absolute bucketload of spoilers for The Scarlet Keys viewer discretion is advised Kyoto everyone and welcome to this review of The Scarlet keys so what is the Scarlet Keys the scallet keys is the most recently released campaign for Arkham Horror and it's come out in this giant big box box you get a big box like this with all the story content in it and a smaller box that has all the player cards in it now the last video we did was a deep dive on the path to kosa which was the second campaign that they published after the Dunwich Legacy the Scarlet Keys is the eighth campaign they've published and we've jumped straight from their second campaign to the most recent one and the reason for that is one of my crew he' already played all the other campaigns this is the one that he hadn't played yet so we thought why not give this one a go and I'm really glad we did because it was very different and a very interesting campaign and I'm really pleased that we got through it now what makes the garet keys unique and a very different campaign from everything else that's been published to date well first let's look at the theme and that starts off with the Scarlet thing so there is a group in The Scarlet keys that are normally led by a character called the Red gloved Man and they all have different red outfits it's like a unifying feature unifying trait amongst this this group uh they're known as the Congress of the keys and each of them is

really unique I'm going to bring up some of the pictures from the promotional material that Fantasy Flight games used to advertise the skaret keys just to show you how sort of different and interesting and intriguing uh the members of this group are now you notice that some of the characters are very very normal looking and very human and some of them less so and one of the cool things about the Scarlet Keys is getting out there and discovering and meeting these different characters now the frame up for the campaign is that you have being pulled into a secret organization it's a little bit of Indiana Jones or James Bond meets Arkham Horror and you are set Globe trotting around the world to discover what thefurious group is up to and that brings me to another one of the really defining features of the Scarlet keys and that is it is an open campaign now you start off with the same starting Mission every time you play this campaign and you end up with the same finale although the finale can be structured differently based on your decisions throughout the game but you end end up leaving and exploring this map and you were given 35 time units with which to explore the map and you can spend those time units traveling around having encounters and having missions or coming across missions there's probably an optimal way to get around there to get the maximum amount of XP but I think the fun part of this is discovering it all and we went through once and we did not do I believe four of the eight incidental missions so we did uh the starting Mission the end mission we did four four other missions and we did a standalone in there as well

because the scalla keys is designed to fit in standalones as well if you want to play them and that's something the other campaigns that always feels off to sort of break the campaign halfway off to Jaun off to Venice or to go to Louisiana or to do one of the other side missions because of how the narrative is structured in those campaigns in The Scarlet Keys you are Globe trodding so if you turn up in Venice well you can just run that mission and that's the thing we ended up going to Monte Carlo and running fortune and Folly which is an amazing Standalone scenario uh if you have not tried fortune and Folly it is uh Oceans 11 uh meets Arkham Horror and uh it's all about planning a casino Heist and everything going to custard about halfway through really cool uh scenario and it fits seamlessly into to uh this campaign as well for us uh because the reward for finishing that one was gaining a key and that's another thing about the Scarlet Keys a lot of these missions end up giving you these powerful relics uh the keys manipulate reality they do unique and interesting stuff and they have like a good side and a bad side and if they're on the good side um and you control one you can use its power and flip it over but then you have to do the bad thing to flip back over and the baddies can also control them and that

means there's this fight all the way through the campaign over who gets to control this collection of keys and going into the finale some of the keys will be in the hands of the baddies some of them will be in your hands and some you won't have discovered because if you manag to discover all the keys on one play through uh well done uh we were something like four or five short um but we got an extra bonus key from the Standalone and that that really solidified that that particular Standalone uh fortune and Folly really fits Under the Umbrella of the Scarlet keys and could possibly even have just been part of the campaign now with the map uh there's a whole bunch of stuff on here and a whole bunch of entries in the book now my group are all old school role players so the idea of reading aloud uh page after page of flavor text that's our Jam we we like doing that kind of stuff we'll put on the silly voices um we'll we'll try our best to do the accents if we can uh we usually can't but we put in a genuine try the campaign though has a bucket load of reading um there's a lot of times you will go to a location and read a whole bunch of text make some decisions but not necessarily get into an actual Arkham campaign uh regular scenario you know you won't be setting up the the table you won't be playing cards you'll just be making decisions and then moving on to the next location

and you can do this like four or five times in a row depending on where you are on the board and um what decisions you're making so you end up spending a good half an hour to an hour or so just reading from the book which might not be ideal for some people as I say it didn't bother us and in fact we found it quite immersive and and very interesting but I imagine playing it uh the second time around getting to those locations uh if you making the same decisions again that will be a bit tiresome um so yeah it be interested to see how we feel about all that reading and uh talking aloud if we go back through the campaign again and we definitely want to go back through the campaign again uh it was a sort of collective decision afterwards that we missed half at least half of what's going on here uh as I say at least four scenarios we missed out on and um it's clearly more stuff for us to play on a second run through so we did not go through uh the Americas or Europe really at all we kind of skipped out of Europe as soon as we could we did a lot of Africa South America and Asia but we didn't really do um Europe or North America at all um so yeah or Central America so yeah if you've played through you'll know which scenarios we missed uh based on that on top of the keys there's two new mechanics that uh the Scarlet Keys introduced and the first one is concealed now concealed what it will do is there's all these little mini cards here and some monsters will have a

concealed rating of say say concealed three that means you'll get their card and three blank cards shuffle them up and deal one out to each location and that represents that you don't know where the creature currently is they then sit in a place called The Shadows which is a sort of half off the board half on the board place where you can't Target them but some effects from the counter deck uh Mythos deck can allow them to Target you um so ideally you want to find them in the shadows and deal with them pull them out of the shadows and and give them a flack and finding cards in um the Shadows means you have to either do direct damage or discover a clue or do a evade test uh in that location and if you succeed instead of you know collecting a clue or whatever you go I'm going to reveal that concealed card and it just happened to be that the group we had set up through no foresight or no planning cuz we didn't know about this mechanic was exceptionally good at doing this um my character had a lot of direct damage um Fraser was playing Agnes who has direct damage at will so she could just go ping and use her natural ability to do one damage to to unbale a card and uh Carolyn um so Jared other Jared was playing Carolyn and she had oh he had the um field agents that would did automatic um clue Gathering so they could ping them as well so we had this

um innate group of characters that just happened to be able to get all over the top of that mechanic so be curious to go back through it with characters that don't have uh direct damage uh and don't have that sort of stuff on call uh I was playing Caron Sinclair and I started off with bat cops in my deck that could do that and then I ended up graduating up to agency backups so the character was all about getting his agency backups down and keeping them healthy and using them to get direct damage and direct clue getting but with the concealed mechanic that just meant that he had this reservoir of ability to go boom discover that card Discover that card and it meant in the grand finale where you are fighting against something and there's a lot of concealed cards involved it was pretty easy it was very very easy finale and this is uh unlike aosa we won the finale Al which is which is pretty good so concealed I thought was pretty cool uh but I feel we were quite well tricked out for it completely and utterly accidentally and I could imagine in some high shroud locations uh conceal could get to be a bit of a pain in the ass the second mechanic was Hollow and what Hollow does is you have to set cards aside from your deck as Hollows so say you've got a hand of five cards and you're to set aside two Hollows so you put say a first aid and a machete to one side then later in the game there'll be effects that do no they're out of the

game you can't you can't access them unless specifically instructed but there will be cards that come along later it go if you have a hollow matching a card in play destroy that card or do something to that card and it just it felt really mean you're like okay I've had to hollow out uh randomly an integral card for how my deck works and then the card comes along goes oh and kill the other one you've got in play so it's really anti- combos um if you get unlucky with Hollows uh can really dismantle any of the sort of internal Synergy you have going on within within your deck construction and I found it really irritating like it took out um so playing Caron I was trying to do a deck where I didn't do many tests because he has stats two across the board he's rubbish at doing checks the goal was to give out as many bonus actions to the other players as possible and then do as much tless damage and test as clue getting as I could uh through allies and other means and uh one of those uh cards that I had was toe-to-toe in combination with guard dog so that allowed me to attack an enemy do plus one damage and automatically hit then they would retaliate hit the guard dog and do more damage back so it's a three damage um effect where I didn't have to do a test uh and it hollowed out in the last game my toad toad to toes and oh really

frustrating um losing one of those in in the last round um when you're building a deck that relies on certain key points or certain uh cards to be recurred and one of them is hollowed out and in the second one is hollowed out by another effect it's really really frustrating so concealed uh and the the whole concealment card things that's a great mechanic that was a lot of fun Hollow yeah I can't say that I particularly enjoyed uh in that one so as for the individual scenarios themselves they were they were good like there was no scenario that I was like wow that that blew me away like there were some in Seath to carosa but I felt they were all quite solid uh I quite like the one where there are a lot of civilian I think it's one of the desert locations there's a lot of civilians and there's just a zombie apocalypse basically happening and you have to save as many as possible now we did really well on that but we also got to it very early um and I believe if we'd got to that scenario later it would have been really really hard and I also really like uh some of the members of the Congress of the keys uh in particular the character that we refer to as kmen San Diego and if you see a picture of her which I'll put one up you'll see why we called her that and she ended up dogging us through our campaign so we we encountered her pretty early and then she kept popping up in other scenarios and just causing

us grief all the way through the game so she kind of became our our primary antagonist uh instead of the Red glove man and uh yeah we ended the campaign with 29 experience points so which is exactly the same total that we ended PA the kakosa with which is kind of freaky so it's not a huge XP campaign um You probably get more but uh again we didn't really know what we were doing and just meandered around the map going to locations that sounded of interest to us and I'm sure if you had like a lightning plan you could probably get another 10 XP before the finale would I recommend the campaign to people absolutely I'm not sure this is a good one to start off with um I think this might be better suited for people who' played uh the game a fair bit the cool things about it is the openness uh there's the replayability of of going around the board um is the sort of sense of agency you have which you don't really in any of the other campaigns you kind of just go from Scenario A to B and it does represent a sort of change in philosophy when they move to uh doing these big boxes instead of selling the pack pack pack pack pack so when they did that they had to make the scenarios like linear they had to make the whole thing go from end to end and the Scarlet Keys is just way more ambitious than that and I think overall it works I think overall this is a good fun package uh we had a really neat time I'm not sure it had the same highs as the path

the kakosa with some of the scenario designs um but it also didn't have any real bum notes like there weren't any scenarios we played that were like eh that was a bit Naf um so I think sort of middling consistency uh and sort of solidness of scenario design really anything that leapt out and went way this is the best game I've ever played so yeah a really good time but not necessarily the greatest uh Arkham Horror has been for us now immediately after finishing the Scarlet Keys we are going to go straight into the insouth conspiracy so hopefully in about 2 months time I'll be back here talking about our encounters with the lovely deep ones of enouth I've put a link in the description of the video to my Carson Sinclair deck which I've lovingly called The Butler I and Jihad and you can see how a deck that revolves around doing test lless damage and not taking tests uh would work so the main focus of that deck is of course it's allies and test damage but it's also about getting blessed tokens into the bag that help the other players out as well so it's very much a mix between blessing and you know direct testers damage and strangely very fun to play like I thought Carson might be a bit crap but he ended up being a whale of a time and if you're into role play or or just thinking about how the game works the agency backup uh we just imagined that was just an army of butlers so everywhere that Carson went he had this just Army of butlers that just turned up and did everything um and Safeguard allowed him to follow

around other characters and yeah he was just generally this Bible thumping iny face um Butler who refused to die and refused to go away oh and because of his dark packed weakness would just occasionally spill scalding hot tea on you anyway a link to that Carson deck is in the description check that out if you can and if you enjoy this video hit the notification button like share and subscribe to the channel oh yeah on the first night we played the Scarlet Keys uh this is what greeted people as they approached and this is what the inside of the room looked like I kind of went a little bit overboard with the mood

lighting

Progress saved