Skip to main content
Loading video...

It's Ok When Someone Doesn't Like That Game You Like

Transcript 11:54

Hey, I'm Alex Mackle from Board Gameco and today Oh my gosh, there's another one. There's another one. Okay, we'll just keep going. Hey, I'm Alex Rackle from Board Gameco. And this this is a video that was prompted by me seeing a post where someone didn't like a game. It's a fairly popular game. I love the game personally, but someone posted how they had played the game and they did not like the game. When I last checked, there were like 74 comments, most of which were like, "Hey, you probably should like the game. It's a popular game. here's what you may have done wrong. Why didn't you like the game? There were a few. There were a few supportive comments, make no mistake. But the vast majority of the comments, while not aggressive, I would say that most people were not aggressive. In fact, I don't know if I saw a single aggressive comment, but most people were like, "You're wrong for not liking the game."

And it made me think that this is a problem that I know exists. I know it exists because Sorry for the cat in the way. It's a pro. Okay, Cal. Cal, this is This is No, Cal, that's the worst place. Cal, you can you can sit here, but you got to be over there. There we go. Okay. Uh, so this is a problem that I certainly know exists because especially as a reviewer, when I don't like a game that's popular, you usually get a lot of push back. You definitely get support, by the way. There are going to be people who feel heard and seen like, "Wait, that reviewer also doesn't like the super popular game that everyone gives me grief for. Yay, I'm not alone." Which kind of reminds you that there's the problem. They feel validated that someone else doesn't like the game when everyone else is giving them a hard time for not liking the game. But a lot of comments will be about how you played it wrong. You didn't do this right. Well, you didn't even mention this aspect and that means you probably did something wrong or it's invalidated or did you play it enough times? Do you play it with the right people? Do you play it with different groups? Whenever a reviewer or a reviewer group, if you're talking about like things like the Dice Tower, whenever a game is not liked, there's usually push back on that. I see it on forum posts. I see it in uh in written reviews and I see it in video reviews. It's okay when people don't like a game that you like. We all have different opinions. Now, the the reality is I should always mention these when I do the videos like this is I recognize that I'm probably not talking to the majority of you. I think the majority of people just don't chip in when these things happen to begin with. The majority of people just don't necessarily engage or see. But when there are people who are engaging, there's usually a lot more people

engaging about how why don't you like that thing that you like. And we have to remember that we all have games that are incredibly popular. No matter who you are, it doesn't matter who you are, but if you are John, okay, or Stacy, could be anyone. John or Stacy, pick your pick who whatever name you want to go with, whoever you are. and think of a game that you love that you've seen someone else whether in a Facebook group or reviewer not like the game and think how you to a certain extent there's a part of you that may have thought that they were wrong that they played something wrong that did something wrong but then the flip side of that is think of a game that is incredibly popular that you didn't love because that happens just as much. We all have games that are popular that we bounced off of. We all have games that everyone else seemed to love and we just didn't get it. And sometimes we just didn't get it a little bit. Oh, people love this game. I just thought it was okay. Other times you're like, "People love this game. I don't understand at all." Like, "What is everyone else smoking? What is going on? Did I play something wrong? I reread the rules after. I did everything. Whatever. I don't know why it is that everyone loves this game and why people are going on and on about it. But I don't like that game." It happens to all of us. There's a term shelf of shame that is often like, you know, people don't love the term shelf of shame. They're like, you know, it's the shelf of opportunity.

It's not the shelf of shame. That never bothered me. But I've never liked the term overrated for exactly this reason. And this my own pet peeve on the nature of putting too much emphasis on our own opinions aso as as opposed to the general space. Overrated is a term that kind of means and and again, I'm giving this too much weight and I acknowledge that. It's just meant to say, "Hey, I think this game is not as good as other people is." But I don't like the term because the term almost implies that it is overrated. My opinion is the right opinion, but other people overrate the game, but my opinion is the standard. Now, again, I recognize I'm giving it too much weight, but the concept the concept there certainly is truth to that that we put too much weight in our own opinion. We all have a natural bias towards ourselves. And that's me, you, we all do. I absolutely trust me when I say I have a natural bias towards myself. And this applies to more than just our opinions on board games and how right we are. It applies to everything we do where we give ourselves grace and and an importance that we don't give to others. We drive great. They drive dangerously. We take calculated risks.

They're just not careful. When we're late, it's for a great reason and we have all the good reasons in the world as to why we were 5 minutes late something. And when they're late, it's because they're inconsiderate. There's often a greater degree of allowance, of importance, of grace, of righteousness that we apply to ourselves as opposed to others. And that definitely happens with board games as well. It happens when you play an incredibly popular game and you don't love it and you think, well, I don't get what everyone else is thinking or this is not that great a game. It happens when you love a game and other people don't love it. And instinctively your first thought, and again I do this too. Instinctively your first thought is to go towards the fact that they probably did something wrong. They probably played it at the wrong player count. They probably didn't give it enough plays. They probably did something wrong as far as the rules go.

They probably had someone teach them the game who railroaded them because they weren't giving a good teacher. If they had a bad experience, it's not because our opinion of the game is wrong. It's because something about their experience was wrong. It's important to recognize this bias in life in general, by the way, but we're just talking about board games for today. So, we're going to focus on board games. But it's important to recognize this bias, not just because of recognizing biases that exist, but also because the board gaming space should be a welcoming space. People should feel free and welcome to post whatever opinions they want without being attacked, so long as those opinions don't cause harm, of course. But in the case of thinking a board game is good or isn't good, it's usually not a case of causing harm. People should feel welcome to post those opinions without the fear of well other people are going to invalidate that opinion in some way, shape, or form. And I do want to do a random call back to a video I did a long time ago. I can't remember what the title was. I think it was something along the lines of don't yuck their yum or something like that. I don't remember exactly, but I did a video once upon a time where kind of the reverse of this where when people love a game, you don't have to jump in and tell them how much you didn't like it. If I post, "By the way, I just played Terraforming Mario.

It's such a great game." For you to jump in and be like, "Eh, it's not that great." That's also not good. But it's not good. The the consistency is here. The consistency is not is not about the fact that you should be allowed to like or dislike a game. The consistency is about the fact that you should be feel free to express an opinion without that opinion being shot down. If you don't like a game, go ahead and post it. But if somebody else loved a game or somebody else just bought a game, if someone else is excited of a game, that's not the time to jump in and say, "Hey, by the way, I didn't like the game." And again, the reverse is truth. The reverse is true as well. When someone else posts, "I just played a popular game and I didn't like it." That's not the time to jump in with a comment about how they played it wrong, about how you like it, about how everyone else likes it, of how it's in the top 100 for a reason, whatever the aspect is. This is not the time to jump in with an invalidating comment. This is a good time to think about what comments are helpful. And this applies to any conversation, by the way, not just a post about someone not liking a game.

But think through a comment that could actually be helpful, engaging, possibly prompt a conversation, but that isn't simply shutting that person down. Someone says, "Oh, by the way, I just played Terrifying Mars and I think it was a terrible game." Great. Why don't you comment something along the lines of, "Oh, what about the game didn't work for you? Were you looking forward to the game for any particular reasons? And did you find that those experiences were not met and why?" Like, prompt an interesting conversation or just simply acknowledgement. That's great. It's always good to learn more about yourself and the types of games you do and don't like. There's so many different types of comments. or another one. Do you want thoughts and advice about diving in again or are you just done with it? Because that also could be interesting. Like sometimes people say some someone says I didn't like terraforming Mars. Sometimes they're just starting a conversation. Other times they're confused and they didn't properly express that they what they really meant to say was I didn't love Terraforming Mars. Why do you like it so much? Or am I doing something wrong? Some there's a implied next step, but you you have to be careful because you don't want to assume too much that that next question is there if it isn't. But it's good to open that door to that. Do you want thoughts and advice about diving in again? Or are you just done with the game? There's so many ways to have an actual interesting conversation that do nothing to invalidate that person, that do nothing to make that person feel less welcome, and that do nothing to effectively tell that person that your like of the game is more important than the fact that they are allowed to talk about games in general. Because that's the message that is being sent. When someone posts something, when someone says, "I just played Terraforming Mars.

I don't get what all the buzz is about. I did not like it at all." When your comment or when the flood of comments are overwhelmingly about how Terraforming Mars is incredibly popular, I don't know what you're missing. Even though you didn't like it, obviously it works for everyone else. When the comments are just about that, what you're effectively telling the person is that the the the acceptance of Terraforming Mars as a great game is more important than the acceptance of the experience that they had. And I think that's a shame. I think it's a shame in general anywhere you go in any capacity in any hobby. But I think board games in particular that in so many aspects are such a social such a social hobby. Uh solo gamers aside of course, but even then there's social communities. There's like there's going to be Facebook groups about solo gaming. It's still a communitydriven hobby. I think that's a time for people to be incredibly welcoming. That's a time for people to actually open the door to conversation and acceptance as opposed to simply telling them that they did something wrong.

The two main takeaways for me on this video and the reason I the whole thing I saw in the first place are number one and possibly less importantly here, but it's an interesting conversation separately is that we really genuinely always have a bias towards ourselves. It's subconscious. It makes sense. Why wouldn't we? But we think we're right more often. We give leniencies to ourselves. We give excuses to ourselves. We give grace to ourselves. There's so many things in life in which we give all of that to ourselves but not to others. Even in this exact example, when someone doesn't like a popular game and your first response is to think about the reasons that they're wrong, but how they did something wrong with the experience, think about the fact that are you applying that same thing to yourself? When you don't like a popular game, do you immediately run through the checklist of did I play it right? Was I playing with the wrong group? Should I play it again? Did I do something wrong?

All these things, any that play the wrong player count, was I having a bad day? Do you run through the gamut of all the checklists for yourself to make sure that your opinion is equally valid when you don't play a popular game? So, number one, we all have a bias towards ourselves. We should do our best to recognize it whenever possible. And number two, and more importantly, for the sake of this conversation and the space that we are in, the board gaming space should be a welcoming space. It should be a place where we are able to engage, communicate, talk to each other, share opinions, share our love for games, and also share those times that we bounced off hard in a game. And it's up to us and how we engage with every single person in this space that will define whether others do feel it is welcoming or not. Until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you enjoyed this video and as always I hope you have a good

Progress saved