What Chapter 2 cards impressed me in my first André and Miguel decks? (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)
Transcript
Hello everybody in YouTube land and welcome. Just today I finished up the Dark Matter playthrough that is currently on playing uh more playing board games which is our VOD and gameplay channel. If you have not subscribed to that, I would love if you could. It's we're trying to hit the 500 subs because uh then I can start, you know, become a YouTube partner, getting a bunch of perks and monetization and, you know, get support on those videos as well. You can find a link to it in the video description. In this one, I'm here to do a little roundup on these decks because, as I said, I finished that run. I had a great time. I ran it through Dark Matter because it's a great testing environment for both Miguel and Andre. And we're going to kind of be talking about these investigators, kind of my initial thoughts on them, the decks, and the new cards, and kind of just how they all function. So, why don't we start by talking about uh the investigators in specific. So, first, Andre Patel.
This guy uh legitimately could not be more of a rogue than how Andre Patel is. 2325. Very rogue stat line. As a reaction, if you succeeded a skill test by two or more during your turn, you may take an additional action this turn. Limit once per round. So, this ability is not at all exciting. like it's not anything that you go, "Wow, this is like such a cool little quirk that I'm able to really take advantage of in a way that is very unique and interesting." But what it really is is it's an ability that's kind of just completely open, right? It lets you do whatever you want to do with it. You can just kind of get whatever job you want to do with your deck and it just basically helps facilitate more to that. The only question it asks is, can you succeed by two or more, which realistically in the rogue class, whether it be in legacy or current or even just chapter 2, um is a very easy thing to say yes to. So, it kind of really just like helps all of the stuff happen that you want to be building the deck around. His signatures, I think, like his ability, um, are kind of just a little bit lackluster and they're kind of just trying to tell you that you should you can do anything with Andre Patel, right? Daniela Reyes, for example, says, "Hey, you are going to be fighting enemies. That's what you're going to be doing from the beginning of the scenario to the end of the scenario.
You're going to be worrying about that in deck building versus when you are taking apart your deck at the end of the campaign." But Andre Patel is kind of just like you can be who you want to be. You can you can be in whatever role that you want Andre to be in. So we have like the attacker evasion, we have the skill test on the scenario card, and we have the investigation or parlay, right? So not exactly like super flashy, but again, they're here and they get the job done. Andre's signature weakness uh is weight of the world. uh when you fail a skill test while weight of the world is in play, take one horror and shuffle it back into your deck. Lives in a very similar place to what um Lucius Galloway is where it's like you're going to be taking horror and it's going to be recurring itself. Andre does have eight horror. And while this thing did poke me for a few like horror throughout the campaign uh and ate some draws, the reality is is when I got fully set up and I had everything like all the pieces that I wanted in play, I kind of just stopped failing tests, which um really took the teeth out of Weight of the World. And I know there's a lot of like jokes about how like Marcus Sangst Stack is bad, but this is now the second Andre Patel deck that I've brought to either a campaign or a gameplay session. And on I I just like stopped failing tests because WellConnected is just an
incredibly powerful card. Like it kind of just like if you don't know what Well Connect is, let me just show you. This kind of just like gets the job done and like really just exactly get that gets that fantasy of Andre Patel where you just don't fail tests when you want to do this. And the crazy thing is my first Andre deck that I built was actually only built with chapter 2 cards and I still just like stopped failing because this is in we can see here this this is the Andre Patel deck. well connected is just here probably the strongest big money payoff even bigger than red clock in my opinion uh is this card here which kind of just says like hey why don't you just like not fail tests anymore and like that's like a pretty good place to be. Um overall I think Andre Patel is a powerful investigator with a lot of powerful cards from the new set but we'll talk into those in the future. Why don't we dive and talk quickly about Miguel de la Cruz the survivor 3234 you may take an additional action during your turn which can which may only be used to play an event elder sign effect plus one you may add a trick or trap card in your discard pal to your hand and he soaks for 88 so like Stella I think he has the same stat line as Stella uh he is a tank both like at all functions in the game whether it be defensively during the mythos phase
or when he is forced to take dam damage and or horror over the course of the game. Miguel de la Cruz is a very powerful uh investigator as well. I think that of the four of the five starter deck investigators, I would say like in the long run, I think Miguel has the foundation to be the strongest of the five. Survivor is in a exceptionally good place in the current state of the game and uh it's literally only going up from here in like the legacy format. In the current format, there's always going to be a form of like rotation which will [clears throat] keep the card pools I don't want to say stagnant cuz that's not the word. But like if if if Miguel gets a very powerful event that's because I mean we know what all the evergreen cards are, right? If Miguel gets a powerful event, it's eventually going to rotate out and then when you're playing in current, uh that's not going to exist. So like Miguel is going to potentially be busted but then like rotate out of that busted sort of behavior. However, uh legacy ain't going anywhere, right? So these cards always exist and this was a legacy focused Miguel deck. But you'll actually see that I actually have quite a few of the new cards kind of kicking in here.
And I mean, actually, the vast majority of this deck is new. Uh, which is, uh, a little bit spicy, which is a little bit spicy. Uh, Miguel's signatures. That's not I mean, Miguel's on the art, but that's not the Miguel I want to talk about. I want to talk about this one. Miguel's signature, the knapsack, is um, uh, you really feel the difference when it's in play versus when it's not in play. I wouldn't say it's required to be playable, right? Like I don't think that like Miguel without his knapsack is in a worse state than Miguel with his knapsack. I would say rather that when Miguel has his knapsack, you will notice the difference, right? Like your deck is just going to be smoother because you are drawing cards um more often, which means that like you're not running behind on the events that you have available to you. Um, there are some cool tricks to kind of like do this without the knapsack, but it's I think a very noticeable difference between the the the different sides of Miguel, whether he has the knapsack in play or not. Um, if you see this in your mulligan, you just keep it.
That's just my advice to you. It's it's a very noticeable difference between the two in terms of just the consistency that it provides. Uh, a very nice difference in comparison to Andre Patel where his signatures are a little bit lackluster in comparison. Feline Hybrid uh is Miguel's signature weakness. It's immune to player card effects. So that means you can't use weapons. You can't use events. Um you can use things like say for example vicious blow that increase damage but aren't dealing damage themselves. Uh but you can't use something like longot that does deal the damage itself. Don't come at me. I also don't like it. But you know that's just how it is. Um, I was a little bit scared of Feline Hybrid at first, but honestly, playing with Feline Hybrid, he's more of a nuisance than an actual threat. Uh, I kind of like him. I kind of like him.
You can also actually kind of game him um to trigger some of your uh traps that don't actually target enemies. For example, scrolling down here to um Hello. There we go. Scrolling down here to glassing. Right. After an enemy enters attached location, you can exhaust glassing, but because you're not targeting the uh feline hybrid with this, the feline hybrid is able to trigger glassing to get the job done. I really like feline hybrid. I think it's a fun signature weakness and I think it's always relevant and I think it kind of changes how you approach drawing cards with Miguel when it's happening during your turn. Miguel naturally wants to refill his hand while the backpack helps with that. If you don't have it, you want to find it in other ways. And the feline hybrid is kind of in theory a bomb for that. And I think that it works ultimately uh even though he is less threatening than he seems at first glance. I just love the elusive keyword in both for and against the players. I think it's a very fun word a keyword to play with and play against. Um okay.
So these were both sort of flexi decks. Um, with Andre leaning slightly more towards getting clues and Miguel leaning slightly more towards combat, I think what we should just do is we kind of should just like I I'll just kind of give like some initial thoughts here on all of the uh the the new player cards. Uh, as I mentioned, I think overall I'm very happy with both Miguel and Andre. I think they're fun to play. I think I'm going to look forward to building them in the future. Uh, I think that they both have good blanket abilities that unlike some of the previous investigators we've seen in the like the like the starter decks in the past. Um, they're good at like keeping you completely open, right? Whereas like say for example um I mean we go to Nat Cho who is very parasitic in his deck building and style of play especially regarding his investigator starter deck and like um Stella Clark who is kind of just like turned into you have to fail kind of like dot deck right where Miguel de la Cruz so like for example um think of how much more limiting he would be if his ability was you may take an additional action during your turn which may only used to play a trick or a trap event, right? Like that is restrictive. This ability is every event Miguel can look at and be like, am I going to cook with this? And I think that's the difference between a a great investigator to a merely good to underperforming investigator in my personal opinion. So, uh I'm not going to talk about how the
decks worked as a whole because they were successful. Um Dark Matter is an easier campaign. Again, I played it to kind of just like stress test the decks out. Uh, and overall it was uh a roar in success as I mentioned. You can go watch this on more playing board games. Long blow. Long bow is an alternative to the ornate bow is a very interesting thing. It functions very similar, right? Like we've had ornate bow since the forgotten age. So it's it gets the job done. We know what it does. We know it does it well. I like the addition of the survivor sort of class perk where uh you can ignore the yoof keyword. I think that's actually a very relevant line of text that makes this feel like something a neutral card shouldn't be doing. Neutral cards should in theory be something that every class can offer.
And I don't think every class should be able to have on their table the ability to fight aloof enemies. But I think that survivor it kind of makes sense, especially in the flavor for this card. Nothing too surprising with Longbow. It was it got the job done and uh it was it was good at at doing that. Daniel Jameson, I think this is a good ally, right? I think that he's he's nice and strong. Um, the plus one foot is nice. I like survivors leaning on that more than leaning on fist, which I think is really good. I like the text. After you fail an attack or evasion, you can attempt it again. Uh, this actually didn't happen too much. Turns out I'm apparently pretty good at Arkham and I build my decks to kind of just like not fail. And I think that Daniel Jameson is going to be an okay version of sort of a half a lucky in the long term. But I think that he's not really a lucky because you still have to fail the test.
And I think that this is like a much healthier version of the card than say for example I mean like Madame sorry uh Granny Orin costs 4 XP for 3 XP for the upgraded version, right? And she's very expensive. So he's obviously worse than that cuz this is a level zero card. But I think that in the long term uh the fact that you still have to fail the test means that like alert and retaliate are both things that this guy can't really deal with. But I think for a level zero ally, this is a fantastic choice for the survivor card pool, and he's going to do a really good job going forward. Uh, Hunter Instincts zero and two are banger cards. These are absolute bangers. Uh, anything that lets you recur things is is a something that you should pay attention to and notice. The level zero getting only level zero cards and the level two getting up to level two cards is is a very nice and healthy sort of like adjustment between the two cards. Um, I was mostly grabbing um Gorilla Tactics, uh, glassings, um, and like like that sort of thing.
Like I got like the e-cash 2 as well. This was kind of like the target for the whole thing. Uh, I think that like worst case scenario, Hunter Instinct grabbing emergency cash is not a bad place for Miguel de la Cruz to be because Miguel de la Cruz finds his emergency cashes fast, which is very good, very strong card. Loner is probably the strongest card I think in terms of how it's warped the game in a way that I when I first read this card I was like Pathfinder is good. Um this is kind of just like a Pathfinder with a different restriction and it's zero. It's sorry it's a two cost zero level card. I was like this is going to be good. I kind of overlooked the fact of how much the survivor class actually really relies on having the restriction of crunched movement. Like we look at like track shoes. This was one of the cards that survivors used to kind of crunch their movement and it was always kind of just blanket playable in the survivor class.
Compare track shoes to loner. This is actually like this is giving the survivors some action compression that I personally think now might have been a mistake to give them. Uh they were already really efficient, but this just upped their efficiency. There was a turn where I used loner to move a location and then used track shoes to move another location and I did not spend a single action in my turn and closed out two locations. And I was just kind of like this is not something that the survivor class should be doing. That seems very dangerous because they make up so much efficiency because they're lacking the action compression to do the basic things like economy, card draw, and movement, right? So, a little bit spooky there in the terms of loner. Uh, I think my favorite UK use case for loner was to play trapping on a location, leave that location, grab an enemy, exhaust loner to move back into the location with the glassing, assuming it's empty, which is not always the case, but is usually the case that you'll get some movement out of loner and then triggering the glassing and getting two clues, which is very powerful. And then like nuking it with the long bow. That was a very common gameplay loop that I did and it it it felt very good each time I did it.
Glassing is nuts. This card is nuts. Again, like there are a lot of just like really quiet things that the survivor class got really good here. Um, this allowing you to also use your foot I think is a little bit overlooked for just how versatile this card can be. I have never done this. I mean, I've only played this in two-player, but um the ability to like not discard it. I never did. I just always use this to get some like unex some like a like a a deduction out of a location. A few days ago on the channel, Daniel and I also talked about this video. Like so I'm kind of like beating a dead horse in this video in this week's videos where I talked about this on like Wednesday as well, but it just happened to be that both these campaigns finished at the same time and I both played I played Glassin and Loner, both of them to great effect.
Survivor card pool is kind of cracked at the clue compression and the movement compression now. It's it's kind of nuts. Gorilla Tactics. Um, good card. Uh, I like playing it fast, right? I like the uh it's it's I think it's just a good kill spell, right? Where you can fight or evade. You get to ping a thing. You may evade, um, target an enemy as if you were engaged with that enemy at another location. So, this works for aloof enemies at connecting locations, but not aloof enemies at your location. So, just a fun little like um thing to keep in mind for that because it says you may target an enemy in a connecting location as if you were engaged with that enemy. So the as if you were engaged is only was a connecting location, but I think this is a very nice kill spell option that I can see investigators outside of Miguel running this in the long term. I think Miguel is going to be the champion of gorilla tactics, but I think especially with Hunter Instinct and any other sort of like evade or fight or even event synergy, this card's going to really sing. Hidden Shelter has proven to be fine. I think it's a good level zero card. Uh if you get like two uses out of it, like two triggers for the team, uh that's really nice. It also scales with the number of players, right? So like uh two players doing this twice is not the same as four players doing this twice.
Like that's eight perks versus four perks. And like that's a pretty big payout comparison. But honestly, I think that Hidden Shelter overall um unless you're playing a support or Miguel de la Cruz is not going to last long in the long term for your decks. It's more it's it's it's good, but it's not great. And it kind of leans more towards the fine side of good. Uh, last new card here was the timely intervention. I also talked about this in the video with Daniel. You see, I fall into a very similar pattern here. Lucky threes and timely interventions. That's dangerous. Uh, in Legacy, and I know you could always say just like don't do it. And it is true. You as a player can just like not play these crazy combos. But I think for the sake of discussion and analysis, it's important to point out that these combos are very easy to do and they kind of just nullify a whole section of the game for the survivor class. And like normally that's okay if this was all survivor was doing, but with loner and glassing and hunter instinct and resourceful and do or die, and I wasn't even playing resourceful or do or die in this deck, um the survivor class can become a very dangerous thing.
On to Andre here. Um, this one had a lot less new cards, but we still tried out some new stuff here. I think Polish Kane or Pol I call it Polished Kane because I'm I'm freaked up and I I sometimes say cards with different names on purpose to entertain myself. Uh, but Polish Kane here uh was actually I think is a kind of a stunning card. Um, this is a card that um, surprised me in how good it was beyond the text, which already was kind of good. Something that I was not expecting when I play Polish Kane, and I have to see if this if it functions like this outside of Andre Patel, but this card was performing on the likes of a weapon that deals two damage. Uh, and I'm not even talking about like the exhaust. The exhaust is exhaust is really good, but like say for example, you are a rogue who can get four actions during a turn, which rogues can get four actions a turn pretty easily. Uh, and then they even get further compression with Olivier.
Uh, Polish cane is actually just like it performed as well as a regular weapon, which I was not expecting it to, but this card is actually kind of gas. I think that it's a quiet sleeper um to really be overperforming and I have my eyes on it for further play to see how it functions with other investigators. And I'm also kind of paying attention to see how often other players bring it to the table because I always use that as a metric to kind of determine how good a card is because people will play cards for multiple reasons. And yes, sometimes people play cards because they're bad, but people play cards most commonly because they're good and they're efficient. And I think that Polish cane might fall into that category.
Speaking of cards that are good and efficient, Lucky Sorry, no. I mean, yes, Lucky Cigarette Case 3, but I meant to click on Olivia Bishop. I just instinctively went to Lucky Cigarette Case 3. Um, this is the new um ally that is like the new hotness and it's good. It's very good. Um, again, Pathfinder is good. And Pathfinder was something that we were happy to pay 1 XP for and then it was taboo to be even more expensive and it was still just worth it. It's one of those things where I often would say in the past like just find the compression that is best for the deck and your play style and your goal, right? So like you don't need to feel inclined to play deduction if you're finding your compression for clues somewhere else. You don't need to save on movement if you have compression in other places to put you advantage over the move actions you're taking. However, at this point now, it's kind of just one of those things where um it's like a perfect death by a thousand cuts where you can do everything competently. So, the game just can't really keep up for it in the legacy card pool, which again is by design, but as part of my analysis and my like my learning experience of playing these decks, Olivier is something that is kind of like he's raising that flag of being like, I am the reason why this class has become so efficient suddenly and why you can get by with playing polish cane, a card that just deals one damage, but it feels like it's performing at a H rate that's
dealing like like a two or two or three experience weapon, which is kind of crazy because like individually um if one of these cards were released, it probably would be fine. But I think when you start adding all this stuff together, it's really kind of creating like a perfect storm of just like incremental value, which is a good way for you to maybe not require compression even though Olivia is compression. Um, it's just like it's it's like if is there's so much compression in your cards that in Legacy you can put it together. If everything's doing it, every action you take, you're kind of just like sneaking ahead on the game slightly. And this guy just giving you compression for movement. Same with loner. It's a very, very juicy thing. All right. I also tried out I just tried out cards here, right? Because this was about like testing and see how they functioned. I wanted to try grapevine out because I was intrigued by this card. Like it doesn't read great. Um but I wanted to know how it actually like kind of functioned. So spend an spend one rumor and exhaust it to parlay. Choose an enemy and reveal location up to three connections away. Move one location at a time along the shortest path to that enemy's location and engaged it. Draw one card. I used this to good effect a few times where I was able to compress on my movement and draw cards, but I think what ultimately brings this card down is yes, the action to play it is something, but just that the movement compression is already so good that I didn't really need like movement compression on top of my
movement compression. One thing I did enjoy about the grapevine was that it actually was really good for aloof enemies. So, like if I'm going into a campaign that I know there's going to be a lot of whipperwills or aloof enemies that I need to spend actions to engage in, like to engage, I'll I'd consider running a grapevine maybe just as a one of because it'll if I'm able to even just draw a card and engage a whipper wheel then hit it with my cane, I'm considering that like a win in terms of my compression. And again, this is just another example about how everything sort of adds up. And if I'm able to like move into a location with a whipperwheel, engage it, draw one card, then kill it with a cane, like that's just some insane value, right? Like there's a lot of different things that again, all these cards just slowly add up in Legacy. And it's like in current and smaller card pools and like limited, which I imagine Travis Burn and I are going to play quite a bit more of in the future. It's harder to find this value out of every single card that you have.
But um it's like it these cards would perform differently there cuz I do think that this card is actually like legit. I think all the text on this card is good and the compression is there. It's just a matter of um can it compete with other forms of similar movement compression. Sudden fall didn't really do too much for me. Um, I did like the upgraded version with the Polished cane like when they were there together and they kind of like sung like a really good sort of like duet like in tandem, right? Like I would hit with the cane, exhaust the guy and then use the sudden fall to deal four like four damage total and it worked really well. it was a little bit awkward where sometimes like again I think that this card would be better if I was like dealing with a more specific sort of mono fighter like because then you're kind of more zoned in on that but there were a lot of times where it was just like less tests for Miguel to kill the guy so it ultimately meant like I was hardressed as as um Andre to take the time to play sudden fall. However, when big enemies were there this worked out very well.
Uh, last two cards here. Oh, no. Yeah, no. No. I talk about out the door as well. Last two events. Quick exit. I tried it out. I don't know. I don't think so. Um, I never even got to the upgraded version. Um, this card doesn't really sing to me. Um, I don't really have anything good to say it. It kind of just like stayed in the deck because I cut other things. Like I had like the uh the book one in here, which I think might kind of be unplayable. Um, but this one is definitely, I think, on the lower end of power, at least for me personally. A card that impressed me in the early part of the campaign, but less so in the late part of the campaign, was right under their noses. Um, I think that when it's able to work, it works really well. I think there are a lot of pieces of movement in the form of like Olivier that you're able to make it work, but I think for 3xP you want it to be consistent. I was again very impressed by this in the earlier ones, but I think also just like Miguel became better at grabbing clues in the long run, returning the glassings that maybe this card functioned a little bit less because I was two flexes. And I think a card like right under their noses and even a sudden fall would do better if I was more focused with my roles. So, I'm curious to give it a shot. But, I was very impressed by this card. I think it's legitimately great. I'd probably give like a 3.5 out of five, right? I think it's a great card. Um, but I was curious to know I'm curious to know why
I felt like it lost its value later in the campaign compared to the earlier part. So, I mean, like, there were still enemies, there were still clues, I was still evading. Like, maybe my clue gain was just getting better. I'm not too sure. And then the last new card here is out the door. I don't want to beat a dead horse too much. I was talking about a bunch about this one last week. This is an insane card. I think this is one of the strongest cards they've printed in a long time. Like I think this card is a five in terms of power, a five out of five. It's a staple. If you have this in your class, you kind of have to be like uh you kind of have to be um find a reason not to play it. I um have found myself actually cutting my Fouian bargains for out the doors. Uh like I was playing a deck recording today. It was a Lucius deck and I was like, "My economy is really good that I'm just committing my Foustium bargains. What's making my economy so good?" Like, why why am I just getting resources out the wazoo? And then I was like, oh yeah, it's this out the door, right? I pair this out the door with an evasion action. I get a clue, maybe draw a card and gain a resource off my pick pocketing. And I'm also just getting four resources on top of that while doing all these other things. The card just represents an insane amount of value. Um, insane card. Insane card. I don't have much more to say than than that. Those are my thoughts on Andre and Miguel and some of these new player cards after my first run of them through Dark Matter. I'm going to be starting another campaign soon. I actually am running the a forhanded solo which I'm
very excited to do with uh four of the remaining investigators that I've yet to play from chapter 2. So maybe I'll share my thoughts on them there. But I think Brethren of Ash might not give me a full picture like a a six or eight. um campaign will like in the form of Scarlet Keys Hemlock versus you know a traditional eight campaign from the past. But I'll definitely keep them up if you want to see the that these kind of discussions in the future. Uh if you do let me know. Uh again, I always make my content based on what you guys say you're most interested in and also of course what I find fun and I enjoy talking about Arkham so I'd gladly do it again. In the meantime, thanks for watching everybody. If you want to support the channel, like, comment, subscribe, or if you want to go above and beyond, you can become a YouTube member or a Patreon member. All the links are down in the video description or on the YouTube page itself. In the meantime, thanks for watching. Go sub to more Playing Board Games as well. Again, I would really appreciate it. Have a good one and as always, a GG's.