Deception: Murder In Hong Kong Board Game Review & Runthrough
Transcript
i think i've got a lead on the place you need to send some back up this could be what we need to crack that case shell casings i better bag this one for the lab else can i find around here blood no just catch up there are so many questions with no answers sergeant this is detective sue better get the forensic investigators up here quick i think i've located another body
deception murdering hong kong is a social deduction game where players take on the role of police investigators as they try to piece the key evidence together in order to solve a crime there's a little twist to this story however and that is one of the police investigators is the murderer so it's a race between the police officers to see if they can resolve the murder capture the murder and arrest him or whether the murderer can deceive their way out and escape before being captured deception murder in hong kong is designed by toby ho it's for four to twelve plays it's published by grayfox games it's a party game and it plays within 20 minutes the main driving force of this game that really makes this exciting is the fact that plays take on important roles as part of this murder investigation if a player is the forensic scientist they're responsible for giving the other players the clues that will help them solve the murder the forensic scientist gives out clues by using scene tiles then allow not allowed to speak or use body gestures the player is the investigator they're responsible for helping to solve the crime they need to identify the key evidence and the means for the murder that the murderer has identified at the beginning of the game the murderer is responsible for deceiving the other players and leading them down false leads if they can do so over three rounds they can win the game the accomplice just helps the murderer to complete their task without being caught the witness is someone who knows who the murderer and the accomplice are but the
murder and the accomplice do not know who they are if the murder and the accomplice are caught before the end of the third round if they can identify the witness then they end up winning the game and everyone else loses what you would essentially do is you take the number of roles equal to the number of players so make sure if it's more than six players you decide whether to use the uh accomplice and witness roles or whether you're just going to use investigator roles for less than six players you use just the investigative murderer and forensic scientist role so once you've shuffled them and dealed out one per player then everyone closes their eyes the forensic scientist knows who the murderer is murderer opens their eyes and tells the forensic scientist by pointing to the means and the key evidence that the other players will need to guess then uh they close their eyes and everyone clippings their eyes and then the game begins so in a typical round of play the forensic scientists would place the cause of death card and the location of crime card at the beginning of the first round and you can see that on each of the cards there are six different choices and these are the sorts of clues that the forensic scientists can actually give during a round of play the forensic signers also takes all the orange cards shuffles them around and then places them randomly in front of them remember the forensic scientist is the only person apart from the murderer who knows the solution they know what the key evidence is so let's say it's the insect and what the means of murder is for
example dirty water the forensic scientists would then use the bullets to progressively give clues to the investigators to help them solve the crime so it might say for example illness disease and then they would let the investigators deliberate over uh what they think could be the connection and obviously the murder will be trying to sway them away once the forensic scientist is happy they might place the next one down so it might be in a hospital and then that will then lead further discussion and you keep doing this until all six bullets have been placed on and i'm just doing this randomly every player would get a chance to put forward their argument about what they think the key evidence is and what the means is and you would do this over three rounds and if by the final round no one has guessed the key evidence or means of murder the murderer wins now when a player wants to make a guess they declare they're making a guess and this can happen at any time they hand in their badge and they can only make one guess i think i've cracked this case the key evidence that i've chosen is a leaf and the means of murder is unarmed when you put the two together you get an unarmed leaf so once the badge is gone they can't make further guesses they can help other people make a guess after looking at the evidence it's quite obvious that she's guilty now keep in mind that the murderer also has a badge as well so they might make a false claim to mislead the other players or to
show that they are in support of the other players what i really admire about the game is the fact that it's very simple to teach very fast to play and very quick to set up so that means getting into the nitty-gritty part of the game especially at the larger play account is very efficient and it works so well like a well-oiled machine i like the fact that it takes those deductive elements from mysterium and pluto and puts it into a much shorter time frame that's much quicker and more efficient and i like how it's got that very party themed uh feel about it whilst allowing people to take on their you know party roles what i do like is that if you are the forensic scientist you don't have to rely on creating uh your own clues if you've ever played the game code names the spy masters often get stuck by creating you know the most difficult combos possible and it's really hard and you tend to have really big gaps whereas in this game you the forensic scientist simply takes the bullet places it on the scene tile and then waits for everyone to discuss the clue that they've actually placed which i really like because it allows the forensic sciences to try and lead the investigators down the right track while you've got that mix going on you've also got the murderer who's trying to divert and misdirect the plays and lead them down the wrong track so i like how there's that to and fro and it really does come down to the creativeness of the group in that respect i like how the
combination of key evidence and the means go together there's hundreds of different possibilities and the way that the murderer needs to be creative about how they can connect uh the means of murder and the evidence together can be quite interesting and also quite humorous for example you've got sulfuric acid and you've got an insect trying to link them together that's an interesting story in itself so what i really think shines is the fact that this game gives an opportunity for every player to present their case so at the end of each round the investigators need to present what they think the key evidence is and what the means of murder is and they also have to explain why and there's no backseat play because everyone has their chance to speak there are some limitations to the game including the fact that when the forensic investigator draws their scene tiles especially in the late game they can be a little bit restricted with the types of clues they can provide to the police investigators sometimes they're forced to choose between a lot of bad choices and this can mislead the investigators down the wrong path and do so unintentionally the box is somewhat deceptive when you look at it in the shop it kind of has this impression that is quite a large game and i've said that the components are fantastic but it's a little bit deceiving in terms of the quality of the length of the game and the depth of the game i mean i paid 80 dollars for this game but i can see there are other social
deduction games which are short fast and play just as well for half the price and i think um if you like the theme it's definitely worth getting it but if you're short on cash there are other games which do the same thing trying to match the thematic and logical link between the key evidence and the means so linking for example an apple to the means of unarmed is going to be quite tricky and doesn't always make thematic sense so i guess it does come down to creativity as to how you're going to explain this to the other players but i can see that this kind of is a hurdle to get over if you're really worried about you know theme so you're trying to tell me that the key evidence we've got here is the lunch box and the means of murder is he was pushed was he pushed on to the lunchbox or was the lunchbox pushed on to him in considering my final verdict i think deception murder in hong kong is a fun fast light game that really has that excellent thematic feel you feel like your investigator is investigating a murder you feel like you're taking on the rolls um however the price point for this game is a little bit steep and for the fact that there are other games in the same social deduction category that do the same thing for a much cheaper price a lot of people opt for those smaller games however if you've got extra change and you like the theme as much as i do then it's well worth the investment
and takes a worthy place on your shelf so buy if you like social deduction games don't buy if you don't have enough money to buy it or you've got other games that you want to invest money into um otherwise thank you for joining me for another board game review this is danny signing out and i will see you again soon if you like my video please subscribe bye