Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dan Bullock on the Question of "Wargames"

Transcript 57:22

all right I think we're live if there's if there's someone out there you should tell us that we're that we're live what kind of embarrassing things can we say in this like moment before we're not you know in the moment before I think we should be talking about how um the definition of a word game should be broadened to include include munchkin but yes we exclude everything else it should really just be 100 munchkin all the time it was like the high water mark for the design yes that's why Jim dunigan got out of the game could never top munchkin he's like I'm out sick of it I'm done yes munchkin the ultimate the ultimate war game yes absolutely of course um the continuation of policy by another another means or something uh yeah oh man hey we're getting comments we must be live oh Alex and Alex Alex Knight in Alexandra are both here I know both of these Alex's yes our favorite Alex is even I have no way of knowing for sure I've never taken any kind of a census but I have a feeling I know most Alex's I think at this point now two-thirds of the Alex's I'm gonna say I know them or I've been acquainted with them Alex is unite indeed all right so now that we are here with y'all still very happy um we are I'm Liz Davidson I'm from Beyond Solitaire and I am here with uh

my buddy Dan Bullock who's the designer of several of War historical games that we're gonna talk about um and we are here to discuss the definition of a war game which has been sort of a Hot Topic in in recent weeks and so obviously we're just gonna capitalize on like the sleazy content creators we are or at least that I am yeah no I um I was just too I liked the points like you made all these great insightful points in your essay I read the uh Rocky Mountain Navy essay on armchairun dragoons I read Kevin Bertram's essay and I was like I am so lazy I'm not gonna write an essay I'm too busy with work which I'm neglecting right now and then all with the games design projects which I'm also neglecting right now um but I was like it would be way better to just stream with Liz and talk my way through kind of an essay like ate some rough essay-ish things without having to formally write anything um if only I had that foresight in college things might have ended differently oh man so um yeah just to kind of background this I think most people who are here here have already been interested in this topic but if you're if you're watching the stream in the future um you should know that we have been collectively I wouldn't say fighting discussing the definition of war game and uh kind of the spur for this particular round of this eternal conversation uh was the golden geek awards for this year in which votes for

women was the second runner-up so it's basically third place but third best war game of the year uh and then there were tons of threads asking well is that even a war game why would you call it a war game and so we've just all been having discourse about it I think discourse is the right word wouldn't you say Dan yes it was discourse there was no threat of violence it wasn't a discourse between states so I couldn't Define this this conversation per se as being a war game apparently um but if if it were a war game then I would wonder what period it falls under and I'm guessing that it would be modern right pretty modern uh absolutely although I mean I'm sure there's some people who are still at the gunpowder period having this conversation I have a lot of I have at least one pre-gun powder um conversation a week I would say um but it's not up for nomination so there's no way to be certain so when we talk about war games yes typically we talk about things as war games that we give them sort of time periods so is it a pollyonic war game is it an ancient war game is it gunpowder but not Napoleonic is it um early modern is it modern is it Civil War uh but I think what's happening is that these definitions and categories are no longer really covering I guess what's happening on our end of Gaming and that that's I think we're the interesting conversation is yeah because we you know all these all these insightful essays talking about what is

a war game and then they put forth their own definitions um but it's it's kind of not to just run past it but it is a little bit more interesting who wants to know what a war game is like I feel like that's the question I'm a little more interested in because the the motives for trying to to get get that definition and getting that label to stick to a lot of things um seem to be kind of Guided by two things I think one is um a means of kind of protecting folks rallying around what they see is a their little corner of a hobby that doesn't really get as much recognition as the games in the larger Hobby for a variety of reasons that might not be the most productive thing to keep it secluded off but what do I know I've just watched symphonic music basically lose all relevance in my lifetime I have no idea maybe there's something to this like weird subscriber mechanic that doesn't really work out um but then there's a secondary thing which is also um if we basically like buy kind of like creating this more open definition of what a war game is are we basically just offering up games to uh an audience that's going to be especially hostile to them because they aren't aren't war games right they're not worry enough they're not conflict oriented enough and then as a result there's just going to be a bunch of one ratings and you know I

know some of these Alex's have had a lot of bad experiences with getting one ratings on games from people who haven't even played their game it's ridiculous right but they're just so divisive they just have to have to just you know poke people in the eye with a game that's you know just reason questions about a certain period of history but um doesn't have the decency to have like hexes and counters and you know all the stuff that people have come to expect from a war game they're downright political about it you know this leads to I guess I guess of the matter right which is so when we talk about War I think there are a lot of people who want to say oh you know a war game has to have pp's in it basically whereas my hexes where the tanks where are the bombs first of all I professional War Gamers do not see it that way like a professional War gamer could very casually have a conversation about wargaming a pandemic a professional War gamer could have a conversation about having a war game where the war never starts because you use diplomacy to fend It Off and so I think that we're outside of what kind of like the the professional lingo is but I also think that we are reaching a problem where games that are naturally grouped with war games but aren't about war fit better with war games than they do with kind of like the mainstream of themes but War Games is not a big enough

category to let them in and so they're in a weird spot but also that's where the most growth in our sector of the hobby is happening so I'm gonna put up arna's comment here I wonder if it would be more productive just push for some other terms and categories that try to then try to change people's minds and term war games we can expand it but it's going to always Clash a bit like I don't actually think that that's wrong I think that this comment there's a lot of Truth to that I think the problem is that for example um what's the game like Annabelle Holland's endurance it's about the Shackleton Expedition it's games as history games as art there's certainly no war in it I mean you're just killing some penguins and feeling depressed about it I don't really think that qualifies um but that game fits better when you're thinking about what are the games I can have a cross conversation about you know Annabelle makes war games and her other games are categorized I think more easily when they're historical pieces like with more games and with games that are like the ones that you're making with games like um you know Laden Freedom which you know we've been joking with Alex about I think the problem is that when you're categorizing the games War isn't cutting it necessarily anymore because it's more natural to put historical commentary games with war games than it is to put them with like wingspan yes well it's a short short answer yes yes it does make more sense to kind of

partner them together I think that the the goal so first off trying to just to go back to um in terms of how professional War gaming sort of defines war game I think you are correct in terms of now that is how it's defined it's a much broader definition um if we even went back to like 2002 looking at Philip sabin's work a little bit and how he defines like a war game like a little bit but it's probably still going to emphasize like no military conflict a bit and then if we in a weird way it's it's just kind of all like the plot points you know if you go far enough back you'll definitely find much more emphasis on Military conflict but it's kind of interesting to me that like uh Jim dunagan's definition in 1980 which um Rocky put in his essay I just love it it's it's so pithy and great uh he says a war game is a combination of game history and science it is a paper time machine basically it's glorified chess all right so first Salvo fired second was second part of his definition is award game is a playable simulation a conflict simulation is another way another name for war game one that leaves out the two unsavory terms were in game he has a broader definition of this than some of our some of our colleagues on our various nominated committees rewards I think he has what that entails in part because he was you know a Visionary designer um I mean he's he made he's made games

that within his own time like that challenged kind of how we conceive of board games how we can see the historical game I mean he was fit to take have you ever seen um the plateau assassinate Hitler like this old magazine game it's like it's got hexes but they're not it's not like a geographical map really it's more of an idea map and it's about getting your your kind of spies or conspirators close enough into these different spheres of influence to get close enough to pop Hitler made him but his his inspiration for the this this type of map and the mechanisms for the game was from a game called um scrimmage and I think it was for football he wouldn't make a game about profession professional football and he used a lot of the same mechanisms in it so I'm just saying Jim knew it's like it's it's just like a lot broader and more interesting than all that it's really not that siled of a thing um but I think that in terms of those definitions it is interesting to see how we've broadened our definition of it um within the I say we like I'm a professional you know like word game or game designer you know like some instructions but I do think that like um if you were to ask like um you know Natalia butowitz or some somebody like about that like they're gonna basically be in line with what you're saying like it's it's about a lot of different types of conflict not all

of them are going to emphasize military some of them present different types of security questions or threats um but it is a broadening definition I don't know that the audience seems is that about it and necessarily has broadened their definition quite as fast but I think that the influx of new people and like younger designers not even the younger designers I just think in general like just like new people coming to the Hobby who may have been brought into wargaming from like a Twilight Struggle or votes for women or even a wingspan I think those folks have a different sense of what war gaming can encapsulate and entail and I think that that's the challenge right now within that within trying to find um the usefulness of that label is it applies to like some of these games yeah I think we're also having like a cross conversation I think that you and I tend to want to view War Games as games that are trying to say something about a historical or like theoretical but still historical conflict if that makes sense something political something social at the same time I think for some people wargaming is more about which mechanisms you're using which is how you end up with the cult of the hex and um it's also how you I think want to include maybe like a science fiction game that uses war game e mechanisms and like call that a war game but it's science fiction and actually don't know if that's as natural appearing as war games and historical games for me

because I mean at that point at what point is it if you fight in it it's a war game yeah it I think um to me it's a little bit more of a stretch personally too it's kind of weird though because you have games like say space Empires for example you're just like we're looking at a hex map we've got little chits there's like a little technology tree but we see crds we see these things they all look very familiar to a wargamer but to me it's like yeah that's not really why I got into gaming was to play this but then conversely there's elements of something like you know folks playing like Republic of Rome or John company and it's like you know what this is why I got historical gaming this is the kind of thing that I'm interested in seeing more of and it's um it kind of adds like all these layers to the sort of ways we can represent Conflict at a table and also trying to be able to teach history but yeah to your point I think you're totally right in terms of um this sense of both how that natural partnership sort of occurs like between these two things I think that might actually be a generational split a little bit I think yeah I think I like my space games because I like my space games I just like space going there killing there dying their space it's fine I like it but it's so divorced from all the historical gaming I do and why I would play that and what I'm looking for in it like I would never read a 40 page playbook for a Sci-Fi game on just like the backstory behind a

bunch of races that don't really exist and things like that then I rather just read a novel and I'm kind of fine with it but yeah this actually kind of leads to a natural uh comment show here so uh Lenny Kim tedious uh wants to know would you consider root a war game or does it have to be historical setting I mean I I think it's it's pretty War gamey to me like I think that the the mechanism it just seems so coin to me like it just feels very very coin yeah it is very cool at the same time at the same time this is very much like is a hot dog a sandwich right like foreign if I said I wanted to play a war game tonight and you brought root over I'd be like what does that make sense like I completely see why people put it in an organ category and mechanically if we're if it's a mechanical definition then yes right but I never say man I feel like playing a board game tonight I think I'm gonna get out rude does that make sense I'll say oh I want to play like an asymmetrical game let me get out rude it makes sense I I think at the same time um this is where you kind of you're talking about how within the natural what people would Define as a war game there's a lot of edge cases and things that certain corners of the audience would be like no not that and others will kind of accept like um I think a lot of a lot of people I play with would probably classify Churchill as a war game despite the fact that like Mark

Herman doesn't consider Churchill war game and some other War Gamers would probably not consider Churchill war game but because of its the relationship it has with war that there's a theater that is sort of like the measurement for what gets accomplished within you know these conferences it feels kind of inseparable it just isn't it doesn't rely that much on word game mechanisms and I don't I think there's something to the point of a lot of how we define whether or not something's a war game it's seemingly very heavy on either the history it's Fidelity to a historical setting or it's basically the mechanisms it's trying to incorporate if those mechanisms are familiar within other war games that people play it's a little bit easier for it to get grandfathered in but if they are really alien and Innovative and super cool then it's just a little easier to be like that not so much like I don't really like that which is a long-winded way of saying if you want to exclude anything there's always some means of doing it like you can always exclude anything you just have to change you raising All Over the Bar as people are trying to enter that's it's simple as that right actually do you want to return to that because I think it's a really good point but first I want to ask do you consider your games to be War Games why or why not and then if it's a no what do you think they are I don't um it's funny I so I've designed war games they're not published um but I think that I definitely make a distinction between those games and

um something like no motherland without or 1979 that being said I do I really do like the conflict simulation tag it's not going to fit everything that well anyways I'm actually interested in a lot of historical games and kind of that Frontier of gaming that wouldn't be well defined as that either you know I mean like I I think that some of these games are that are going to be pushing the boundaries within historical gaming are gonna make that tag also kind of useless like in a short amount of time so even if we just Kick the Can like just a couple more feet ahead of us that's going to be great for like the votes for women for this guilty land for games like that but it'll quickly end up getting outmoded by somebody who just wants to make a game about 18th century fashion and then that's gonna suck because I want to play that game and I want that to get recognition and I want that to find its audience but that's not going to be a like broadening war game to include my you know imaginary fashion game isn't really going to help War gamers have a broadening appreciation for yeah games outside of that I think most of those people who play War Games already play other historical games the thing that they don't want to do is they're sticklers for how these basically like sharing the distinction of like a war game with another kind of historical game um but the problem is that when you are sort of keeping those titles out of your little corner of the hobby it just really looks like you're closing the

door to things like diversity of ideas diversity in terms of designers and broadening the scope of what a historical game can mean and I think in actuality it's more than it's just like yeah but it's not a war game though it's like really the extent of the argument even if we just don't all share you know a definition of what that is yeah um it just so happens that it upholds a certain hierarchy that is that makes the hobby continue to look the way it has looked for the past like 20 years which is why you and I like wrinkle our noses at it yes yes so Russ from cardboard conflict says how do you compare this to talks like in music is this hard rock or metal I think there's a problem with humans that I need to put things in buckets so I actually think that for the most part so I say this as a ghost fan let's just say that's a constant question laughs are they metal or not some people will tell you very vociferously no but they win metal Awards all the time and actually I think that is where it comes in you know this this distinction really doesn't matter outside of awards nominations and kind of internal Declarations of status and like being a real one within our community does that make sense yes I I 100 agree I I don't I don't know I mean I think the real one thing is a is a little bit less but the awards thing I think I think that is exactly

right yeah well I do think that so one thing that uh volco said on Twitter when I mentioned this topic that was very interesting was oh well you know are you sure you want people to think something is a war game because what if that intimidates people and kind of scares them off and I think that that is actually threaded into this conversation in a way that it's hard to pick out but I do suspect that there's a certain amount of intellectual posturing about a real war game being about a real topic and being about real and I'm not saying that people would say like oh first woman isn't about Real History because I think anybody would acknowledge it is right but there's a certain I want to keep this box separate and I don't know why exactly that is but a lot of people who are very interested in the preservation of that box are also interested in preserving other social boundaries in which I have no interest at all right no exactly do you think do you think do you think part of it might have something to do with there's a sense that some historical designers and Publishers have that what they put forward is especially with war games like with the the very you know military forward kind of you know conflict-oriented games is that the games that they've made are researched and they feel like those games are actually apolitical they're just reporting facts they have a bias they don't make a statement and when you have a game like say Joseph Kelly's Molly house their game is

not like that it's just it it it's pouring forth something else and because it's also not because it's a queer game the immediate assumption is that well that's a political game like I don't want to play a political game I don't want to think about politics when I'm playing a historical game to which I mean is a historical designer I just think it's like you're insane all these are they all have a bias inheritance um there's just the ones that own their bias and understand where it comes from and others that don't really understand um I guess fundamentally how anything works I guess would be written words like you know like if if I made a game about the Philippine Insurrection for example but I only consult English sources in those translated to English despite my intentions are like you know like it doesn't matter like I have a bias now because there's so much so many viewpoints that aren't going to be incorporated into my design they can't be because of my limited focus and the scope of what I'm willing to bring into that game and I think that there's it's not always going to be something that's with malice and like like a kind of like ulterior motives that we are trying to put some sort of bias and you know kind of push people I just think that the bias it's kind of foolish to not recognize that it's there and even when we're choosing player roles and you know Victory objectives we've immediately decided this is important these other things are going to be abstracted away and those things require

a certain level of bias and we think that we're who are informed to decide which of these things should be highlighted and which things should be obviated but I mean it's still a choice right and not everyone's going to agree with that choice um but I think that when we're talking about the political games versus the war Games part of that is that you know some folks think that they can make hypothetically let's say uh uh an apolitical game about being president of the United States and that seems impossible like it's just not possible like you just can't yeah yeah so just kind of catch up on our since I want to give attention to our comforters while they're all here with us so the pink Phantom says that to them war is closer to military than history so Morgan needs military conflict but historical content is optional so I think that this is a I mean this is certainly a Viewpoint that a lot of people have I will say that I think that war is so much more complex than that because there are so many historical factors that lead to a war and there's so many issues of supply and weaponry and everything that have historical underpinnings I just don't really think they can be fully separated like I don't think that you can pull War out from history or from politics partially for the reasons that you were talking about and partially because of just true like situational factors that lead to Wars turning out the way they do yeah I also think the war being closer to military than history there's a reason why there's an aversion toward

coverage of wars that are part of more recent history right yeah because then it he's closer to politics like we understand it's politics and it's not that you know there's not that there's not a very political way to say cover you know this the American Civil War it's just more that it's it would be less divisive than trying to make a game about the war in the war in Ukraine or U.S Afghan war or something along those lines those would be really really tough and I think that that's why we see certain subject matter get done to I mean I don't know if I'm allowed to cuss over over this yeah it will be fine but they're like they've done bulge to [ __ ] death like just death and I get it like I understand that at this point now everyone wants to do their own cover version that's that's cool I love this that can we just change what we're covering can we just cover a different song because to me it's like they're covering like American Pie or something and I just like I'm I'm like just I cannot deal with it anymore it's just too many too many covers of the same song so I just want to repertoire to change like every 10 years or just pick something different do something else it could be another bad song we could do Billy Joel's piano man we just there's any number of bad songs we can just we can try to do our own rendition of so find a new bulge to cover something hover your bulge everyone cover your bulge everyone

um so Rod humble um wants to play the 18th century fashion game now I do too actually uh and it has a good comment that you know he regards texting counter games as not real war games it's mini rules in in his mind which is funny because I actually often hear miniature games referred to as war games and depending on who you're talking to they do not understand War Games as we understand it at all and they think that you mean like for you that you mean like Warhammer and then they get really disappointed when you don't mean Warhammer yeah it is disappointing I understand we are we are so disappointing yeah I understand I um I basically only I've only ever played like there's more games probably because I don't have like any rulers or measuring tape I just have no means of I don't I didn't have the basement space I was a renter for such a long time you know you just can't can't be having all that Warhammer crap

really good at made the term a sense of community identity I do think there's something to that because people are still hearkening back to the olden days The Glory Days of wargaming and they usually mean these games specifically this publisher you know Avalon Hill is like has Mythic proportions yeah at this point it it actually it's interesting too when you see how many ways it's influenced the the present hobby like in sometimes in small ways sometimes in larger ways some things it's just like what people would would shape is the box like what size is the Box what did people make their boxes look like other things are like what what games they view as Classics and then how they try to reincorporate those things decades after certain mechanisms are actually fashionable or really gives but I mean I think about that a lot you know the you'll get the whirly gig boxes for like Pax from your John company and stuff like that yeah I feel like it's got that sort of like book bookshelf oh yeah like they're totally going for it and um but it's just like it's it's infected all of our brains we all think about old things like this all the time it's just like a sense of like this is what I want this to look like this this looks right to me because that's that's the whole point right when you get your game published it needs to look like the other games you've got on your shelf that you grew up looking at and finally wishing oh one day I'll be a designer I wonder what my game will look like then you try to do that yeah I mean

I'm a classicist so you know I like the old things uh there are several comments in here about bulges that we will politely do uh Kevin burcham's Fashion Is War which I actually took me yeah but I I want to see like a predator like um mini Edition like I think that'd be really great oh my God but with like a line of sight Incorporated so uh Costa zafaropoulos says it is impossible to abstract something without bias I do think that that is true because however you're choosing to cut down reality you've chosen which parts to keep which parts to toss and which parts to make look Loom larger than others yeah I just I think that that's accurate I agree even when you're even when what you're trying to abstract is just complexity yeah there's still a bias toward simplicity so I guess yeah I also think that there's like a constant kind of battle among even the things that everybody accepts as war games right like is it crummy enough what is Chrome should we have enough detail in it like you know do we need to get down to All the Right exact types of tanks and all the exact right types of missiles versus you know can you do something that's more like resist which is a very popular game last year where you know you're basically stacking numbers with special powers but it represents resistance to fascism

yeah that was like one of my two favorite historical games last year it was resist and then Salerno 43. and the distance between these two games feels like a [ __ ] football field but I love them both I enjoyed them a great deal and I thought about them a lot after playing them like a long time afterward um but I think um the way like the humanity of resist and how it portrays these individual like individual resistance Fighters as people with a profession and then when they step out you know I mean and they actually basically are um outed as resistance Fighters as part of the Maki um they are kind of quickly snuffed out right they're like just these little Flames get extinguished right away but to some powerful effect but it was just really neat to see these two sides of these people they kind of feel like a little bit lived in despite the fact it's just one card with like two divided into two pieces right or two sides um and then even the way that missions were kind of laid out where you depending on the order and sequence of play you'd see you'd see not just the variability but it kind of told a story and it told a different story every time you played it yeah um and it had the flexibility of the campaign or the one-off I just thought that that team did an amazing job but that game um and everything from the art like everything just reinforced yes kind of

the humanity of that story and it was a really interesting way to view um resistance and like depict it within a game um so I thought that was really cool but is it a war game actually you know what's really funny is that I thought that votes for women was more of a shoe and for Morgan than resist and I think that that actually has a lot to do with my biases I just want to point out that chaos kids would like to tell us that war is fashionable too it works both ways yeah that's the attraction we almost have toward napoleonics I think they just like the snappy dress you know like the clothing is just a little more Choice yeah you gotta have the Good Hat yeah yeah there's not enough games with tricorn hat wearing I mean yeah if you put them in space I feel like it would really would really give give people things to think about when they're reading the Playbook you know all the cat people they're wearing they're wearing tricorn hats in space I'm going to read a little more about these guys I wonder what they're up to you know I'm I'm all for it that's funny so but I do want to come back around so I think that we all have to know where our own biases are coming from and like you know I think that a lot of how we want to Define more gaming comes from what we want from wargaming as people as Gamers as commentators so for me when I'm playing a game and like actually I thought that what you said about resist was great because I think it brings out why resist counts does that make sense but for me I'm always looking for what is this game trying to tell me what's it trying to

say what kind of statement is it making and do I think it does a good job and so that means that for me something like conflict of Heroes is less compelling even though I do really enjoy moving the tanks around I think it's got a great AI right and something like votes for women which is trying to evoke a social movement and so I think that those things again as we mentioned are like more closely related to each other than either of them is to something like Calico or um you know the calico's fun I don't mean it like that you know what I mean no I know what you mean but like these things are on a totally different register in terms of what they're trying to do and you know it's not just oh let's have a nice family entertainment with a little competitive Teeth Let's like say something let's communicate something about what happened in the past and how we see it and how we want other people to see it and like you know how this conflict should be modeled and so for me broadening the definition matters because it gives more room for what interesting things people could say so do you think that there's potential within a broadened definition to expose some of these games to an audience that's just going to be a lot more hostile to them I think it works both ways I think yeah on the one hand we see lots of very kind of cranky responses to things like for example what's for women when it is perceived as intruding on a space where

I personally think it belongs um I also think though that war gaming is a branch of a hobby that needs to be appreciated more and then I'd like to see more people feel confident to try and I truly believe that if we do not broaden things out a bit we're going to keep it too exclusive and we're going to keep it too tight and we're gonna kill it we're gonna smother it and that's not what I want I think that we could have Rich and compelling conversations that are inviting and that by choosing to be overly aggressive about our definitions that we exclude people that maybe we would wish that we hadn't in the long run and I would rather invite them in than avoid ticking off my drunk uncle at Thanksgiving okay so it's interesting so I I can understand that and I think that I I guess the distinction I would make is I'm not as concerned with taking off uh drunk uncle old grognerd person it's more it's more about I would worry about what would happen to the small publisher who's putting out the Little Indie game about cool topic that is virtually uncovered and then getting just a student with like one ratings before the game's ever been released yeah on the heels of like you know kicking off a

Kickstarter campaign or something like that My worry is about those games getting kind of snuffed out before they have a chance and then also that that could play into making Publishers even more reticent to pick up those types of titles and as it is now there's already this feel of I mean look at a game like um like Taylor strauss's like um stolo Uprising right yeah it's just a game that like a lot of war game Publishers just didn't have the stones to put out they just lack the courage to put this game out and it's just it's just that you know and whether it's a matter of them not wanting six chance based on like they don't think Their audience is going to buy this game whether it's a matter of I don't want to put it on my pre-order system and find out whether or not my audience is willing to buy this game uh which is a little bit sadder considering you know that takes like no investment whatsoever um but then you see a company like catastrophe decides to basically throw their hat and ring like we're going to put that out we're going to do that I mean like a brand new company has the courage to put this game out that nobody else is like willing to face that challenge to do it and they're rewarded by it and I think that also but that game the more if we were to push that even more into a war game Space where Suddenly It's like this is a war game and we want you War Gamers to check this out and play it even though we get the sense that this is part of the um backlash this title is probably going

to be just that it's sort of miscategorized worth being misconstrued as this thing that doesn't really fit alien either I think that it's just going to make it a little bit tougher for designers especially since the ratings the weight of these ratings well I know they don't matter and you know they don't really matter the problem is that when some folks look at games the first thing they look at when something's on sale unlike Miniature Market or something or if they're you know local game store is oh I've never heard of that game what is that oh 50 off that seems good and then they'll look it up and they'll see it has like a 6.5 rating they'll be like screw it I'm not buying that type of thing and it reflects poorly also on the designers when they're trying to pitch future projects to other Publishers and so it's really I just want to make sure that like public like basically the designers games are gonna find the audience that's going to be receptive to what they want to make it's like I just want them to not just make the weird little game that they want to make but also finding the right home within a publisher and finding the Right audience that's going to actually want to kind of dive into that game with them

I think that first of all speaking of bulges grow one all of y'all who are afraid to like publish something like throw it and cover it that's all but um you know I I also after saying at the at the same time I think that making sure that you're being as inviting as possible is going to create a wave that drowns that out I think that the portion of our population that is that level of cranky is shrinking I think that the portion of our population that could be interested is growing and I also think that if you're talking about marketing and putting something in the right place like the thing about Stonewall Uprising is it yeah it's a deck builder you could play it like any other deck builder right but it's so emotionally affecting and it's so important that I just don't feel comfortable putting it next to you like the aeon's end or astronauts you know output this year and saying like oh yeah this is the same kind of game because they're just not like I love astronauts and I love aeon's end but if I had to choose a game to survive for the next 500 years I would choose Stonewall uprising God I hope one of my games last 500 years so Russ mentioned that um he thinks theme is a pasted on thing and a war game is saying something so resist is talking about hidden cells in the choice that revealing meant capture so make it count I'm just kind of curious if we were going to compare say Liz boa to Watergate for example now these are

both games about a his we'll say their games about a historical you know topic right but for one of these the theme is a little bit like it's thematic mechanics right like we have like mechanisms and it sort of it's about the history and the other one it feels like might be might be speaking out a turn here but I feel like lizard is just using Lisboa as like the pretext to kind of do a point salad thing like it's just more more about like giving you a menu of options than having you score as many points of different types as you possibly can um I just don't think that those are necessarily the same type of historical game um but do you think that the that like in all cases like there's there's probably some historical games that are also treating that as I pasted on thing not all of them but there's definitely some elements of that yeah I think there's certainly elements of that I mean just personally like within wargaming where you know again I mentioned something like conflict of Heroes right you can make that in space and it would be the same game it doesn't really have to be an Eastern Front game um you know I also think though yeah I actually thought that Liz boa was remarkably thematic for a hero just because every single thing did have at least some kind of historical connection um I thought pimpero was very interesting this year um you know it's from Julian pombo who is uh lucero's developer on many projects and I thought the game was

really interesting because again like yes it's a Euro game and I know that there are people who know actual things about wind farming that found inaccuracies in the game at the same time it you know that's true more gifts too uh and you know it's a real attempt to kind of communicate the theme but with like a Euro facing and I find that I'm not necessarily willing to rule that out at the same time I think that you know something like heaven and Ale I mean that's not really about that spoiler I haven't played it yet now I know I'm now I know too much I mean I think that euro is actually and actually this leads to the a part of the conversation I kind of wanted to lead to to kind of close out which is that um and we'll go on a while because we we do like that but I really have thought about the way I like to describe the kinds of games I'm into and I do use the word historical a lot I tend to think about historical games because I think that that indicates that my interests are inclusive of War games they're usually exclusive of sci-fi games although I will play them for fun sometimes and they also in my mind are meant to exclude things like um what are some like just like those sort of paste on Euros right like it's it's Orlean is not a historical game to me it's set in a historical period kind of I guess technically but it's not a history it's not a history game

um and so for me like that's where I'm the significant I'm using to try to get it what I want but I also wonder like does that even work like is that a term that you think could work or just like all definitions is it bound to fall apart I mean every I think labels kind of like models are all going to be flawed but you use the labels where they're going to be useful and you try to digress from them they're not going to be particularly helpful and I think that in the space of gaming um you can be as specific or as broad as you want um I just I find more and more that the people I play with and the people I meet in a lot of these events they're they're all Omni Gamers they play all kinds of things everybody plays all kinds of things because sometimes it's a matter of like I play with my spouse I play with my kids I play with these other nerds that like this other common game and then I play the song and I play like Netrunner with these other people it's just like they all like have these they're like more like trying to find a player for every freaking thing they would want to play so they get an opportunity to scratch every kind of hitch and it's interesting there's not a lot of folks that are just out there being like you know I only play games about future zoos I really don't want to play games about anything but a future Zoo it's just future zoos from now on yes all right so uh Russ has responded I haven't played Liz boa but he would put Watergate in the working category as much as Twilight Struggle true shall I

think that makes sense also um liquidity says uh that he likes that point but it feels like negotiating with terrorists and I think that made your point about like not pissing off a certain in segment and for sales reasons and like I I do kind of sympathize at that point yeah I I'm willing to negotiate with pretty much anybody unfortunately makes you a good War gamer character flaw oh man uh and then so bayonet Brandt hey Brent uh says it's the unquantifiable Alchemy of mechanics plus theme plus model slash Fidelity that hits every player differently and how they tie together is a function of how well the designer synthesizes all those inputs I don't think that's a good comment um I think that does hit like the right Crossroads where we all are kind of struggling to figure out what we're the most comfortable with and what what is we want to talk about when we want to talk about war games so do you think oh is it too late to bring up this point potential things that we're looking at is is this is the audiences I think are kind of related because these games are sort of like they're like cousins of each other and in some respects sometimes it's close relations because of their marriage not really sure but I feel like sometimes

the idea is that um if we've got say an award for a war game being given out but there is no comparable award for just historical games at large as any kind of Distinction then these two are going to end up competing against each other or kind of forced to compete for the same you know kind of Accolade and the issue becomes that it's well this is the only chance that a war game has to like win something through say you know bgj and this is the only chance that like a historical game has so it's like we're gonna pit these two against each other and whichever one has the largest audience that's going to be what resolve those popularity contest when in actuality these two games should probably each have their own kind of distinctions there should be they should both be celebrated you know I mean yeah by audiences I think there are some times when you would put them both in the same category right like if you want to look at like the best comment on a historical event then you can include what somebody would consider a traditional war game or you can include something that somebody wouldn't does that make sense like I think that there are certainly categories where they really should be together um I can also see I can't see historical as a more inclusive umbrella term the problem is that it would leave out the Sci-Fi people but I think you could just graft it on whatever it's fine you and your aliens um but uh I I do think that you know you could you could Envision right a situation where there's just a little bit more Nuance in the categories like instead of just forcing it by time period right you could say something like oh this is the best simulation of

political conflict this is the best simulation of a kinetic conflict this year uh this is the best um you know commentary on Social Development this year like I mean I sort of you know you could I'm not saying you have to do it that way right but there are other ways we could be dividing these things that would leave some room and also I think maybe convey more meaning for like why we think a game is so good absolutely I to your point the that those those types of alternate categories provoke discussion and debate online it gets your award talked about whereas pre-gun powder blah blah blah it's just not not that rich of a conversation to really be hosting right but if we start having to like split hairs it's like is this is this more of a political game or is it more about you know emphasizing that it's you know say uh cold warrior I think or is it that it's a negotiation game more significant for this other words like the idea is that things have like multiple places where they might be able to be nominated but also like it just it's inviting a rich discussion about these games and I think that that's probably more interesting than having categories because some of the category distinctions for various Awards they don't really have a lot of entries because there's just not that many games in the space and I don't know that as a designer I would feel super psyched about winning an award in a year when there were only three games that could have competed for said award but you know like the orderly matters if there's like a wide field of games that could

have been considered and personally I don't know about you Liz I like the kind of games I can't possibly win Awards those are just my favorite that's kind of my bag I just like things that are a little bit harder to love you know yeah well it's part of the charm right so Lenny Kim says one definition of art is if the artists say it's art why not if the designer says it's a war game I actually think that that is a more complicated question so yes what the artist says they want does matter but I also think that once you turn something over into the world that the reader responds is reactive of me right like also helps to find what something is um you know Eno tool will tell you oh I'm not an artist I'm a graphic designer but I don't really think that any of us really see him that way um I think that that's a pose of humility perhaps but that you know he is doing interpretive work he is doing art at the same time that he's making something functional um but I mean it's interesting to talk about right like if somebody says this is not a war game but to all of us it totally is like who's right I kind of feel like once you turn something over to your audience they get a say and like that's what makes this so interesting right because whatever your intentions are and I'm thinking about this with night witches right now like are designing right it's like okay so like what are my intentions for how this game will be received versus what will people see when they play it and I can't unlike something where I'm writing and even when you're writing right there's so much loss between what was in my brain and what went into yours

like with whatever medium of communication we used like it's a mess absolutely there's a a clip of uh when Marcellus is asked by an audience member um if jazz is more important to the player or to the audience or to The Listener and Marcellus takes four big steps to that audience member asking the question and he goes to the listener but the player is the first listener that's kind of the thing like I think to a certain extent it kind of holds here too yeah all right so Rod has an issue comment which is not sure Awards or reviews matter to be honest no one remembers them just the games I think there's some truth in it but I also think that Awards and reviews matter for whether people are going to play the games and then remember them yeah I it I'll tell you it does matter to the Publishers who are in them because it gives them added recognition especially those that aren't able to Market their games aggressively or at all and I think that it matters to designers who are looking at designing their second third fourth and Beyond games um in raising their not necessarily even raising their profile but just maintaining a profile particularly for games that don't exist in a retail space so that's another kind of consideration with some of these words and things like that they don't really have shelf space

in the same way I've seen I've had pictures sent to me of my games on store shelves I have never seen my game on a store shelf like ever and it would be super weird if it were to happen but it's just like I just don't think of my games I think in that same same way like you know you see like a Martin Wallace game on a shelf somewhere you're like oh that's a real game that's like a that's like a store thing you buy you know type of game like code names or something like these these are just like a different total species it just feels like a it's much more out there yeah yes so Brent just I'm just gonna put this when I played night which is I saw a crap ton of flat guns trying to shoot me down that would be accurate oh and uh and then Alex says None of jazz comparisons and working conversations thanks for the rare crossover Dan I'm here to provide for my Alex's this is why I want I want to have this particular ly see the world in a really interesting way and in a nuanced way and that that makes it you're you're an interesting conversation partner for this stuff because there's so much flexibility in what you can see well thank you one of the one of the joys to having like a lot of range in terms of what what you read what you study what you do is that all this feels like a a synapse misfiring like it's just you're kind of grabbing from all these random places to form a form kind of articulate your argument and uh so

it's very strong when you're trying to form analogies and it's very weak when you're trying to be coherent within a kind of reconcile a lot of contrary ideas within themselves yes also some love for blood and treasure uh so we played at Circle DC and they've pointed to it when trying to tell their non-gamer friends what kind of cool stuff war games are capable of and why they're in the hobby so as we close out do you want to just tell us what blood and treasure is and where you can be found so that people can go and start Twitter sure so uh I'll start with where it can be found currently not anywhere yet but um it's a design that I have um been kind of shopping the Prototype around um for that's on the uff can war and more specifically it's about the role of American firms uh who are fulfilling uh private military contracts uh during the war so players are actually taking on the role of those firms and then trying to uh grow their firms and then of course the winner is going to be the player who's grown their firm the most but it's an interesting take on kind of the US Afghan war from a perspective that hasn't really been gained um so is that a war game it's I mean it's pretty War adjacent at the very least but if I call it one that's going to totally change what everyone says about it so maybe I should just let them decide right Liz yes whether or not it's a war game let the readers respond but uh yeah I also put your Twitter

I'll show it one more time go find Ian I can be found anywhere online as Beyond Solitaire so I'm easy to catch but uh Dan thank you so much for coming I have this conversation with me everybody in um who is with us on the stream thank you all for coming and like making this fun and adding the conversation we really enjoyed having you thank you Liz thanks everybody foreign foreign

Progress saved