Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 19:49

welcome to John Gates Games episode two today I'm going to talk about clles I'm going to do a brief rules explanation and then I'm going to discuss my varied opinion on this game CES is a game about conflict in ancient Greece where each player takes a colored faction and they try to out build and out fight their way to being the first team to get to two Metropolis is controlled at the end of their turn and I'm going to talk about how you get to that point this game is controlled by an auction which allows you to get access to the various actions that you can do on your turn I'm going to discuss the actions now then I'll discuss how the auction works so we have five Gods here four of them are on cardboard um tokens that can move around they could be in various orders as the game progresses it's random uh at the beginning of the game and in at every Point through the game I just set these up in a logical order for teaching Apollo down here he's always at the botttom he he's always last so what these Gods let you do we have Poseidon here he lets you build ships move ships and build Harbors uh if you were to win the favor of Poseidon then that's all you're going to have access to on your turn you're going to be able to buy some creatures I'll explain that in a second but it's a compartmentalized you can't do the actions of the other gods if you wanton the favor of Poseidon on this turn uh Aries is very similar you get to build units move units possibly attacking or maybe just taking empty land and you can build

fortresses Zeus allows you to purchase priests which are in a stack right here they all have a minus one at the bottom they give you discounts on paying for the favor of the Gods when you evaluate the auction so very powerful he also lets you cycle through the creatures by paying gold and you can build a temple with him and Athena finally lets you purchase thinkers over here I'll explain what they do in a minute uh she has no specific action associated with her but you can also purch universities and place them out in your domain on the map Apollo is essentially a pass all players could go there if they want to only the first player is going to gain access to this cardboard Cornucopia if you notice on the board many of the locations have single and double cornucopias this is your income in gold at the beginning of every round so the number of cornucopias equals the amount of gold you take so being the first person to put a uh to take Apollo gives you access to this you can stick it on your one of your islands and you permanently go up one income or that Island does whoever controls it gets that income Apollo also gives you a buck so he's a nice guy all right so I'm going to discuss what these uh buildings do at the end of the day the game is about controlling these metropolises I talked about over here these guys so they're they're built in two different ways we have the four building types and we have the thinkers that Athena lets us buy the first one is is the harbor it helps you defend the sea areas around

the island that you happen to put it down on the Fortress helps you defend any attacks on that island that it's on the temple gives you gold discounts for purchasing the creatures which I'll explain in a minute very good and the university has no in-game action associated with it the only reason universi universities exist and the only reason you're going to buy them is because in order to make metropolises you have to get one of all four of these buildings is one of the two ways and the moment you have one of all four in your domain not necessarily on one Island they're forced to go back to the bank and then you get to place a metropolis down on one of your islands and the Metropolis is nice because it counts as a harbor of for a temple and University so you get all those bonuses in one building also you're one half the way to Victory if you can keep control of that Metropolis the other way to make metropolises is to have collect your fourth thinker uh they have no in-game effect um much like the university but once you get four of them you are forced to put them back to the bank and that generates you another metropolis and you plunk that down a few yellow over here and if you still have act control of both of those at the end of the game then then yellow wins these are the only two ways to generate metropolises so this is why Athena is important she's a very endgame role all right I'm gonna discuss the creatures now on a turn when you evaluate uh the god that you want the favor of you have the option of purchasing any uh up to three of these

creatures new ones don't come out between Gods so turn order becomes very important uh in this case whoever takes Poseidon is going to have first access uh the creature cards do all sorts of things there's a deck of them right here uh for instance we have this one right here which summons the Kraken which is one of the few cards in the game that has a miniature and you can place that down on the board and it eats all the ships and you could pay money and it continues to walk around eating ships kraken's pretty great uh and it stays out there which is the only one of the Miniatures that actually does and then you have cards like the Cyclops here it lets you turn one small building type into another so that Fort could now become a harbor which might be what you need to make your set of four and the Chimera lastly is a very powerful card it lets you play a card that was previously uh used all right so let's talk about the auction in this game uh the top four gods are going to have bids placed on them Apollo doesn't need any money he gives you money so going up here in this case green player would bid first and let's say they want to build ships and or move ships and they say it's worth two gold to me so they place two there and then black might say well I really want these discounts on the auctioning so I'm going to go three right here then yellow says I want to build ships so he bids four out bidding green and at this point green can't jump back into Poseidon at least at this moment if he goes to Aries and gets bumped he can come back again but he might say you know what this income is looking mighty

fine I'm going to plunk down there and uh we just keep going and people you know they might out bid and this person goes over here and you know it keeps going until it Heats hits an equilibrium where no one is conflicting anymore and then everyone pays uh like I said these priest cards give you discounts you can see A Little Priest icon you always have to play at least one but for every card you have you pay one less minimum of one but it can be very powerful leveraging the actions you actually want to take on your turn uh so now I'm going to talk briefly about combat uh we have two combat dice in this game combat is very simple I'm going to pretend that yellow here had three ships in this spot right here and they do a beside move they move here move here they maybe want to take over this Cornucopia that's on the board that blue has been getting income from now combat between yellow and blue yellow rolls a die blue Rolls a die these are not standard d6s they have one Zer they have two 1's two twos and a single three on them blue Rolls a die yellow rolls a die and then you add them up in this case yellow would be 3 plus three is six blue would be 1 + 2 is three blue loses a figure if it had been a cookie situation where yellow would roll a zero and blue had rolled a two then that would be a tie three on three they'd both lose one yellow would still win uh so that's combat uh The Troop combat Works exact same way the only way to move troops is to oh Red's in trouble he lost his ship but green can jump over

here and uh and attack or Etc it works the exact same way all right well that is the gist of the game I'm going to discuss my feelings on it so I have 18 recorded plays of this game and over that time I found things that I love things that I'm pretty indifferent to and things that I really dislike so I'm going to discuss those in order I'm going to start with the things I love uh the things I love the art is amazing these are the player Shields that come with the game and just every single piece of this game just oozes amazing production value and art for instance every single characters uh has different models like red has crazy two store Berserker dudes blue has awesome uh bow and arrow dagger Amazon ladies green has sword wielding Pike dudes so and also you got boats with two sales and boats with one sale just really really great how they the attention to detail there they really made them all different uh the first mechanical thing that I just love about this game is the auction mechanic here auctions are not usually my favorite thing in games but I just love it in this game uh the reason for that is cu it's very tight and there's lots of strategic interesting things you can do when you're jumping around you know for instance if uh black here had outb yellow uh for the blue uh for the Poseidon then yellow's like well I just I really really need to move my boats so I'm going to bump red and I'm going to hope that somebody

else comes back in wanting Aries and Aries is like oh you suck I'm going to I don't know Zeus is amazing if I put a five here I have four extra gold I can buy two priests and then blue says yeah okay well Aries is good and you know yellow gets to come back in here it's just you can think several turns ahead who wants to do what so who am I a bump so they can do what I want them to do so I can get back into the thing I want and maybe you out bid by a lot another thing about the bidding is that you can bid really high uh you can come in and you know plk this down right here and say you know I'm going to I'm going to bid 13 and and especially when you open with that everyone goes what you can afford that you're like yeah I can and I really need to move my boats uh often times you do that if you're in a situation where you might be able to win you know you just cash out all your money you've got a bunch of pre priests you keep these you don't cash them out but you got a bunch of priests you got a bunch of money cuz you did Apollo a couple turns in a row or something like that now you just spend tons of money because you know there might be a card up here that lets you do something that can get you the end of the game you know maybe you just needed to go first so you have first access to the Cyclops who lets you change your red building into a blue building which gives you the set and gives you your second Metropolis things like that uh often times people actually go crazy bidding on a god they don't care about specifically for player or order because they go in that order so they can have first dibs on the monsters up here so that's really interesting and the way they all Shuffle around is very interesting also the the relative power of the game uh Power of the Gods in the game Athena early game

no one wants her you can usually get her for one or two gold no problem late game Athena gets huge because Athena is the she's the Keystone you have to have thinkers or universities in order to make your metropolises so you can't you can't make any of them without Athena at some point you're going to have to do Athena sometimes first turn Athena for one gold not that big of a deal and you have it for the future uh so the second thing I really love about this uh is specifically Apollo just really interesting decision when you want to be the first person to go down here and take that Cornucopia to permanently add to your Revenue I mean if you take bide and you move a boat and you move the boat over and you get one of these well that's one income and Apollo is one income so often times it's just really really good to do Apollo another thing I really really like is that the actions are split up between the gods so if you um if you win the favor of Zeus this is what you're doing on your turn you're doing this and maybe buying some creatures if they still exist remember they don't new ones don't come out between the gods so if they all get bought early they're gone for that round and yeah you're buying you're buying a priest or you're maybe cycling um through some creatures you know this is all you can do you don't have to think about oh do I my move and do I attack like nope that's all I have if you take Aries just where do I attack from and you better have set up your boats so that you have a valid attack path because if you didn't and there isn't maybe you take this card right here which turns one opponent's boat into yours and that gives you an attack path there's just lots of different ways that these things integrate together and the fact that they're compartmentalized

is really nice uh I didn't spef specifically mention this in the gaml but as you evaluate your turn you put your columns back in reverse order and so this is just a nice little thing where and it also means if you take Apollo you're always going to be number one on the next turn um and then you can go big because you just got a bunch of money so it's a little bit of a self balancing mechanism why these uh may be better than you realize because on your next turn you're going to have a better spot in the ranking which I really like uh in general I really like the creature cards they add a lot of variety to the game there's a big Aster risk to that which I'm going to get to in a minute uh so now I'm going to talk about things I'm indifferent to I'm I'm indifferent to the combat to be honest it I don't love it I don't hate it it's very simple you know if you come in here like I said in the rules explanation with these three boats you're probably going to win you might take some attrition and maybe you get crazy unlucky and blue wins out but usually the battles go the way you want you expect them to every now and then they don't everyone goes what and it's you know it's kind of fun but I don't know I don't love it I don't hate it it works uh the other kind of weird thing is the first Blood issue and that is that in order to make these metropolises you have to either get one of each of the five smaller buildings or five of these thinker guys which which means often times no one wants to be the first person to make these the board doesn't start with these the moment one of these is made you know say yell makes this here suddenly the other four players are like that looks pretty tasty I want that I'm going to try and use cars to take it you know I'm going to try and attack I'm

going to move my boats you just become the target really fast if you're the first person making a metropolis so there's a weird mechanic where or dynamic really where people just delay delay delay uh getting out these metropolises cuz they don't want to be the first one with them they want to take someone else's it's a little odd I don't like it I don't hate it it's it's just it's okay uh things that I really dislike about this game uh number one the Pegasus uh this is a creature card it comes in the creature card deck and it is just a absolute GameChanger it lets you move uh troops from one Island to another Island without the use of boats so you know you take your troops from over here and you go all the way over here and you take over that Metropolis you know say you had three or four troops on here something like that maybe you had or six you have a there's a zero some number of troops so if you have all of them here they're not defending somewhere else but doesn't matter I it really feels like out of these 18 games probably eight of them have been decided by the Pegasus you know Pegasus comes out people grown one person cheers because they happen to be the first person they bid like crazy o here to take the Pegasus to jump over to take the undefended Metropolis which the person thought was fine because there were no opponent's boats next to it for instance and then I nope doesn't matter Pegasus over and they take it and there's there's little you can do to defend against the Pegasus while also uh progressing towards the end game you can turtle up like crazy so you're always defended and no one can Pegasus you waiting for it to come but it might not come and then you don't win because you haven't built a good engine or you just

work on your engine and you say well maybe they'll Pegasus someone else or maybe the Pegasus won't show up and then maybe you win or maybe the Pegasus shows up and it just totally trounces your plans that you've been working on for half an hour it's annoying uh however I've played the game without the Pegasus like I threw it in the and the game suffered because of it cuz now you didn't have the threat of the Pegasus so I it's a it's a can't live with it can't live without it I'm really not sure what to do with the Pegasus so I leave it in and I just tell everyone hey there's this card it's really really powerful it sometimes changes the games and anyway so the next thing I dislike about this game is the fact that these Miniatures are so rarely used I talk about the Kraken every time the Kraken comes out it pretty much gets used it's very powerful and it stays that's cool none of these other four remain more than a turn and none of these three have ever been bought in 18 games they're just not good enough for the gold cost uh and they just what they do is so rarely applicable it just it's a it's a design space waste I feel like these could have been way more interestingly used so they actually stayed out there for longer periods of time they did more interesting things I mean this one right here defends you against three specific cards on one specific Island just no one takes it it's just a waste uh polyus here throws rocks and destroys ships or pushes ships away he's he's pretty cool he comes out every now and then but again only for one turn so annoying I think the expansion might help this I don't have the expansion um just as far as the base game goes they could have done more with these uh the

last thing that I want to talk about is uh the end game it kind of comes in to play with this guy right here but I found that the end is often times anticlimactic you know oh the Pegasus comes out H and then one person jumps over and they win and all that okay well I couldn't have done anything about that and let's clean up the game that person wins or you know you have you someone goes Zeus and they spend eight gold just cycling cycling cycling hunting for one specific card like this one and then they change that one building into the other they make their second metropolis and Aries has happened and no one can attack him and they win and it's just kind of like oh okay all right it just very often times I feel like over 50% of the time the end is anticlimactic in this game which is frustrating now that I've discussed my issues with the game I want to briefly and finally talk about player count this game plays up to five players I've never played it with two uh I've played a few games with three most of them with four and many with five uh I have to say I prefer it with four and five probably five is my favorite favorite although five can be a bit long sometimes over two hours the reason for that is with five is the only time that all five of these gods are going to be available in a four-player game the bottom one isn't and on the next round that one will be the top God and these three would get shuffled up and uh and then this one will be face down Etc so you you you're missing one every round in a four player game which is fine in a three-player game You're missing two and then these get shuffled and come up here and I don't know it's a bit weird having that

many pieces out of the puzzle um I I just like that also three-player games seem to go a little quick so uh like I said five maybe a little long but I think that's the best way to play the game three a little short four is probably the sweet spot but also the board gets smaller this is a five player board and four player you flip them over and three player they get smaller and smaller so it's uh proportional so I've had this game for years and I plan to keep it for years I don't see myself trading it away or selling it because I really enjoy playing it I just don't like how it ends and that enjoyment of the in-game play in general beats out the often anticlimactic end through various means that I've I've described um because of this like I said doesn't come out very often maybe twice a year or something like that but I can see myself continuing to want to play it twice a year for quite a long time in the future and as I'm playing I kind of know that this one might end anti-climatic but right now this one auction bid this one moment is just so great that it makes it worthwhile at the end of the day I go back and forth about purchasing the expansions I've heard various positive and negative things about it I think I'll likely acquire it at some point um but as a base game I say I recommend it with the asterisk that people just go into it knowing that there could be some weirdness the end could be a bit odd and it's in general it's worth it overall I hope you've enjoyed this review uh let me know if you have any questions or comments thank you very much

Progress saved